使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Deborah Belevan - Vice President of Investor Relations
Deborah Belevan - Vice President of Investor Relations
Good evening, everyone, and welcome to Duolingo's Q3 earnings webcast. Today after market closed, we released this quarter's shareholder letter, a copy of which you can find on our website at investor.duolingo.com. On today's call, we have Luis von Ahn, our Co-Founder and CEO; and Gillian Munson, our CFO. They will begin with prepared remarks before we open the call for questions. Analysts may ask a question by using the raise hand feature.
各位晚安,歡迎收看 Duolingo 2024 年第三季(Q3)財報網路直播。今天在美股收盤後,我們發布了本季的股東信,您可在我們的網站 investor.duolingo.com 上找到副本。今天的電話會議由共同創辦人兼執行長 Luis von Ahn,以及財務長 Gillian Munson 出席。他們將先進行事先準備的發言,之後我們會開放提問。分析師可使用舉手功能提出問題。
Please note that this call is being recorded (Operator Instructions). Before we begin, please note that we will make forward-looking statements regarding future events and financial performance. These statements are subject to risks and uncertainties described in our SEC filings and are based on our assumptions we believe to be reasonable as of today. We undertake no obligation to update them. We will also discuss both GAAP and non-GAAP financial measures.
請注意,本次電話會議將被錄音(操作員指示)。在開始之前,請注意我們將就未來事件與財務表現發表前瞻性陳述。這些陳述受我們向 SEC 提交文件中所述之風險與不確定性影響,並基於我們截至今日認為合理的假設。我們不承擔更新這些陳述的義務。我們也將同時討論 GAAP 與非 GAAP 財務衡量指標。
Reconciliations between the two can be found in our earnings materials, and we encourage you to review them when evaluating our performance. And now I will hand over to Luis.
兩者之間的調節表可在我們的財報資料中找到,我們鼓勵您在評估我們的表現時一併查閱。接下來我把時間交給 Luis。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Thanks, Debbie, and thank you all for joining. We had a great Q3. Daily active users accelerated for a second quarter in a row to 29% year-over-year growth, up from 23% in Q2. Bookings, revenue and profitability were also ahead of expectations. At the beginning of the year, we laid out a plan to prioritize teaching better and user growth, knowing it would take time to see results.
謝謝 Debbie,也感謝各位參與。我們第三季表現非常出色。日活躍用戶(DAU)連續第二季加速成長,年增 29%,高於第二季的 23%。預訂額(bookings)、營收與獲利能力也都優於預期。今年年初,我們提出一項計畫,優先提升教學品質與用戶成長,並且知道需要時間才能看到成果。
We're now seeing the user acceleration we hope for, and I'm proud of how our team has executed against our strategy. We expect this momentum to continue with year-over-year DAU growth in Q4 similar to Q3 and Q4 bookings slightly ahead of previous guidance. Every new learner expands the audience we can monetize over time. While teaching better and user growth remain our top priorities for this year, we're gradually leaning more into monetization in ways that preserve the quality of our free experience. Our ambition is to ultimately reach 1 billion learners, and build a much larger business over time.
我們現在正看到我們所期待的用戶加速成長,我也為團隊依照策略落實執行感到自豪。我們預期這股動能將延續,第四季的 DAU 年增率將與第三季相近,而第四季的預訂額將略高於先前指引。每一位新學習者都會擴大我們未來可變現的受眾。雖然提升教學品質與用戶成長仍是今年的首要任務,但我們正逐步更著重於變現,同時維持免費體驗的品質。我們的抱負是最終觸及 10 億名學習者,並在時間推移中建立更大的事業規模。
The more people we can teach, the bigger that opportunity becomes. With that, I'll turn it over to Gillian.
我們能教會的人越多,這個機會就越大。接下來我把時間交給 Gillian。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Thank you, Luis. I'm glad you're all here this evening. We started the year with an ambitious plan to reaccelerate our growth, and our Q3 results show we're executing well. The numbers from the quarter are pretty straightforward, so I'll double-click on just 2 items. First, a look at how broad our DAU and bookings growth was.
謝謝你,Luis。很高興今晚各位都在。我們以一個雄心勃勃的計畫展開今年,目標是讓成長重新加速,而第三季的結果顯示我們執行得很好。本季的數字相當直觀,所以我只深入說明兩點。第一,看看我們 DAU 與預訂額成長的廣泛程度。
Year-over-year, DAU growth accelerated across 8 of our 10 largest countries. Additionally, year-over-year subscription bookings growth was in the double digits in the majority of the regions we serve. Secondly, Q3 operating expenses include an $11 million bonus accrual. This bonus rewards our team for reaccelerating user growth. We're on track to hit the targets, so we've begun to record the expense.
以年增率來看,我們前 10 大國家中有 8 個國家的 DAU 成長加速。此外,我們服務的大多數地區,其訂閱預訂額(subscription bookings)年增率達到雙位數。第二,第三季營業費用包含 1,100 萬美元的獎金應計(bonus accrual)。這筆獎金用於獎勵團隊成功讓用戶成長重新加速。我們正朝達成目標邁進,因此已開始認列該費用。
A second portion of the bonus is included in our Q4 guidance. and we expect to pay the full bonus in early 2027. Turning to Q4. We expect year-over-year bookings growth of 13%, revenue growth of 14% and an adjusted EBITDA margin of 26.1%. To help you build your models, I want to give you just a couple of items to consider.
獎金的第二部分已納入我們第四季指引中,我們預期將於 2027 年初支付全額獎金。談到第四季,我們預期預訂額年增 13%、營收年增 14%,以及調整後 EBITDA 利潤率為 26.1%。為了協助各位建立模型,我想提供幾個需要考量的項目。
We expect gross margin to fall slightly from Q3 as we roll out Video Call to all Paid Subscribers. Operating expenses will likely grow faster than revenue because of our continued investments and the second portion of the bonus I just mentioned. As a result, we expect adjusted EBITDA to be roughly flat year-over-year at $84 million. For the full year, we expect to deliver 12% year-over-year bookings growth and 18% revenue growth paired with a 26.5% adjusted EBITDA margin. We plan to provide our full outlook for 2027 in February.
隨著我們把 Video Call 推廣至所有付費訂閱者,我們預期毛利率將較第三季略為下滑。由於我們持續投資,以及我剛提到的獎金第二部分,營業費用的成長速度可能會快於營收。因此,我們預期調整後 EBITDA 約為 8,400 萬美元,年增大致持平。就全年而言,我們預期預訂額年增 12%、營收年增 18%,並搭配 26.5% 的調整後 EBITDA 利潤率。我們計畫在 2 月提供 2027 年的完整展望。
We are encouraged by the momentum we're seeing in our business and look forward to answering your questions. Back to you, operator.
我們對業務所展現的動能感到鼓舞,也期待回答各位的問題。交還給你,操作員。
Operator
Operator
(Operator Instructions)
(操作員指示)
Ygal Arounian.
Ygal Arounian。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Hey, good afternoon, guys. Thanks for taking the questions. I guess, I want to maybe start with the growth that you guys are seeing and we expect to continue into 4Q. A number of levers you guys are pushing here. And maybe if you could just kind of quantify or qualify what the biggest drivers are between the new partnerships and the games and the Junior's Toy Hunt and those kind of engagement features that you're driving? And then just a second part of that question, any difference in terms of monetization or retention or other KPIs that you're seeing from these partnerships? And should we expect you to do more of those?
嗨,各位下午好。謝謝讓我提問。我想先從你們目前看到、並預期會延續到第四季的成長談起。你們正在推動多個槓桿。也許你們可以量化或定性說明一下,最大的驅動因素是哪些——在新合作夥伴關係、遊戲、Junior's Toy Hunt 以及你們推動的那類互動功能之間,究竟哪些影響最大?另外,第二個問題是:從這些合作帶來的用戶來看,你們在變現、留存或其他 KPI 上是否看到任何差異?我們是否應該預期你們會做更多這類合作?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Okay. Yes. Thank you for the question. So first of all, the majority of our growth for this year comes from product improvements. We've, in the past, discussed our notion of The Green Machine, which is basically an optimization system that we have that just makes the app better over time.
好的。是的,謝謝你的問題。首先,今年我們大部分的成長來自產品改進。我們過去談過「The Green Machine」的概念,基本上那是一套我們用來讓 App 隨時間持續變得更好的最佳化系統。
And basically, every week, the app has hundreds of new A/B/B tests that make it a little better. And that's the vast majority of our improvement in active users comes from improvements in retention because of that. The product is getting better. Now over the last few months, we've had a few events that are also very important and important to call out. One of them was the Streak Revival last quarter.
基本上,每週 App 會進行數百個新的 A/B/B 測試,讓它一點一滴變得更好。而我們活躍用戶提升的絕大部分,來自於因此帶來的留存改善:產品正在變得更好。不過在過去幾個月,我們也有幾個同樣非常重要、值得特別提出的活動。其中之一是上季的 Streak Revival。
This quarter, we had the partnerships with Brawl Stars and also Eggy Party. And they did bring users, but I really want to emphasize that we just believe that the majority of it is from improvements to the app, which is why we think that this is going to continue going forward. In terms of the uses that we have from these partnerships, they retain very well. And part of the reason for that is because we did some product work to make it. So the way these partnerships work is that you're a player of Brawl Stars or whatever the game that is partnering with us is.
本季我們與《Brawl Stars》以及《Eggy Party》合作。它們確實帶來了用戶,但我想強調的是,我們相信其中大部分仍來自 App 的改進,這也是我們認為未來能持續的原因。就這些合作帶來的用戶而言,他們的留存表現非常好。部分原因是我們做了一些產品工作來配合。這些合作的運作方式是:你是《Brawl Stars》或其他與我們合作遊戲的玩家。
You come to Duolingo to get rewards for that game, for Brawl Stars for example. But in order to get the rewards, we get you to stay multiple days on Duolingo. And what that does is it builds a habit. And so we see that these players that are coming in have very good retention.
你會來到 Duolingo 以獲得該遊戲的獎勵,例如《Brawl Stars》。但為了拿到獎勵,我們會讓你在 Duolingo 上連續停留多天。這樣做會建立使用習慣。因此我們看到,這些新進來的玩家留存非常好。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
And I think as you think about both DAU and bookings, I think what we've been talking about is how broad-based -- the growth was in the quarter, both from a geographic perspective, in terms of how the product is working. We're feeling really good about the broadness of the growth we're seeing in the business across both DAU and monetization.
而我認為,當你同時看 DAU 與預訂額時,我們一直在談的是——本季的成長有多麼廣泛:不論從地理分布角度,或從產品運作的角度。我們對於在 DAU 與變現兩方面所看到的廣泛成長感到非常樂觀。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yes. I mean we're basically growing across all regions, and we accelerated across 8 of our top 10 markets in terms of DAU growth. So we're very happy with that.
是的。我的意思是,我們基本上在所有地區都在成長,而且就 DAU 成長而言,我們前 10 大市場中有 8 個市場出現加速。所以我們對此非常滿意。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Thanks so much for taking my question.
非常感謝回答我的問題。
Operator
Operator
Wyatt Swanson, D.A. Davidson & Co.
Wyatt Swanson,D.A. Davidson & Co.。
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Thanks, guys. Could you guys give some color on the Paid Subscriber additions relative to daily active users? Paid subs growth has continued to slow year-over-year despite DAUs picking back up. Is that predominantly a function of extended free trials? Or could you give any additional color on that and whether you expect those trends to change at all?
謝謝各位。你們能否就付費訂閱者(Paid Subscriber)新增人數相對於日活躍用戶的情況提供一些說明?儘管 DAU 回升,付費訂閱者的年增率仍持續放緩。這主要是延長免費試用所致嗎?或你們能否提供更多背景,以及你們是否預期這些趨勢會有任何改變?
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
I'll cover the subs numbers and then maybe you can talk a little bit about the trends in there. Wyatt, the way to think about subs numbers is the largely follow the revenue. So they're kind of an average in there. So the subs numbers tend to follow that revenue growth. So in terms of subs growth, probably that bottoms in a couple of quarters as we work through the bookings from prior to this quarter.
我先說訂閱者數字,然後也許你可以再談談其中的趨勢。Wyatt,理解訂閱者數字的方式是:它們大致上會跟著營收走。所以它們有點像是其中的平均值。因此,訂閱者數字往往會跟隨營收成長。就訂閱者成長而言,隨著我們消化本季之前的預訂額,可能會在接下來幾季觸底。
So as we rebuild the bookings growth, that revenue growth will come after and those subs growth numbers will come as well. So it's just -- that's like sort of a math thing mostly. And then Luis, maybe you'll talk a little bit about sort of how bookings are going near term.
因此,當我們重新建立預訂額成長後,營收成長會在之後跟上,而訂閱者成長數字也會隨之而來。所以這主要就是——大多是數學上的關係。然後 Luis,也許你可以再談談短期內預訂額的走勢。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Yeah, I mean, we started the year with a very clear strategy to prioritize teaching better end user growth. And we've -- and it's very hard to reaccelerate user growth, and we're very proud of the fact that we have done that. But we also, at the beginning of the year, we said, look, our bookings are going to fall within this box of somewhere like 10% to 12% year-over-year growth. We're in the higher end of that.
對,我的意思是,我們在年初就有一個非常明確的策略:優先把教學做得更好、帶動終端使用者成長。而且我們——要讓使用者成長重新加速是非常困難的,我們也為自己做到這點感到非常自豪。但同時,在年初我們也說過,你看,我們的預訂(bookings)會落在這個區間,大概是年增 10% 到 12%。我們目前是在這個區間的較高端。
We feel pretty good about that. But we just have not been concentrating very much on monetization. But what we have done in monetization this year is try to invent new ways of monetizing that are more DAU aligned. And the good news is that we have found a number of them. One of them is longer free trials, like you mentioned.
我們對此感覺相當不錯。但我們確實沒有把太多精力放在變現上。不過我們今年在變現上做的,是嘗試發明一些與 DAU 更一致的新變現方式。好消息是,我們已經找到好幾種。其中之一就是你提到的更長的免費試用期。
There are others, for example, monetizing the Avatar suits like we talked about, that does really well with IAPs. And there's just a number of other things that we're going to be doing, and we're slowly starting to monetize more that way. Another thing that we're really excited about is Chess is completely under monetized. We're going to be monetizing it Chess. We're very proud.
還有其他方式,例如我們談到的 Avatar 服裝的變現,這在 IAP(應用內購買)方面表現非常好。除此之外,我們還會做很多其他事情,而且我們正慢慢開始用這種方式做更多變現。另一件讓我們非常興奮的是,西洋棋(Chess)目前的變現程度完全不足。我們會把西洋棋做變現。我們非常自豪。
We just hit 10 million daily active users in Chess. So it's now a relatively significant amount of our users are doing Chess. And we think there's a lot of low-hanging fruit there.
我們剛剛在西洋棋達到 1,000 萬日活躍使用者。所以現在有相當可觀的一部分使用者在玩西洋棋。我們認為那裡有很多唾手可得的機會。
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Got it. Thanks, guys.
了解。謝謝各位。
Operator
Operator
Ryan MacDonald, Needham & Company.
Ryan MacDonald,Needham & Company。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Hi, Ryan.
嗨,Ryan。
Ryan MacDonald - Analyst
Ryan MacDonald - Analyst
Hi. How's it going? Thanks for taking my questions. Luis, just wondering if you could kind of provide a little more color on sort of the early days of the testing of moving Video Call called the Super Duolingo, what you're seeing in terms of user engagement there or even conversion? And then how that sort of informed your view about the decision to sunset Duolingo Max here?
嗨。最近如何?謝謝回答我的問題。Luis,我想請問你能否再多補充一些細節:關於把名為 Video Call 的功能移到 Super Duolingo 的早期測試階段,你們在使用者互動(engagement)甚至轉換(conversion)方面看到了什麼?以及這如何影響你們決定在這裡逐步下架(sunset)Duolingo Max 的看法?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yes. It's a great question. I mean when we first started Duolingo Max, the higher subscription tier, what we did -- we have to start it because we had some AI features that were just very expensive to serve. I mean the cost of these AI features was high. We did say back then that if we managed to bring the cost down, we may put these features in other tiers.
是的,這是個很好的問題。我是說,當我們一開始推出 Duolingo Max(較高的訂閱等級)時,我們之所以要先推出它,是因為我們有一些 AI 功能提供服務的成本非常高。也就是說,這些 AI 功能的成本很高。我們當時就說過,如果我們能把成本降下來,我們可能會把這些功能放到其他等級裡。
What happened was that the premium feature of Duolingo Max, which was Video Call, when we first launched it, it was costing about $0.30 per call, just generally on AI inference. We've managed to reduce that cost to well under $0.01 per call, and that's mainly by moving to open source models or open weight models. So we feel really good about that, and that allowed us to put Video Call in Super. And that was actually a really good thing. When we A/B tested that, it's good for revenue, but also it allows us to give Video Call to about 10 times as many users because we just have many more Super subscribers than we have Max subscribers.
後來發生的是:Duolingo Max 的主要高階功能,也就是 Video Call,在我們剛推出時,每通通話的成本大約是 0.30 美元,主要是 AI 推論成本。我們已經把這個成本降到遠低於每通 0.01 美元,主要是透過改用開源模型或開放權重模型。因此我們對此感覺非常好,也讓我們能把 Video Call 放進 Super。這其實是一件非常好的事。我們做 A/B 測試後發現,這對營收有幫助,同時也讓我們能把 Video Call 提供給大約 10 倍的使用者,因為 Super 訂閱者遠多於 Max 訂閱者。
And that's good because that means 10 times as many people are learning better, they'll tell their friends, et cetera, et cetera. So we just view this as very positive. And because of that, and when we tested just -- we actually just tested a sunsetting Max, it was very clear that the right decision was to sunset Max. So we've started doing that. We don't think -- in the short term, we don't think this is going to have a major bookings impact.
這很好,因為這代表有 10 倍的人能學得更好,他們會告訴朋友等等。所以我們把這視為非常正面的事情。也因為如此,當我們測試——我們其實也測試了逐步下架 Max——結果非常清楚:正確的決策就是下架 Max。所以我們已經開始這麼做。我們認為——短期內,我們不認為這會對預訂(bookings)造成重大影響。
It's slightly positive. It's not a major bookings impact. But in the long term, we think this is really going to help us because more and more people are going to get Super. I mean, this is one of the main reasons why people are going to get Super. So we feel pretty good about that.
它是略為正面,但不是重大的預訂影響。不過長期來看,我們認為這會非常有幫助,因為會有越來越多人訂閱 Super。我的意思是,這會是人們訂閱 Super 的主要原因之一。所以我們對此相當有信心。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Yes. And I think what's interesting about the process we've taken here is that we've worked down the exposure to Max fairly significantly. So the vast majority of our bookings now is not Max. It's single digits in both in terms of the number of paid subscribers and the bookings there. So it's become a very small thing that we're going to manage, and we've obviously shown this year that we can manage these things quite well.
是的。我覺得這個過程有趣的地方在於,我們已經把對 Max 的曝險大幅降低。所以我們現在絕大多數的預訂(bookings)都不是來自 Max。無論是付費訂閱者數量或預訂金額,Max 都只占個位數百分比。因此它已經變成一個我們要管理、但規模很小的項目,而我們今年也顯示出我們能把這類事情管理得相當好。
Ryan MacDonald - Analyst
Ryan MacDonald - Analyst
And Gillian, maybe just assumptions for sort of like churn as you're going through the process? And is this something that you're going to push out sort of all at once to existing Max subscribers? Or are you just going to do it gradually upon renewal? Thanks.
另外 Gillian,想請教在這個過程中,你們對流失(churn)的假設是什麼?以及你們會把這件事一次性推給現有的 Max 訂閱者,還是會在續訂時逐步進行?謝謝。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
So we have essentially stopped selling Max to new users. We will be moving Max individual to Super Family at a similar price. So they will be getting the ability to add their friends and family on all the great features that you have in Max moving over to Super. And then that will just leave us with Max Family which we will be ending the year with, which is the smaller portion of bookings and paid users that I mentioned before. So we've really managed down that process.
所以我們基本上已經停止向新使用者銷售 Max。我們會把 Max 個人方案轉移到 Super 家庭方案,價格相近。這樣他們就能把朋友和家人加入,並享有你在 Max 裡的所有優秀功能,轉移到 Super。接著就只會剩下 Max 家庭方案,我們會在年底時結束它;它在預訂與付費使用者中所占的比例較小,就像我前面提到的。所以我們確實已經把這個流程的影響大幅降低。
And again, kind of to what Luis' point was, as we go test this, it ends up being net positive for us. And then on the long term. In the short term, we manage through it, but you've seen we've really managed down the exposure there, and we feel really good about our ability to manage it.
而且同樣呼應 Luis 的觀點,當我們去測試這件事時,結果對我們而言是淨正面(net positive)。長期來看是如此。短期內我們會把它管理好,但你也看到我們已經大幅降低那邊的曝險,我們對自己的管理能力感到非常有信心。
Operator
Operator
Shweta Khajuria, Wolfe.
Shweta Khajuria,Wolfe。
Shweta Khajuria - Equity Analyst
Shweta Khajuria - Equity Analyst
Good to see you both. Thanks for taking my questions can I please two, one is a follow-up on bookings growth. So how do you think about this lag between DAU growth and bookings growth as we think about bookings growth catching up, how should we be thinking about it as we think of '27? And then the second one is on gross margins. Is 72% the guidance that you provided, Gillian, a good run rate now that Video Call transition will happen.
