使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good day, everyone, and welcome to the Insignia Systems third quarter earnings conference call.
Just a reminder, today's conference call is being recorded. Except for the historical information mentioned, the matters discussed in the conference call are forward-looking statements. The Company's actual results could differ materially from these forward-looking statements as a result of a number of factors, including risks and uncertainties as described in the Company's Form 10-K/A for the year ended December 31, 2010 and other recent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Company wishes to caution listeners not to place undue reliance upon any such forward-looking statements, which speak only as of the date made.
At this time, I'd like to turn the conference call over to Mr. Scott Drill, President and Chief Executive Officer. Please go ahead, Mr. Drill.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thanks very much. And thank you all for participating in this conference call in which we will discuss our third quarter results and then answer any questions you may have.
With me are John Gonsior, our CFO, Al Jones, our Senior Vice President of Sales, Scott Simcox, our Senior Vice President of Marketing Services, and Glenn Dahl, our Vice President of Corporate Development.
And with that, I'm going to turn it over to John to review the third quarter numbers.
John Gonsior - CFO
As you can see in today's press release, we just completed a very disappointing quarter. We reported a net loss for the third quarter of $1,721,000, or $0.11 share, compared to net income of $932,000, or $0.06 per basic share, $0.05 per diluted share, for the same quarter one year ago.
Net sales were $3,060,000 for the third quarter compared to net sales of $8,517,000 for the same quarter last year. Our POPS revenue for the third quarter was $2,563,000 compared to POPS revenue of $7,858,000 in 2010.
For the first nine months of 2011, net sales were $13,033,000, compared to $22,726,000 for the nine months of 2010. POPS revenue for the first nine months of 2011 was $11,382,000 compared to $20,557,000 for the same period in 2010.
Net income for the first nine months of 2011 was $51,477,000, or $3.31 per basic share, $3.23 per diluted share, compared to net income $1,151,000, or $0.07 per share, in 2010.
Net income in the 2011 period included a gain from the settlement of our litigation against News America of $89,762,000 before income taxes.
Even in the wake of this poor performance, our cash balances remain strong at just under $32 million as of September 30th. Additionally, we have repurchased approximately 2.8 million shares under our share repurchase program at an average price of $5.42.
Lastly, our legal expense was $158,000 for the third quarter, which is down from $305,000 in the second quarter of this year.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thanks, John. As John mentioned, our POPS business in the third quarter was extremely disappointing. In addition to some difficulties in successfully implementing our business arrangement with News America, we have been impacted by the loss of Kroger at the end of 2010 as well as tighter CPG budgets due to, among other things, higher commodity prices.
The relationship with News America has recently deteriorated. As mentioned in the release, things did seem to improve in the aftermath of the August 25th ruling following our hearing on August 19th in front of Federal Magistrate Judge Arthur Boylan. We were pleased with the majority of that ruling.
However, the relationship hit a new post settlement low last Thursday when we were informed that they would not hang our signs for a cycle beginning November 6th because the signs contain color backgrounds. Historically, most of the signs we've sold and the signs they have sold under their Price POP Guaranteed program have contained color backgrounds.
00 Central. A letter from our attorney to their attorney is now in the public record and can be accessed through the PACER service, which is an acronym for Public Access to Court Electronic Records.
We're optimistic we will receive a favorable ruling on Friday requiring them to hang our signs. An adverse ruling or delayed ruling would be very detrimental to our business. In addition, there are a number of other issues which probably will have to be brought to the federal magistrate judge at a later date, which most likely will be this month.
On a more positive note, while the business continues to be soft, we have $3.5 million in POPS customer orders for the current quarter with approximately four weeks of selling time left. This represents a modest improvement over the third quarter.
Looking ahead to 2012, we are optimistic about our prospects if we can resolve our issues with News America. Our new laser die cutter should help us secure new retailers and increase our CPG sales. Further, our relationship with Valassis is stronger than ever and they are excited about selling our extended portfolio of products, which includes our new Insignia ShelfPOPS and BannerPOPS programs.
With that, I'm going to open it up for questions.
Operator
(Operator instructions.) Mason Matschke of Raymond James.
Mason Matschke - Analyst
Hi, Scott. How are you?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, I've had better days.
Mason Matschke - Analyst
I have two questions. The first one, I just wanted to get a better understanding of what the attorneys intend to do about the situation with News Corp. And my second question was do you believe that there will be penalties assessed to News Corp., financial penalties, for what seems like a six month delay in getting this business started?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
The second question I don't think I want to comment on. Potentially there certainly could be, but we don't want to lay out our strategy on a call which we know they'll be listening to.
The basic legal strategy is to enforce our rights under the 10-year agreement we got as part of the settlement back in February. And as I said on the last call, I guess unfortunately it's not surprising that it's been difficult, given the fact that we've been in litigation with them for 10 years.
