使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Insignia Systems fourth-quarter earnings conference call. Just a reminder, today's conference is being recorded. Except for the historical information mentioned, the matters discussed in this conference call are forward-looking statements. The Company's actual results could differ materially from these forward-looking statements as a result of a number of factors, including risks and uncertainties as described in the Company's Form 10-KA for the year ended December 31, 2010 and other recent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Company wishes to caution listeners not to place undue reliance upon any such forward-looking statements, which speak only as the date made.
And at this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Mr. Scott Drill, President and CEO. Mr. Drill, you may begin.
- President, CEO
Thank you, and thank you all for participating in this conference call in which we will discuss our fourth quarter and year-end results and then answer any questions you may have. With me are Glen Dall, our Chief Operating Officer, John Gonsior, our CFO, and Al Jones, our Senior Vice President of Sales. I'm going to now turn it over to John who will discuss the numbers.
- CFO
Thanks, Scott. As you can see in today's press release, we completed another disappointing quarter. Our fourth-quarter results were as follows. We had net sales of $4.2 million, of which $3.6 million was POPS revenue. This compares to net sales of $7.3 million for the fourth quarter of 2010, of which $6.7 million was POPS revenue. There was a net loss of $388,000, or $0.03 per share. This compares to net income of $5.4 million, or $0.32 per diluted share for the fourth quarter of 2010. On a year-to-date basis, we had net sales of $17.2 million, of which $15 million was POPS revenue. This compares to net sales of approximately $30 million for 2010, of which $27.2 million was POPS revenue.
Net income was $51.1 million, or $3.35 per basic share and $3.29 per diluted share. This compares to net income of $6.6 million, or $0.42 per basic share and $0.39 per diluted share for 2010. Net income in the 2011 period included a gain from the settlement of our litigation against News America of approximately $89.8 million before income taxes. Net income for the 2010 year included a tax benefit of approximately $5.7 million related to the valuation allowance reversal that took place in 2010. With that, I will turn it back over to Scott.
- President, CEO
Thanks, John. Our business in 2011 and currently is extremely disappointing. Although this is the case, our sales force is optimistic about the second half of 2012. Nevertheless, we felt it was necessary to make some significant expense reduction moves immediately to protect shareholder value. Last Friday, we eliminated 34 positions which represented 29% of our workforce. In addition, we reduced the base salaries of our sales force and certain members of our Management team, including me. I accepted a 50% decrease. Further, we cut spending on some discretionary programs. While these decisions were tough, we felt they were mandatory under the circumstances. The yearly savings will be approximately $3.1 million. We will take a first-quarter restructuring charge of approximately $450,000. The goal is to return to profitability, and that can now be achieved at a quarterly POPS revenue level of approximately $5.5 million. And based on our bi-weekly sales conference call is morning, we think this is achievable in the near future.
The other key decision was naming Glen Dall to the new position of Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer. Glen will have line authority over all functional areas of the Company except for finance. Glen has been with the Company since September of 2009 in the role Vice President of Business Development. Prior to that, he spent 19 years in various positions at Valassis. With that, I'm going to turn it over to Glen who's going to will talk a little bit about our relationships with News America and Valassis.
- COO
As a relates to our relationship with News America, I'm very pleased to be able to speak to the fact that we resolved many of the business issues that we had in 2011 which we feel confident will allow our salespeople and our business people to focus on the business of the business and revenue improvement. Our relationship with Valassis continues to be strong and we continue to work with them on ways that we can improve our go to market strategy with both CPGs and with increasing our retail network. With that, I can turn it back to John.
- CFO
Okay, thanks, Glen. And then just some financial highlights I thought worth mentioning include the following. Legal expenses continued to decline in the fourth quarter of 2011, our legal expense was $135,000 compared to $704,000 in the fourth quarter of 2010. Our legal expense for the 2011 year was $1.6 million versus $2.1 million in 2010. Our balance sheet remains strong with $23.2 million in cash and equivalents as of December 31, 2011. Finally, we have approximately $8.3 million of the POPS orders on the books for 2012, $3.5 million of which are set to run in the first quarter. At this point in 2011 we had approximately $8.7 million of POPS orders on the books, with approximately $4.3 million set to run in the first quarter of 2011. Additionally, we did at a program in the past couple of hours that should account for approximately $200,000 of revenue which is set to run later this year.
- President, CEO
Okay, thank you John. With that, I'm going to open it up for questions.
Operator
(Operator Instructions) [Mark Karwoski], private investor.
- Analyst
Hi, guys. I came into the call a little late, but I did go through all the financial information. I guess the one question that comes to my mind is the reorganization or the reduction of 29 employees. My question is, you hate to see anybody lose jobs, but this kind of seems like it's way after the fact. I mean if the relationship is indeed getting better with News America and things are going well with Valassis, where did this epiphany come to finally reduce the staff by one third of the workforce and why wasn't something like that done six or eight or nine months ago?
- President, CEO
Because we were optimistic that the back half of 2011 would be much better than it ultimately turned out to be. So frankly, in early November, we were considering restructuring. We thought that we would give ourselves, and we discussed it at a December 6 Board meeting, but we thought we'd give ourselves until the end of February to see if the business could turnaround. And remember, through a lot of 2011, we were not getting along that well with News America, we were in front of the federal magistrate on several occasions trying to get our issues resolved and the hope was, and as Glen said, most of our issues are now resolved, the hope was that once we get -- got through that process that-- and got some clarity on different issues, the most significant of which was sign content, what the sign can look like, what it has on it, that then things would pick up. But they haven't, so we did it in this timeframe.
- Analyst
So then we can basically assume that although the relationship appears to be better, you guys aren't extremely optimistic about business for the rest of the year, otherwise you would be cutting one third of your workforce.
- President, CEO
We're optimistic it's going to be much better than it is in the first quarter and then it was in the third and fourth quarters of last year. But we just felt, as I said in the narrative and I don't know if you were on for it, but we just felt it was necessary at this time to make these cuts to protect shareholder value. And so we did it. And actually, the number was not 29, that was the percentage that it represented. The number was 34 positions that were eliminated.
- Analyst
And you do guys anticipate any type of a profit then for 2012? Seems like the bar has been lowered quite a bit. Are we hopeful for a nice profit this year?
- President, CEO
We're hopeful that -- there probably won't be a profit for the year because there will be a loss in Q1. As I said, if you had been on for the narrative, we break even at about $5.5 million. I'm optimistic that we can get there in the foreseeable future. I'm not giving a specific timeframe. If we do $16.5 million and I am just picking that number because it ties into breakeven, $16.5 million in POPS revenue, the last three quarters of the year, that should be breakeven-ish. It's all whether we break even or make a profit is purely a function of where revenue comes in.
- Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
- President, CEO
Thanks.
Operator
[Bob Ramsdell], investor.
- Analyst
Hi Scott, how are you doing? Are these-- a couple questions for Glen. Number one, the relationship with News is good and we have $8 million going into '12, are there any orders that have been garnered from the News relationship going forward? Or are we just hopeful that we'll have some orders through that relationship?
- COO
I don't have the exact specifics Bob, thanks for the question. But in terms of the exact specifics on the percentage of revenue that's falling through the news network, I don't have that at my fingertips.
- President, CEO
I do.
- COO
Okay, Scott does.
- President, CEO
Okay, as of a couple weeks ago, the percentage on the books for Q2 is 29%. Again, as of a couple weeks ago the number was 21% for Q1.
- Analyst
Okay. And Glen, in the announcement, we talked about digital marketing products. Could you be a little clearer as to what that kind of -- is that a product that we have developed ourselves? Is it a joint venture with somebody? And what is the revenue model and what are the hopes going forward for that?
- COO
Bob, at this point in time, we do have a pilot test scheduled and we're now soliciting from some key CPG clients for that pilot test. It is with a partnership with another company, but this time we don't have an agreement written up with them, so we're not able to publicly disclose that information. And part of the pilot really is to get something out there to see how consumers are interacting with it. It's basically a variant of our sign that would include a digital interactive component for consumers in aisle, and what we're really hoping to see is to what degree consumers interact with that. How successful it is for the participants on our CPG side as well. And then based on that and potentially some other pilots and tests, we could then start developing some revenue models. But it would be premature to do that right now.
