使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good day, ladies and gentlemen.
Welcome to the Macy's Inc third-quarter 2013 earnings conference.
As a reminder, today's conference is being recorded.
At this time, I would like to turn the conference over to Ms. Karen Hoguet.
Please go ahead.
- CFO
Great, thanks.
And good morning and welcome to the Macy's Inc call scheduled to discuss our third-quarter earnings.
I am Karen Hoguet, CFO of the Company.
Any transcription or other reproduction of the statements made in this call without our consent is prohibited.
A replay of the call will be available on our website, www.macysInc.com, beginning approximately two hours after the call concludes.
Please refer to the Investor Relations section of our website for discussion and reconciliations of any non-GAAP financial measures discussed this morning.
Keep in mind that all forward-looking statements are subject to risks and uncertainties that could cause the Company's actual results to differ materially from the expectations and assumptions mentioned today due to a variety of factors that affect the Company, including the risks specified in the Company's most recently filed Form 10-K.
We are very pleased with our third-quarter performance.
We produced a comp-store sales increase of 3.5%, or 4.6% on an owned-plus-licensed basis, a 30-basis-point increase in EBIT rate, and a 31% increase in diluted earnings per share.
This is an improvement in trend from the first half of the year, and it makes us cautiously optimistic about our outlook for the fourth quarter.
Sales in the third quarter were $6.276 billion, up 3.5% on a comp basis.
This is on top of a 3.7% comp increase last year in the third quarter.
This is towards the higher end of our guidance of 2.5% to 4% for comp-sales growth in the back half of the year.
Including licensed sales, comp sales were up 4.6% in the quarter.
This is the most comparable metric for customer demand.
This is particularly true this year because we have converted businesses like athletic shoes from being owned to being licensed.
The owned-comp dollars would be zero this year for these businesses, against obviously a big number a year ago, so making the comp sales somewhat misleading.
And this 4.6% on an owned-plus-licensed basis compares to 2.4% in the first half of the year.
This is over a 2-point improvement in trend.
As we said at the end of the second quarter, we felt we had to intensify our marketing and enhance our value offering to drive the Business in the current economic environment.
We did both and we are happy to say it paid off.
The customer responded well to the cleaner and bolder look to our sale advertising, some new promotional handles, and great values on fresh merchandise.
We also improved graphics and visual merchandising in the stores and on our website, in order to make our sales and values more obvious.
This was a real team effort.
During the third quarter, the number of transactions increased approximately 1%, which is improved versus the first half of the year when the transaction count was roughly flat.
Units per transaction was up 2% in the third quarter versus being flat in the Spring.
And our average unit retail was up slightly in the quarter.
And remember, last year our average unit retail in the quarter increased 4.5%.
Also as evidence of the success of the changes that we made is the fact that the change in trend was very widespread geographically.
Sales improved across all of the Macy's regions in the country in the third quarter, with particular strength across the south and in the northeast.
Bloomingdale's had a strong quarter as well.
We also saw broad-based strengthening across all major categories of business.
There are lots of good news stories, and only a few weaker ones.
Starting with women's apparel, we are pleased that this category has continued to strengthen.
The season change was positive for this business, with our customer responding very well to the newness.
Our strength in women's apparel was driven by our private brands, cashmere, dresses, suits, coats and active.
And our impulse business, which is aimed at the older millennial customer, had a great quarter, including a terrific launch of a new private brand, Maison Jules.
And while sales in juniors continued weak in absolute terms, the trend did improve versus that in the first half of the year.
Sales in the center core categories continued their very strong performance, driven by handbags, cosmetics, fine jewelry, intimate apparel, and boots.
The trend in watches did, however, slow somewhat in the quarter.
Performance in men's continued good, with particular strength in active, tailored clothing, and cold-weather merchandise.
And our home business was outstanding, with particular strength in home textiles, housewares, furniture and mattresses.
Luggage was the one category within home that weakened in the quarter.
Looking at the third quarter, we are particularly encouraged by three trends that bode well for the fourth quarter.
One, the traditional gift categories are trending very well.
This would include businesses such as fine jewelry, cosmetics, cashmere, handbags and housewares.
The second encouraging trend is that the cold-weather businesses were all strong -- coats, boots, sweaters, et cetera.
If we have anywhere close to a normal weather pattern this year, this could add significant volume.