I know your client, Mr. Corcoran. I've had some good conversations with him, so I say this respectfully. Perhaps there were some things we could have structured differently. But, this latest blowup where last Thursday they tell us they're not hanging the signs, there is no legal protection against them, in our view, outright breaching the agreement. And that's our view of it.
And if you go on that PACER site, you'll see a pretty strong letter laying out our position. And we think it's pretty, from our perspective, indisputable that they have to hang these signs. The signs are consistent with signs we've done under the program prior to this upcoming cycle. And they're consistent with signs that News Corp. sold and executed under their program.
And in fact, we've been executing PPG programs for News Corp. for News America that had been sold prior to the settlement agreement. That was part of the settlement, and many of those signs contained color backgrounds. I mean, it's a color world. It's not a black and white world.
So, we're going to do everything we can to make sure that our rights under the settlement agreement and in the 10-year arrangement are protected. And it's critical to our future that we succeed in that effort.
Mason Matschke - Analyst
Well, it just seems every time you go back to News Corp. and the judge tries to lay down the law, News Corp. just says -- they put their hands up and stop you from doing business.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
It's been very frustrating. But, we're not giving up. We have no choice but to fight on and make sure that our -- we get what we're entitled to under the 10-year business arrangement.
Mason Matschke - Analyst
Okay. Well, thank you very much. And good luck with the next quarter.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thank you, Mason.
Operator
Bill [Renn], private investor.
Bill Renn - Private Investor
This might be a question for John. John, it seems like the gross profit has deteriorated to almost nothing from last year at this time. How do you see the gross profit going forward?
John Gonsior - CFO
Well, I appreciate the question. And there is no hiding the fact that gross profit has gone down substantially since this time last year. The reason for that is our cost model is -- there's high fixed costs along with that. So, on low sales, it almost wipes out our gross profit.
Now, as Scott alluded to, I think the best way for us to grow revenue and therefore grow gross profit, both dollars and percentage, is going to be through this deal with News America. And there is -- until we can increase the revenues, there is not much that we can do on the cost side to -- I don't want to say artificially, but to lower those costs more so than the revenues that we pick up.
I don't know if that helps answer your question.
Bill Renn - Private Investor
Yes, it does. It just seems like --.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Gross margin is very much volume related. At times when we've done $8 million in a quarter in POPS revenue, the gross margin's been north of 50%. And conversely, when you have a quarter like this, which we haven't had for a long, long time, you see where it is. And it's really a revenue issue.
Bill Renn - Private Investor
Man, it just seems like the Company was headed -- without the volume, News Corp. aside, it seems like with the POPS revenue declining that the only thing that was going -- that is a hope is the News Corp. thing. Without that, with the POPS revenue declining and the high fixed cost of the cost of goods sales, it can't be profitable.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
We need to make the News Corp. 10-year business arrangement work. And we're going to do everything in our power to achieve that.
Bill Renn - Private Investor
Well, good luck. I wish you all the luck. It just doesn't seem like they're -- want to be your business partner.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thank you.
Bill Renn - Private Investor
Yes.
Operator
Bob Ramsdell, private investor.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Hi, Bob.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Hi, guys. One thing, if you could clarify on the deal with News, are they hanging up all our signs?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
No, just in their -- in the expanded network, which includes about 12,000 stores.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Okay. So, our business last year with the stores hanging signs generated $7.8 million in revenue, right? That's the number, anyway. And this year it's $2.5 million. So, without News, without News hanging signs, without News's 12,000 stores, without anything, we're now -- we now have a -- and we lost Safeway, which is 25% of the business. But, we are down 67%.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
We picked up Safeway through the business arrangement with News. We lost Kroger at the --.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
I meant Kroger. I meant to say Kroger. Excuse me. Excuse me. I meant to say Kroger is 25%.
The question goes to Al. What are the CPGs telling you? Why are they -- I mean, let's forget about the News deal. Let's forget about NAM altogether. Let's forget about everything except the lovely $125 million we got. What are the customers telling you that they're doing two thirds less business with you when you go and make a call on General Mills or whoever? What are they telling you?
Al Jones - SVP, Sales
Well, I think, again, the Kroger factor has to be looked at very closely. While it was representing about 35% of our business actually running through Kroger, Kroger was kind of the anchor to our mall and it had an effect beyond that 35%.
But, now with the addition of Safeway, we've reacquired a very reputable anchor and our national network looks strong. So, I feel -- again, looking ahead, once we get these operational issues, our sales reps are saying we are being built into plans and there's a lot of confidence of success.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Has there been any demonstration of that in 2012 as yet? Usually you're a couple quarters ahead. Are you seeing anything in the first and second quarter of 2012?
Al Jones - SVP, Sales
We're just seeing commitments by brands to put us into plans and to speak that they'd like to purchase categories and those things that normally mean a positive sale.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Al, you might talk about the expanded portfolio.