- Analyst
Is the-- where does the cost of the hardware lie, with the retailer or with us, or with the partnership?
- COO
It's some of it-- it's really not a hardware cost, Bob, it's more of a software cost and it actually would be leveraging the mobile devices of consumers, so smartphones or cell phones or hand-held devices.
- Analyst
I see, okay. I mean and there are any number of competitive products out there in that world. I assume -- I'm sure you're aware. And the less question is, and I asked this last time, do you feel as though this Groupon type of -- the group-- actually it's a question for Al probably more than you Glen, or at least at this point. Is Groupon and all of these coupon kind of things that pop up in your computer 25 or 30 a day, do you feel as though that's hitting into the old in-store world, or is that something that -- so that's the question? Right, I think we did address this last time, Bob, but yes certainly it's a good question. I think the Groupon or LivingSocial, those type of couponing models really from a CPG perspective and when you look at how CPG clients, the turn in grocery and the profit model there, it's probably not the way they're going to go and we really haven't seen too many CPGs. Some have dabbled in it, and maybe like a General Mills who has a lot of products. But in terms of in-store, that's really not the model that we're looking that thinks-- we think is going to be successful. There are a lot of other online couponing or what's called load to card, basically loading a couponing value onto a shopper's frequent shopper card. Those are the people that we've been talking to, and that's more similar to this project that we're working on now. Great. All right.
- President, CEO
Thanks, Bob.
Operator
[Mike Reynolds], investor.
- Analyst
First question, well first I want to say I know it's difficult and affects a lot of good people, but I want to commend you on the tough decision to implement the restructuring plan including the pay cut, I think that goes a long way. But one of the things I wanted to address was there's been a lot of chatter on the message boards, I'm sure you guys don't follow that, but people are talking about the bonuses last year when the settlement was reached and talking about the insider stock sales in late November. So just want to give you a chance to address I guess maybe the insider sales. You mentioned earlier that in early November you were considering a restructuring. Then in late November, I mean quite a hefty -- I don't want to misstate the amount, but $1 million was spent on buying shares from you and other insiders. And I know it was taken at the lower of certain price and average over the last several days, but the Company had also been in the marketplace buying those last several days.
So I'm just kind of curious, have you-- do you want to address that or kind of talk through what the rationale was for that? I know you mentioned tax issues, but anything else driving that? I just-- I'm an investor and I want you to do well but I've seen examples like this were things like that have resulted in shareholder lawsuits and I don't want to see any of that happen there, so I'm just kind of curious if you could talk through the logic on the bonuses, the logic on the insider sales, everything was done with legal counsel, there are no issues?
- President, CEO
No, there are no issues. First of all, let me address your bonus question. That was tied purely to the litigation settlement. That was a plan that had been approved by -- I mean to the latter, it had been approved previously by shareholders. We --
- Analyst
Good.
- President, CEO
Okay, but we've then voluntarily ended that plan candidly because lead counsel fall to the optics on it would not look good to a jury. So the formal plan that have been adopted and approved by shareholders went away, but after the settlement, those bonuses that were paid to roughly 16 employees were 100% in line with the plan that had been approved, and then for legal strategy reasons, dropped. So I hope I have addressed that question--
- Analyst
Thank you, yes.
- President, CEO
Fully, okay. So there-- we didn't -- again I'm being repetitive, but to the letter, the amounts paid were consistent with the previously approved plan.
- Analyst
And what about the stock sales, yes?
- President, CEO
Yes, secondly, when those sales were made, the status of our business had been fully disclosed. I think our earnings call for the third quarter was November 3. We had a horrendous third quarter, had an operating loss north of $2.8 million. It was clear we were going to do better in the fourth quarter, we weren't -- if I-- I hope I didn't misspeak, we are considering a future restructuring if the business didn't come back but not a restructuring in the November/December timeframe. And in fact, what we ended up doing is consistent with that. We waited to see if the business would come back. It didn't to the extent we had hoped it would, we're doing better than we did in the third quarter, but that's not saying much. And so that's the first thing, first thing I want to say about that. There had been full disclosure on the state of the business.