And the third encouraging trend was the stronger growth in women's apparel businesses, including that of the older millennial customer, which is always great for our Business.
Turning to gross margin, the gross margin rate in the quarter was 39.2%, down 40 basis points versus last year.
This is in part due to the increased shipping costs associated with our omni-channel business, but our merchandise margin was down as well in the quarter.
Fortunately, we were able to more than offset this reduction with a 70-basis-point reduction in SG&A as a percent of sales.
Expense in dollars grew only 1% over last year for the third quarter, in spite of the continued omni-channel investment and the added marketing expense.
We benefited in the quarter from the leveraging from the stronger sales.
Also, depreciation and amortization was $12 million below last year, and our credit profitability increased $8 million over last year.
As expected, the benefit from credit was much less relative to a year ago than that experienced during the first half of the year.
Operating income in the quarter was $360 million, up 11% over last year in dollars, and 30 basis points higher as a percent of sales.
Interest expense was $96 million versus last year's $103 million, and tax expense was $87 million compared to last year's $77 million.
The effective tax rate was below last year in the quarter.
We now expect our annual effective tax rate to be approximately 36%, which is approximately 95 basis points better than what we expected at the start of the year, due to our securing the benefit of additional state and federal income tax credits, and settlements throughout this year.
Net income in the quarter was $177 million, 22% above last year's $145 million.
Average diluted share count in the quarter was 380.2 million shares, down 7% from last year's 407.9 million shares.
And earnings per share on a diluted basis was, therefore, $0.47, or 31% above last year's $0.36 per share.
Inventory at the end of the third quarter was up 7% over last year, and consistent with our plan.
As I discussed at the end of the second quarter, this increase was caused by the calendar shift.
With last year having the 53rd week, there are unusual inventory comparisons at the end of each quarter.
We aim to have inventory in our stores on the same calendar date, regardless of when it falls in the fiscal calendar, since that's how customers shop.
So, for example, the last day of the third quarter this year was November 2, versus last year when it was October 27.
So, receipts in the first day of November were booked in the third quarter this year and the fourth quarter last year.
And also, with our November sales growth planned significantly higher than that in December and January due to the compressed calendar, and to a lesser extent the year-rounding on Sandy, we needed to be sure we had stock in stores and in warehouses to support our growth.
By year end, however, we do expect inventories to be back at a more normal level of increase relative to the prior year.
This inventory increase, net of payables, was the primary reason the net cash provided by operations was $70 million below last year; but remember, this is due to timing.
Cash flow from investing activities was $74 million favorable to last year, so cash flow before financing activities was $4 million above last year.
We utilized $447 million to buy back 10.1 million shares in the third quarter.
Year to date, we have bought back 27.6 million shares for $1.25 billion.
We also issued $400 million of 10-year debt during the quarter, with a coupon of 4 3/8%.
As you read in our press release, our guidance for the Fall season is unchanged.
For comp sales, we are expecting 2.5% to 4% for the back half of the year.
We do expect continued pressure on our gross margin rate in the fourth quarter, but hope to be able to offset it with lower SG&A as a percent of sales.
Year-rounding on the 53rd week, however, does put pressure on the SG&A rate.
And we continue to expect our annual earnings per share on a diluted basis to be $3.80 to $3.90.
So, while we are very satisfied with our performance in the third quarter, all eyes at Macy's and at Bloomingdale's are now focused ahead to the fourth quarter.
And we are very excited about what we see for the holiday season.
We feel especially prepared this year.
Our merchants have outstanding assortments planned for every store and online.
Our stores, Macys.com, Bloomingdales.com, and our mobile apps are being continuously improved to enhance the customer shopping experience.
We have more fulfillment capacity, including four online fulfillment megacenters, as well as 500 Macy's stores now equipped for shipping.
And you will be seeing very compelling marketing again this year.
This year, as you know, we have six fewer days between Thanksgiving and Christmas.
So, the holiday shopping season will be shorter and more intense.
We expect a heightened sense of urgency among customers, so it's important that we be ready for her every day, every time, and every way she shops.
Our promotional calendar is full of great fashion and gifts with great value.
Speaking of gifts, the merchants have been working all year on a fabulous assortment of items, especially for Macy's, from our stars -- Polo Ralph Lauren, Tommy, Calvin Klein, Michael Kors, and others.
You will see these star gifts in every door.
And in the spirit of My Macy's, they are being tailored by region.