Al Jones - SVP, Sales
Yes. Another thing we're excited about because it kind of came together just this past week was that we've expanded our portfolio with two additional products, as Scott had mentioned, a ShelfPOPS and a BannerPOPS. They're signs that contain a little bit more equity messaging on them but no price. And we have a subset of our current network which is exclusive to us.
So, we are working with our partners, Valassis, that are in the business of selling this type network. And we're looking at -- we've looked at an arrangement where they will do this subset of stores so they can be inclusive in the sales that they make to their clients.
So, they are very optimistic, and the word just kind of went out to the sales force. And so, that's something we're hoping starts showing dividends immediately.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Could you explain that? What is the new product?
Al Jones - SVP, Sales
It's called ShelfPOPS and BannerPOPS. It's a similar product to some competitive products out there. So, what I'd say in extended portfolio, normally when someone, a CPG client, buys a national contract, they're trying to get -- especially for a new item, they're trying to get signage in as much of the ACV, all commodity volume, out there.
So, these additional 3,000 stores will help those clients gain access into additional ACV. And with the help of Valassis representing that portion of the network, it should be -- a check the box sale is kind of the term that we're using. And we're looking forward to it.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
What is the laser die cutter? What is that?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Glenn, you want to take that?
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
Sure. This is Glenn Dahl. The laser die cutter is some new equipment that we are -- will be installing and have up and running before the end of the year. And what that allows us to do is produce much higher quality signage, which is going to help us a lot in terms of retaining our retailers in our network as well as, we think, the ability to gain additional retailers because they are higher quality signs.
Along with that, there is going to be some operational efficiencies and some savings on paper and things like that that are going to help us out, as well as time savings and accuracy in terms of the production of the product.
And then, there's also, we feel, going to be a sales increase because the products that we're able to offer to the CPGs, we'll be able to do some different shapes and some things that can help promote their products much more efficiently as well as produce some really unique signage for our retailers. So, we feel that in addition to the efficiencies we're seeing, we're going to be seeing increased sales from that as well.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Okay. Thank you.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thanks, Bob.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
(Operator instructions.) Jacob Ajayi from Africa Mutual Funds.
Jacob Ajayi - Analyst
Good afternoon, gentlemen.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Good afternoon.
Jacob Ajayi - Analyst
Yes. My question is just looking at where do we go from here, because it looks like we've been spending a lot of time on litigation. And while we were losing customers and long-term clients, I just want to know what kind of arrangement you have in place to replace those lost customers.
And second, I know that you have about $31 million in cash. I don't know if we want to go into areas of online advertising and all that kind of thing.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, first of all, we haven't -- we've lost business on the CPG side of the equation but we have not lost CPG customers, nor have we lost significant retailers other than Kroger.
Now, we picked up 12,000 stores as part of this arrangement, this 10 year business arrangement with News America which does include Safeway. It includes some Dollar Stores. It includes Kmart. What's important is to make that arrangement work where our CPGs buy that network on a regular and obviously a higher volume basis than what we've seen so far.
And a real key to that, unfortunately, is working out some of these legal issues with News America. And it's unfortunate that we end up back in front of the federal magistrate as much as we do. We are lucky to have had that mechanism in the settlement agreement so that we have a means of forcing News Corp. to do what they're supposed to do under the terms of the agreement.
So, in my view, first and foremost we have to fix the core business. We're always looking at new technologies. Glenn Dahl is involved in that to a large extent. But, we're going to focus on the core business. We're going to fix it. We're going to owe another $4 million or $5 million in taxes on that $31 million.
So, when the dust settles, if we didn't buy back any more shares, which I'm not saying we won't do, but if we did not buy back any more, we'd have about $24 million in cash in round numbers. If we completed the share repurchase plan, we'd have about $19 million in cash in round numbers. And we're going to be very careful with that cash. We're not going to run off and get involved in new ventures that would require us to part with the cash.
I hope I've answered your question.
Jacob Ajayi - Analyst
Well, partially. But, I just want to know that there is -- a lot of advertising is going online and on various smartphones and all that kind of thing. Are we planning to take our customers in that direction?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Glenn, do you want to talk about that without giving any specificity to certain things we've looked at?
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
Certainly. We've been talking with a number of partners in the digital promotion space. And what we're looking to do is leverage our relationships with retailers and CPGs in the stores that we have our at-shelf signage with into digital promotions that consumers can interact with in the aisles of the grocery store using their smartphones, potentially loading offers onto their frequent shopper card, and potentially receiving further discounts at the point of sale in grocery.
And we think that's a natural extension for our product. And a lot of the technology providers that we are talking to are very excited about the relationships that we do enjoy with our retailers and with our CPGs.
Jacob Ajayi - Analyst
I think that gives me some assurance that we are really moving with the times. Thank you for taking that initiative.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
You're welcome. Thank you for the question.
