Asure Software Inc (ASUR) 2006 Q1 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Good morning and welcome to the 2006 first quarter Forgent earnings conference call. [OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS] I would now like to turn the presentation over to your host for today's call, Mr. Michael Noonan. Sir, you may proceed.

    早安,歡迎參加 Forgent 2006 年第一季財報電話會議。[OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS] 現在我想把簡報交給今天會議的主持人 Michael Noonan 先生。先生,您可以開始了。

  • Michael Noonan - IR

    Michael Noonan - IR

  • Thank you and welcome everybody to Forgent's conference call. Now, before we start I'd like to mention that some of the statements made by management during this call might include projections, estimates, and other forward-looking information. This would include any discussion of the Company's business outlook. These particular forward-looking statements and all other statements that may be made on this call that are not historical facts are subject to a number of risks and uncertainties that could affect our outcome. You are urged to consider the risk factors relating to the Company's business contained in our latest periodic reports on file with the Securities and Exchange Commission. These risk factors are important and they could cause actual results to differ materially.

    謝謝,歡迎各位參加 Forgent 的電話會議。在開始之前,我想先提到,管理層在本次電話會議中所做的部分陳述可能包含預測、估計以及其他前瞻性資訊。這包括任何關於公司業務展望的討論。這些特定的前瞻性陳述,以及本次電話會議中可能提出的所有其他非歷史事實之陳述,均受多項風險與不確定性影響,可能影響我們的結果。敬請各位參考我們最近提交給美國證券交易委員會的定期報告中所載、與公司業務相關的風險因素。這些風險因素非常重要,且可能導致實際結果出現重大差異。

  • This call is being recorded on behalf of Forgent and is copyrighted material. It cannot be recorded or rebroadcast without the Company's express permission and your participation implies consent to the call's recording. After we have completed our review of the quarter we will open up the call for questions from the financial analyst community. I'd like to now turn the call over to Richard Snyder, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer of Forgent. Richard.

    本次電話會議代表 Forgent 進行錄音,並屬受版權保護之資料。未經公司明確許可,不得錄音或轉播;您參與本次會議即表示同意本次通話被錄音。在我們完成本季回顧後,將開放金融分析師社群提問。現在我想把電話交給 Forgent 董事長兼執行長 Richard Snyder。Richard。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Thank you, Michael, and good morning. Thank you for attending Forgent's 2006 first fiscal quarter conference call. With me this morning is Jay Peterson, who is our Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. And as customary on these calls, I'll be making some comments with regard to our results, have Jay give you some details around the numbers, and then we'll open it up for your questions.

    謝謝你,Michael,早安。感謝各位參加 Forgent 2006 會計年度第一季電話會議。今天早上與我一同出席的是我們的副總裁兼財務長 Jay Peterson。依照這類電話會議的慣例,我會先就我們的業績做一些評論,接著由 Jay 提供數字方面的細節,然後我們將開放各位提問。

  • Our focus in the fourth quarter continued to be on the intellectual property program. We continued to work on the litigation process for the '672 and the '746 patents. And we believe we've made significant progress with dates and with schedules. We're working on both actions simultaneously and are in a heads-down mode in litigation.

    我們在第四季的重點仍然放在智慧財產權計畫上。我們持續推進 '672 與 '746 專利的訴訟程序。我們相信在日期與時程安排方面已取得重大進展。我們同時推進兩項案件,目前正全力投入訴訟。

  • Let me update you on the progress of each one of these actions. On the '672 patent, in the northern district of California, Judge Fogel reconfirmed the Markman hearing for February 13 2006, which, as you know, is only ten weeks away. This is going to be an important milestone for the case. The court also placed Microsoft on the same schedule, and now that we have a regular schedule and order with claims, construction dates, the litigation process is on course and moving forward. We also added the law firm of Susman Godfrey to head our legal team on '672. Steve Susman and his team have an excellent record of success, and I'm very pleased to be working directly with Steve to win this case based upon its merits and sound legal process.

    我來向各位更新這兩項訴訟的進展。就 '672 專利而言,在加州北區法院,Fogel 法官再次確認 Markman 聽證會日期為 2006 年 2 月 13 日;如各位所知,距今僅剩十週。這將是本案的重要里程碑。法院也將微軟納入相同的時程安排;現在我們已有固定的時程與命令,包括權利要求解釋的日期,訴訟程序已步上軌道並持續推進。我們也新增 Susman Godfrey 律師事務所領導我們在 '672 案的法律團隊。Steve Susman 及其團隊有極佳的勝訴紀錄;我非常高興能與 Steve 直接合作,基於案件本身的實質理由與健全的法律程序來贏得此案。

  • On the '746 patent, in the eastern district of Texas, Judge Davis set a Markman hearing for July 2006 and a trial date of February 7, 2007. The court also transferred and consolidated Scientific Atlanta and Motorola with the original case. We have a scheduling order, claims construction dates, and a trial date. So we are moving full steam ahead with this action as well.

    就 '746 專利而言,在德州東區法院,Davis 法官將 Markman 聽證會訂於 2006 年 7 月,並將開庭審理日期訂於 2007 年 2 月 7 日。法院也將 Scientific Atlanta 與 Motorola 移轉並併入原始案件。我們已有排程命令、權利要求解釋日期,以及審理日期。因此,我們也正全速推進此案。

  • For those of you who have not visited our website, I would encourage you to do so, for there are the latest and more detailed information on the cases as well as links to other sites that give background and substance around these cases.

    尚未造訪我們網站的各位,我鼓勵大家前往瀏覽;網站上有關於案件的最新且更詳細資訊,並提供連結至其他網站,說明這些案件的背景與實質內容。

  • Now, changing subjects, I'd like to comment on our software business. NetSimplicity software sales grew significantly by adding new customers that reflect a variety of market segments, and we're particularly pleased to see large enterprise customers moving toward this simple and easy method of scheduling their meeting rooms.

    接著換個話題,我想談談我們的軟體業務。NetSimplicity 軟體銷售因新增客戶而大幅成長,這些客戶涵蓋多元的市場區隔;我們尤其高興看到大型企業客戶正轉向採用這種簡單、易用的會議室排程方式。

  • With that, I'd like to do a quick overview of our financial results for the quarter. We generated about 3.6 million in total revenue for the quarter, while we're pleased with these improved results and the increased licensing activity, we are continuing to aggressively seek additional licenses to continue to maintain a strong cash balance. NetSimplicity grew at a brisk pace and on a year-to-year basis we almost doubled the revenue from this software business. Third, we continued to maintain a healthy cash balance for the quarter, and we also continued to lower our overhead and expense structure. Now, on the intellectual property, in terms of licensing we did 2.9 million in the first quarter of '06. We are continuing with settlement discussions, and we'll seek additional license opportunities from companies like those who settled during the quarter, such as RIM -- R-I-M -- Axis, and EFI.

    接下來,我想快速概述本季的財務結果。本季我們的總營收約為 360 萬美元;雖然我們對這些改善的結果與授權活動增加感到滿意,但我們仍將積極尋求更多授權,以持續維持強勁的現金餘額。NetSimplicity 以相當快的速度成長,按年比較,我們幾乎使這項軟體業務的營收翻倍。第三,本季我們持續維持健康的現金餘額,同時也持續降低管理費用與成本結構。在智慧財產權方面,就授權而言,我們在 2006 年第一季達成 290 萬美元。我們仍在進行和解討論,並將從本季已和解的公司(例如 RIM——R-I-M——Axis,以及 EFI)等,尋求更多授權機會。

  • Let me comment briefly on the software. NetSimplicity continues to improve with growth of 19% in the quarter and almost 100% year-over-year. We're seeing healthy margins, rising ASPs, and approaching a break-even and generating cash. We continue to be encouraged by the progress that we're seeing in this business. Now let me turn this over to Jay for some specific financial information.

    我簡要評論一下軟體業務。NetSimplicity 本季成長 19%,年增接近 100%。我們看到健康的毛利率、上升的平均售價(ASP),並正接近損益兩平且開始產生現金。我們對於在此業務中看到的進展仍感到鼓舞。現在我把時間交給 Jay,請他提供更具體的財務資訊。

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • Thank you, Dick. Good morning. I would like to discuss the financial highlights from this past quarter for our intellectual property business and our NetSimplicity software business. In addition, I will briefly discuss our balance sheet and cash position. My final comments will relate to high level guidance for the future.

    謝謝你,Dick。早安。我想討論本季我們智慧財產權業務與 NetSimplicity 軟體業務的財務重點。此外,我也會簡要說明我們的資產負債表與現金部位。最後,我將就未來提供高層次的指引。

  • First off, intellectual property. Revenue for IP licenses increased to $2.9 million this past quarter, and we signed seven intellectual property licenses bringing the total for the program to 52 licenses. Licensees this past quarter included, among others, Research In Motion, Axis, and Electronics For Imaging -- EFI. Programs to date, we have realized approximately $105 million in total license revenue from the '672 patent. Intellectual property operating expenses for the quarter were $750,000, up from the prior quarter's level of $600,000, due to increased litigation related activity.

    首先是智慧財產權。本季 IP 授權營收增加至 290 萬美元;我們簽署了 7 份智慧財產權授權,使該計畫的授權總數達到 52 份。本季的被授權方包括(但不限於)Research In Motion、Axis,以及 Electronics For Imaging——EFI。截至目前,我們已從 '672 專利累計實現約 1.05 億美元的授權總收入。本季智慧財產權營運費用為 75 萬美元,高於前一季的 60 萬美元,原因是與訴訟相關的活動增加。

  • Intellectual property margins were 28% this past quarter. This figure is exposed upward going forward due to two reasons. One, a lower monthly retainer with our new law firm, and two, we will soon reduce the residual interest to our former law firm from 50% down to 10%. In the future, we will need approximately $4.5 million in intellectual property revenue in order to be profitable. This assumes no growth in software revenue. Compare this $4.5 million figure to the $6.5 million figure that we talked about a year ago.

    本季智慧財產權毛利率為 28%。展望未來,該數字有上升空間,原因有二。第一,與新律師事務所的每月顧問費(retainer)較低;第二,我們將很快把支付給前任律師事務所的剩餘分成比例由 50% 降至 10%。未來,我們約需 450 萬美元的智慧財產權收入才能達到獲利。此假設軟體收入沒有成長。請將這個 450 萬美元的數字與我們一年前談到的 650 萬美元相比。

  • Let me now turn to our software business. Revenue grew by 19% this past quarter, and by 68% over Q1 fiscal year '05. In addition, we grew bookings, software maintenance backlog, and ASPs. Also, since we acquired this business, we have doubled the size of our ASPs since the purchase of the business. Margins for NetSimplicity were 73%, up 3% from the prior quarter's level of 70%. And operating expenses for NetSimplicity were $880,000, essentially flat with the prior quarter. This past quarter, our software business consumed approximately 40 to $50,000 in cash and is very close to generating cash. In terms of total operating expenses for the quarter, they amounted to $2.8 million, essentially flat with the prior quarter.

    接著談我們的軟體業務。本季營收成長 19%,相較於 2005 會計年度第一季成長 68%。此外,我們的訂單(bookings)、軟體維護遞延收入(backlog)以及平均售價(ASP)也都有成長。同時,自我們收購該業務以來,我們的 ASP 規模已較收購時翻倍。NetSimplicity 的毛利率為 73%,較前一季的 70% 提升 3%。NetSimplicity 的營運費用為 88 萬美元,與前一季基本持平。本季我們的軟體業務約消耗 4 萬至 5 萬美元現金,已非常接近開始產生現金。就本季總營運費用而言,合計為 280 萬美元,與前一季基本持平。

  • Let me now turn to balance sheet and liquidity. Our cash balance remained flat with the prior quarter's level of $17.3 million. Our DSO this past quarter was a healthy 17 days, and our current ratio was 3.1, and our working capital totaled $12.5 million.

    現在我來談談資產負債表與流動性。我們的現金餘額與上一季持平,為1,730萬美元。本季我們的應收帳款週轉天數(DSO)維持在健康的17天,流動比率為3.1,營運資金合計為1,250萬美元。

  • Last topic is guidance. And I would like to provide guidance in four different areas. First off, we are confident we will achieve IP license revenue during this current quarter. In addition, we believe we will achieve IP revenue throughout fiscal year 2006. And again, as in the past, predicting the exact timing and magnitude of IP revenue remains a difficult task. Number two, we will continue to diligently manage our operating expenses, and we are committed to reducing expenses in nonessential areas. Also, we are planning on increasing spending in our intellectual property program between now and the trial. Number three, we believe that the NetSimplicity software business will continue to grow and will generate cash in the near term. And the last guidance point is that we are forecasting that we will maintain strong cash balances and working capital. In addition, we believe that we will have adequate financial resources to get our two patent cases in front of a jury. I would now like to turn the call back over to Richard Snyder.

    最後一個主題是財測指引。我想在四個不同領域提供指引。首先,我們有信心在本季達成智慧財產(IP)授權收入。此外,我們相信在2006會計年度全年都能達成IP收入。同樣地,如同過去,預測IP收入的確切時點與規模仍然是一項困難的工作。第二,我們將持續嚴格管理營運費用,並致力於在非必要領域降低支出。同時,我們計畫在現在到審判之前,提高在智慧財產計畫上的支出。第三,我們相信NetSimplicity軟體業務將持續成長,並在短期內產生現金。最後一項指引是,我們預期將維持強勁的現金餘額與營運資金。此外,我們相信我們將擁有充足的財務資源,讓兩起專利案件都能進入陪審團審理。現在我想把電話會議交回給Richard Snyder。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Thanks, Jay. Well, as you can see, we are continuing to stay on course, we're focused, we will continue to look at the IP opportunities. We're particularly focused around our litigation process. As someone once said during the quarter, the wheels of justice grind slowly but they do grind, and we're pleased that we have visibility to dates and to the process that it's going to take to be successful. The software continues to grow and we will watch that and continue to manage that accordingly, and then on the cash side we're going to continue to maintain our cash balance as best we can and to bring down our expenses accordingly. So all in all, I think it's a -- it was a good quarter for us, and we're continuing to move forward along these lines. Now I'll turn it back over to Michael.

    謝謝,Jay。如各位所見,我們持續按既定方向前進,我們很專注,也會持續尋找IP機會。我們特別聚焦在訴訟流程上。正如有人在本季曾說過的,正義的車輪轉得很慢,但確實會轉;我們很高興能清楚掌握日期與達成成功所需的流程。軟體業務持續成長,我們會持續觀察並相應管理;在現金方面,我們會盡力維持現金餘額,並相應降低費用。總的來說,我認為這是——對我們而言是個不錯的季度,我們也會沿著這些方向持續向前。現在我把電話交回給Michael。

  • Michael Noonan - IR

    Michael Noonan - IR

  • Well, thanks, gentlemen. And with that, I'd like to open up the meeting for questions from the financial analysts. We'll ask [the operator] to coordinate the session.

    好的,謝謝各位先生。接下來,我想開放給金融分析師提問。我們請[接線員]協調這個環節。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • [OPERATOR INSTRUCTIONS] Your first question comes from Mike Heim of A. G. Edwards. Please proceed.

    [接線員指示] 第一個問題來自A. G. Edwards的Mike Heim。請開始。

  • Mike Heim

    Mike Heim

  • Hi, guys. Good quarter. Question for you regarding the Markman. Could you give us a little color and explain to us the magnitude of the Markman and what it means for the Company? And my second question is, is if you continue to get license, what do you plan to do with any excess cash? Thank you.

    嗨,各位。這一季表現不錯。我有個關於Markman的問題。你們能否多提供一些背景,說明Markman的重要性與其對公司意味著什麼?第二個問題是,如果你們持續取得授權收入,你們打算如何運用任何多餘的現金?謝謝。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Mike, this is Dick Snyder. With regard to the Markman hearing, this is a -- sort of a milestone, if you will, in the case for those who are not familiar with the patent litigation where both sides come together in the court and define the terms under which they'll proceed in the legal process. And this is important because it sets the definitions around the patent and around the discussion of how the case will move forward. And from then on, the -- both sides are really restricted in the way in which they deal with these matters. So typically this is seen as an event where clarity comes for both sides, and we believe that this will be a significant event which will allow us to move forward.

    Mike,我是Dick Snyder。關於Markman聽證會,對於不熟悉專利訴訟的人來說,這算是案件中的一個——可以說是里程碑;雙方會在法庭上聚在一起,界定在法律程序中將依據哪些術語與定義來推進。這很重要,因為它會針對專利以及案件如何推進的討論,建立相關定義。從那之後,雙方在處理這些事項的方式上都會受到相當限制。因此,這通常被視為一個能讓雙方獲得更清晰界線的事件;我們相信這將是一個重要事件,能讓我們繼續向前推進。

  • On the second part of your question, with regard to if we're successful in continuing to get cash in our licensing activities, I would give you the following kind of guidance. Number one, we're going to continue to make sure that we have sufficient cash to be able to get this through trial, make sure that we have sufficient resources to bring to bear all of the resources necessary to be successful in court. If we have cash beyond that, we'll continue to look at a dividend or perhaps a stock buyback, and after that, we'll continue to look at the ability to invest some of that for the growth of our software business. So I think that gives you kind of an outline of what we and the Board are thinking in terms of cash.

    至於你問題的第二部分,若我們在授權活動中持續成功取得現金,我會給你以下這類指引。第一,我們會持續確保有足夠現金能支撐案件走到審判,並確保我們有足夠資源,動員所有在法庭上取得勝訴所需的資源。若在此之外仍有多餘現金,我們會持續評估發放股利或可能進行庫藏股買回;之後,我們也會持續評估將其中一部分投資於軟體業務成長的能力。我想這大致勾勒出我們與董事會對現金運用的想法。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • And your next question comes from Richard West of J.M. Dutton.

    下一個問題來自J.M. Dutton的Richard West。

  • Richard West - Analyst

    Richard West - Analyst

  • Good morning. I have two questions. One, the RIM situation, do you see any effect on the patent license that you've already granted to them?

    早安。我有兩個問題。第一,關於RIM的情況,你們是否看到對你們已經授予他們的專利授權有任何影響?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • No, none whatsoever.

    完全沒有。

  • Richard West - Analyst

    Richard West - Analyst

  • Okay. And two, about in mid-November, an organization -- I don't know it -- [INAUDIBLE] is challenging the JPEG patent for reexamine. Does this have any need for worry, or can it be delaying the trials at all, now that the Markman hearing has been set?

    好的。第二,大約在11月中旬,有一個組織——我不認識——[聽不清]正在挑戰JPEG專利並申請再審查。這是否需要擔心?或者在Markman聽證會已經排定的情況下,這會不會延後審判?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Yes, it's not uncommon to see defendants in a patent litigation case look at asking the patent office to reexamine patents. So we see this as a normal activity. We also look at the -- at that petition itself. It doesn't contain any new information from our perspective, so we're proceeding forward. We're confident that we can prevail in this matter. It's unknown with regard to delays in the case, because it really depends upon how the processes unfold, so I can't predict that. But from our perspective, it's moving forward at full speed.

    是的,在專利訴訟案件中,看到被告向專利局提出專利再審查的要求並不罕見。因此我們認為這是正常行為。我們也檢視了——該請願本身。從我們的角度來看,它沒有包含任何新的資訊,所以我們會繼續往前推進。我們有信心能在此事上勝出。至於是否會造成案件延宕,目前無法確定,因為這取決於流程如何展開,所以我無法預測。但就我們而言,一切正全速向前。

  • Richard West - Analyst

    Richard West - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Your next question comes from the line of [Michael James], [Kuckinosh] Capital. Please proceed.

    下一個問題來自[Michael James],[Kuckinosh] Capital。請開始。

  • Michael James - Analyst

    Michael James - Analyst

  • Hey, guys, can you give me a breakdown of the number of employees that the Company has? And then also, can you tell me what the addressable market is for NetSimplicity and at what point does the Company shut it down because it continues to burn cash after we've seen the management run alliance, and that burned through 25 million of the shareholders money?

    嘿,各位,你們能否提供公司員工人數的明細?另外,你們能否說明NetSimplicity的可服務市場(addressable market)有多大,以及在什麼情況下公司會把它關掉,因為在我們看到管理層經營run alliance時,它持續燒錢,燒掉了股東2,500萬美元?

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • Yes, I can answer both questions. This is Jay Peterson. First off, we have at present 32 full-time employees in the Company. Eight of those employees are involved in either accounting, executive positions, or intellectual property positions. The remaining 24 are involved in our software business, and in terms of the NetSimplicity business, we do not believe that the minor investment we've made in that business of late is -- we believe that investment will pay off. We are happy with the growth of that business. We're happy with the margins, and we're happy with the overall prospect of that business going forward. And the cash burn from that business in the last quarter was about 40 to $50,000.

    可以,我可以回答這兩個問題。我是Jay Peterson。首先,目前公司有32名全職員工。其中8名員工從事會計、主管職務或智慧財產相關職務。其餘24名在我們的軟體業務部門;就NetSimplicity業務而言,我們不認為近期對該業務所做的小額投資是——我們相信這項投資會有回報。我們對該業務的成長感到滿意。我們對毛利率感到滿意,也對該業務未來的整體前景感到滿意。而該業務在上一季的現金消耗約為4萬到5萬美元。

  • Michael James - Analyst

    Michael James - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Your next question comes from David DeWitt of DeWitt Capital.

    您的下一個問題來自 DeWitt Capital 的 David DeWitt。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • Good morning, gentlemen. As somebody who is relatively new to the story, and try to get my hands around the technology that is going to be examined here in the Markman hearing, any background at all about how the technology was invented, how the Company came about owning the technology, I think this would be helpful. I've been in intellectual property situations before, and so I usually have had some better handle on the steps along the way. And there are companies like NTP that go out and acquire patents for others, and they -- but this company seems to have acquired a company, Compression Labs, and I guess at one point it wasn't -- nobody questioned who invented this technology, but any comment in that regard would be helpful.

    各位先生,早安。作為一個相對剛接觸這個故事的人,並試著掌握將在 Markman 聽證會中被檢視的技術,我想了解任何關於這項技術如何被發明、公司如何取得並擁有該技術的背景,我認為這會很有幫助。我以前也處理過智慧財產權相關情況,所以通常對一路走來的步驟會更有概念。也有像 NTP 這樣的公司會去向他人收購專利——但這家公司似乎是收購了一家公司 Compression Labs,而我猜在某個時間點,這項技術是由誰發明的並未受到質疑;不過若能就此發表一些看法,將會很有幫助。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Sure, David. This is Dick Snyder. I would say that the background behind this was that Vtel, the predecessor of Forgent was in the video conferencing business, had a very deep and rich technology background, a large development department that looked at developing video codecs. In other words, the ability to process video over networks. And in doing that, they acquired a company called Compression Labs, and in acquiring that, that technology was very similar to Vtel's own, so the combined patent portfolio after the acquisition contained many patents related to compression and to video technology. One of those is the '672 patent which relates to image compression. And from there, obviously, we have looked at presenting this patent in the market as infringed by people who do that particular process. One of the other patents out of the Vtel portfolio is the '746 patent which is the other patent that we are prosecuting at the moment.

    當然可以,David。我是 Dick Snyder。我會說,這背後的背景是:Vtel(Forgent 的前身)當時在視訊會議業務領域,擁有非常深厚且豐富的技術背景,以及一個規模很大的研發部門,專注於開發視訊編解碼器。換句話說,就是在網路上處理視訊的能力。在這個過程中,他們收購了一家名為 Compression Labs 的公司;在收購之後,該技術與 Vtel 自身的技術非常相近,因此併購後的合併專利組合包含了許多與壓縮及視訊技術相關的專利。其中之一就是與影像壓縮相關的 '672 專利。而從那之後,顯然我們一直在市場上主張該專利被從事該特定流程的人所侵害。Vtel 專利組合中的另一件專利是 '746 專利,也就是我們目前正在推進的另一件專利。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • So if you looked back at this ten years ago and Compression Labs was -- I mean would it have been apparent to somebody observing the industry back when this was all occurring that, yes, Compression Labs really did create this, and then sort of just people's attention just faded away from it? Because that's -- you're talking about a huge, huge market here.

    所以如果回頭看十年前,Compression Labs 當時——我的意思是,對於當時觀察這個產業的人來說,是否會很明顯地知道:是的,Compression Labs 的確創造了這項技術,然後只是大家的注意力逐漸淡去?因為——你們談的是一個非常、非常龐大的市場。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Yes, I think what you're pointing to is how did this become part of a -- of kind of a standard, and that really, those folks who were part of the standards body were well aware of the patents available, and proceeded forward. So those in the know, if you will, the technology folks who have created various technologies for their products along the way to use, have been aware of the background behind the Compression Labs patent. It's just to the extent to which people know that it's embedded in their product sometimes that can be a discussion.

    是的,我想你指出的是:這是如何成為某種——某種標準的一部分;而實際上,那些參與標準制定機構的人非常清楚有哪些可用的專利,並且仍然繼續往前推進。所以所謂「知情者」——也就是一路以來為其產品打造各種技術的技術人員——一直都知道 Compression Labs 專利背後的來龍去脈。只是有時候,人們對於它在多大程度上被嵌入到他們的產品中,這件事本身可能就會引發討論。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • And your last question comes from [Carter Waynbeck] of Concord Equity. Please proceed.

    而您的最後一個問題來自 Concord Equity 的 [Carter Waynbeck]。請繼續。

  • Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

    Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

  • Good morning gentlemen. I have two questions. First, regarding -- I've done a lot of -- I spent a lot of time reading court documents, and I've noticed that there have been a number of defendants that have notified Microsoft in the lieu of a letter of indemnification, basically stating that if Microsoft -- if we actually win this case and Forgent prevails, that they're going to ask Microsoft to pay their way. And I think a lot of people are not familiar with that, and I want to understand it a little bit better, why exactly they're doing this and who they are that are doing it and what your thoughts are. That's my first question.

    各位先生,早安。我有兩個問題。第一個,關於——我做了很多——我花了很多時間閱讀法院文件,我注意到有不少被告已經通知微軟,作為替代一封補償(indemnification)函的方式,基本上是在說:如果微軟——如果我們真的贏了這個案子、而 Forgent 勝訴,他們將要求微軟替他們支付相關費用。我想很多人對此並不熟悉,我想更了解一些:他們為什麼要這麼做、是哪些人這麼做、以及你們的看法是什麼。這是我的第一個問題。

  • Second question is, the second patent, which you guys haven't spoken a lot about except to really put the name up, from what I understand it's regarding DVR. What I want to understand about it is, is TiVo the same as DVR, and if so, what part of DVR that you guys claim to have as a patent and why is TiVo not involved in the litigation?

    第二個問題是,第二件專利,你們除了把名稱提出來之外其實沒有談很多;據我了解它與 DVR 有關。我想了解的是:TiVo 是否等同於 DVR?如果是的話,你們主張擁有專利的是 DVR 的哪一部分?以及為什麼 TiVo 沒有被納入訴訟?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Okay, Carter, this is Dick. With regard to Microsoft, as you know, Microsoft has a lot of large customers in the computer industry. And it's our understanding that they have a variety of different arrangements with their customers, including indemnity clauses, and I'm sure that this particular patent issue is one that they're considering in regard to their relationship with their customers, but it really is immaterial to Forgent. We look at infringement by product and, of course, we talked with those customers specifically with regard to their infringement. So I think Microsoft is dealing with that, and we're continuing with discussions with everyone.

    好的,Carter,我是 Dick。關於微軟,如你所知,微軟在電腦產業有很多大型客戶。據我們了解,他們與客戶之間有各式各樣的安排,包括補償條款(indemnity clauses);我相信這個特定的專利議題,是他們在考量其與客戶關係時會納入評估的一項因素,但這對 Forgent 其實並不重要。我們是以產品是否侵權來看待問題;當然,我們也就其侵權情況與那些客戶進行了直接溝通。所以我想微軟正在處理那部分,而我們也會持續與所有人進行討論。

  • Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

    Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

  • Are you still going to put some more pressure on Microsoft?

    你們還會對微軟施加更多壓力嗎?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Well, I'm sure they feel obligated to their customers, and they certainly have behaved that way in the past, and they have a reputation for standing up for their customers. I think that's certainly something they're going to continue to do. With regard to the DVR patent, that much the same as our '672 cuts across a wide swath of different applications. Certainly TiVo is well-known in the industry, but I can't comment really on -- with regard to the application of this particular technology or any particular customer.

    嗯,我相信他們對客戶感到有義務,而且他們過去確實也是以那種方式行事,並且他們有為客戶挺身而出的名聲。我認為這當然是他們會持續做的事情。至於 DVR 專利,它與我們的 '672 一樣,涵蓋了非常廣泛的不同應用。TiVo 在業界當然很知名,但我無法就——就這項特定技術的應用或任何特定客戶發表評論。

  • Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

    Carter Waynbeck - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • And you have a follow-up question from Richard West. Please proceed.

    您有一個來自 Richard West 的追問。請繼續。

  • Richard West - Analyst

    Richard West - Analyst

  • Yes, I'd like to go back to the RIM announcement and agreement. When you announced that -- didn't make any comment as to if that was a one-time payment or a running royalty future payment. Can you comment now?

    是的,我想回到 RIM 的公告與協議。你們宣布時——並沒有評論那是一次性付款,還是未來持續性的權利金(running royalty)付款。你們現在可以評論嗎?

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • Yes, Richard. This is Jay. It was a one-time payment to comprehend past sales and projected future sales.

    可以,Richard。我是 Jay。那是一筆一次性付款,用以涵蓋過去的銷售以及預估的未來銷售。

  • Richard West - Analyst

    Richard West - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • And your next question comes from David DeWitt. Please proceed.

    您的下一個問題來自 David DeWitt。請繼續。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • Again, relatively new to the situation, you're looking at Microsoft as a defendant, and I'm sure there's a large addressable market there along with everybody else that's in there, and I don't know if you've -- I mean just generally speaking, is there any way to quantify what it is we're looking at, or is there any way you can discuss from an investor standpoint what would be the best case, worst case, or any general information in that regard in terms of royalty rates or anything else you can say in that regard?

    我再次說明,我對這個情況相對較新;你們把微軟列為被告,我相信那裡有很大的可觸及市場,和其他所有在其中的公司一樣。我不知道你們是否——我的意思是,一般而言,有沒有辦法量化我們正在看的規模?或者從投資人的角度,你們是否能討論一下最佳情境、最差情境,或任何在權利金費率或其他方面你們能說的一般性資訊?

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • David, I can echo what we've said in the past. We believe this is a large opportunity. There's definitely some uncertainty as we go forward trying to capitalize on that opportunity. Program to date, I mentioned that we have about 50-odd licenses, and we have noticed -- sent notification of our patents to literally hundreds of additional companies. How that gets quantified in terms of the opportunity in the future cash flow for the Company is just uncertain at this point in time. We've got $105 million from those 52 licensees, and projecting this, in terms of the timing and the magnitude is just very difficult going forward.

    David,我可以重申我們過去所說的。我們相信這是一個很大的機會。在我們往前推進、試圖把握這個機會的過程中,確實存在一些不確定性。截至目前的計畫進度,我提到我們大約有 50 多份授權,而且我們已經向數百家其他公司發出我們專利的通知。至於未來公司現金流的機會要如何量化,目前仍不確定。我們已從這 52 家被授權方取得 1.05 億美元;而要往前推估其時間點與規模,確實非常困難。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • Yes I guess I see some of the past licensees were significant in size. I mean, I think I saw one for 15 million and one for 16 million, in that range.

    是的,我想我看到過去的一些被授權方規模相當可觀。我的意思是,我想我看到一個是1,500萬,另一個是1,600萬,大概在那個範圍。

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • Yes. And we believe if we're successful we will have those size of agreements going forward.

    是的。而且我們相信,如果我們成功,未來我們將會有那種規模的協議。

  • David DeWitt - Analyst

    David DeWitt - Analyst

  • Okay. Well, that just gives me an idea what possibly could happen if you guys are successful. Thank you.

    好的。嗯,這讓我對如果你們成功,可能會發生什麼有個概念。謝謝。

  • Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

    Jay Peterson - VP, CFO

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Thank you, sir. Your next question comes from [Blake Dettum] of National Securities.

    謝謝您,先生。下一個問題來自 National Securities 的 [Blake Dettum]。

  • Blake Dettum - Analyst

    Blake Dettum - Analyst

  • How are you, gentlemen?

    你們好,各位先生?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Good, thank you.

    很好,謝謝。

  • Blake Dettum - Analyst

    Blake Dettum - Analyst

  • I have a question. When the day finally comes, and I do feel that it will come, when the 40-odd defendants finally see the light, Forgent is on the winning end of all this litigation. Where is Forgent five years down the road?

    我有一個問題。當那一天終於到來,而且我確實覺得會到來,當那四十多名被告終於看清情勢,Forgent 在這些訴訟中站在勝利的一方時,五年後的 Forgent 會是什麼樣子?

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Well, that's a great question, and I think it has seeds in the discussion about what we're going to do with the cash. The Board is very interested in making sure, number one, that we take care of the current situation and that we do return the value to shareholders through these patents. And we have a variety of ways to do that. Short-term after we're successful we can certainly look at things like dividends and buybacks, but we believe ultimately too, that we can deliver value through a growing and profitable business. That may start with our software business being large enough to be able to return an investment to the shareholders, and there may be other opportunities as well. But for now, we're really focused on the first step, which is making sure that we are successful.

    嗯,這是個很好的問題,我認為這也埋下了我們要如何運用現金的討論伏筆。董事會非常關注,第一,確保我們處理好目前的狀況,並且透過這些專利把價值回饋給股東。而我們有多種方式可以做到。短期來看,在我們成功之後,我們當然可以考慮像是股利與庫藏股回購之類的作法,但我們也相信,最終我們可以透過一個成長且獲利的事業來創造價值。這可能會從我們的軟體業務成長到足以為股東帶來投資回報開始,此外也可能還有其他機會。但就目前而言,我們確實專注在第一步,也就是確保我們能夠成功。

  • Blake Dettum - Analyst

    Blake Dettum - Analyst

  • Thank you.

    謝謝。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Thank you. Your next question comes from [Robert Strugel] of RIS Investments. Please proceed.

    謝謝。下一個問題來自 RIS Investments 的 [Robert Strugel]。請繼續。

  • Robert Strugel - Analyst

    Robert Strugel - Analyst

  • Let me ask you, we've been involved with Vtel, and now with for Forgent for a long period of time, and you guys were at the forefront at one time with Vtel, and it seems like you just -- looking at your patent protection, you're not really developing any new products or doing anything other than suing other companies. Our stock has gone from $5.50 down to under $1 at times, but now the whole value of the company is 40 million, a little over 40 million, maybe closer to 50, and we collected 100 on so-called patent protection lawsuits. So the question I have is, why is the market looking at our stock so cheaply? Do they feel that we are going to be overwhelmed with these litigation expenses, or we're not going to prevail, or why is nobody noticing us? And the third question, the next question is, why do the insiders have so little shares? We have guys with 40,000 shares, 50,000 on $1.73 stock. Seems to me that we should be holding a little more stock in the Company from the insiders to show that they're really as optimistic as they're talking on the phone today.

    我想問一下,我們長期以來一直參與 Vtel,現在也長期參與 Forgent;你們曾經在 Vtel 時期走在前端,但看起來你們——從你們的專利保護來看——並沒有在開發任何新產品,也沒有做除了起訴其他公司以外的事情。我們的股價從5.50美元跌到有時不到1美元,但現在公司的整體價值是4,000萬美元出頭,可能接近5,000萬,而我們從所謂的專利保護訴訟中收到了1億。所以我想問的是,為什麼市場把我們的股票看得這麼便宜?他們是覺得我們會被這些訴訟費用壓垮,或是我們不會勝訴,還是為什麼沒有人注意到我們?第三個問題、下一個問題是,為什麼內部人持股這麼少?我們有人持有4萬股、5萬股,在1.73美元的股價下。在我看來,內部人應該在公司持有更多股票,才能顯示他們真的像今天電話會議上所說的那麼樂觀。

  • Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

    Richard Snyder - Chairman, CEO

  • Well, first of all I appreciate you staying with us as long as you have. As you mentioned, Vtel had a very rich history and background, but frankly the Company was failing, or it did fail in that business. The video conferencing segment of the industry did not produce the kind of growth and expectations as a whole. And it's continued to evolve. On our part, we were really forced to look at changing ourselves, reinventing ourselves, if you will, and looking at what assets that were here and available that we could ensure that we gave a adequate return to shareholders, and that turned out to be our patent portfolio. That's what we're focused on today. It may evolve. As the previous questioner asked, what do we do in the future? It may evolve into something else. But today we know that these are the strongest assets that the Company has, and we are focused on making sure that we develop and maximize the most from them.

    嗯,首先我很感謝您一路以來長期支持我們。如您所提,Vtel 有非常豐富的歷史與背景,但坦白說,公司在那個業務上正在失敗,或者說確實失敗了。整體而言,視訊會議產業的那個細分領域並沒有帶來預期中的成長與期待。而且它仍在持續演進。就我們而言,我們確實被迫去思考改變自己、重新塑造自己,並檢視現有且可用的資產,確保能為股東帶來適當的回報,而結果就是我們的專利組合。這就是我們今天所專注的。它可能會演變。如同前一位提問者問的,我們未來要做什麼?它可能會演變成其他事情。但今天我們知道,這些是公司最強的資產,我們專注於確保我們能夠開發並將其價值最大化。

  • With regard to insiders, the Company has changed dramatically. We are a very small company, moving from probably at the heyday of around 500 employees, we're down, as Jay said this morning, to 32. So that has a big effect with regard to insiders and what shares they hold. It is a volatile situation, or has been, but I believe that if you look at the holdings of the key people, this is fairly standard for this kind of size opportunity.

    至於內部人持股,公司已經發生了巨大的變化。我們是一家非常小的公司,從鼎盛時期大約500名員工,現在如 Jay 今天早上所說,已降到32名。因此,這對內部人以及他們持有的股份數量有很大的影響。這是一個波動的情況,或者說一直以來都是,但我相信如果你看關鍵人士的持股,對於這種規模的機會而言,這相當標準。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • That concludes the question and answer session. I would like to turn the call over to make Michael Noonan for closing comments.

    問答環節到此結束。我想把電話會議交給 Michael Noonan 作結語。

  • Michael Noonan - IR

    Michael Noonan - IR

  • Thanks, and thanks again everybody for participating in our call today. We look forward to speaking with you again soon, and good-bye.

    謝謝,也再次感謝各位今天參與我們的電話會議。我們期待很快能再次與各位交流,再見。

  • Operator

    Operator

  • Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your participation in today's conference. This concludes the presentation. You may now disconnect. Everyone have a great day.

    各位女士、先生,感謝您參與今天的會議。本次簡報到此結束。您現在可以掛線。祝各位有美好的一天。