There will be no doubt that Macy's is the holiday headquarters for gifts.
We are mindful of mitigating factors, such as the economy and the shorter season.
So, we have redoubled our efforts to notch up our holiday execution.
We believe we are well positioned to capture more than our fair share of the business.
We hope you are as excited as we are about what you will be seeing at Macy's and Bloomingdale's in holiday 2013.
And now I'm happy to take your questions.
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
We'll take our first question from Matthew Boss from JPMorgan.
- Analyst
Hi, Karen.
Good morning.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
At the June Analyst Day you outlined an outlook, was pretty impressive, 5% top line, 15% net income, and a 20% earnings growth.
Any changes to the plan as we think forward, appetite for potentially increased capital allocation if the backdrop were to stabilize through holiday?
- CFO
Well if we look at it, there really hasn't been a change.
Our strategies are working.
Our outlook is really unchanged, and we're always looking for opportunities to invest our capital wisely.
But at this point I think our budget for next year, which is approximately $1 billion, give or take some, is what we expect to spend.
- Analyst
Okay.
Perfect.
And then from a marketing and promotional standpoint, it sounds like you guys stuck to the outlined game plan, the more aggressive game plan you talked about last quarter.
Can you talk about some of the changes that worked in the quarter?
And as you talk about doubling down into the holiday, what incrementally we should think about into 4Q and into the holiday here?
- CFO
I think what we did is the second quarter started we looked at some of our promotional events and decided that perhaps they had become a bit stale.
So we changed some of the promotional handles.
For example, added door busters and deals of the day as opposed to morning specials.
We looked at the actual items that we had been promoting and decided some of them needed to be changed or freshened.
We spent a lot of time analyzing which items drove other business, what we call radiated sales, so that we could do this intelligently.
We also worked in the stores to make the visual better for the customers in the stores to see the values that we were offering.
So as I said, it was a complete team effort.
The stores, the websites, marketing, merchants, everybody was involved here.
- Analyst
Sounds like it worked well.
Congrats on the quarter.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
We'll take our next question from Paul Swinand from Morningstar.
- Analyst
Good morning.
Thanks for taking the questions.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
You talked a little bit at one of the conferences about omni-channel and localization.
I'm wondering if you're doing promotions or omni-channel marketing that's leveraging the localization that you're getting out of My Macy's?
- CFO
When we do marketing we are doing localized marketing when there's a particular item or event going on in that community, things like the Kentucky Derby or sporting events, so that is happening.
But so much of the marketing is more nationally driven.
But when you think about the localization of assortments, often it's sizes, colors within our major brands.
It's not completely different merchandise.
So the national marketing works well.
- Analyst
Got it.
Interesting.
And then kind of on the same lines with the licensed sales, is that driving incremental traffic, and are they marketing both online and nationally as well in coordination with you?
- CFO
They are.
And we believe that for businesses like Finish Line or Sunglass Hut, some of the big installations, we do think it helps traffic and it's just part of the overall plan for getting more customers in the door.
- Analyst
You mentioned analyzing incremental or ancillary sales from that traffic.
Is that also resulting in sales to other departments?
- CFO
In some cases, yes.
- Analyst
Thank you very much and best of luck for holidays.
- CFO
Thank you very much.
Operator
We have a question from Charles Grom from Sterne Agee.
- Analyst
Thanks.
Good morning, Karen.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
On the second-quarter call you called out or you referenced some crowding out concerns.
Just wondering if you feel as if those pressures abated or did you guys just simply execute better here?
Because it was a pretty big swing in your comp from quarter to quarter.
- CFO
I think as we said at the end of the second quarter we needed to make some tweaks in what we were doing, keep the fundamental strategies, but perhaps execute slightly differently.
And we spent the second quarter putting it all together and working together as opposed to over-reacting too quickly, and what we changed did work in the third quarter as you can see.
Business was strong in August and September, strengthened in October, but it was strong all quarter.
- Analyst
Okay.
Good to know.
And then just first half of the year you also called out that budget shopper as being a little bit weaker but appears that the value message resonated a little bit more.
Any thoughts on that customer demographic?
- CFO
It's hard to tell.
Once again, we're reporting first.
I think we need to wait and see how other people did.
I think we did well with that customer in the quarter.
But again, I have to wait and see how our competitors did.
- Analyst
Okay.