Operator
Steve Moore of Stone Securities.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Hi, Scott and John.
John Gonsior - CFO
Hi, Steve.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Hi, Steve.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Hi. I was wondering about these color-backed signs. If this rules against us on Friday, would that affect the $3.5 million in sales we have locked up for this quarter?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. Those signs that are scheduled to run in the NAM network, between what we've sold and what Valassis has sold, the revenue total is close to $200,000. So, yes, it would impact us by $200,000.
But, more importantly, it would impact us with respect to our relationships with the CPGS because they would -- it would affect our CPG relationships. And if you go online to PACER, you'll see that we've laid out our case in a four-page letter to the judge.
From our perspective, and I think you'll agree when you read the letter, it's pretty much black and white that News is required to hang the signs. So, I'd be -- disappointed would be an understatement if we got an adverse ruling on Friday or if the judge did not rule on Friday, because time is of the essence and these signs need to start going up on Sunday, the 6th.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Okay. And also, when we paid these attorneys -- I hate to beat a horse, but when we paid them, we had already paid them $22 million to $25 million over the years. And then, they were supposed to be done with that from what they got. And it doesn't show up in what they received out of the $125 million. They got the 25%. So, therefore we must be looking for a greater number, quite a bit, over the next 10 years from the settlement.
And I guess my question is I'm looking at -- I've done a lot of numbers crunching with other people and things, and we were looking for like $1.00 a share out of you people or more for the next 10 years or more. That's minimally. And my question, I guess, is these attorneys, are they going to give back some of that upfront money if we don't get this thing settled? Because they're at fault for not getting us our income, it appears to me. This is falling into the cracks. I hate to be a -- give you a hard time, but --.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
First of all, let me clarify what the arrangement was with the attorneys. And the attorneys involved were not local counsel, which is Best & Flanagan. The law firm that was the lead firm on the case in the antitrust and the Lanham Act litigation was Kelley Drye & Warren. And there was a team of attorneys out in New York, Washington, DC, and Chicago that worked on the case.
When we entered into our arrangement with Kelley Drye -- and actually not to confuse it, but the explanation, it actually originally was with Collier Shannon, which was based in Washington, DC, and then they merged with Kelley Drye.
So, when we entered into that arrangement in the late summer of 2004, the arrangement was as follows, $50,000 per month retainer, 25% of any judgment above and beyond the $50,000, and all expenses. So, unfortunately you've got the misconception that what we paid them, the $600,000 a year in retainer monies, would offset the 25%. That's not the case.
And they took incredible risk. I talked to a lot of law firms, by the way, out in the Washington, DC area, which is where most of the antitrust work is done. And Collier Shannon was the only firm that wanted to take the case because it's so high -- it was such a high-risk case. It's hard to win antitrust cases.
So, they, in some months, and one can argue about the accuracy -- I trust their timekeeping. But, I'm just telling you some months they had, based on their internal accounting, $800,000 in the month in time into the case. That was at the height of discovery. Now, one could say, well, that was really -- and I know Mr. Corcoran feels this way and I say that respectfully again. Maybe it was $500,000 rather than $800,000.
But, in my view, the deal we struck with Collier Shannon, which then became Kelley Drye & Warren, was a great deal for the Company because we could not have afforded to fight that litigation for the number of years we did without this semi contingent arrangement. And the answer to whether they're going to give some of the money back, not a snowball's chance in hell that any of that money's coming back.
Steve Moore - Analyst
I didn't really think so.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. Oh, I'm just being blunt. It's just not going to happen.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Okay.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
And again, Steve, I, we, the team, we're extremely frustrated with how this has dragged out. We settled it February 9th. We're coming up on nine months since the settlement. And we're back in front of the magistrate this Friday, which is November 4th. I don't need to tell you the dates.
A lot of this stuff could not have been protected against. And as I think you know, I'm subject to a non-disparagement provision in the settlement agreement. And of course I would never disparage News America or News Corp., but a lot of the media in this world is doing it. And I don't know whether all the allegations that are coming out in the media have merit or not. But, there are a lot of allegations out there about how they conduct themselves.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Yes, that's for sure. I guess we don't need to get into all that. We can read it.
Also, they had a brief article this week that Groupon was going to hurt us. I don't believe that's the case at all. I had talked to John several weeks ago, and Groupon has nothing to do with what we do, people walking through a store. Is that correct?
John Gonsior - CFO
Glenn?
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
Yes, that would be correct. I don't know, John, if you had already commented on this. But, Groupon really is a different business model and most of their sales come from local key businesses, things like local franchises, dry cleaning, spa services, etc. And we really don't see them as a significant competitor in our space.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Okay. I'm sorry to keep you. But, Safeway stores, if everything goes as planned with News marketing, we should be able to fully replace Kroger. Is that correct?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes, we think that -- and I've said it on previous calls, we think the 12,000 stores we picked up in this business arrangement should more than offset the loss of Kroger.