很高興見到你們兩位。謝謝回答我的問題。我可以問兩個嗎?第一個是關於預訂(bookings)成長的追問:當我們思考預訂成長追上 DAU 成長之間的這個落差時,對於預訂成長何時會追上來、以及我們看向 2027 年時應該怎麼思考?第二個是關於毛利率:Gillian,你提供的 72% 指引,在 Video Call 轉移完成後,是否可以視為一個不錯的常態水準(run rate)?
When we think about costs coming down, but at the same time, usage for Video going up? Is it a good run rate sort of a margin to think of?
當我們認為成本會下降、但同時 Video 的使用量會上升時,這是否是一個可以用來思考的毛利率常態水準?
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Yes. For -- I'll let Gillian answer the gross management question. For bookings growth, our users monetized over time. Generally, when we have a new user, there's some chance that they're going to sign up and pay for the subscription. But many of them, it just takes sometimes years to monetize.
是的——毛利率管理的問題我讓 Gillian 回答。至於預訂成長,我們的使用者會隨時間逐步被變現。一般來說,當我們有一位新使用者時,他們有一定機率會註冊並付費訂閱。但其中很多人需要一些時間,有時甚至要好幾年才會被變現。
So we're just very happy with the fact that we have a much larger user base, now active user base, that will eventually try to monetize. We're not giving guidance for '27 just yet. But I think the thing we're saying is we feel pretty good about our bookings growth, and we're starting to concentrate more monetization now that we have really managed to reaccelerate DAU growth.
所以我們對於現在擁有更大的使用者基礎、也就是更大的活躍使用者基礎感到非常開心,因為他們最終都會嘗試被我們變現。我們目前還不提供 2027 年的指引。但我想我們要表達的是:我們對預訂成長感覺相當不錯,而且在我們成功讓 DAU 成長重新加速之後,我們現在開始把更多重心放在變現上。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, and in terms of the gross margin, obviously, not guiding to next year, but -- yet, but if you think about this year, gross margin, we thought it would be about 2 points lower. The AI costs have not been as high as we thought, which is great, and we're still putting AI out, AI-based features like Video Call out to all of our paid users by the end of the year. So we feel really good about our ability to manage that. I would say our appetite to give AI-based features to our customer base is very high.
是的,至於毛利率,當然我們還沒有——也還不會——對明年提供指引。但如果你看今年,我們原本以為毛利率會低大約 2 個百分點。AI 成本沒有我們想得那麼高,這很棒;而且我們仍然會在年底前把像 Video Call 這類 AI 驅動的功能提供給所有付費使用者。所以我們對自己管理這件事的能力感到非常有信心。我會說,我們把 AI 驅動功能提供給客戶群的意願非常高。
We think there are really creative things we can do with it. So sort of like you saw this year, we'll manage this to an overall plan, but again, not giving next year's guidance. I would just say we do have an appetite to give as much as we can to customers, and you've seen us do that this year.
我們認為可以用它做出非常有創意的事情。所以就像你今年看到的,我們會依照整體計畫來管理,但同樣地,我們不提供明年的指引。我只想說,我們確實很願意盡可能多地把功能提供給客戶,而你也看到我們今年就是這麼做的。
Deborah Belevan - Vice President of Investor Relations
Deborah Belevan - Vice President of Investor Relations
Thank you both.
謝謝你們兩位。
Operator
Operator
Bryan Smilek, JPMorgan.
Bryan Smilek,JPMorgan。
Bryan Smilek - Analyst
Bryan Smilek - Analyst
Thanks for taking the questions. Just two quick ones from my end. Last quarter, we had talked about CURR improvements at all-time highs. And new cohorts are retaining better. Just curious any updates you have there, especially as the velocity of DAU growth starts to accelerate would have the overall curve trends look like on a cohort basis? And then, Gillian, just briefly on paid marketing as well.
謝謝回答問題。我這邊只有兩個簡短問題。上一季我們談到 CURR 的改善達到歷史新高,而且新的 cohort 留存更好。想請問你們有沒有任何更新,特別是當 DAU 成長速度開始加快時,從 cohort 的角度看整體曲線趨勢會是什麼樣子?另外,Gillian,也想簡單問一下付費行銷(paid marketing)的情況。
I believe up nicely year-on-year as you gain greater efficacy. Can you just talk about some of the LTV to CACs that you're seeing and where you're deploying marketing spend by channel?
我相信隨著你們效率提升,年增表現會相當不錯。你能否談談你們目前看到的一些 LTV 對 CAC 的情況,以及你們按通路部署行銷支出的方式?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, I can talk a little about CURR. I mean we mentioned CURR last quarter, it is a metric that we're very proud of. And it is the main metric we optimize to increase daily active users to increase the retention of the app. We don't want to get into the business of guiding CURR and giving updates in CURR every single quarter.
可以,我可以稍微談一下 CURR。我是說,我們上季提到過 CURR,這是我們非常引以為傲的一個指標。它也是我們用來最佳化的主要指標,以提升每日活躍用戶並提高 App 的留存。我們不想進入對 CURR 提供指引、並且每一季都更新 CURR 的業務。
So we're not talking about the precise numbers, but it basically keeps increasing. And that is a majority of the DAU growth that you see comes from increases in CURR.
所以我們不談精確數字,但它基本上持續在上升。而你看到的 DAU 成長中,多數來自 CURR 的提升。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
And then on paid marketing, this has been a real success story of our team this year. So just to put it in perspective, paid marketing is about 60% of our noncomp marketing spend, which is a bit over $100 million. We are profitable on that marketing spend, but we continue to believe we have more room to build upon the LTV CACs that we look at for the business. In terms of where that money is spent, it's really pretty broad-based, and we move it around fairly actively in terms of what is creating good returns for us. And the team continues to do that really effectively.
至於付費行銷,這是我們團隊今年真正的成功案例。為了讓大家有個概念,付費行銷約占我們非合作(noncomp)行銷支出的 60%,總額略高於 1 億美元。我們在這筆行銷支出上是有獲利的,但我們仍然相信,在我們用來評估業務的 LTV/CAC 上,還有進一步提升的空間。就資金投放的去向而言,其實相當分散,我們也會相當積極地在不同通路間調整,把預算移到能為我們帶來良好回報的地方。團隊也持續非常有效率地在做這件事。
So I think the net on paid for Duolingo is it's probably never going to be the majority of how we go to market. That's just not how we think about it. But it's a really helpful tool and our team has done a really good job. And we're feeling that we're getting better and better returns on it and getting smarter on it. So it's been additive to us in 2026 and will be probably again in '27.
所以我認為,對 Duolingo 來說,付費投放的結論是:它大概永遠不會成為我們市場推廣(go-to-market)的主要方式。我們不是那樣思考的。但它是一個非常有幫助的工具,而我們團隊做得非常好。我們覺得回報越來越好、也越來越聰明地運用它。所以它在 2026 年對我們是加分的,到了 2027 年可能也會一樣。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Yeah, I should say for internally, this is one of the biggest wins we've had this year that we became actually intelligent about performance marketing. And I'm very happy about that.
對,我也想補充一下,從內部來看,這是我們今年最大的勝利之一:我們真的變得懂得如何做成效型行銷(performance marketing)。我對此非常開心。
Operator
Operator
Mark Mahaney, Evercore.
Mark Mahaney,Evercore。
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
Let's try 2 questions. I know this Video Call functionality as you're rolling it out across more of the Super Duolingo users subscriber base. What have you seen so far in terms of the boost that's had to engagement and retention or satisfaction? I would assume that it's had a material impact. It's one of the reasons why, as the costs come down, you're spreading it out.
我試著問兩個問題。我知道你們的「視訊通話」功能正在擴大推廣到更多 Super Duolingo 訂閱用戶。到目前為止,你們在參與度、留存或滿意度方面看到什麼提升?我猜它應該帶來了顯著影響。這也是為什麼隨著成本下降,你們會把它推廣得更廣。
But what have you actually seen in the data so far? Is it too early to tell? And then secondly, I know you talked about Chess earlier, so how about my second favorite topic, which is math. And how many users -- and I didn't see anything in here, but maybe it's in your press release, but the adoption you're seeing there, is there an opportunity there to also do a separate or combined price action?
但你們目前在數據上實際看到的是什麼?現在判斷是否還太早?第二個問題,我知道你們先前談到西洋棋,那我第二喜歡的主題是數學。數學那邊有多少用戶——我在這裡沒看到相關內容,但也許在你們的新聞稿裡——你們看到的採用情況如何?那裡是否也有機會做單獨或合併的價格調整?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, thank you for both questions. So video call, I mean, look, we feel really good about video call. It is a feature that actually teaches this conversation, and we see adoption of it continue to grow. The team just keeps making it better and better.
好的,謝謝這兩個問題。關於視訊通話,我是說,坦白講,我們對視訊通話感覺非常好。這是一個真正能教會對話的功能,我們看到它的採用率持續成長。團隊也一直把它做得越來越好。
And we see -- one of the ways we measure it is just a number of words spoken per active user, not practices or Video Call, but practices are of Duolingo. And that number just keeps going up. It's kind of -- I think it's roughly doubled over the last year or so. So we feel pretty good about that. And the other thing is we know that when people try video call, during the free trial, for certain types of video calls that we tailored to the user's difficulty, then they are more likely to subscribe to actually pay for the subscription.
而且我們看到——我們衡量它的一種方式,是每位活躍用戶的口說字數,不是指練習或視訊通話的次數,而是指在 Duolingo 上的練習所產生的口說字數。這個數字一直在上升。大概——我想在過去一年左右,差不多翻倍了。所以我們對此相當有信心。另一點是,我們知道當人們在免費試用期間嘗試視訊通話,尤其是我們依照用戶難度量身打造的某些視訊通話類型時,他們更有可能訂閱並實際付費。
So we feel really good about it. This is a feature that just keeps getting better. In terms of math, look, this is also my favorite topic. I love math. I love our math product.
所以我們對它感覺非常好。這個功能只會越來越好。至於數學,坦白說,這也是我最喜歡的主題。我愛數學,也很喜歡我們的數學產品。
It keeps getting better and better. It's also a huge opportunity. There's about 1 billion people in the world learning math. So I really think it's a huge opportunity. It is growing about at the same rate as languages.
它也在變得越來越好。這同時也是一個巨大的機會。全球大約有 10 億人在學數學,所以我真的認為這是很大的機會。它的成長速度大約和語言學習相同。
So I'm happy that it is growing, but I would hope that it can start growing at the rate that Chess is growing, which is growing faster. So we're going to continue making a better teaching tool. One of the things that we have found, by the way, is -- this is not that big of a thing to learn, but people prefer to play the game of Chess than to learn math.
所以我很高興它在成長,但我也希望它能開始以西洋棋那樣的速度成長,因為西洋棋成長更快。所以我們會持續把它做成更好的教學工具。順帶一提,我們發現一件事——這不算什麼驚天動地的發現——人們更喜歡玩西洋棋的遊戲,而不是學數學。
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
They're both good.
兩者都很好。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
I think they're both good, but hey.
我覺得兩者都很好,但就是這樣。
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
Mark Mahaney - Equity Analyst
Thank you very much.
非常感謝。
Operator
Operator
Omar Dessouky, Bank of America.
Omar Dessouky,美國銀行。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Hi, Omar.
嗨,Omar。
Omar Dessouky - Analyst
Omar Dessouky - Analyst
Hi there. Thanks for taking my question. I wanted to elaborate a little bit on the gaming partnerships. You highlighted Brawl Stars and Eggy Party, which you said, brought millions of new users. So how scalable is this approach? Have you approached a meaningful percentage of like the top 100 mobile game developers out there? And what is the economic incentive for game publisher to collaborate with you, particularly that you're kind of competing for the same consumer attention?
嗨,你好。謝謝讓我提問。我想更深入談一下遊戲合作夥伴關係。你提到《Brawl Stars》和《Eggy Party》,你說它們帶來了數百萬新用戶。那這種做法的可擴展性如何?你們是否已經接觸了市面上前 100 大手機遊戲開發商中相當有意義的一部分?另外,對遊戲發行商而言,與你們合作的經濟誘因是什麼,尤其是你們某種程度上是在競爭同一批消費者的注意力?
And then I have a follow-up along the same lines.
然後我還有一個同樣方向的追問。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
So we're very happy with these partnerships. I mean generally, for a lot of parts, people come to us as opposed to us having to go to them. I mean, just historically, people really want to partner with us. So we're very happy.
我們對這些合作非常滿意。一般來說,在很多情況下,是他們來找我們,而不是我們必須去找他們。我的意思是,從歷史上看,大家真的很想跟我們合作。所以我們很開心。
We think we're going to continue doing some of these. Now it's not the case that there are hundreds of such partners that we're going to do. So we're seeing it more. And this is probably going to happen a couple of times a year. And they do bring users, and we're very happy with that.
我們認為會持續做其中一些合作。不過也不是說我們會有上百個這樣的合作夥伴。所以我們的看法是,這類合作大概一年會發生幾次。他們確實會帶來用戶,我們對此很滿意。
But most of our events, if you look at what the plan for next year, most of our events are first-party events. These are our own things that are -- we're going to do things like Avatar suits and stuff like that. In terms of what is the incentive for the game publishers, there's no money being exchanged in these partnerships and we didn't pay them and they didn't pay us to do that. What we're finding with them with these partnerships is that it's a win-win for both. They get a bunch of users, and we get a bunch of users.
但如果你看我們明年的規劃,大多數活動其實是第一方活動(first-party events),也就是我們自己做的事情——我們會做像是角色造型套裝(Avatar suits)之類的。至於遊戲發行商的誘因,這些合作並沒有金錢往來:我們沒有付錢給他們,他們也沒有付錢給我們。我們在這些合作中看到的是雙贏:他們獲得一批用戶,我們也獲得一批用戶。
So it doesn't seem like we're competing for that. And generally, the incentive is just cross-promotion and for certain games, certainly the case for Supercell and Brawl Stars, they do a lot of things to keep their game fresh. And one of the things that they did when they did the partnership with us is for about a period of a few weeks, the entire games was just teamed with Duolingo, and the players like this. It was a very positive thing in their community. So that's the incentive for doing that.
所以看起來我們並不是在競爭那件事。一般而言,誘因就是交叉推廣;而對某些遊戲來說——以 Supercell 和《Brawl Stars》為例——他們會做很多事情來保持遊戲的新鮮感。他們與我們合作時做的一件事是,在幾週的時間裡,整個遊戲都換上 Duolingo 的主題,玩家很喜歡。這在他們社群裡是非常正面的事情。這就是他們做這件事的誘因。
I mean they gained also a bunch of active users and revenue.
我的意思是,他們也獲得了一批活躍用戶和營收。
Omar Dessouky - Analyst
Omar Dessouky - Analyst
Okay. And my follow-up is, does this somehow dovetail with your performance marketing? Because as we all know, mobile games are a major driver of just the performance marketing within mobile gaming apps in general. So do you view this approach as sort of complementary to that? Are you looking to penetrate more of the gaming kind of audience and bring those over through performance marketing and using this experience to a -- how should we think about that going forward for you?
好的。那我的追問是,這是否會與你們的成效型行銷有所銜接?因為我們都知道,手機遊戲是整體行動 App 成效型行銷的一個主要驅動因素。所以你們是否把這種做法視為互補?你們是否希望更深入滲透遊戲受眾,透過成效型行銷把他們帶過來,並利用這些經驗來——未來我們應該如何看待你們在這方面的策略?
Is it a pretty big audience.
那是一個相當大的受眾。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yes. I do think they're related. Because you're right, a lot of the performance marketing ads are for games. Certainly, the ads as we show in our product as well. So we do think they're related.
是的,我確實認為它們是相關的。因為你說得對,很多成效型行銷廣告都是遊戲的。當然,我們在產品裡展示的廣告也是如此。所以我們確實認為它們彼此相關。
We did see when these partnerships were going on, we did see our performance marketing actually benefit from the partnership. So we do see that. I don't think we fully understand the relationship with these 2, but I do think they are additive to each other.
我們也看到在這些合作進行期間,我們的成效型行銷實際上也從合作中受益。所以我們確實看到這點。我不認為我們已經完全理解這兩者之間的關係,但我確實認為它們能彼此加乘。
Operator
Operator
Ron Josey, Citi.
Ron Josey,花旗。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Hi, Ron.
嗨,Ron。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
I think you're muted, Ron.
Ron,我想你靜音了。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
There you are. We hear you.
好了,我們聽得到你了。
Unidentified Participant
Unidentified Participant
Hey, you can hear me.
嘿,你們聽得到我嗎?
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Yeah. Yeah, hi.
是的。是的,嗨。
Unidentified Participant
Unidentified Participant
Perfect, thank you. Sorry about that. This is [James Michael] on for Ron. Given experiments per week grew faster than head count last year, and Green Machine have driven two quarters of acceleration. Can you provide more color on the underlying changes in the architecture of the testing process? And how much more throughput there could be an AI to run more of the experiment design and analysis?
太好了,謝謝你。抱歉剛才那樣。我是代替 Ron 的 [James Michael]。鑑於去年每週實驗數的成長速度快於人員編制成長,而且 Green Machine 推動了連續兩季的加速。你能否更詳細說明測試流程架構底層有哪些變化?以及若用 AI 來執行更多實驗設計與分析,吞吐量還能提升多少?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yes, we're very happy about that. If you look right now, our -- the number of experiments that we ran, call it, the last month, is up about 90% year-over-year compared to last year. And our employee number grew by like 10%. So per capita, this is a major improvement. A lot of that -- not entirely, but a lot of that is because of AI.
是的,我們對此非常滿意。如果你看現在,我們——我們執行的實驗數量,以上個月來說,與去年同期相比大約年增 90%。而員工人數只成長了大概 10%。所以以人均來看,這是非常大的改善。其中很大一部分——不完全是,但很大一部分——是因為 AI。
We're just seeing -- it took some time for the promise of AI in coding to actually turn into improvements in speed, but we are now seeing that. And we're seeing not just significantly higher experiment count, which I believe will continue going up and up and up. but also the latency, the time between an idea to it being in front of the users is much shorter now. And that allows us to iterate a lot. And I think that's extremely compatible with our process of improvement because we just run a ton of A/B/B test.
我們確實看到——AI 在寫程式上的承諾花了一些時間才真正轉化為速度上的提升,但我們現在正在看到這點。而且我們看到的不只是實驗數顯著增加(我相信還會持續往上、往上、往上),延遲也下降了:從一個想法到呈現在使用者面前的時間現在短很多。這讓我們能大量迭代。我認為這與我們的改進流程非常契合,因為我們就是跑大量的 A/B/B 測試。
And what's good about AI is it's particularly good at these smaller changes. Larger changes, a lot of times, it still kind of messes up. But the smaller stuff, it's pretty good at it, and we mainly run on hundreds and hundreds of tiny changes. So we're finding it quite compatible with the way we operate. And this is why we feel pretty good about our ability to continue growing both our DAUs because of growth in retention, but also our monetization because we're going to -- my sense is next to you.
AI 的好處在於,它特別擅長這些較小的改動。較大的改動很多時候它還是會有點搞砸。但小的東西它做得相當好,而我們主要就是在做數百、數百個微小改動。所以我們發現它和我們的運作方式非常相容。這也是為什麼我們對於能持續成長 DAU(因為留存提升帶來的成長),以及變現(因為我們將會——我的感覺是接下來輪到你了)都相當有信心。
I don't know the exact quantity, but we're going to run a hell of a lot more experiments next year than we did this year.
我不知道確切數量,但明年我們會跑比今年多得多的實驗。
Unidentified Participant
Unidentified Participant
Helpful. A quick follow-up on that. Last quarter, you flagged shorter attention spans and testing shorter minimum session lengths. Has anything shipped here and are you seeing down amount gained specifically from session frequency as well as retention?
很有幫助。針對這點快速追問一下。上季你提到注意力時間變短,並在測試更短的最低單次使用時長。這方面有任何功能已上線嗎?你們是否看到具體的提升,特別是在使用頻率以及留存方面?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, we're working -- this is something we're really working on. We're not disclosing any of that, but we are actively -- we have staffed teams now to try to increased engagement throughout, and we feel pretty good about that work.
是的,我們正在做——這是我們真的很努力在做的事情。我們不會披露任何細節,但我們正在積極——我們現在已經配置了團隊,嘗試在整體上提升互動度,我們對這項工作感覺相當不錯。
Unidentified Participant
Unidentified Participant
Thank you.
謝謝。
Operator
Operator
Justin Patterson, KeyBanc.
Justin Patterson,KeyBanc。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Justin, how are you?
Justin,你好嗎?
Justin Patterson - Analyst
Justin Patterson - Analyst
I'm great, Luis. How are you doing?
我很好,Luis。你怎麼樣?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Also great.
我也很好。
Justin Patterson - Analyst
Justin Patterson - Analyst
Great. Well, first off, congratulations just with the DAU progress this year. You've certainly come a long way within there. I guess as we head out of this year into '27, how do you think about just the right degree of friction and step to put back to the app and steps to monetize, so you don't repeat the lessons of 2025 within there? And I'll have one follow-up.
太好了。首先,恭喜你們今年 DAU 的進展。你們在這方面確實走了很長一段路。我想問的是,當我們從今年走向 2027 年,你們如何看待在 App 中回加多少「摩擦」與步驟、以及變現所需的步驟,才能避免重蹈 2025 年的教訓?我還有一個追問。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
It's a great question. I mean we're -- we have a strict guardrail inside the company to not degrade the free user experience anymore. The good news is that we really -- we took this year to figure out how to monetize without degrading the free user experience. And I think we just found a number of levers that work that we feel pretty good about that. But yes, I mean, this is a lesson learned.
這是個很好的問題。我們——公司內部有非常嚴格的護欄,確保不再降低免費使用者體驗。好消息是,我們確實——我們用今年來摸索如何在不降低免費使用者體驗的情況下進行變現。我認為我們找到了一些有效的槓桿,而且我們對此相當有信心。但沒錯,這確實是一個學到的教訓。
We do not want to mess up the free user experience anymore. I don't believe that's going to happen.
我們不想再把免費使用者體驗搞砸了。我不認為那會再發生。
Justin Patterson - Analyst
Justin Patterson - Analyst
Got it. And then thinking about just the decision to deprecate Max in this way, putting Max users into the Super Family plan. Talk about just why that's the right choice versus the individual family plan. Or excuse me, the individual Super plan. And then that creates the potential for more paid sharing, if you will, friends, potentially sharing with one another.
了解。接著談到以這種方式淘汰 Max、把 Max 使用者導入 Super Family 方案的決策。請談談為什麼這是正確的選擇,而不是導入個人家庭方案——抱歉,我是說個人 Super 方案。這也可能帶來更多「付費共享」的可能性,例如朋友之間彼此共享。
So would love to hear about how you're thinking of the guardrails in there. So these are truly net new people versus some canceling and just getting on a friend's plan.
很想聽聽你們如何思考其中的護欄,確保這些是真正新增的付費人數,而不是有人取消後改加入朋友的方案。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, it's a good question. I mean the first thing to say is that at the moment, even though family plan is a pretty good deal when compared to the individual. Even though that's the case, we like it because it has extremely high retention. So over time, it just -- we like it. The retention is really good.
是的,這是個好問題。我想首先要說的是,目前即使家庭方案相較個人方案算是很划算。即便如此,我們喜歡它,因為它的留存率極高。長期來看,它——我們喜歡它。留存真的很好。
And it makes sense that the retention is really good. If you have people as long as one of them is still using it, they kind of keep paying for the plan. So that's why we like it. The reason we decided to move Max individual to Super Family was because they're roughly the same price. So that allowed us to not have kind of a onetime decrease in bookings from these people.
而且留存很好是合理的。如果你有一群人,只要其中有人還在用,他們就會繼續付這個方案的費用。所以這就是我們喜歡它的原因。我們決定把 Max 個人方案移到 Super Family,是因為它們價格大致相同。這讓我們不至於在這些使用者身上出現一次性的預訂額(bookings)下降。
And for them, we think it's a good deal. I mean, it's basically the identical features just you can invite five more people. And that will happen. I'm sure there's some amount of cannibalization, but we're not really seeing that in the numbers. It's not material enough for us to like see anything that is like, oh, this is actually bad for us because we've been A/B testing this for a little while.
對他們來說,我們認為這是很划算的。我是說,功能基本完全一樣,只是你可以再邀請五個人。而那確實會發生。我確定會有一定程度的蠶食效應,但我們在數據上其實沒有看到。它的影響不夠重大,讓我們看到任何像是「喔,這其實對我們不利」的訊號,因為我們已經做了一段時間的 A/B 測試。
And we just it looks good.
而且看起來效果很好。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
And I think it speaks, Justin, to our confidence and the size of the market opportunity here. to be able to do that, and we're really not concerned that we're going to impact our market opportunity. We continue to be extremely bullish about what's ahead for us and the billion learners that we think we can touch, it's going to give us a much bigger business over time.
我認為這也反映了,Justin,我們對這裡市場機會的規模與我們的信心:我們能這樣做,而且我們並不擔心會影響我們的市場機會。我們依然對未來非常看多;我們認為能觸及的十億學習者,將在長期帶來更大的業務規模。
Operator
Operator
Alec Brondolo, Wells Fargo.
Alec Brondolo,Wells Fargo。
Alec Brondolo - Analyst
Alec Brondolo - Analyst
Yes. Hey, thanks so much for the question. Greatly appreciate it. I think the other change this year to touring beyond the deprecation of Max is the light tier. I've been seeing lights here. I've been seeing light tier be kind of merchandise to me and my testing of the app pretty frequently in the third quarter and the beginning of the fourth quarter. So just any thoughts about your expectations around kind of light penetration next year? And the state of the advertising experience in Duolingo right now would be great.
是的。嗨,謝謝讓我提問。非常感謝。我認為今年除了淘汰 Max 之外的另一個變化是 Light 方案。我在第三季以及第四季初測試 App 時,經常看到 Light 方案被推送給我。所以想請教你們對明年 Light 滲透率的預期?以及目前 Duolingo 的廣告體驗狀況,也希望能分享一下。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Okay, so it's light and ads. Light, we are testing it. We have not pushed it very far and we may try to push it more. We're mainly driven by the results of our A/B tests and I think our A/B tests for Light have just not been home runs. I think there's probably some wins there, but they just haven't been home runs. So I don't actually know what will happen with Light. It's a much cheaper plan that also has ads. I just don't know what will happen. It may be the case that ends up only being.
好的,所以是 Light 和廣告。Light 方面,我們正在測試。我們還沒有大規模推進,但可能會嘗試推得更廣。我們主要是由 A/B 測試結果驅動,而我認為 Light 的 A/B 測試結果還稱不上是大獲全勝。我覺得可能有一些勝利點,但還不是那種「大爆發」。所以我其實不知道 Light 最後會怎麼發展。這是一個便宜很多、同時也包含廣告的方案。我真的不知道會怎樣。也許最後只會——
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Served in certain regions, kind of probably regions with lower GDP per capita. But I don't actually know. At the moment, this is pretty small, and we just have not seen it be a major home run.
在某些地區提供,可能是人均 GDP 較低的地區。但我其實不確定。目前這規模還很小,我們也還沒看到它成為一個非常大的「大獲全勝」。
But it's there. It's still being tested. In terms of ads, we feel very good about ads in terms of the team. We now have.
但它確實存在,仍在測試中。至於廣告,我們對廣告很有信心,就團隊而言。我們現在已經有——
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Okay. So it's light on that. We are testing it. We have not pushed it very far, and we may try to push it more. I mean we're mainly driven by the results of our EBITDA.
好的。所以關於 Light 就先說到這。我們正在測試,還沒有推得很廣,但可能會再推進一些。我們主要是由 EBITDA 的結果驅動。
And I think our EBITDA for light have just not been home runs. I think there's probably some wins there, but they just haven't been home runs. So I don't actually know what will happen with light. It's a much cheaper plan that also has ads. I just don't know what will happen.
我認為 Light 的 EBITDA 表現還稱不上是大獲全勝。我覺得可能有一些成果,但還不是那種「大爆發」。所以我其實不知道 Light 最後會怎麼發展。這是一個便宜很多、同時也包含廣告的方案。我真的不知道會怎樣。
It may be the case that ends up only being served in certain regions, kind of probably regions with lower GDP or capita. But I don't actually know. At the moment, this is pretty small, and we just have not seen it be a major home run. What is there, it's still being tested. In terms of ads, we feel very good about ads.
也許最後只會在某些地區提供,可能是人均 GDP 較低的地區。但我其實不確定。目前這規模還很小,我們也還沒看到它成為一個非常大的「大獲全勝」。它確實存在,仍在測試中。至於廣告,我們對廣告感覺非常好。
In terms of the team, we now have an actual serious team working on our own ads business. So we feel like next year, our ads business is going to do well. And just to remind you about our ads business, we've had historically not invested much in our own ads. And so what we did is we just used these ad networks with kind of the lowest common denominator of ads. And what we're doing now is we are switching those to much higher quality ads.
就團隊而言,我們現在已經有一支真正認真在做自家廣告業務的團隊在運作。因此我們覺得明年我們的廣告業務會表現得很好。也提醒一下大家,過去我們在自家廣告上歷來投入不多。所以我們做法是使用那些廣告網路,投放某種程度上「最低共同標準」的廣告。而我們現在正在做的是,把那些廣告切換成品質高得多的廣告。
Now that takes some time to do, in part we're doing it through the direct sales, we now have a direct sales team. It's not a very large direct sales team, but it's a very good direct sales team. But we're doing some of that. And also, we're just switching the ads to higher-quality ads. So the transition is going to take some time.
當然這需要一些時間,部分原因是我們透過直銷來做這件事;我們現在有一個直銷團隊。這不是一個很大的直銷團隊,但它是一個非常優秀的直銷團隊。我們會做一部分直銷,同時也只是把廣告切換成更高品質的廣告。所以這個轉換會需要一些時間。
But once we're done with the transition, you're just going to see ads that are significantly higher quality on Duolingo with kind of more well-known brands and higher quality brands and in addition, that pay us more. I think over the long term, we feel actually pretty excited about our ads business.
但一旦轉換完成,你就會在 Duolingo 上看到顯著更高品質的廣告,會有更知名的品牌、更高端的品牌,而且另外也會付給我們更多。我認為從長期來看,我們其實對廣告業務感到相當興奮。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
The team made some really nice progress during the quarter. So if you look at the full quarter, the ads business was sort of flattish but actually, it exited the quarter growing nicely. So we think the team is making good progress there.
這一季團隊取得了很不錯的進展。所以如果你看整個季度,廣告業務大致上算是持平,但其實在季度末是以不錯的成長態勢收尾。因此我們認為團隊在這方面進展良好。
Operator
Operator
Andrew Boone, Citizen. Andrew.
Andrew Boone,Citizen。Andrew。
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Guys, appreciate you taking the question.I wanted to go first in terms of following up on Justin's question. As we think about 2027, you guys clearly have transitioned from monetization now into engagement. As we go back to a monetization format, should we expect a change in terms of how you guys are going after that? Is that different in-app purchases? Are there any things that are now off limits?
各位,感謝讓我提問。我想先接續 Justin 的問題。當我們思考 2027 年時,你們顯然已經從變現轉向到參與度(engagement)。當我們再回到變現模式時,我們是否應該預期你們在推進方式上會有改變?會不會是不同的應用程式內購(in-app purchases)?是否有任何事情現在變成禁區?
Like is it a restarting of the engine that was previously up and going? Or are you guys going to approach this differently? And then just my second question, another follow-up. But as we think about AI unlocking Duolingo broadly, Luis, is the biggest needle mover for AI, is it internal? Is it new products that become available?
這會像是把之前已經運轉起來的引擎重新啟動嗎?還是你們會用不同的方式來做?另外我的第二個問題也是延伸追問:當我們思考 AI 在更廣泛層面解鎖 Duolingo 的可能性時,Luis,AI 最大的推動力是內部(internal)嗎?還是會是新產品的推出?
And what happens as we've seen AI deflation kind of come through the model? Like what does that unlock for you in terms of internal processes that now become available maybe in a year or two years as we've seen with video calls? Thank you.
以及當我們看到 AI 的「通縮」逐步反映在模型中時會怎樣?例如在一到兩年內,像我們在視訊通話(video calls)上看到的那樣,這會為你們解鎖哪些可能的內部流程?謝謝。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Great. In terms of monetization, I mean, I don't know exactly how to answer your question in terms of like is it a restart? Is it -- I mean we've been working on monetization this year. It's just we told the monetization team, look, you cannot degrade the free user experience anymore. We have to come up with new ways of monetizing.
好的。就變現而言,我的意思是,我不確定要怎麼精準回答你關於「是不是重啟」的問題。我的意思是——我們今年一直都有在做變現。只是我們跟變現團隊說,你們不能再去降低免費用戶體驗了。我們必須想出新的變現方式。
And they have. And that's working really well. So I think you're going to see us -- first of all, the way you're going to see us work is similar to how we've been working the whole time, which is we're going to run thousands of A/B/B tests to try to monetize better. The one thing that you're not going to see us do is add friction to the free user experience, but we're going to do all kinds of things. Certainly, there's IAPs in there.
而他們確實做到了,而且效果很好。所以我想你會看到我們——首先,我們的工作方式會和一直以來很類似,也就是我們會跑成千上萬個 A/B/B 測試來嘗試把變現做得更好。你不會看到我們做的一件事是:在免費用戶體驗上增加摩擦(friction)。但我們會做各式各樣的事情。當然其中包含 IAP(應用程式內購)。
Certainly, there's better ads in there. But there's also other things that get people to subscribe. Video Call is a good thing. I mean, Video Call for the longest time was just available in Max. Now that it's in Super, I think we feel a lot better about merchandising it more often because it's a lot more affordable.
當然也包含更好的廣告。但也還有其他能促使人們訂閱的做法。視訊通話(Video Call)就是一個很好的例子。我的意思是,視訊通話在很長一段時間內只在 Max 方案提供。現在它也在 Super 方案裡了,我們覺得更能放心地更常去推廣它,因為它便宜得多、更可負擔。
I mean the reality is that Max was a pretty expensive plan. So we feel pretty good about that. But generally, the type of work they're going to do is just a lot of A/B/B tests.
現實是 Max 是一個相當昂貴的方案。所以我們對此感覺很好。但總體而言,他們要做的工作類型就是大量的 A/B/B 測試。
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Luis, I don't mean to interrupt, but does that imply that conversion rates then don't improve on a go-forward basis? Because you guys then need to grow with users without additional friction?
Luis,我不想打斷你,但這是否意味著未來轉換率(conversion rates)不會再改善?因為你們需要在不增加額外摩擦的情況下,靠用戶成長來推動?
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
I don't know the answer to your question, whether we're going to be able to improve them or not. Obviously, we do want to improve conversion rates. I don't know. I feel like there are some things -- some of the things we've done this year have improved conversion rates, things like longer free trials, improve conversion rates. And by the way, at the moment, we're not offering longer free trials to every user.
我不知道你的問題答案,也就是我們是否能改善轉換率。顯然我們確實想提升轉換率。我不確定。我覺得有一些事情——我們今年做的一些事情已經提升了轉換率,例如更長的免費試用期就能提升轉換率。順帶一提,目前我們並沒有對每一位用戶都提供更長的免費試用期。
We've kind of given them to some users. We're going to expand that further. So I do believe there's some increase in conversion rates. I don't know by how much. But what is true is that what you're not going to see us do is kind of squeezing users.
我們算是只給了部分用戶。我們會進一步擴大。所以我確實相信轉換率會有一些提升。我不知道幅度會是多少。但可以確定的是,你不會看到我們去「擠壓」用戶。
You're not going to see us do that.
你不會看到我們那樣做。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, and I think, Andrew, you already saw in the quarter, we reaccelerated bookings growth in the quarter relative to last quarter. And I think you're seeing us be careful about how we go do all that. One of the things we've talked to you all about is that top of the funnel matters a lot. Top of the funnel converts in a multitude of the amount that the core base does.
是的,而且我想,Andrew,你在本季已經看到,相較於上一季,我們在本季讓預訂(bookings)成長重新加速。我想你也看到我們在做這些事情時很謹慎。我們跟各位談過的一點是:漏斗頂端(top of the funnel)非常重要。漏斗頂端的轉換量是核心基礎用戶群的好幾倍。
And so that's why you've seen us work on things like paid marketing, some of these outreach things growing in new places and new products. And I think that's a piece of the puzzle to on an aggregate basis.
因此你會看到我們在付費行銷(paid marketing)、一些外展(outreach)活動、在新地區成長以及新產品等方面投入。我認為這些在整體層面上是拼圖的一部分。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
And then your second part of your question was about AI. We are -- there's 2 places and you mentioned the 2 places that AI really helps. One is just internal productivity. And the other one is AI features in the product. And we're very happy about both.
然後你問題的第二部分是關於 AI。我們——AI 主要在兩個地方帶來幫助,而你也提到了這兩個地方。一個是內部生產力(internal productivity),另一個是產品中的 AI 功能。我們對這兩者都非常滿意。
In terms of internal productivity, like I said previously in the call, we're just seeing our team be able to ship A/B/B tests much faster. And we're getting to the point where simpler A/B/B tests are now being shipped by non-engineers. So a person who's a product manager or a designer is now able to fully from idea to it's in the app. They're able to do it now by themselves without the help of an engineer. Now that doesn't mean we don't need engineers.
就內部生產力而言,正如我先前在電話會議中提到的,我們看到團隊能更快地推出 A/B/B 測試。我們也正走到一個階段:較簡單的 A/B/B 測試現在可以由非工程師來上線。因此,一位產品經理或設計師,現在可以從想法到真正進到 App 裡,整個流程都能自己完成,而不需要工程師協助。當然這不代表我們不需要工程師。
We need engineers for all kinds of things, including the system. We built an internal system that allows us to do that. We're trying to make the system better and better. So we definitely have a major need for engineers. But the fact is that significantly more people are able to run their own A/B/B tests.
我們在各種事情上都需要工程師,包括系統本身。我們建立了一個內部系統,讓我們能做到這件事。我們也在努力讓這個系統越來越好。所以我們確實非常需要工程師。但事實是,有顯著更多的人能夠自行跑自己的 A/B/B 測試。
And so I don't know the precise increase in a number of A/B tests that we'll run next year, but it will be multiples of what we ran this year. I don't know if it will be 3 times. I don't know if it will be 10 times. I don't know because all this stuff is changing, but it will be multiples. And so I'm very happy with that.
因此我不知道明年我們會跑的 A/B 測試數量精確會增加多少,但會是今年的好幾倍。我不知道會是 3 倍,還是 10 倍。我不知道,因為這些事情都在變化,但一定會是倍數成長。所以我對此非常高興。
And that, I think, is one of the things that we feel bullish about. In terms of the product, you'll just see us put AI in a lot more places. We're working on a number of features, particularly practicing speaking, that are not just Video Call, that you'll see there. And in addition to that, you'll just see improvements in how fast we can ship new teaching modules, let's call them. Like, for example, we're just going to teach a lot more Chess, a lot more content.
而我認為,這也是我們看多(bullish)的原因之一。就產品而言,你會看到我們把 AI 放到更多地方。我們正在開發多項功能,特別是口說練習,不只是視訊通話(Video Call),你也會看到那些功能。此外,你也會看到我們在推出新的教學模組(姑且這麼稱呼)方面的速度提升。例如,我們會教更多西洋棋(Chess),提供更多內容。
We'll just be able -- we're able to just ship it way faster now.
我們現在就是能——能夠快很多地把它們上線。
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Great. Thank you.
很好,謝謝。
Operator
Operator
Alexander Sklar, Raymond James.
Alexander Sklar,Raymond James。
Alexander Sklar - Analyst
Alexander Sklar - Analyst
Thank you, Two-part question for me on gross margin. First, maybe for you, Gillian, just will the sunsetting of Max, have any impact on gross margin beyond what you've outlined in the fourth quarter? And then second, for you, Luis, the mix of direct payments outside the app store, any change to how you're thinking about that opportunity, either just as a result of the rise in personal agents to drive traffic more direct to you or just more than market testing?
謝謝。我有一個關於毛利率(gross margin)的兩部分問題。第一,可能想請教你,Gillian,Max 方案的下架(sunsetting)除了你在第四季所說明的內容之外,是否還會對毛利率造成任何影響?第二,想請教你,Luis,關於在 App Store 之外的直接付款(direct payments)的組合占比,你對這個機會的看法是否有任何改變?不論是因為個人代理(personal agents)的興起,可能帶來更多直接導流到你們這邊,或是單純因為更多市場測試?
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
So Alex, our guidance for the fourth quarter, which implies gross margin will come down just about point-ish. It is inclusive of the transition we're expecting on Max. I think as you've seen our team do all year, we're always have an eye to how do we get more efficient with our AI spend. But I think we also want to fit more AI in the product and then balance that to our bottom line. So you will, we believe, see some decline in the gross margin sequentially, but still a very attractive number and we'll be able to put a lot more AI content in the product and do the Max transition as well.
所以 Alex,我們對第四季的指引意味著毛利率大概會下降約 1 個百分點左右。這已包含我們預期在 Max 上的轉換。我想如同你今年看到我們團隊一直在做的,我們始終關注如何讓 AI 支出更有效率。但同時我們也希望在產品中加入更多 AI,並在此與損益表之間取得平衡。因此我們認為你會看到毛利率在季比上有些下滑,但仍會是非常吸引人的水準,而且我們也能在產品中放入更多 AI 內容,同時完成 Max 的轉換。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, And in terms of direct payments, we do -- for the longest time, at least in our apps, I mean, we have an iPhone app and an Android app and our website. For the longest time, you can only do direct payments on our website. We can now do direct payments in certain regions and for certain users for our apps. We do use it in certain cases, and particularly one of the places where we're using it quite a bit is in performance marketing.
對。至於直接付款(direct payments),長期以來——至少在我們的應用程式端——也就是 iPhone App、Android App 以及我們的網站,長期以來你只能在我們網站上進行直接付款。我們現在已經能在某些地區、針對某些用戶,在 App 內進行直接付款。我們在某些情況下會使用,尤其我們使用得相當多的一個地方是在成效行銷(performance marketing)。
When we acquire user performance marketing, we actually acquire them to a website and then get them to download the app. That's pretty standard practice. So you'll see us do some of that. I don't know -- just judging just by the number of people we have working on this, I don't know if this is going to be a major driver for next year. I mean we do use them in different places, but it is not the case that at the moment, we're like we must switch everything to direct payments.
當我們透過成效行銷獲取用戶時,實際上會先把他們導到網站,然後再引導他們下載 App。這是相當標準的做法。所以你會看到我們做一些這類操作。我不確定——單就投入在這件事的人力規模來看——我不確定這會不會成為明年的主要驅動因素。我們確實在不同地方使用,但目前並不是那種「我們必須把所有東西都切換到直接付款」的狀態。
That's not currently in the cards.
目前沒有這樣的規劃。
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Wyatt Swanson - Analyst
Got it. And as it relates to kind of the record Q3 gross margin, you wouldn't attribute any of that to the growing mix of driving traffic directly to yourself?
了解。那就第三季毛利率創新高這件事而言,你不會把其中任何一部分歸因於把流量更多地直接導向你們自己(自有渠道)的占比提升嗎?
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
No. The main delta in the gross margin was better revenue and less AI costs than we expected going through.
不會。毛利率的主要差異在於營收表現更好,以及 AI 成本低於我們原先的預期。
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
Ygal Arounian - Analyst
All right. Thank you both.
好。謝謝兩位。
Operator
Operator
Ross Sandler with Barclays.
Barclays 的 Ross Sandler。
Ross Sandler - Equity Analyst
Ross Sandler - Equity Analyst
Hey, guys. Luis, I wanted to go back to the big picture with AI. So we can all see that AI is progressing at a pretty massive clip. The models are getting better. The latency is getting faster. Meta even followed you guys with kind of a sassy avatar launch recently.
嗨,各位。Luis,我想回到 AI 的大方向。我們都看得出來 AI 正以非常驚人的速度進展:模型變得更好、延遲更快。Meta 甚至最近也跟進你們,推出了有點俏皮的虛擬分身(avatar)。
But the question I have is that, like there's some academic research that says one-on-one tutoring is sort of one of the best ways for anyone to kind of learn a new subject. So you talked a little bit earlier about how you're going to integrate some of these more native AI interactive elements to the app. Right now, it's been like kind of an add-on with video. But I'm curious how you're thinking about like the long term, could these become much more core versus kind of the tap and learn gamified tap and learn use case that we started with at Duolingo. And how does that change, I guess, the business model for Duolingo as you integrate more of that?
但我想問的是:有一些學術研究指出,一對一輔導可能是任何人學習新科目最有效的方法之一。你先前也提到你們會把一些更原生的 AI 互動元素整合進 App。現在看起來比較像是以影片形式的附加功能。但我好奇你們怎麼看長期:這些功能是否可能從「附加」變成更核心的體驗,而不是我們在 Duolingo 一開始的那種點擊學習、遊戲化的點擊學習使用情境?當你們整合更多這類功能時,這會如何改變 Duolingo 的商業模式?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yes. So it's a great question when we think about a lot. We know today -- a few years ago, maybe 4 or 5 years ago, we did a bunch of research that shows that Duolingo was about as good as a classroom for language learning. We've gotten better to the point where I'm pretty sure we're better than a classroom now. But we are today not as good as a one-on-one human tutor.
是的,這是個我們經常思考的好問題。我們知道——幾年前,大概 4、5 年前,我們做過一系列研究,顯示 Duolingo 在語言學習上的效果大致相當於課堂教學。我們之後持續進步到我相當確定現在已經比課堂更好。但目前我們仍不如一對一真人家教。
And nothing has gotten as good as a one -- a good one-on-one human tutor is still better than where we're at now. We think that over the next few years, we will be able to be as good as a one-on-one human tutor. Because we just see how much we're improving every year. I mean, the thing about one on one human tutors is that they're not improving. They're like it's about as good as them, but we're improving.
而且到目前為止,沒有任何東西能達到——一位優秀的一對一家教仍然比我們現在的水準更好。我們認為在未來幾年,我們將能做到和一對一真人家教一樣好,因為我們看到自己每年進步的幅度非常大。我的意思是,一對一真人家教的特點是他們不會變得更好;他們大致就維持在那個水準,但我們在持續進步。
So we think we're going to get there. Now there's something very important to mention, which is that, to a large extent, even though one-on-one human tutors are very effective at teaching, to a large extent, most people don't want to do that. I mean, there's a small fraction of people that are willing to do that, but most people just don't want to -- even if it's given up for free. It's just -- it happens that it's not that compelling of an experience on your mobile phone when compared to TikTok or Instagram or whatever. It's just not that compelling.
所以我們覺得我們會達到那個水準。不過有一點非常重要要提:在很大程度上,即使一對一真人家教教學非常有效,但大多數人其實不想那樣學。願意這麼做的人只占很小一部分,多數人就是不想——即使免費提供也是如此。原因在於:在手機上,和 TikTok、Instagram 或其他內容相比,這種體驗並沒有那麼吸引人。就是不夠有吸引力。
So what we want to do is we wanted to have something that is as effective as a one-on-one human tutor, and we think we can do it, but it will not look like a one-on-one human tutor. It will, in the end, still feel gamified because ultimately, the thing that is most important, even though one on one human tutors are very efficient and effective, the thing that is most important, the major failure mode is people just dropping off.
所以我們想做的是:做出一個在效果上能和一對一真人家教一樣好的東西,我們也相信做得到,但它最後呈現的樣子不會像一對一真人家教。最終它仍會帶有遊戲化的感覺,因為歸根結底,最重要的事情是——即使一對一真人家教非常有效率、非常有效——最大的失敗模式其實是人們會中途放棄。
Like you can have a very effective one on one human tutor, but people just will be like, yes, I'm going to stop going to that. So what we're working on is it will still feel gamified, but you will see a lot more AI in there for us trying to meet you where you are. I mean, by the way, the reason one on one human tutors are better than a classroom or better than what we do right now is that they are really good at adapting to you.
你可以有一個非常有效的一對一真人家教,但人們仍可能會說:好,我不去了。所以我們正在做的會是:它仍然會讓人覺得是遊戲化的,但你會看到更多 AI 在裡面,讓我們能在你所在的程度上與你對接。順帶一提,一對一真人家教之所以比課堂、或比我們現在做的更好,是因為他們非常擅長因材施教、適應你。
They're just -- they just -- and they do even things like they read your facial expression when they're saying something to you, they can see that you're like, you look confused. So you don't even have to say it and they quickly adapt to you. That's why they're so good. And this -- I believe the technology is just getting better and better, and we'll be able to do that. It will take some time, but we'll get there, I think.
他們就是——他們甚至會做一些事情,例如在跟你講解時讀你的表情,他們能看出你看起來困惑。你甚至不用說,他們就能很快調整教法。這就是他們厲害的原因。而我相信這項技術只會越來越好,我們也將能做到這點。這需要一些時間,但我想我們會做到。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
But then, Ross, the sheer number of users of Duolingo and the database we have puts us in a position to do the best that can be out there in the market. I think that's a really powerful thing that we have. The incredible number of people who use us every single day and working off that data to come up with the exact right way to teach them.
不過 Ross,Duolingo 的龐大用戶數以及我們擁有的資料庫,讓我們處在一個能做出市場上最佳成果的位置。我認為這是我們非常強大的優勢。每天使用我們的驚人用戶量,以及基於這些資料去找出教他們的最正確方式。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, I mean that's a really good point. The data that we have in terms of people learning, I mean, I don't think anybody -- well, we know, we just -- nobody has the amount of data of people learning that we do.
對,我的意思是這點非常好。我們在學習者行為方面的資料——我不認為有人——我們知道,就是——沒有人擁有像我們這樣大量的學習者資料。
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Andrew Boone - Analyst
Thank you.
謝謝。
Operator
Operator
Nathan Feather, Morgan Stanley.
Morgan Stanley 的 Nathan Feather。
Nathan Feather - Analyst
Nathan Feather - Analyst
Hey, everyone two on my end. First, when you talk about focusing more on monetization next year than you did this year, what does that actually mean internally? Is that more people dedicated to monetization pass? Is that changing kind of the hurdles for what you accept? How should we think about what that actually means?
嗨,各位。我這邊兩個問題。第一,當你們說明年會比今年更聚焦變現(monetization)時,內部實際上代表什麼?是投入更多人力在變現路徑上嗎?還是改變你們對可接受方案的門檻?我們應該如何理解這句話的實際含義?
And then second, just given the real success of the Chess course, how are you thinking about new course expansion, both in terms of the time line for when you might pursue that a little more aggressively? Then also the type of subjects you think would be applicable here may be different than what you had tried previously.
第二,鑑於西洋棋課程非常成功,你們如何看待新課程的擴張?包括你們可能在什麼時間點會更積極推進?另外,你們認為適用的主題類型可能也會不同於你們過去嘗試的方向。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
These are both great questions. What does it mean for focus more on monetization? I mean, this year was a unique year in that we told the whole company look -- what really matters is accelerating DAU growth. We have a huge opportunity ahead of us. We have to figure out how to accelerate user growth.
這兩個都是很棒的問題。所謂更聚焦變現是什麼意思?我的意思是,今年很特別,因為我們對全公司說:你看——真正重要的是加速 DAU 成長。我們面前有很大的機會,我們必須想辦法加速用戶成長。
And by the way, accelerating user growth is really hard. So hey, let's go there. So we put a bonus for the whole company, and we said, let's go and accelerate user growth. Next year is a little different. What we're telling everybody is we continue to focus on user growth because it's such a big opportunity ahead of us.
而且,加速用戶成長真的很難。所以我們說,好,那就全力去做。我們為全公司設了一個獎金,並且說:我們一起去加速用戶成長。明年會有點不同。我們告訴大家的是:我們仍會持續聚焦用戶成長,因為我們面前的機會非常大。
But you know what else matters, monetization. So I think you're just going to see more A/B/B tests related to monetization, and that's kind of how we're going to operate next year. In terms of new courses, we're not announcing new courses at the moment. What I will say is when we added Chess, a AI helped quite a bit. And we were able to add Chess from idea to being in the app in about nine months.
但你知道還有什麼也很重要嗎?變現。所以我想你會看到更多與變現相關的 A/B/B 測試,這大概就是我們明年的運作方式。至於新課程,我們目前沒有宣布新的課程。我能說的是,當我們加入西洋棋時,AI 幫了很大的忙。我們能在大約九個月內,從想法到把西洋棋放進 App。
What I will say is that we know that we can do that even faster now.
我要說的是,我們知道現在甚至可以更快做到這一點。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Okay, looking forward to hearing more. Thanks, guys.
好的,期待聽到更多。謝謝各位。
Operator
Operator
Arvind Ramnani, Truist.
Arvind Ramnani,Truist。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Hi, Arvind.
嗨,Arvind。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Hi, thanks for doing this. Yeah, I don't know why my video is not showing, But nevertheless, yes, I just want to ask about sort of the inference costs and DAU is, right? So you've had a nice jump in your DAUs, up like 30%. What is that doing to influence cost per DAU, right? Is basically -- are you seeing your cost per year are coming down faster than AI usage for user going up?
嗨,謝謝你們安排這場。是的,我不知道為什麼我的影像沒有顯示,但不管怎樣,我想問的是推理成本和 DAU(每日活躍用戶)相關的問題。你們的 DAU 有不錯的跳升,上升了大約 30%。這對每 DAU 的推理成本有什麼影響?也就是說——你們是否看到每年的成本下降速度快於每位用戶 AI 使用量的上升?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, we are seeing that. I mean we want to put a lot -- we have been putting a lot more AI in the product, and we are seeing cost per DAU come down quite significantly. The main reason is for the majority of our users, open weight models are about as good as frontier year models. There are some small cases where a frontier model is still needed. But for the majority of our users, the open weight models are plenty good.
是的,我們確實看到這種情況。我們希望在產品中加入更多 AI——而且我們一直在這麼做——同時也看到每 DAU 的成本顯著下降。主要原因是,對我們大多數用戶而言,開放權重模型的效果幾乎和最前沿模型一樣好。有一些小眾情境仍需要最前沿模型,但對大多數用戶來說,開放權重模型已經足夠好。
So whenever we're able to switch from using a frontier model to an open weight model, the cost savings are pretty high, and we're able to do that quite a bit. So our team has done a really great job at being responsible about that.
因此,只要我們能從使用最前沿模型切換到開放權重模型,節省的成本就相當可觀,而且我們能做到這件事的情況其實不少。我們團隊在這方面非常負責任,做得非常出色。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Yeah, no, of course. And I think you're now kind of at the forefront of it, it seems like that's kind of what the more experience or the more service uses of AI are doing as they start in the frontier model and they eventually migrate. Particularly if you kind of know if you have a level of sophistication. And I guess kind of the other thing is you want to put more AI in the free experience to drive DAU growth.
是的,當然。我覺得你們現在有點走在最前面了;看起來更有經驗、或更偏服務型地使用 AI 的公司,往往都是先從最前沿模型開始,最後再逐步遷移。尤其是當你們具備一定程度的成熟度與精細化能力時。另一點是,你們想在免費體驗中加入更多 AI 來帶動 DAU 成長。
And I think you've cited at one of the big reasons you kind of the cost of video dropped like 95% or whatever. So the question I want to ask is, where is inference costs were free users stopped making sense, right? Like inference is you can deliver that very inexpensively. But it's a breakpoint where inference cost per free us really doesn't make any sense. And you say, like, hey, we're going to start giving this to the free user.
而且我記得你們提到過,其中一個重要原因是影片成本下降了 95% 之類的。所以我想問的是:推理成本在什麼情況下,對免費用戶就不再合理?也就是說,推理本身可以非常低成本地提供,但會有一個臨界點,當每位免費用戶的推理成本不再划算時,你們才會說:好,我們要開始把這個提供給免費用戶。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, I guess the way I'll answer your question is that we are going to spend some on inference cost in free users next year. It's not a ton, but we are going to spend some on that because we do want to give some of these AI features to free users. But you call it single-digit millions that we're going to spend next year on inference costs for free users on kind of live inference costs.
是的,我想我會這樣回答:明年我們會在免費用戶的推理成本上花一些錢。金額不會很大,但我們確實會花一些,因為我們希望把部分 AI 功能提供給免費用戶。你可以把它想成明年在免費用戶的即時推理成本上,支出是「數百萬美元的個位數」等級。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Yeah. And sorry, last question on this is. Are you still like -- and I'm not looking for the next quarter, but are you just a few years away where your business becomes large enough where you basically are going to own some of the compute? Or will you -- how are you accessing this, right? Are you using the AI cloud?
好的。抱歉,關於這點最後一個問題:你們是否仍然——我不是在問下一季——但從幾年的角度看,你們的業務規模是否會大到讓你們基本上會自建、擁有一部分算力?或者你們會——你們現在是怎麼取得這些資源的?你們是在用 AI 雲端嗎?
Are you using the inference providers? Are you doing this internally? Like how are you accessing the inference or the compute to do this?
你們是在用推理服務供應商嗎?還是內部自建?你們到底是如何取得推理或算力來做這些事的?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah, I mean it's all of the above. I think the majority right now is inference providers. But we're trying some internally. So it's kind of all of the above, but we'll -- we'll do what makes sense for the business.
是的,我的意思是以上皆是。我認為目前大多數是透過推理服務供應商,但我們也在嘗試部分內部自建。所以算是多管齊下;我們會做對業務最合理的選擇。
Yes.
是。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Yeah, classic A/B/B testing, which is always been very smart on that.
是的,經典的 A/B/B 測試,你們在這方面一向很聰明。
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Gillian Munson - Chief Financial Officer
Yeah, The team is really creative on this and has done a really excellent job at managing it.
是的,團隊在這方面非常有創意,也在管理上做得非常出色。
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Arvind Ramnani - Analyst
Yeah, perfect.
好的,完美。
Operator
Operator
Ralph Schackart, William Blair.
Ralph Schackart,William Blair。
Ralph Schackart - Analyst
Ralph Schackart - Analyst
I jumped on light, so I apologize if you covered this. But you mentioned on the call that you're going to be running multiple more tests in 2027, they referenced like 90% year-over-year testing year-to-date. I'm guessing that's made on the product side, but can you sort of clarify all of that's on the monetization side. But maybe the more important question is, how are you able to run these tests next year at this scale? And then also focus on the monetization.
我剛加入,所以如果你們已經談過我先道歉。不過你們在電話會議中提到,2027 年你們會進行更多測試,並提到今年迄今測試量年增約 90%。我猜這主要是在產品端,但你們能否釐清這些是否也包含變現端?但更重要的問題可能是:你們明年如何能以這樣的規模來跑這些測試,同時又能聚焦在變現上?
Do those experiments need to drop by, I don't know, a rate of 50% to 45% year-over-year growth. But kind of walk us through the path that you can continue to run these experiments and drive monetization next year?
這些實驗是否需要下降到——我不知道——年增 50% 到 45% 的速度?但請帶我們走一遍,你們明年如何能持續跑這些實驗並推動變現的路徑?
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Yeah. So the way we improve the product is we work on three main things. We do improvements to we call it user growth. So that usually is improvements in retention of the product that increases daily active users. We do improvements in monetization and then we do improvements in teaching better.
好的。我們改善產品的方式主要聚焦三件事。我們會做我們稱為「用戶成長」的改進,通常是提升產品留存,進而增加每日活躍用戶。我們也會做變現的改進,然後也會做「教學效果更好」的改進。
In all -- in these 3 buckets, the way we work is we basically run a ton of A/B tests in each one of them with the aim at improving one of these things. So this particular A/B test is aimed at improving monetization. This particular A/B test is aimed at teaching better, et cetera. And we just run a lot of these. At the moment, like we mentioned, we're about 90% higher than, for example, the last month, we ran 90% more A/B tests than we did one year ago.
在這三個面向中,我們的做法基本上是在每個面向都跑大量 A/B 測試,目標是改善其中一項指標。比如這個 A/B 測試是為了提升變現;那個 A/B 測試是為了教得更好,等等。我們就是大量地跑這些測試。就像我們提到的,目前我們的測試量大約比去年同期高出 90%;例如上個月我們跑的 A/B 測試數量,比一年前多了 90%。
We believe that, that will continue increasing. So just overall, we're going to be able -- for monetization, but also for teaching better, but also for daily active user users. We're going to be able to run a lot more experiments next year. I don't know how many more because it depends on a lot of things, how our processes improve, et cetera. But it really is getting to the point where the bottleneck is you're starting to get cookie bottlenecks that we're not the thing that we used to normally think about bottlenecks.
我們相信這個數字還會持續增加。所以整體而言,不只是變現,也包括教學效果更好,以及每日活躍用戶相關,我們明年都能跑更多實驗。我不知道會多多少,因為取決於很多因素,例如流程如何改善等等。但確實已經到了這樣的程度:瓶頸開始變成一些我們過去不太會認為是瓶頸的事情。
For example, a bottleneck now is ideas. I mean, like even coming up with ideas of what to test, we just -- we're -- that has become a bottleneck. Another bottleneck is when for example, one of the things that we're able to do now is, like we mentioned in a previous answer, we're able to get non-engineers to actually launch an A/B/B test. So like a product manager or a designer is actually able. We built an internal piece of software that allows a product manager to just, without the help of an engineer, do an entire change of them.
例如,現在的瓶頸之一是點子。也就是說,光是想出要測什麼的點子,就——我們——這已經變成瓶頸。另一個瓶頸是,例如我們現在能做到的一件事是——就像我們在前一個回答提到的——我們能讓非工程師實際上線一個 A/B/B 測試。也就是說,產品經理或設計師實際上可以做到。我們打造了一套內部軟體,讓產品經理在不需要工程師協助的情況下,就能完成一次完整的變更。
They're not large changes. They're small stuff. But we're able to do that. But another bottleneck comes what if that person is a product manager, they introduce a bug to the app, who fixes it? Because I don't think they'll know how to fix this.
這些不是大型變更,而是一些小改動。但我們能做到。不過另一個瓶頸就出現了:如果那個人是產品經理,他在 App 裡引入了一個 bug,誰來修?因為我不認為他們知道怎麼修。
So it's -- so this is the -- our processes are going to have to change. And we're in the middle of that, like a couple of the things, I don't even know the answer for what is the case, what we're going to do. But I do know that we're going to be able to run some integer multiple of the number of A/B tests that we ran this year.
所以——所以這就是——我們的流程必須改變。我們正在這個過程中;有幾件事我甚至還不知道答案是什麼、我們會怎麼做。但我確實知道,我們將能以某個整數倍的幅度,跑出比今年更多的 A/B 測試。
Operator
Operator
I'm showing no further questions. This concludes the Q&A section of the call. I would now like to turn the call back to the host for the closing remarks.
我這邊顯示沒有其他問題了。問答環節到此結束。接下來我想把電話會議交回主持人做結語。
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Luis Von Ahn - Chairman of the Board, President, Chief Executive Officer, Co-Founder
Just thank you all for being here, and thank you for the great questions. And especially thank you for -- thank you to the team for the really great work so far this year. We're very proud of our results.
感謝各位今天的參與,也謝謝大家提出很棒的問題。並且特別感謝——感謝團隊今年迄今為止非常出色的工作。我們對成果感到非常自豪。