Then just last question on the guidance, the implied fourth-quarter view, looks like you're projecting roughly speaking about, say, 50 basis points of margin compression versus last year despite going against your easiest comparison of last year.
So just wondering, is that mainly the cycling of the 53rd week or is there some credit give-back, just can you help us out on connecting the dots there?
- CFO
I'm not sure how you came up with that estimate, so maybe we should talk offline.
That doesn't sound right.
- Analyst
Okay.
I'll circle back after the call.
Thanks a lot.
Operator
We have a question from Kimberly Greenberger from Morgan Stanley.
- Analyst
Great.
Thank you.
Congratulations on a really terrific quarter, Karen.
- CFO
Thanks, Kimberly.
- Analyst
I'm wondering if you could just talk to us about your philosophy in terms of SG&A management.
I think there was obviously a really nice surprise here in the SG&A expense in the third quarter.
How do you think about monitoring your business as it's unfolding and whether to release SG&A dollars or pull in SG&A dollars?
And was there any sort of concerted effort in the quarter to be really sort of lean with the SG&A budget?
- CFO
I think Macy's has always been very disciplined on the expense line and we always try to be lean but appropriately investing and growing the business, and I think the third quarter demonstrated that again.
We did invest in marketing as we said we were going to do.
And still from the bottom line perspective did a terrific job I think in terms of the SG&A performance.
But we are always disciplined and always looking for ways of being more efficient.
I don't know that we did anything differently in the third quarter.
- Analyst
Great.
Thanks so much, Karen.
Operator
We have Stacie Rabinowitz from Consumer Edge Research.
- Analyst
Hi.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
You've been talking on the call about the difference in the marketing this quarter and you've been talking a lot about choosing different items, better, bolder, different kinds of advertising and messaging.
Was there anything, any point, any category where it was just plain deeper discounting or was it really just a more targeted, better executed marketing strategy?
- CFO
No, it really was just more targeted, better strategy.
I would not say there was any wholesale deeper discounting going on.
Did we give some additional value?
Yes, in some places we did, but nothing that obviously hurt the bottom line of the Company in any dramatic way.
- Analyst
Great.
Thanks.
Operator
We have a question from Paul Trussell from Deutsche Bank.
- Analyst
Good morning.
- CFO
Good morning, Paul.
- Analyst
Just going back to your comments on the cadence of the quarter, you mentioned that October you saw some accelerated demand.
Could you just speak at all to kind of the magnitude of October's results versus earlier in the quarter?
- CFO
Well, there's a lot of focus on October.
I'm not quite sure why.
The whole quarter was very strong and October did get stronger, but from my perspective I'd focus on the third quarter in total.
But the strategy worked right out of the gates.
- Analyst
Okay.
Thank you.
And then early on the call you spoke about capital plans for next year likely being in that $1 billion range once again.
From that standpoint, is the leverage target still 2.4 to 2.7?
And if that is the case, given how well the cash flow generation, EBITDA growth has been, are you still open to adding debt to the balance sheet either this year or next?
- CFO
I think the easiest way of answering that, Paul, is that is still the credit rate targets, the 2.4 to 2.7 and my guess is we would stay towards the middle to lower end of that as opposed to levering up too much.
But again, with the EBITDA growing, there is some capacity.
- Analyst
Thank you.
Operator
And we have a question from Paul Lejuez from Wells Fargo.
- Analyst
Thanks, Karen.
Just wondering if you could quantify on the gross margin line how much the shipping costs hurt that line versus the merchandise margin decline?
And then just wondering about any specific categories that perhaps took the brunt of the merch margin compression, or was it more broad-based?
Thanks.
- CFO
It was broad-based and we don't break out the components of margins that way.
- Analyst
Got you.
How about the performance of mall stores versus off-mall stores, Karen.
- CFO
We don't have many off-mall stores.
We have the big free standing stores like Herald Square, 59th Street.
But most of our stores are in malls.
- Analyst
Any comment on that store, how the progress is going in terms of the refurbishment and what that's doing for business in the Herald Square store.
- CFO
The progress is terrific.
The first and second floors are just about all open again for business, look terrific, and the renovated areas are exceeding our expectation.
So we feel really good about what's been done down here.
- Analyst
Cool.
Thanks and good luck.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question is from Liz Dunn from Macquarie.
- Analyst
Hi.
Let me add my congratulations.
- CFO
Thanks, Liz.