However, we have been stymied in our attempt to really fully implement the Price POP Guaranteed program, which is what we bought, through that network of 12,000. We're selling them, but -- and frankly this was going to be a pretty good cycle starting November 6th. And I don't know how News thinks, but all of a sudden out of the blue we hear that they're not going to hang the signs. Well, I don't know. You can make your own inference.
Steve Moore - Analyst
Well, Scott, our people have about 1.2 million votes in your favor. We think you can do it. I think you're going to pull this off. I think your sales people are going to (expletive) this up and go get these guys, and I wish you guys all the best. Let's get them.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thanks, Steve. And I am very sorry for our current state. But, thank you.
John Gonsior - CFO
Thanks, Steve.
Operator
John Roginski, The Financial Group.
John Roginski - Analyst
Hi, Scott. How are you?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Been better, John. How are you?
John Roginski - Analyst
I've been better as well. I was looking at the transcript from the Valassis conference call last week. And it looks that they were affected by increased coupon usage. I guess part of my question is do you see the CPG budgets turning more towards more efficient advertising, and how much of an effect will that have on you going forward?
Also, I am wondering exactly how friendly does the relationship between you and News have to be to be successful? I did read in your release here that the worst is behind you. And it seems -- it kind of -- a little bit on both sides of the fence, to call it as I see it, that we remain hopeful that our efforts will -- that it will resolve our issues with News, but at the same time that the relationship is very tenuous. So, if you can expound on exactly what you think it's going to take to make this thing work, exactly how friendly it has to be, I'd really appreciate that.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
I'm going to let Glenn Dahl handle the first part of the question, then I'll come back to the second part.
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
Certainly. As it relates to your first question, in terms of the couponing industry and how that's going with consumers, one of the things we feel is always a strong hallmark of our POPS product is the fact that it does convey value to the consumers. And consumers will always, always respond to value and savings.
So, we're conveying that in the aisle. And as we talked a little bit earlier on the call, with our strategy of aligning with some digital partners to be able to offer consumers greater savings in a digital form, be it on a smartphone or at the POS, is where some of the CPG dollars are moving, away from the traditional paper couponing.
So, if we can effectively align ourselves with partners in that space, again leveraging the retailers and the CPG relationships we have, we think our sales will then take advantage of that rising trend in that direction.
Scott, I'll turn it back to you.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. I mean, I would -- first of all, I don't think it needs to be that friendly for it to work. The history, of course, is not only 10 years of litigation but what was a very contentious negotiation process back in January and February leading up to the settlement agreement on February 9th.
And in that kind of a process, I can be difficult. I was difficult. I'd have to say I played hardball and I think there were some feelings that -- some emotions that remained in the aftermath of the settlement.
I actually have attempted to get together with their -- I have, in my view, extended an olive branch and offered to have dinner with Mr. Mixon, time and place of his choice, to try and let bygones be bygones and move forward in a positive manner. That offer was rejected. I'm sure he'll hear this tape or hear about it, and that offer is still good.
I really do want to work in a friendly way going forward with News America. It's critical to our future. It's not so critical to their future, of course. So, that offer is always good.
Failing to get closer in that kind of a way, I think we've got to rely on the federal magistrate to enforce the settlement agreement. And I'm pretty confident that that will happen. It's taking some time and much longer than we would like, but we're going to keep at it. And fortunately, as I said earlier, I believe we have a mechanism to make that happen.
And when a federal magistrate issues an order, I don't care what corporation you are, I don't think you want to be in violation of a federal magistrate's order, in contempt of court potentially. So, I'm not saying they've done anything that'd constitute that, but we're going to just keep going back until we make it work.
John Roginski - Analyst
I wish you the very best with that. I am very curious to ask you more specifically about what you meant when you said that the worst is behind us. What did you mean by that statement specifically? Is it as far -- the worst as far as the soft market is concerned? Is it the worst as far as the News arrangement is concerned, a combination of the both -- the two?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
What I was alluding to primarily is that we had a quarter where revenue was a number that I could not ever fathom in this timeframe revenue would be at, and the fact that we have about $1 million more on the books than what we did for the entire third quarter in the fourth quarter, the fact that we've got the laser die cut system coming on, the fact that we've got the expanded portfolio, the strength of our relationship with Valassis where actually a few of us are attending a retirement gathering for one of their top executives later this month.
So, we've got a lot of things going our way. And I just can't imagine ever having another quarter that's as abysmal as the one we just finished.