Secondly, with respect to those sales later in November, and I think they took place the first three -- the week of Thanksgiving, so fairly shortly after the third quarter release, the issue was alternative minimum tax. And I don't know if you're aware of how that works, but at the time of exercise, let say you've got an option at $1 and the market price is $7, you've got tax-- the exerciser has tax liability on that $6.00 spread unless there's a disqualifying disposition which would include a sale. So it's a scenario where let's say somebody have 100,000 options, there'd be a paper gain, if the options were at $1.00, market price was $7, there'd be a paper gain of $600,000. So when the stock comes off, the optionee finds himself or herself in a position where tax is getting paid on phantom gains that were never realized, and the alternate-- so the Company did buy some shares from some Officers. The alternative was for the officers to sell the stock on the open market. Now one could argue well that's not practical given how thinly we're traded. But one way or another, people would have been getting rid of that stock to not pay tax on the phantom gains.
So there was careful consideration given by the Board. I had to sell -- I don't mind sharing this with you, I had a $1.4 million tax problem. When I exercised some non qualified options as will some qualified ISOs back in the February time frame, I didn't sell any stock, or I sold a small amount of some stock I already had to help finance the option exercises. I had to pay ordinary income tax on that gain and I couldn't even get rid of that gain on the non qualified shares. So anyway, I'm rambling on, but I had a $1.4 million tax problem. Other people had tax problems not of that magnitude, but certainly very significant and more than they could deal with based on their own financial situation. So--
- Analyst
Yes, well in the future, wouldn't someone just sell the options or the stock at the time the options vest so they don't have to deal with this liability later, or is that not how people typically do it? I mean I hear what you're saying and I appreciate the problem.
- President, CEO
Well I wish I had, okay, but I was optimistic. Anytime the CEO sells stock, even if it's on an option exercise, the CEO and other Officers get a lot of flak. So I believed with 100% conviction that the News America business arrangement was going to result in significant revenue growth through the year. I knew I was going to have to deal with some tax issues later in the year. My personal hope was that the stock would be $10 when I was dealing with those issues. But obviously, that didn't happen.
- Analyst
Yes, well, all right, I appreciate your candor. It think it just was something out there, people were kind of ranting about and I think rightfully so, people have their own money put in the Company as well and I think it's helpful to understand the background on it and hopefully the efforts that you've talked about today will put us in a position we don't have to talk about losses in the future, we can talk about how much money we're all going to make.
- President, CEO
Well the politicians always talk about changing the tax code and dealing with this alternative minimum tax issue which is incredibly unfair, and if you remember when the tech bubble burst back around 2000, a lot of officers out in Silicon Valley who had options, they exercised them, let's say the stock given stock was $100, I'll use the same example, the option price might have been $1 or $10. Well they owed money on a spread and then the new stocks crashed and they couldn't get out and then they ended up going bankrupt. There are many stories like that from that timeframe. So it's -- the politicians should do what they say they're going to do and get rid of this alternative minimum tax the way it's currently in forced. Okay, thanks.
Operator
David Johnson with Maxus.
- Analyst
Good afternoon. First I'd like to applaud your costs cutting, I guess everyone could be a little concerned on the timing, should we have done it sooner or not, but happy to see it in place. My question staring at today's results are I'm a little surprised at cost of sales have crept down so little when the net sales are down 40%, yet cost of sales are down just over $300,000. Is there some reason we can't drive that down more or we haven't seen a larger decrease in that expense category?
- CFO
Well this is John. One thing on that is with the cost cutting moves we did make, we will pick up some of that in reduced cost of sales going forward. But the reason you're not seeing that go down proportionately to revenue is that a very high percentage of our cost of sales, especially when sales are low are related to fixed cost that don't really go away. So when your sales are only say $3.5 million, $4 million, the gross margin percentage of his miniscule but if that just goes up $1 million, the gross margin percentage is going to go up exponentially. And so that's the reason you're not seeing the cost of sales number coming down, it's just because a lot of those cost are fairly fixed. The variable component of our cost of sales is not very high relative to total cost when the revenues are that low or when the cost of sales or that low rather.
- Analyst
Is there any way we can try to drive more of our cost to be variable so we can be more nimble in times like this?
- CFO
We've -- we're constantly looking at things like that. That isn't something that we've -- we've tried to go as far as we can with it I guess, without anything more significant being done. But at this time, I guess we've done what we can and we should be a little more nimble now, just given that we've taken out some of those fixed cost I mentioned.
- Analyst
All right, thank you.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
[Bill Hern], private investor.
- Analyst
Say a quick question about the cash on hand. there's $23.2 million of cash as of December 31, have all the income taxes been paid for the gain?
- CFO
There's about I'd say $0.5 million left to pay, but other than that, yes.
- Analyst
And any other deferred expenses that are also in that legal fees, compensation, things like that?
- President, CEO
Yes, the bonus-- this is Scott again, the bonus paid to me in connection with the litigation was spread over three years for the benefit of the Company because unless it's a pre-approved plan, officially pre approved, the Company could not deduct over $1 million in compensation for me and anyone fiscal year. So for the benefit of the Company, rather than taking it as a lump sum, two thirds of it, which is $1.6 million, is the two thirds, was deferred over two years. So there's another $800,000 that will be paid this March, and a third $800,000 paid next year.
- Analyst
Okay, so let's just say if you've got about $2 million of the $23 million that's due still from old business, do you see the cash going flat or up next year? Or down, I should say.
- President, CEO
Well we hope, as I said earlier, to get to at least a breakeven situation. I'm not predicting in the second quarter there is some chance we can get there. And in that scenario, cash would be flat through the end of the year. We think we're going to end the first quarter with cash between $20 million and $21 million roughly. And of course we've got the restructuring charge that we're going to take. There were some severance packages for the 34 people that we let go on Friday. So cash should hopefully remain in the $20 million range.
- Analyst
Okay. All right, thank you.
- President, CEO
Yes, thank you.
Operator
[Jon Roginski] with Diversified Financial.
- Analyst
I got a couple for-- a questions actually. First of all CPG budgets, we-- obviously they were crunched down pretty handily in 2011 and I've been reading a lot of that had to do with coupon usage. And one thing I was wondering was if you see any signs of CPG budgets or CPGs rather turning more towards more in-store versus couponing for 2012? I also know that, I guess that some of the CPG budgets reset later in the year as well.
Second part of the question is, I'm kind of reading this and I'm hoping I'm correct, that the News Corp relationship is getting more healthy, and I'm wondering if you still see that as your number one growth area? And if you do, do still have some semblance of hope that you might still get what you went into it for in the endgame?
- SVP- Sales
This is Al Jones. As far as the CPG budgets, we are seeing them come back a little bit. In terms of participants, we're up to about 30 participants in Q1 versus last year around 19. So we're getting more participants of the program, they are being a little bit more account specific in their planning and targeting their dollars very specifically. So-- but we are seeing the budgets come back a little bit from, as you mentioned, they were down about 22% last year. So I think that's it.
- President, CEO
No, there was another part.
- Analyst
Well again I was looking more towards the opening up later in the year. Do you see them opening up further due to the fiscal budget resets? And do you think they'll target more towards the in-store or do you think they're going to go with FSI or something else?
- SVP- Sales
I'm optimistic on the in-store. I mean we're seeing our book sales for the second half be higher than they were last year. And we're seeing a lot of new item launches that are planned by the clients that we're hoping to be part of, so I see them picking up.
- President, CEO
Glen, do you want to talk about --
- COO
Sure. And then Jon, I'll key in for the second part of your question, I think relative to the News America portion of our relationship. And actually one of the things we also did in December was we brought on in-house counsel and Colleen Davenport and then also a different strategy in another commercial litigator here in Minneapolis that as part of our business strategy we think has helped with the News America situation. On the business side, like I said, we did come to resolve on a number of issues and are more confident going forward that it's been stabilized.
But also from a business perspective, it's allowed us to focus more on the business and on our CPG clients knowing that we have an in-house person that's going to be managing the legal perspective and legal side of our News America relationship. So we really do see a significant part of our business growth flowing through the News America network as well as the ability to be able to add on additional retailers through that agreement but also continuing to focus on our own retail network and growing that as well as our relationship with Valassis and their retail network.
- Analyst
Okay and the last part of the question was, and this is kind our of my own curiosity, is do still you see yourselves able to achieve what you went into the News agreement for when all is said and done?
- COO
I would say--
- Analyst
Obviously when you guys struck to deal back in February of 2011, you had something in mind that you would value that deal at. I guess I'm wondering did the 12 month delay or so, did that lower your expectations or do you still see us coming out of this with what we went in it for?
- COO
It definitely did set us back from a timing support as you alluded to. I think just because of our business resources and our focus of working through the fine lines of the agreement.
- Analyst
Yes, I get the timing thing, we understand that. But I'm wondering if we're still going to get what we wanted out of this thing?
- COO
I would say our optimism has been tempered a bit by our experience. We had expectations and goals going into the relationship that we didn't know to be factually correct or not. And I would say that that's -- while there's potentially not the same amount of optimism in our goals, we are cautiously optimistic and feel it's going to be a significant part of our growth.
- Analyst
Okay. Can you quantify that at all?
- COO
I wouldn't be able to at this point.
- Analyst
Okay. Fair enough.
- President, CEO
Thanks, Jon.
Operator
[Bob Ramsdell], investor.
- Analyst
Just a quick question, and I've asked it a million times and I apologize, these 6000 Dollar Stores, Scott, are we ever going to -- is that just kind of anything that the CPGs care about or can we get them to put [storings] up? Or is that just kind of the tail end of the dog?
- President, CEO
Well there's a couple issues and [Lid] was alluding to as we started to roll out, there's some cost associated with how we actually roll out to these Dollar Stores that for us to be as profitable as we need to be, we need to have multiple signs sold in the same cycle for those stores. We're getting a little traction on it, but a lot of the dollars that CPGs have are put into the cost of goods and therefore, they don't really have additional dollars to spend on advertising on top of that. So the brand selection is limited, and the dollars aren't as great. But we're continuing to focus on it, and we have some ideas to improve it and make it better.
- Analyst
Okay, thank you.
Operator
Tristan Barr with MTB Asset Management.
- Analyst
I guess I'm just having trouble reconciling some of these decisions and numbers. Scott, on the last call you had said when you sign this agreement that you would hope to turn into something around $60 million in POPS revenue. Then on this call, you said that $5.1 million profitability run rate and that given what you see now it's unlikely that we're going to have a full year profit. So you're exiting the year hopefully at a-- something like a $20 million on rate, but given the fact that that's now at the end of this year, two years after this agreement was signed, I mean why isn't either the revenue higher or why aren't we back in front of the magistrate arguing that there's been material damage at this point?
- President, CEO
Let Glen handle it.
- COO
All right. Well one of the things, Tristan, I think there's market forces at work above and beyond the News America relationship. Certainly as I said before, we are not as optimistic, we're cautiously optimistic on that front.
- Analyst
Yes, but that's a one-- you're talking about $20 million versus $60 million, that's an enormous difference.
- COO
Well let me say this. First of all, the number I referenced earlier in this call was a breakeven number. I said we'd breakeven at POPS revenue of around $5.5 million. That wasn't a projection. The $60 million was a goal --
- Analyst
Was it $5.5 million or $5.1 million, I'm sorry?
- COO
$5.5 million I said is where we breakeven. The $60 million was a goal for our core POPS business over time in a non-specified timeframe, there was never a statement that in this timeframe we'd be at a $60 million run rate, so--
- Analyst
Okay, but still, I mean that's-- it's-- those two numbers are just light years apart. I mean and again, you're now talking about being (inaudible) so maybe you're slightly over your breakeven run rate as you exit the year. But that is two years after this deal or close to two years after this deal would have been finalized. I mean there's been material damage, you guys have had to lay off a third of your employees. If this new law firm is so good and so aggressive, why aren't we back collecting money from News saying look you guys monkeyed around us about the color of the sign, what have you, it's had a significant impact on our business, it's had a significant impact on our employees, all of which have been reflected in the stock. price, I guess I just don't understand the disconnect between all these variables.
- COO
Well first of all, with respect to what we exit the year at in terms of a sales run rate, I don't know what it's going to be. I'm simply pointing out with the breakeven run rate is, which is about $5.5 million a quarter after the expense reduction moves. We -- our goal has been to make the News America relationship work. And yes, we had to be in front of the magistrate on several occasions last year. But the tone of it changed of the dealings with News America changed in mid-December. We had a meet and confer, I think I talked to you about that. The tone was much more conciliatory. I got to be careful because we've got a confidentiality agreement. But personally, I don't want to fight with them anymore. And I can't speak for them because I might be breaching some confidentiality, but we want to make the business arrangement work and we're striving towards that.
- Analyst
I understand that. I think it's just a little hard for your investors to reconcile the fact that you say you're cautiously optimistic or even-- and look, I'm all for right sizing expenses to revenues but at the same point in time, it is hard to reconcile the fact that you're aggressively cutting your workforce by this much if you think that this agreement is going to work. Again, given the fact that this agreement was something that at one point time, and I understand that's not the case any longer, but unless there's been an enormous degradation of the value of the contract, you thought was going to be worth $60 million. And now, I mean you're taking one third of your workforce out, it's hard to reconcile those two things.
- COO
Well Tristan, you know what the third-quarter numbers were, you know what the-- now know what the fourth-quarter numbers were, we gave you the booking number in the release, the business isn't where it needs to be. So as I said earlier, to protect shareholder value to not hemorrhage cash, we felt it was appropriate to cut expenses to the extent we did. I hope the business snaps back and maybe we'll be hiring some of these people back if that's the case. But I don't think you want us burning the kind of cash we've burnt operationally in Qs3 and 4 and obviously that'll be the case in Q1.
- Analyst
You mentioned that there were some macro differences between when the statement was made in the current -- what macro issues do you feel have been the most impactful at this point?
- President, CEO
I think that was Glen's.
- COO
Yes, Tristan that was-- I said that. And there were, and Al if you want to chime in on this, but really from a perspective of in-store spending from CPGs while we are seeing for the back half, some more greater interest. Overall the in-store industry as we're seeing it across all of the players, we're seeing that budgets are down, that activity is down overall and part of that from what we're hearing and seeing was CPGs is that they're actively looking and spending in digital media, whether that be in-store, electronic couponing, whether it be online and things like Facebook and social media, there's a lot of attention and budget testing and budgets toward it from a CPG perspective into those spaces. So that's something that we didn't see as strong in terms of looking at 2011 and into 2012 of the in-store budgets going into those spaces. And still from the competitive perspective, when the pie is shrinking, then the competitive forces with the other people in the in-store arena are becoming more aggressive as well. So all those things coming together combined with the fact of the time it's taken us to get our business relationship under control and moving forward is really impacted what you're seeing through '11 and going into '12.
- Analyst
I mean have you guys set had [benchmark] with News at this point? I mean I understand that there's only so much that you can disclose, but I mean this wouldn't be the first time that you guys have thought an attitude had changed and then maybe they backside a little bit. I mean what's to say that this pickup is actually meaningful, and that it will continue to ramp throughout the year?
- President, CEO
That's a-- Tristan, we can't get-- a lot of this is confidential between -- we've got a very strict confidentiality provision in our definitive agreement with News and we really can't go there on this call.
- Analyst
All right. I mean I guess that's all the questions. I mean I think it's a legitimate question for your shareholders to want answered. I understand there's a limit to what you guys can say, but anyway, all right thanks, guys.
- President, CEO
Thanks, Tristan.
Operator
(Operator Instructions) And there no questions from the phone line.
- President, CEO
Okay, well thank you all for listening and I obviously wish things were better, and we're trying to make the right decisions to stop hemorrhaging cash and to turn the business around. And we're, as Glen said, cautiously optimistic that it's going to be better going forward. Thank you.
Operator
This concludes today's teleconference. You may now disconnect at this time.