- Analyst
I guess as we look at this earlier opening, the Thanksgiving opening, are you looking at the fact that more people are doing it this year as an opportunity because there will be more traffic and more excitement around it, or do you think it's perhaps more of a risk because there will be more places for the consumer to go?
- CFO
No, I think that would be an opportunity.
If you look at it on a balance.
- Analyst
Okay.
As we think about these licensed categories, is the net financial impact positive or are you looking at that more as just being able to offer kind of better merchandise to your consumers, and did you see any lift in adjacent categories to those categories that you licensed?
- CFO
What we do, as we're looking at licensed categories, it's always driven by assortments we want to offer the customer.
So for example, in the case of athletic footwear, we were not able to offer the best brands, the best shoes within those brands to the customer on our own.
And by partnering with Finish Line, we've been able to do that.
So it's always driven by trying to give our customers the best assortments we possibly can.
And we often find that it helps.
So for example, I think the athletic footwear business is helping our active business as well as some of the millennial categories.
So I think that's good for us and I believe Finish Line, it's been good for them as well.
- Analyst
Do you think there are any other big categories to do this in?
- CFO
I would say there's some smaller categories, but at this point I can't think of anything of major size.
But again, we're always looking to be able to offer the customer merchandise that we think she expects from Macy's and try to get it in the best way that we can.
- Analyst
Okay.
And then final question.
Can we just have a little bit more color on the performance of Bloomingdale's during the quarter.
- CFO
Yes, I'm sorry, we always tend to focus on the 90%.
Bloomingdale's had a very good quarter and improved their trend relative to the spring season as well So I would say fairly comparable performance deltas and continues to do well.
- Analyst
Great.
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question is from Michael Binetti from UBS.
- Analyst
Hey Karen, good morning.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
So my math really quickly, just on the near term here, looks like the comp for the fourth quarter could be anywhere from 2% to 4%.
You've obviously been ahead of it and had a good read on what the promotional environment will need to be for the year.
With all that given, when you sat down and thought about the range for the fourth quarter, what do you think it takes to get to the high end of that range?
- CFO
Well, it's a good question.
I have to stop and think about it.
Obviously, a little help from the economy would always be helpful to that end.
And it would just have to mean that our assortments and execution was even that much better than our peers.
I think would be the two factors I would think.
- Analyst
Okay.
- CFO
Also, by the way, weather.
- Analyst
Right.
It sounds like you're pretty happy with November trends so far.
How do you gauge how much of what we're seeing is really calendar or comparison related versus a true pick-up in demand, the six fewer shopping days you mentioned will compress December.
- CFO
If you look at the third quarter, we were pleased throughout the quarter.
- Analyst
Right.
- CFO
So that's really what our optimism is based on.
- Analyst
Got it.
And then just my last question, so in the quarter there was a nice article run about you guys significantly increasing the space you're allocating to the athletic brands.
Maybe you could talk a little about why the time is now to get bigger there, what did you learn, and I'm always frankly impressed with how quickly these things are rolled out in your stores after you mention it in an article.
So how soon will we see more of these Nike, Under Armour, North Face, shops rolling out for your stores?
- CFO
It's no surprise that active has become an important part of what customers are wearing and needing, sometimes it's for athletic endeavors, sometimes it's just to run errands, and we saw a big opportunity here and in fact that's what is happening in terms of performance in the stores.
- Analyst
How fast do you see that rolling out?
- CFO
Well, all of -- most of our stores today have active.
We'll just be expanding them as we see opportunities.
Again, from a My Macy's perspective with what kinds of assortments.
- Analyst
Great.
Thanks, again.
Great quarter.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
And our next question is from Jeff Stein from Northcoast Research.
- Analyst
Hey, Karen.
Good morning and great quarter.
Could you talk a little bit about the millennial brands that you've introduced this year.
You've called out Maison Jules as one of your more successful brands, but wondering about some of the others you've introduced.
And it seems that most were rolled out to a limited number of doors for fall.
So I'm wondering based on the performance that you've seen from all of the brands collectively, should we look for a material expansion as we head into spring?
- CFO
I think you will see big expansions as we go into next year.
As I said, that business has done very well.
Maison Jules has been particularly successful.
I think it's probably the first private brand launch that we've done that was done through the lens of My Macy's.
And we actually put different assortments in different regions and different colors and different sizing.
Plus, we also incorporated the omni-channel strategies, so there's tagging on the merchandise that offers extended sizes and colors online.
So interestingly, Maison Jules is the first time we've launched a brand where we had what I would call the whole MOM strategy encompassed, and it's been very successful.
I would say some of the other brands, some have done well, some have done less well and sometimes it just takes time for a new brand to be tweaked and fine-tuned and improved.
But by and large we feel very good about the brand launches and do expect to have quite a bit of roll-out as we go into '14.
- Analyst
Great.
And with respect to your online business, can you talk about the momentum in Q3 relative to Q2?
Because I understand if I remember correctly that you did see a little bit of weakening in Q2 in your online business.
And what's going on with respect to how you're achieving your growth?
Is it more transaction driven?
Average unit retail or both?
- CFO
Well the online business as we said when we stopped reporting it separately is getting just so hard to measure.
So many customers are shopping online, going in the store to buy and vice versa, so it really is hard to break it out and say that.
Having said that, the business has not weakened and is very strong.
Now, that may be customers on a smartphone in the store.
But nonetheless, if you look at online transactions, it's done very well.
- Analyst
Great.
Great.
And from a marketing perspective, are you also planning to increase your marketing as a percent to sales in Q4 if you hit your comp guidance range?
- CFO
I can't be that specific, Jeff.
- Analyst
Got it.
Okay.
Thank you.
Operator
And our next question is from Richard Jaffe from Stifel.
- Analyst
Thanks very much and well done, Karen.
- CFO
Thank you.
- Analyst
Just a question on the juniors business, it seems like mstylelab is an opportunity and any thoughts of why that hasn't performed as well as the better juniors and what might be done in time for Christmas?
- CFO
No, it's been a tough business for us as you know for a while.
We did begin to see some improvement.
We are making some changes in the assortment, getting a little bit more key item focused, and we're feeling a little more encouraged but we are getting much more success with that older millennial customer through the impulse category.
- Analyst
And just a quick thought on the effectiveness of the in-store fulfillment of e-commerce sales.
Any way you can share that with us or that you've been able to gauge how well it's been working?
- CFO
It's been working extremely well.
Our stores have done a terrific job executing it and are almost as fast and accurate as our mega centers.
So that's really very good news.
But the real benefit of the store fulfillment actually has -- and hopefully I can do this simply.
But it is enabling us to put fashion assortments into all of our doors, whereas we might not have done so before having the ability to use that inventory to satisfy internet demand.
What it's doing is helping our stores have more fashion, better assortments, and getting more four-wall growth in addition to obviously efficiently getting the goods to our internet customer.
Great example of that right now on the floors is cashmere, where we have stocked significantly more fashion colors in all of our Macy's stores, and much less inventory in our mega centers for the fashion colors, so that our stores look better and are growing faster and at the same time then satisfying internet demand from that inventory.
- Analyst
Interesting.
- CFO
It's really the omni-channel dream.
- Analyst
And the in-store fulfillment, is it meaningful yet or still in the very early stages.
- CFO
No, it's meaningful.
You've got 500 doors and my guess is we'll roll it out to most doors by next year.
It is meaningful.
- Analyst
Could it some day be a majority of your fulfillment?
- CFO
I don't think it will ever be a majority but it does enable us to get inventory closer to the customer.
One of the things we're testing as of this quarter is buy online, pick up in store, which based on early reads I think will for sure be rolled out next year.
And so that's another capability that is allowing us to get merchandise to the customer faster, in a way that she likes.
- Analyst
That makes sense.
Good to hear.
Good luck this holiday season.
- CFO
Thank you very much.
Operator
We have a question from Lorraine Hutchinson from BOA.
- Analyst
Thanks, good morning, Karen.
- CFO
Good morning.
- Analyst
Just wanted to follow up on the merchandise margin.
Do you expect pressure to intensify in the fourth quarter?
And then how are you thinking about the need to continue to provide that kind of value in the first half of next year?
- CFO
I would say the pressure will continue.
Don't know that it will intensify.
I may get more thoughts on that as I see others report and hear what they're saying.
But I do expect it to continue.
And in terms of spring, it may continue but I don't think -- I'm not sure yet on spring.
We'll have to see.
- Analyst
Great.
Thank you.
Operator
And we have a question from David Glick from Buckingham Research Group.
- Analyst
Good morning.