John Roginski - Analyst
That's certainly encouraging. The first quarter of 2012, I know you'd alluded prior that it looked much stronger in light of the new budgets being established. Is it still the case that we can look forward to some new relationships or some developing budding relationships, or is that all based solely on the -- on what happens on Friday?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, the new relationship -- we've got to get deeper into CPG budgets. We've done business with most of the major CPGs in the country. The new relationships would be with new retailers, and that's a focus. And we hired, as I think I may have mentioned in the last conference call, a key guy on the retail side, John Thompson, who came out of a company, Unicous Marketing. And he spent 19 years at Valassis prior to Unicous. Very experienced industry veteran.
And John, along with our retail team -- which is already a good solid team, but he augments it. And we've got a number of initiatives in place to try and expand the retail network. So, that's where -- the key part of the business where new relationships would be created.
John Roginski - Analyst
And one more thing. Your relationship with Valassis, you're making very clear that's very strong. And as things unfold, it seems that, especially at these prices, it might be a nice little fit, and I'm sure there's some speculation out there. Is that something that is becoming perhaps a little bit more attractive, more than just a strategic alliance with Valassis? You can infer at will.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, of course if there were discussions of that nature, I couldn't disclose them.
John Roginski - Analyst
Of course.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
But, I think the fact -- I think I probably can disclose that we are not -- our view is we've got to go it alone. We've not been approached by anybody. There's nothing going on on the M&A front. And we're fully intending -- you never say never, but we're fully intending to forge ahead as a standalone company.
John Roginski - Analyst
I would prefer that. And again, I'm looking forward to seeing what Q1 looks like. Again, I don't know if you answered that or not, but does Q1 still hold promise like it did before?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. I mean, that was Al who alluded to Q1. But, it's too early to have great visibility on it. There's a lot of activity, a lot of reservations. Valassis, as Al said, is optimistic about being able to tack on the expanded portfolio to a lot of existing orders they have. Their in-store business, in terms of -- without divulging anything, in fact I don't even know the number. But, I think they're doing pretty well and I think they're going to help us a lot this next year.
John Roginski - Analyst
That would be wonderful. Well, thank you very much for your time, Scott.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. Thank you, John.
Operator
Craig Schembri of Sigma Financial.
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Hey, Scott. This is Craig here.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Hi, Craig. How are you?
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Real good, thank you. Hey, just a quick couple questions here. I guess concerning the loss of Kroger and obviously the tremendous impact it's had on the business, is there any talk about renewing that contract or is there anything you can share with us as far as a possibility of bringing them back onboard?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, it's an ongoing effort on our part. We're not close to bringing them back at this juncture. But, we certainly would like to and it's an objective, and it's been -- it's a priority. It's easier said than done.
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Sure. Did they leave for someone else? Are they doing their own in-store stuff?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
No, they did not leave for another sign with price program.
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Okay. Okay. I guess another question would be, I know we've talked about the visibility being a little bit tough. But, do you guys plan to give us any guidance, any revenue guidance for 2012 based on any of the forecast models you guys are using and based on any of the budget planning meetings you've had with your clients and retailers?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
We're in the planning process for 2012. And typically, we haven't put out what our internal plan number is. I think probably when we do the fourth quarter call in February, we'll obviously have a lot better visibility on precisely where Q1 is going to come in, and we'll have a better feel for the year. We'll know more about how Valassis is doing with the extended portfolio. So, probably not much prior to that in terms of guidance.
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Okay. And then, I guess the last question would be pertaining to the repurchase strategy. I'm not sure what's exactly on the cash side. That'll be $20 million, $21 million. I think you said cash and cash equivalents were $32 million. It just seems like there's nobody in the bid side right now. Can you guys share with us any strategies you guys may have internally to keep the stock propped up here until you get things going in the right direction?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, I think we're going to be conservative with respect to share repurchases. The bulk of the repurchases were made in the first quarter in the aftermath of the settlement. We had some long-term shareholders who had big positions that wanted partial liquidity. No one zeroed out.
But, I think given the -- and clearly, the repurchases have not propped up the stock price. The thinking was, aside from providing liquidity to some key long-term shareholders -- and anyone else who wanted to sell, for that matter. We didn't discriminate with respect to who we repurchased shares from. But, the idea was that, as the revenue grew and net income grew, we'd be dividing a smaller number of shares into whatever net income turned out to be and that would be good for the share price.
Now, we were all very optimistic about the prospects for the new 10-year business arrangement with News. And we still think we can make that work, as I said. But, so far it has not come to fruition. And I think given the performance in Q3 and the loss, and there clearly will be a loss in Q4, I think we want to be careful with our cash. I'm not saying we aren't going to buy some shares, but my sentiment is we should be a little more conservative.
And some of our shareholders think we should cut it off and others want -- I mean, there's a wide spectrum of opinion. Others think we should be in there buying every day. And that's kind of been the mode we've been in, buying a lot of days, small amounts generally, because there's a volume limitation. But, that clearly hasn't done much for the stock price. It will for EPS once we're making money again.
Craig Schembri - Analyst
Sure. Okay. All right. Well, good luck this Friday.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thank you.
Operator
Steve Emerson of Emerson Investment Group.
Steve Emerson - Analyst
Hey, Scott.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Hey, Steve. How are you doing?
Steve Emerson - Analyst
Good. Yourself?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Good. Good. Actually (multiple speakers).
Steve Emerson - Analyst
I came on late to the call so the question may have already been answered. But, are you asking for relief that would take the form of takeover the sign placement network?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
No, we are not.
Steve Emerson - Analyst
I don't know how you can compel News Corp. to be a willing partner.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, they're contractually obligated to be, so our focus is on making the existing agreement work. And if we fail in that, God forbid, we'll have to consider some other alternatives.
But, our focus is to make the existing agreement with News America work for both parties. And if we do well with it, News America makes money on the program and everybody should be happy.
Steve Emerson - Analyst
Okay. And to carry out Bob Ramsdell's argument or concern, it just doesn't seem the numbers are adding up. We're -- the loss of Kroger should have been a third of your volume, yet you were down far more than that. And I did understand your answer that there is coattails to Kroger. Perhaps you could flesh that out a little bit better.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
I'm not quite sure I understand the question.
Steve Emerson - Analyst
You're going from $7 million to $2.5 million year-over-year. A third of your volume was Kroger. You were down far more than that.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Okay. Yes, I think a key thing is that, as we struggled with the new relationship with News America, we lost some momentum in our sales force. The CPGs didn't have confidence that -- they didn't know what they were buying necessarily, whether it was going to be properly executed, and it just affected the whole business.
With Kroger gone, the rest of the network, with the exception of SUPERVALU, is just not as attractive to the CPGs. So, with Safeway and SUPERVALU, if both programs are operating on all cylinders, and SUPERVALU is, then they'll buy those two chains and they'll buy other chains in our network.
But, with just SUPERVALU and some uncertainty about Safeway -- and we were out of Safeway for a number of cycles due to some logistical issues which had to do with getting pricing. And it's fairly complicated and I don't want to -- there was some confusion in the relationship between a third party firm called ODT and News America. And that relationship ended and we didn't have a -- ODT was getting the prices. We didn't have a mechanism to get the Safeway prices.
So, it was a fouled up situation in the midsummer, Steve. And it affected overall revenue. I hope I'm answering your question.
Steve Emerson - Analyst
Okay. Thank you very much.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes. Thank you, Steve.
Operator
Bob Ramsdell, private investor.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Hey, Scott.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
What's the acronym for that -- to pick up that letter that you sent?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
It's PACER, P-A-C-E-R, and it stands for Public Access to Court Electronic Records. If you have troubles tracking it down, Joyce can help you.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Oh, okay. Great.
And secondarily, Glenn, without any specificity, I know you don't want to get into specifics, but you've been looking at these other opportunities for the Company. Are those opportunities 2013 opportunities, 2012 second half? How long have you been working with these companies that you're talking to, and what's the potentiality, in your mind? Are we talking about something that could happen in 2012 or is it beyond that?
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
Bob, that's a great question. We've actually been talking to some of these companies for some time this year and actually had talked to some late last year. And we potentially have some test opportunities fleshed out that we might still be able to get to either within this calendar year or probably Q1 of 2012.
And pending how those tests come out and how our partnerships come together, we're thinking we could launch potentially Q2 or maybe into Q3 of 2012.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Great. Thanks.
Glenn Dahl - VP, Corporate Development
You're welcome.
Bob Ramsdell - Private Investor
Thanks a lot, Scott.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Thanks, Bob.
Operator
Tristan Barr of MTB Asset Management.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
Scott, you started to touch on something that I'd like a little bit more clarity on. I mean, both the Company and actually you personally, I believe, you exercised and held at an ex dividend price around $4.70, $4.80. The Company was clearly buying as high as $5.00. The stock's at $1.85. Those purchases were made with optimism about this contract that you're saying should be able to be -- or the relationship, excuse me, that should be able to be salvaged and it doesn't have to be completely rosy for it to work well.
I mean, for those numbers to work, that you guys would be buying as aggressively as you were at $5.00, I mean, this has to be pretty significant. If this is all subject to legal redress, why you guys would start hesitating purchasing now at $1.85 just doesn't make a lot of sense.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
I was just saying that I think we want to be a little more conservative and conserve cash. And again, I got a wide range of opinions from key shareholders on both ends of the spectrum. One of our largest shareholders, two of our largest shareholders, in fact, and one of them is our largest shareholder, thinks we should suspend it and conserve cash. Another shareholder who is in the top five has the same sentiment.