Thank you, Karen.
Most of my questions have been answered.
I just thought perhaps you could give us a little more color on women's apparel.
It sounds like the moderate businesses are picking up a bit in the seasonal categories.
I'm just trying to get a better understanding on sort of moderate versus better trends and how much is really driven by sort of that stronger value message and the favorable trends in seasonal apparel.
- CFO
I think a lot of it has to do with the fact that the fall fashion is both wearable and interesting.
And the customers are responding well.
We have consciously gone after that opening price point business lately and have been very successful there.
Also getting a benefit from the cold weather goods, sweaters, cashmere, coats, et cetera, active, because as we talked earlier both true-active and ath-leisure is an up-trending category.
Private brands are doing well.
Inc is very strong as are other of the regular price -- I'm sorry, the opening price point brands.
So it's really fairly broad-based.
- Analyst
That doesn't mean your better brands, which have been a real strength for you over the last several years, that doesn't mean they're slowing down, it's just better performance at the moderate level?
- CFO
That's correct.
That's correct.
- Analyst
Thank you very much.
Good luck in the fourth quarter.
- CFO
Thanks.
Operator
We have a question from Priya Ohri-Gupta from Barclays.
- Analyst
Thank you for the question.
Just two, if I may.
One, I was wondering if you might be able to talk a little bit about your intra-quarter traffic trends, so from month to month.
And just secondly, was hoping you might be able to give us a little bit more context around how you think about debt issuance, given that you do look to be sort of in the low to mid range versus your target, you did come to market in September but it was only for $400 million.
Any thoughts as to why sort of that wasn't a higher figure given the capacity you have, and do you look to come multiple times a year?
Any color you can provide.
- CFO
I think the only color I can provide in terms of debt issuance is what we've said, which is, again, expect us to be in the mid to lower end of our range, targeted range of the 2.4 to 2.7.
That's really all I can say on that.
In terms of trends during the quarter, as we have said, the August, September period was strong, as was October.
So I don't have the traffic patterns or the transactions by month in front of me.
But it wasn't like business had been weak and suddenly got strong in October.
- Analyst
Okay.
Thank you very much.
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
At this time we'll take a question from Dana Telsey from Telsey Advisory Group.
- Analyst
Good morning, Karen.
And congratulations on a terrific quarter.
The licensed businesses seem to be gaining traction and helped to add traffic also.
On the existing licensing business, anything different that they're doing that you're learning from at Macy's or Bloomingdale's, and should we be looking for new licensed businesses to be added?
Thank you.
- CFO
Not that I know of in terms of what we're learning but I'm sure we do both in terms of assortments as well as selling service, because we're always looking to learn from any of our partners.
And as I said earlier, I don't expect any major new categories to be licensed.
But we are always trying to find ways of improving our offering to the customer so there may be something at some point.
- Analyst
And then just on the tax rate, does it stay at this level for 2014?
- CFO
At this point I would say no, my suspicion is -- again, I don't have the full plan yet but my suspicion is it will go back to the 37% like level.
- Analyst
Thank you.
Operator
We have a question from Michael Exstein from Credit Suisse.
- Analyst
Thanks so much, Karen.
A couple of very quick ones.
Was there less disruption for the business from the Herald Square renovation this quarter than previous quarters?
Number one.
Number two, was women's the top performing area in terms of percentage growth?
- CFO
Let me do those two.
Then you can come back.
- Analyst
Okay.
- CFO
There was less disruption from Herald Square.
There was actually as much disruption but there's more good news so the net was favorable this year to a year ago in the third quarter.
- Analyst
And what about women's, was that the top percentage gainer for the quarter?
- CFO
We don't disclose those numbers.
- Analyst
And then finally what would be the implications for the inventory if you added back the inventory that was in place in the licensed businesses, the formerly owned businesses that are now licensed in terms of what would be the like to like inventory year over year?
- CFO
If you did -- let me give it a different way.
Comp inventory was just slightly higher, Michael.
- Analyst
Okay.
- CFO
It's not a big factor.
- Analyst
Okay.
I appreciate it.
- CFO
Maybe 1%.
I've been focused on the versus plan comparisons.
- Analyst
Okay.
- CFO
But a slight impact.
- Analyst
Perfect.
Thank you so much.
Operator
We have a question from Rob Wilson from Tiburon Research.
- Analyst
Hey, Karen, thank you.
The $8 million higher credit income in Q3, what should we expect in Q4?
And will that be impacted by the extra week last year?
- CFO
Well, we have not given guidance by quarter.
We have said that the back half of the year would be much less of an increase than the first half.
So I don't expect anything materially different in the fourth quarter than the third quarter but we really have not given guidance on that.
- Analyst
So not necessarily any real impact from that extra week last year?
- CFO
Again, I'm not giving guidance by quarter.
- Analyst
Okay.
And one last question.
The tax rate, is it -- I guess my math would suggest you're expecting a higher tax rate in Q4 than the first three quarters of the year.
Is that correct?
- CFO
That's correct.
And that relates to the timing of settlements and the receipt of credits.
- Analyst
Okay.
Well, thank you.
Congratulations.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
We have a question from Brian Rounick from BLR Capital Partners.
- Analyst
Thanks for the question.
Just Karen, in the fourth quarter as a result of the 53rd week comparison, what do you expect the spread to be between top line and same store sales?
- CFO
I'm sorry, you caught me by surprise.
My guess is it will be sort 4.5-ish kind of points.
- Analyst
Okay, great.
- CFO
Sort of that kind of range.
- Analyst
Thank you very much.
Operator
Stephen Grambling from Goldman Sachs.
- Analyst
Good morning, Karen.
Thanks for taking my question.
This is a bit of a follow-up to Richard and Lorraine's questions, but the guidance suggests that you will have the third straight year of gross margin pressure, and I realize part of that's been shipping from online and now some merchandise margin pressure, but can you help us frame the longer-term trajectory of gross margin?
And maybe specifically address the opportunity from optimizing inventory across channels?
- CFO
My view is, and I've said this forever, that the long-term prospect on gross margin rate should be flattish.
There will be quarters and times where it goes up or down.
But again, I think flattish is the right long-term perspective.
- Analyst
And then when we think about optimizing inventory and I guess this goes along with the getting better fashion brands, is there any way to frame that opportunity and how big that could be?
- CFO
No, there really isn't.
We obviously hope that as we can better optimize inventory we can perhaps improve gross margin rate, but at this point I think I urge people to think flattish.
- Analyst
Great.
Thanks.
Good luck into the holiday.
- CFO
Thank you.
Operator
Our next question is from Craig Hutson from Loop Capital.
- Analyst
Good quarter.
A balance sheet related question.
By my count you have at the end of the latest quarter 14 issues that have a 7% or higher coupon, which makes you considerably different than the rest of your investment grade peers.
Now that you are solidly investment grade and have that 2.4 to 2.7 times leverage target, what is the rational for not trying to clean up the balance sheet and go after and tender for a lot of those high cost debt --
- CFO
We constantly do the math on that and it gets to an issue of what the net present value of what those kinds of transactions are.
- Analyst
Okay.
Operator
Our next question comes from Bernard Sosnick from Gilford Securities.
- Analyst
Karen, yesterday I was at the Bay Shore mall in Long Island where you have a new store.
The retailers there say traffic in the mall has picked up since the store opened, which implies a good performance for the store.
I'm wondering if you could give us a little color on that.
But my main point is that the appearance of the store is really nice, but different than from what you have in your traditional stores to a certain degree.
From that, can we judge that there are thoughts that you might have with regard to renovations of the stores going forward?
And if so, could you give us some thoughts on that?
- CFO
Unfortunately, Bernie, I don't know the answer to the question.
I hear the store looks spectacular.
We're very happy with it.
I think everybody on the team has now been there except for me.
So unfortunately I don't know the answer to your question.
I'll get it and get back to you.
But I know we are very pleased with how it looks and how it's doing.
- Analyst
It's a positive impression that I got that caused me to ask the question.
- CFO
Good.
I'll find out and get back to you.
Yes, thanks.
- Analyst
Thank.
Operator
We'll take our final question from Greg Hessler from Bank of America-Merrill Lynch.
- Analyst
Thank you.
My question's already been answered.
Operator
Thank you.
At this time I'll turn the conference over back to Karen Hoguet for any final closing remarks.
- CFO
Great.
I just want to thank you all for your support and your interest in Macy's, and hopefully you'll do a lot of shopping with us during the fourth quarter.
Thanks and I'll talk to you all soon.
Operator
Once again, ladies and gentlemen, that concludes today's conference.
We appreciate your participation today.