It's just all over the board. So, it's not suspended. It's something we discussed during a Board conference call yesterday in preparation for today's call. And I'm not saying we're going to stay out of the market, but I don't think we want to go in and buy -- I don't think we want to complete, in the near term, the remaining $5 million or thereabouts that is authorized. I'm not saying we won't continue to buy stock.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
Well, okay, fair enough. Look, that's always an area where there's going to be a wide range of opinions. Could you maybe go into as much as you can? And I understand why it would be difficult, but I think some of your longer term investors would be interested in hearing -- again, $5.00 was where you guys were buying stock and you personally.
I mean, there had to be considerable optimism surrounding this relationship. You hear a lot about losing Kroger. Well, that happened before those purchases occurred. So, clearly there was a lot of belief that this relationship would far exceed the damage that the loss of Kroger inflicted on the Company.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Yes, absolutely. I'm sure I said in previous calls that we've -- and releases. We thought the 12,000 stores we picked up through the NAM business arrangement would more than offset the 2,200 or 2,400 Krogers that are no longer in the network.
And yes, when we were buying stock at $7.00, call it, a lot of it was in the $6.50 to $6.80 range back in the March/April timeframe, I thought we were getting a bargain. It seemed -- I personally had expected the stock to go into the $7.50, $7.75 range. I remember after we announced the sale, and I think you told me, if I'm not mistaken, that you sold some stock aftermarket north of $8.00.
So, there was incredible optimism. Some of our largest shareholders didn't sell a share. And things don't always work out according to plan, and now we're dealing with a different reality. And again, I go back to the statement that the majority of what's been repurchased was repurchased in that March/April timeframe.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
I guess what I'm trying to get at, Scott, is is the reality different or not? I mean, the contract as it stands is in place. If you guys can get enforcement of the contract as you thought, then you still would have the opportunity for revenues and earnings that would justify prices higher than where you purchased, or is that contract now materially impaired?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, we're going to find out and we're going to learn a lot on Friday as to the mindset of the federal magistrate. And my enthusiasm -- I shouldn't -- let me retract that. My optimism has been dampened a little bit by having a quarter in which we did $2.5 million in POPS revenue. So, I'm just trying to be realistic.
So, it's a long ways between doing $15 million a quarter. I had hoped -- and I don't know if I shared this with you, but internally, and I'll put it out there, we had hoped that with this network we could build the business over the next couple, three years to $60 million in POPS revenue and have pretty healthy operating margins. And the fact that here we are nine months later and we're coming off a $2.5 million quarter with $3.5 million on the books is just a little dose of reality is all.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
Fair enough. The last thing is is, look, I understand your loyalty to the legal team, and I'm not going to kind of reopen that can. But, I just kind of wonder, since they weren't incented at all on this final operating agreement, I mean, they got the chunk of the settlement and they're out the door, if they spent as much time on this final agreement as they should have and if there is not some redress there, because clearly this agreement was not buttoned up the way it should. News seems to wriggle through any loophole that they find in this deal. And look, I mean, the lawyer's job is to close those holes.
So, I understand, on the one hand, being very loyal to the only person that was willing to take the case, but, at the same point in time, I mean, they did make out very well in the end. And you guys are kind of stuck holding the bag on an agreement that News clearly doesn't feel is worth the paper that it was printed on.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Tristan, I think -- please do me a favor and go on PACER and read the court --.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
I actually did, and I -- for whatever reason, that letter is not showing up on PACER.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Well, then it will tomorrow. And when we spoke the other day, or I guess it was yesterday, I said that I'd be happy to talk to you tomorrow. Read the letter and tell me your opinion of the quality of the legal work and whether you think they're -- and I'm not directing this at you.
But, I'm just saying I don't think there is any way the agreement, the definitive agreement, could have been written to prevent what's happened in the last week. And it's all laid out in a four-page letter. In our view, it's just a blatant breach of the agreement. And I don't think there's any way to guard against that.
Tristan Barr - Analyst
Well, again, look -- and this'll be the last thing I say. I mean, I have no idea, I haven't read the letter. So, maybe what you're saying about the last week is true and that there was no way to address that.
But, this isn't the first hiccup in this agreement. I mean, the last quarter wasn't that great because there were some hiccups in the agreement and it took some time to get back in front of the judge and get some things hammered out that -- again, I'm not in that room, I have no idea, but for an outsider to reasonably assume should have been hammered out in the negotiation process.
So, I look forward to reading the letter. And I appreciate you taking the time on the call.
Scott Drill - President, CEO
You're welcome.
I'll just say this. The issues that got decided in the August 25th ruling following the August 19th hearing, I don't think those issues could have been protected against in the agreement. It's just my opinion. Maybe I'm too close to the situation. But, I just wanted to leave you with that. You there? Anyway, I'll talk to you tomorrow.
Operator
(Operator instructions.) Mr. Drill, there are no further questions. Are there any closing remarks?
Scott Drill - President, CEO
Just, again, thank you for participating in the call. And sorry things are the way they are right now, but we are going to do our best to make them better. Thank you.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, this concludes today's conference call. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect.