美國合眾銀行 (USB) 2016 Q4 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

  • Welcome to U.S. Bancorp's fourth-quarter 2016 earnings conference call.

  • Following a review of the results by Richard Davis, Chairman and Chief Executive Officer, and Terry Dolan, U.S. Bancorp's Vice Chairman and Chief Financial Officer, there will be a formal question and answer session.

  • (Operator Instructions).

  • This call will be recorded and available for replay beginning today at approximately noon Eastern Standard Time through Wednesday, January 25 at 12 midnight Eastern Standard Time.

  • I will now turn the call over to Jen Thompson of Investor Relations for U.S. Bancorp.

  • Jen Thompson - SVP of IR

  • Thank you, Melissa, and good morning to everyone who has joined our call.

  • Richard Davis, Andy Cecere, Terry Dolan and Bill Parker are here with me today to review U.S. Bancorp's fourth-quarter results and to answer your questions.

  • Richard, Andy and Terry will be referencing a slide presentation during their prepared remarks.

  • A copy of the slide presentation as well as our earnings release and supplemental analyst schedules are available on our website at USBank.com.

  • I would like to remind you that any forward-looking statements made during today's call are subject to risk and uncertainty.

  • Factors that could materially change our current forward-looking assumptions are described on page 2 of today's presentation, in our press release and in our Form 10-K and subsequent reports on file with the SEC.

  • I will now turn the call over to Richard.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thank you, Jen, and good morning, everyone.

  • Thanks for joining our call.

  • While the economy was challenging, and often unfavorable in 2016, it was a good year for U.S. Bank.

  • As you can see on slide 3 of the presentation, we reported record net income of $5.9 billion and record earnings per diluted share of $3.24 for the full year.

  • Our 2016 return on common equity was 13.4% and our efficiency ratio was an industry-leading 54.9%.

  • We reported strong loan growth and strong deposit growth and we returned 79% of earnings to shareholders through dividends and buybacks.

  • I am also pleased with our fourth-quarter results which are highlighted on slide 4. In the fourth quarter we reported net income of $1.5 billion or $0.82 per diluted share.

  • Healthy balance sheet growth supported 2.1% sequential growth in net interest income and strength in fee businesses, such as payments and trusts, drove 3.9% noninterest income growth compared with the year earlier.

  • Credit quality remained stable in the fourth quarter.

  • Turning to slide 5, our profitability metrics continue to be among the best in the industry.

  • In the fourth quarter our return on average common equity was 13.1% and our efficiency ratio was 55.3%.

  • Terry will now provide more details about our fourth-quarter results.

  • Following Terry's remarks Andy, whom we announced yesterday will assume the CEO role at the April shareholder meeting this year, will provide some insight about our opportunities for growth in the current environment.

  • Terry.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Thank you, Richard.

  • I will start with a balance sheet review and then discuss our fourth-quarter earnings trends.

  • Turning to slide 6, you can see our loan and deposit growth trends.

  • Average total loans outstanding grew 1.1% on a linked quarter basis and increased 6.2% compared with the fourth quarter of 2015 or 5.6% excluding a credit card portfolio acquisition at the end of the fourth quarter of 2015.

  • In this year's fourth quarter the linked quarter growth -- increase in average loans was led by a rebound in growth in average total commercial loans of 1.6% and strong growth in several consumer categories.

  • As expected and in line with industry trends, residential mortgage loan growth slowed in the fourth quarter reflecting both seasonal factors and a slowdown in refinancing activity driven by higher rates.

  • Also commercial real estate mortgages were essentially flat compared with the third quarter of 2016 as customers paid down mortgages and evaluate the potential of policy changes and the outlook for rising rates.

  • Total average deposits increased 11.8% compared with the fourth quarter of 2015 and were up 3.3% on a linked quarter basis.

  • The sequential growth was highlighted by a 3.5% linked quarter increase in non-interest-bearing deposits.

  • Turning to slide 7, credit quality remained relatively stable for the third quarter.

  • Net charge-offs as a percentage of average loans were 47 basis points in the fourth quarter, up 1 basis point compared with the third quarter and flat with a year ago.

  • A seasonal increase in our credit card net charge-off ratio offset declines in commercial and commercial real estate net charge-offs.

  • Nonperforming assets decreased by 3.7% compared with the third quarter, improvement was driven by commercial loans, residential mortgages and other real estate.

  • And while NPAs increased 5.3% versus the fourth quarter of 2015, NPAs as a percentage of loans plus other real estate rose just 1 basis point to 59 basis points.

  • We continued to add to the allowance for loan losses in the fourth quarter to support loan growth.

  • I will now move to earnings results.

  • Slide 8 provides highlights of fourth-quarter results versus comparable periods.

  • Fourth-quarter net income of $1.5 billion was down 1.6% compared to the third quarter.

  • The fourth quarter is seasonally lower from a fee revenue perspective each year and this year was no different.

  • On slide 9 you can see that total revenue increased by approximately 1% in the fourth quarter compared with the third quarter and grew 4.3% on a year-over-year basis.

  • Our year-over-year revenue growth was primarily driven by solid loan growth funded by strong deposit growth and strength across our fee businesses.

  • Turning to slide 10, net interest income on a taxable equivalent basis increased by 2.1% compared with the linked quarter and was up 4.6% compared with the prior year.

  • Linked quarter growth reflected 2.1% average earning asset growth and a stable net interest margin.

  • The benefit of higher rates to loan yields was offset by higher average cash balances and lower yields on security purchases and reinvestment rates on existing securities.

  • Slide 11 highlights trends in noninterest income, which declined by 0.6% versus the third quarter, reflecting typical seasonal patterns and a 24% decrease in Mortgage Banking revenue.

  • The Mortgage Banking revenue decline was in line with our December guidance and reflects both seasonality and a drop in refinancing activity due to higher interest rates.

  • On a year-over-year basis noninterest income increased by 3.9% driven by strength in payment services revenue, trust and investment management fees and Mortgage Banking revenue.

  • I will highlight a couple of items within noninterest income.

  • Merchant processing revenue grew 5.6% on a year-over-year basis adjusting for the impact of currency rate changes.

  • Trust and investment management fees increased 9.5% year-over-year reflecting lower money market fee waivers along with account growth, an increase in assets under management and improved market conditions.

  • Given the recent increase in the short-term rates the impact of fee waivers in 2017 will be minimal.

  • Turning to slide 12, noninterest expense increased 2.5% compared with the third quarter, in line with our expectation.

  • On a year-over-year basis noninterest expense increased 6.9%.

  • The primary drivers for the increase on both a quarterly and year-over-year basis were higher compensation expense, professional services expenses and other non-interest expense.

  • Compensation expense reflects hiring for business growth and compliance programs, including addressing the AML consent order and DOL implementation.

  • We believe the trajectory of cost for these programs is stabilizing.

  • As a reminder, professional fees and other expense are seasonally higher in the fourth quarter.

  • In the fourth quarter other [non-interest] expense was driven by higher costs related to investments and tax advantaged projects, which abates somewhat in the first quarter of 2017.

  • I will finish with a look at our capital position.

  • Turning to slide 13, our common equity Tier 1 capital ratio, estimated using the Basel III standardized approach as if fully implemented at December 31, was 9.1%, which is well above the 7% Basel III minimum requirement and our internal target of 8.5%.

  • Our tangible book value per share was $18.70 at December 31, up 7.2% from a year ago.

  • In the fourth quarter we returned 81% of our earnings to shareholders through dividends and share buybacks.

  • We expect to remain in our targeted payout ratio of 60% to 80% going forward.

  • I will now turn the call over to Andy.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Thanks, Terry.

  • I would like to provide some insights into our thoughts on how we are positioned for growth in the current environment.

  • For the full year 2016 average loans increased by 6.9% and we think for the full year 2017 a 6% to 8% growth rate is very achievable.

  • We expect the pace of growth slightly to be more weighted towards the later part of the year as customers become more comfortable with the economic future post inauguration.

  • In the first quarter we expected loan growth to be similar to the linked quarter growth experience in the fourth quarter of 2016 as customers consider the implications of potential policy decisions and tax decisions of the new administration.

  • We also expect relatively flat growth in the residential and commercial mortgage loans as seasonally slower growth and credit card balances.

  • Coming out of the first quarter we are optimistic that an improving economy will spur more consumer activity, which will help both our payments businesses and our consumer lending businesses.

  • An improved economic backdrop should also result in increased business spending on development and capital investments and we are well positioned to capture our fair share of that lending and fee activity.

  • Given the improving interest rate environment, including the current shape of the yield curve, we expect that the net interest margin, or the NIM, will expand modestly in the first quarter.

  • We look for mortgage revenue to decrease 10% to 15% in the first quarter, in line with an expectation for lower refinancing activity reflecting both seasonal trends and the impact of higher market rates.

  • We expect expenses to decline slightly on a linked quarter basis, primarily driven by seasonally lower professional fees and a decline in tax credit amortization expense resulting in a relatively stable efficiency ratio.

  • Finally, given the underlying mix and quality of the overall portfolio, we expect credit quality to remain relatively stable.

  • I will now turn the call back to Richard.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thanks, Andy.

  • And I am proud of our record fourth-quarter and our full-year 2016 results.

  • We maintained our industry leading performance measures and reported a 17.7% return on tangible common equity in the quarter and an 18% return for the full year.

  • That concludes our formal remarks.

  • Andy, Terry and Bill Parker and I would now be happy to answer any questions.

  • Operator

  • (Operator Instructions).

  • John McDonald, Bernstein.

  • John McDonald - Analyst

  • Good morning.

  • Richard and Andy, congratulations to both of you on yesterday's announcement.

  • Just wondering, Richard, if you have any additional color to share on what drove the timing of the decision to do the transition now.

  • Obviously it has been well-planned but just what drove the exact timing?

  • And then also what exactly will be entailed in the role of Executive Chairman for you going forward?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thanks, John.

  • I know you will all be disappointed you can't kick me around anymore, that is the number one goal (laughter).

  • First of all, this was very well telegraphed and I want to thank you for setting it up that way.

  • I hit my 10-year anniversary as the CEO of the Bank last month and many years before that I conferred with the Board and our senior leaders and told them that [I had] a couple of thoughts that [attended] to the notion that at 10 years I think it is the right time for a transition.

  • I think that for any Company of any type.

  • And it seemed that we were three years away.

  • Second point, John, was that our success was sitting right here.

  • Andy was clearly becoming the perfect person to lead the Company based on his talents and his skills.

  • I had worked with him seven years as a partner at that point.

  • And I wanted to make sure that as a Board and as a CEO we telegraphed him, first of all, that he was a candidate and it was up to them to make that final decision.

  • And that the candidacy wouldn't come eight years from now when I am 65 and he is 62.

  • And it seemed appropriate that we locked down that succession as soon as we could and we started that process privately back then.

  • And then equally important to me, and it is just a personal thing for me, I want to do something else in my life that is entirely different.

  • I call it a calling, if you will; I don't know exactly how to explain it.

  • And I know it is a little odd to have a 58-year-old healthy CEO leaving to go nowhere.

  • But that is really what it is, because I am not leaving this Company; I am handing it over to a great management team and a great leader.

  • And I am looking forward to being successfully part of it in the future as an advocate and an exclusive partner in this part of the banking environment.

  • So I am really going off to do something uniquely different and I will see what comes about in the next few months.

  • As you know, I will be the CEO for another 90 days until April 18 and I will be full in on that job until which time our shareholder meeting in Nashville will hand over the reins.

  • I will then step up to be the Executive Chair.

  • And what that means, John, is really what I am now.

  • So think of it this way, I had three titles two years ago, I gave Andy one of them last year, I am giving him another one in April, and I'm keeping the last one because I am selfish.

  • I'm going to be Chairman for a while until the transition is ensconced and complete in both the Board and the Street, you guys, are comfortable that we have made that transition.

  • And it is my hope that there is a lot of continuity and sustainability with what we did.

  • And yet I also hope Andy feels the permissions to do what he needs to do and make adjustments into the future.

  • So as an Executive Chair we are not telegraphing that we are separating the titles of Chair and CEO permanently, we are just doing it because we would do that in any succession.

  • We think that is one of the best practices.

  • And then in the future, whenever I move away and the Board has the decision to either merge the two titles again or not.

  • And that is a decision we don't have to know or telegraph now because we don't have that decision afoot.

  • So hopefully that is clear and I will be working with the lead director as a partner and that is what happens when you have an Executive Chair and a lead director, we will work together with Andy to guide the Board and to give him guidance to manage the Company.

  • John McDonald - Analyst

  • Okay, great, that is super helpful.

  • Thank you, Richard.

  • And just a follow-up then on expenses.

  • When you think about the year, it seemed like 2016 for U.S. Bank was a year of kind of digesting maybe an above average expense drag.

  • You mentioned a few things like DOL, consent order -- it seemed like there were some compliance costs, maybe some stepped up investments.

  • Just wondering as you look at the operating leverage dynamics for 2017, does it get better from both ends with higher rates helping revenues and maybe easier comps on expenses?

  • Could you flesh that out a little bit?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Yes, I will.

  • And then I will give it to Andy to color.

  • The answer is, yes, you are right, [I work] from both ends.

  • Look, I am more disappointed than anybody that we hit that 55% efficiency ever.

  • It is a reality and something that we needed to do.

  • A big part of that is the AML consent order and I think most banks are probably dealing with some form, public or private, on the issue for AML.

  • And it's a remarkably expensive process.

  • I mean remarkably.

  • And we underestimated that but we are able to handle it as we go forward.

  • As Terry said, that is stabilizing now only to mean that it has peaked.

  • But also means we don't know when it starts to come down but it will definitely come back down because it has got an endpoint, it is a consent order.

  • I will say that that is a fair amount of the number that has moved us from what might have might have been 53% or 54% into the 55% and we will see that come down.

  • DOL is also a time vested event that will come and go by middle of this year.

  • And as we said before we're investing heavily into it, we have got a great partner; we believe we've got the right solution.

  • And no matter what happens in Washington we would do this anyway, so it is not bound by any kind of regulation or changes that might occur.

  • So those are two big enough issues that have taken our efficiency ratio, our expenses up a little higher than we would like, but we think that they sustain and start moving down.

  • And then you know as well as anybody the fact that the interest rates are starting to move and that the curve has steepened; well, that is the other benefit.

  • And so, from both ends let's call this -- and probably this quarter, which will be pretty flat on efficiency, probably the high water mark and then we will get back to places you expect us to be.

  • The other thing that is sitting underneath those numbers is this remarkable cost of innovation and technology.

  • And we can talk about it until you can't stop listening, but it will only show itself in the future when you will see which companies really made those investments and we are ready to jump to a new kind of real-time payments mobile environment.

  • And those that didn't; and we are one that is.

  • And so, our capital expenditures are right now, and again this year, probably twice what they were many years ago and probably half again what they need to be in the future years.

  • But we are spending that kind of money to get this thing ready for this environment that is going to change pretty quickly.

  • That is also a time bound issue where that CapEx starts to come down.

  • Probably this will be another peak year and then we will start moving down.

  • So everything moves back to getting into the low 50%s without a lot of work but with just time passing.

  • Andy, do you want to --?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • And I would add, Richard -- so as you said, we expect two rate increases in 2017 midyear, at the end in December.

  • Given that and the expectation for the stronger economy plus the brand and innovation investments we made, we expect accelerated revenue growth in 2017 and positive operating leverage.

  • John McDonald - Analyst

  • Great, thank you.

  • Operator

  • John Pancari, Evercore.

  • John Pancari - Analyst

  • I just want to get a little bit more color on what you are seeing in terms of loan demand and borrower appetite post the election.

  • And where are you seeing strengthening?

  • Is it in certain markets like in some of the borrower appetite in the Midwest given some of the manufacturing implications or is it some of your other markets?

  • Thanks.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • John I will start and then I will hand it to Bill for a little bit more detail.

  • So first I will tell you that there is more optimism and positive commentary for a lot of our business customers, but we haven't seen a significant change in utilization or actually takedown of credit yet.

  • So while the talk is there the actual action has not yet shown itself.

  • We do see steady growth in middle market, small business and the higher corporate loan growth, and auto is strong as is the mortgage activity.

  • But again, because refinancings are down we will expect that to diminish.

  • But again, the key point I would make is we are not seeing huge changes, in fact, it is relatively flat in terms of the overall utilization rate.

  • And then there a couple of areas that we are choosing not to be as active in, and I'm going to let Bill comment on that.

  • Bill Parker - Vice Chairman & Chief Risk Officer

  • What Andy is referring to there is commercial real estate.

  • We do see some of those markets as being sort of late stage credit cycle.

  • If you look back we had fairly robust growth in our construction -- real estate construction book and that is slowing now.

  • It is even slowing with our client base; they are being more cautious.

  • Multi-family is an area that, if you look at the forecast, there are forecasts pretty broad-based of potential rent declines in a lot of the major cities.

  • So we are being more cautious there.

  • And then on commercial mortgages, sort of the term portion, we've been fairly flat to down in that area.

  • And there is very aggressive competition for long terms, fixed rates, limited covenants to no covenants, non-recourse.

  • And that is just not a market that we play in.

  • So that is one area where we are just going to see lower growth based on the business we do.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • So John, this is Richard, we have been here before 10 years ago when we started to see the bifurcation of loan growth by different appetites by different banks.

  • And it always sounds a bit like a victory to say we are just not going to be as aggressive, we are not going to fight on terms, we are not going to fight on tenor, we are not going to do certain kinds of loans.

  • And it might sound a little bit of an excuse, but it is really part of the strategy and it is the think we are going to stick with.

  • We are not changing that approach.

  • I will give you an example.

  • Commercial real estate, $43 billion portfolio, $17 billion of it is in small communities because remember we are really kind of a community bank at heart.

  • And there is a lot of smaller banks that are doing some things that you guys aren't even writing about because you don't follow the small banks.

  • But we are in the middle of that and we are not going to play.

  • And while it would be easier to give you guys some loan growth in certain areas, it won't be on terms or tenor or stretching or underwriting on any category.

  • It will be on price because we have got the cost advantage, we are going to use that advantage where we can.

  • But when you do price you do it only for AAA kind of customers and then you have the higher quality customers, who by the way in this last quarter also had access to the capital markets more than other customers.

  • And you will see our capital markets fees are much higher than they were expected.

  • While loan growth might have been on the low end of our range it is probably a good outcome because it reflects the quality of our customers.

  • So we are going to stick to that, that is not the kind of thing you won't see change.

  • And while we might take a little heat because I know loan growth is a good proxy for a healthy bank, it has got to be at the right quality and at the right terms and we are just going to stick to our guns.

  • John Pancari - Analyst

  • Okay, that is helpful.

  • And then on that competitive point, I just want to get an update from you on a comment you made at a conference this past quarter around how much of the tax benefit could ultimately accrete to the bottom line.

  • I think you had indicated that about 50% to 60% of any benefit that you do see from corporate tax reform could accrete to EPS.

  • Is that still your thinking?

  • Do you have any update there and any additional color you can get us on how do you come up with that [general] range?

  • Thanks.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Sure, John.

  • And this is Terry.

  • So I mean obviously there is still a lot that has to happen with respect to tax policy both in terms of the amount of the rate and what ends up continuing to be deductible and all sorts of things.

  • But if you think about the tax credit business, the tax credits will still be worth 100% [and] all the rest of that stuff.

  • But the area that we would see an impact I think is really related to the tax benefit that you get on the investment that you make in those assets, so basically the tax benefit on the shield.

  • But to keep it simple, if we saw a tax -- a corporate tax rate decline of 10% we would expect our effective tax rate to benefit or go down by about half of that or about 60% of that.

  • So think about 5 percentage points to 6 percentage points, in that range.

  • That is essentially what we would expect to see a change in our effective tax rate and it is because of the various dynamics associated with how tax credits work.

  • John Pancari - Analyst

  • Okay, so that is not any -- that doesn't factor in anything competitively like the expectation that some of this benefit could get competed away?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • No, that --.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • No.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • I know what you are talking about and we don't see that, that is not -- I am not predicting that that is going to be given back by the banking industry as a form of competition.

  • This is just a singular event that could happen -- by the way I'm going to say tax benefits, unless you guys know something I don't -- it really has to go through the budget process.

  • So this is probably more a late 2017/2018 issue much as we all want it to be immediate.

  • And I think that is one of the reasons customers -- we're also a customer of others -- are holding back on some final decisions until we see what and when things happen and taxes is one of them.

  • But we are quite efficient now, we are proud of where we are.

  • So I don't want to be punished for having been more tax efficient than others.

  • But it also means there is a little less benefit.

  • If the most aggressive tax benefits accrue we will get a little bit less of it.

  • But it is still a benefit to a good starting point.

  • John Pancari - Analyst

  • Got it, all right.

  • Thanks again, and Richard, and Andy congrats.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thanks John.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Thanks John.

  • Operator

  • Betsy Graseck, Morgan Stanley.

  • Betsy Graseck - Analyst

  • A couple of questions.

  • Just one as a follow-up on the compete away question that has been coming up on a bunch of calls.

  • The corporates that you work with, the larger they get the more I think they are aware of how much wallet share and what the value is that they are providing to you.

  • So I guess the question is why do you think that it won't get competed away given that it tends to be a pretty dynamic process in those discussions?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Well, I will go first and then Andy can jump on.

  • They do know their wallet share.

  • By the same token part of it is by design because they have learned over the years they don't want to be doubled or tripled down with one partner.

  • So first of all they have the need to have more than one partner in and above just competition and rate.

  • Second thing is if you look at the way the industry is handling the rate increases, it relates to the liability side of the balance sheet, right.

  • We are a little smarter this time and we are not giving it all away immediately and we are not colluding either because we never talk.

  • But we are also being very careful and thoughtful about protecting about what needs to be a wider range between the cost of liabilities and the cost of assets.

  • And if that behavior continues I think the same action comes with taxes, [where we'll] find it.

  • We do it in pricing and yet the world is still reasonable and aligned.

  • And I think with taxes it is going to be the same thing.

  • We are all going to want to do our very best to protect what benefits our Companies and help our customers do well.

  • But this Company for one would like to bank that and find it in other forms particularly in credit quality and cost of funds.

  • So, I am not saying others won't try it, but we also have never really been competing on that level.

  • If somebody wants to compete on price bring it on because we can beat them every day for the highest quality customer.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • And to that point, Richard, you know we already have the advantage of the best rated bank which gives us a plenty of an advantage which we already take advantage of in terms of getting new business and/or achieving a higher return.

  • So that is the other component here.

  • Betsy Graseck - Analyst

  • Okay, no, that is helpful.

  • Maybe I could also ask a separate question on the NIM outlook.

  • I think, Andy, you mentioned expand modestly in -- was it 1Q 2017 or 2017?

  • But just wanted to tie that in with the commentary on this deck where you talked about how the reinvestment rate on securities was lower.

  • Just wondering if that is the angle with which a higher reinvestment rate on securities is going to drive that expand modestly.

  • Maybe you could help me understand if that is the case and how much expand means when you say expand modestly?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • So, Betsy, I will start and then hand it over to Terry.

  • On the expand modestly, it was a comment specific to the first quarter.

  • It related to both the increase in LIBOR in the short-term end of the curve as well as the long-term end of the curve and is principally around loan pricing and deposit pricing.

  • The investment security portfolio sort of stabilization occurs a little about mid-year and then that would be beneficial towards the end of the year.

  • Terry, anything you would add to that?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes.

  • No, when you talk about the reinvestment rates, as Andy said, when we get to the end of the first quarter into the second quarter we start to see that inflection point and so that will help the margin.

  • As Andy said earlier, we plan for a rate hike December of last year, June and then December.

  • And so when we think about the margin first quarter it will expand modestly and then it will probably accelerate a bit from there.

  • Betsy Graseck - Analyst

  • Okay, perfect.

  • Thank you.

  • And then last question -- on the impact of the stronger dollar on your merchant processing business and elsewhere if it is material, but I think it is mostly there.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, it is mostly there.

  • So our stated revenue growth, Betsy, was 2.8% year over year and that is -- excluding the FX impact it was about 5.6%.

  • So every 1% and whatever the currency is, about $1 million a year.

  • Betsy Graseck - Analyst

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Scott Siefers, Sandler O'Neil Partners.

  • Scott Siefers - Analyst

  • First, Richard and Andy, congratulations to both of you.

  • Well deserved (multiple speakers).

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thank you.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Thank you.

  • Scott Siefers - Analyst

  • I guess first question on the expenses -- I appreciate the commentary for the full year on operating leverage and expenses.

  • Just hoping you guys might be able to put sort of a finer point on the slight drop in costs you expect in the first quarter.

  • I guess as I look back over the last few years the magnitude of drop into 1Q, it used to be much more significant I would say but it has gotten lesser as we have gotten more recent.

  • Just curious if you can maybe give us a sense for order of magnitude of what you would expect that drop to be.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, so, this is Terry.

  • So when we end up looking at the first quarter, we would expect that drop to be about in a percentage point kind of range.

  • But the drivers behind that is that professional services fees are always seasonally high in the fourth quarter and included in that are compliance costs related at DOL and other things which will start to abate in the second and third quarter.

  • So some of those compliance costs specifically related to DOL will start to go away.

  • And then of course the tax credit amortization that we have in the fourth quarter is always seasonably high in the fourth quarter and it comes back down to normal.

  • And if you remember last quarter we gave some guidance around how much that might go up.

  • I think it was above $60 million.

  • And that won't all go away but probably about 60% of that will abate in the first quarter.

  • So those are the biggest drivers in terms of why we see expenses going down.

  • Scott Siefers - Analyst

  • Okay, perfect.

  • Thank you.

  • And then maybe switching gears to the fee side.

  • Terry, can you give a sense for what the dollar level of the equity investment income was in the fourth quarter?

  • And I guess just to the extent possible, I know that is a volatile line, but your sense for what a typical level might be going forward?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, in terms of equity investments, when we think about quarter it's probably I am going to say $20 million to $30 million than what we had seen in the third quarter.

  • Fourth quarter is probably more of a what I would say a normalized sort of level.

  • So when you think about equity investments on a go-forward basis it is probably going to be comparable to the fourth quarter when we think about the first quarter.

  • Scott Siefers - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • All right, that is good color.

  • Thank you guys very much.

  • Operator

  • Marty Mosby, Vining Sparks.

  • Marty Mosby - Analyst

  • Congratulations on the shift and the evolution of the management team there.

  • And Richard, what I wanted to ask you was as you take on the role solely of Chairman of the Board and working with your lead director, will you still take on most of those responsibilities?

  • Because that is a large share of what you do when you have CEO and Chairman is you have a lot of activities just working with the Board, making sure that that process is going.

  • So that relieves a lot of burden from what Andy would have to do initially as he takes his new responsibilities.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Marty, you nailed it.

  • That is exactly why the transition is, we think, best practice because it affords me a chance to work with the Board and make sure that Andy has got the time and energy to work with the management team and to work on the issues.

  • I will not be in the day-to-day management of the Company because that is also a best practice is to stay out of running the Company, but to help him with the Board side of it.

  • And I will be an ambassador to the Company; I will do whatever he needs me to do.

  • I can go places for him if he needs me to.

  • I am not to go on TV a lot, I am not going to talk about it as the ex-U.

  • S. Bank CEO, I am not going to do that because the voice has to be his and the current management team.

  • But you got it right.

  • And when the transition is satisfactorily complete and the Board and I and Andy feel that we've made that successful transition, then we will move it to the next step and they can decide where the Chairman position lies.

  • But it will give Andy the time to get focused on all the right things to run the whole Company.

  • Marty Mosby - Analyst

  • And then Andy and Terry, when you are -- one of the things in the release that has been consistent across all of the bank so far, which is to me the biggest surprise, is that deposit growth is continuing not just to be relatively strong but in your case was actually picking up as we have kind of gone into rates starting to move up a little bit.

  • And we would think some re-risking would be deploying some of this liquidity back into the system.

  • I'm just trying to figure out where all that deposit growth is coming from, because, like you said, your deposit betas are going to be tied to what is happening on your deposits.

  • And right now it is continuing to grow which gives you a lot of flexibility on pricing.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • So, Marty, I will start and Terry will add on.

  • So I am going to say three areas are focused why we are growing deposits.

  • First of all on the wholesale side -- and that is a continuation of us taking market share.

  • And along with that market share is new customers who have deposits.

  • Secondly, it is our Corporate Trust business.

  • Corporate Trust is a great business, it is very higher return, great fee business.

  • But importantly it also generates a tremendous level of deposit activity.

  • And we are growing that business both domestically as well as in Europe and that is very helpful.

  • And thirdly is the retail core base.

  • As we continue to take market share -- and this is one of the things we have talked about being very prudent around branches.

  • While it is true that we have consolidated 40 or 50 branches the last couple years we have done that very thoughtfully, in a manner that says we don't want to lose space; we want to optimize the footprint, but we don't want to lose customers or deposits.

  • And I think that deposit growth you are seeing is because of that manner of closure or consolidation which is very thoughtful.

  • Terry, what else would you add?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, I would add maybe just two different things.

  • One is not as corporates are kind of waiting to see what happens from a policy perspective as they have cash and they are waiting to figure out how to deploy that, they are probably parking it a little bit.

  • And then as we talked about in the third quarter with money market reform, there was a fairly strong inflow of deposits in the third quarter.

  • I am not sure that all of that has abated yet as people kind of figure out what they are going to do from a money market standpoint in terms of government funds or whatever.

  • So those are the two things I would just add.

  • Marty Mosby - Analyst

  • Thanks.

  • Operator

  • Matt O'Connor, Deutsche Bank.

  • Ricky Dodds - Analyst

  • Hi, guys, it is Ricky Dodds from Matt's team.

  • Just a quick question on -- the goal is positive operating leverage.

  • And if we don't see those two hikes that you guys have kind of built into your forecast is the goal of positive operating leverage still achievable?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • It's more challenging.

  • This is Andy, it is more challenging.

  • And we have always had great balance around making sure we are investing for the future and recognizing our short-term objectives.

  • And we believe firmly we can get there with the two rate increases that I mentioned.

  • It will be more difficult; we will have to continue to measure that balance short-term versus long-term but it would be more difficult.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • And you know, Ricky, they are not equal because if we get the June one and not the December we are there.

  • If we get the December 1 and not the June much harder.

  • So -- and I know there is a lot of forecasts that have a June/September/December, we are just using the June/December projections right now.

  • Ricky Dodds - Analyst

  • And then maybe an unrelated follow up on deposit betas.

  • Obviously not a huge impact with the first hike.

  • But as you think about more hikes what is your thinking there both on the commercial and consumer side?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, so I mean that is a good way of looking at it in terms of commercial and consumer.

  • So in terms of the December rate hike and kind of what we are seeing right now it's very similar to what we experienced a year ago in terms of the deposit beta.

  • So kind of the middle teens to upper teens, kind of in that ballpark.

  • When we model it out, especially on a longer-term basis, and so as we see rate hikes and if we would see a June rate hike or a December rate hike or maybe even a September rate hike that will start to normalize.

  • We typically model it in the 40% to 50% range in terms of deposit betas.

  • And then also from a modeling perspective, we assume that there is going to be some deposit disintermediation that would take place during that time because of economic growth.

  • So hopefully that kind gives you some perspective.

  • And of course it will be more sensitive with respect to the wholesale deposits, corporate trust deposits than it will be on the retail side.

  • Ricky Dodds - Analyst

  • Perfect.

  • Thanks, guys.

  • Operator

  • Ken Usdin, Jefferies.

  • Ken Usdin - Analyst

  • Thanks, good morning, guys, and also congratulations to both of you.

  • Can we talk a little bit about fees?

  • Understanding that the NII side looks to have a pretty good path to growth based on your loan and NIM comments.

  • Can you talk us through what you think would be the lead driving forces on the fee side especially given that it looks like mortgage might be a more difficult comparison looking ahead?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Yes, I will start.

  • This is Andy.

  • The fees, as you said, three components I would highlight.

  • Number one is mortgage down 10% to 15%.

  • Number two, payments, so our payments revenue this quarter on a year-over-year basis up 4% but actually about 5.5% excluding FX, 5.3%.

  • And we actually saw good growth in all three categories, the merchant acquiring, the card issuing as well as corporate.

  • So we would expect to see that continue to grow particularly as we see increased spend both from a personal standpoint as well as from a business standpoint.

  • So that is the second category.

  • And the final category I would mention is our trust and investment fees.

  • That is going to be positively leveraged to a growing economy and continuing together investment activity in our private client as well as our retail base overall.

  • So those three categories I think -- those two categories offset that mortgage category and we will see growth in fees.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Hey, Andy -- this is Richard, Ken.

  • Why don't you also give a little color, because I don't know if the will come up later, that on the payment side we don't chase volume or revenue and just like we don't chase loans or quality.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Right, I should mention -- so, and Elavon is the best example of that.

  • So I mentioned that our core growth stated is about 2.8% and excluding FX it is about 5.6%.

  • But what you see on volumes is actually a decline in volumes and that is because we intentionally exited some very low margin large customers who were not profitable.

  • And we did that intentionally.

  • You will see that impacting volumes but you did not see it impacting revenues.

  • And I think that is a great example that we are trying to do this in a smart way.

  • Ken Usdin - Analyst

  • And that was actually going to be my follow-up.

  • So it looked like the credit and debit card comped a little bit harder year over year, whereas corporate and merchant, to your last point, started to look better.

  • Are we near the point where you think that we can get all three of the individual lines of payments moving the right way on a revenue growth perspective?

  • And if not what is still holding that back?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Yes and let me hit on them each.

  • So Elavon, as I mentioned, strong growth on the revenue, same store sales up just under 4% driven by airline and fuel and that drove that 5.6 ex FX revenue growth.

  • Corporate card is two stories.

  • Number one is on the business side of the equation; we continue to see strong middle market virtual pay, commercial freight payment growth and that is positive.

  • But that was offset somewhat by government spend being down a bit.

  • Sometimes that happens in the fourth quarter; we saw that occur this time.

  • I think that will come back or flatten out.

  • But that is what drove some of the lower growth activity you saw in corporate.

  • And then finally on the card side, on the issuing side our growth in fees was about 7.5% less than that excluding Fidelity.

  • But it was also impacted by one less processing day in the fourth quarter which impacted growth about 1% or 1.5%.

  • So those three things are what is driving it overall.

  • And as I said, I think all these categories we would expect to grow in 2017.

  • Ken Usdin - Analyst

  • Thanks a lot, guys.

  • And best of luck.

  • Congrats.

  • Operator

  • Erika Najarian, Bank of America.

  • Erika Najarian - Analyst

  • Congratulations, Richard and Andy.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thank you.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Thank you.

  • Erika Najarian - Analyst

  • Richard, we will sure miss you, but we are looking forward to having Andy at the top.

  • So my first question, you mentioned in the prepared remarks that the trajectory of regulatory-related costs are stabilizing.

  • And you mentioned how expensive the AML consent order was and DOL compliance.

  • I am wondering if -- the stabilization seems like the natural trajectory of regulatory-related cost.

  • But if we get some regulatory relief from the new administration is there an opportunity for reg costs to actually go down for U.S. Bank?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • And the answer is yes.

  • It wouldn't be this year and I will tell you I am going to be a prognosticator here.

  • But based on what I understand, the administration that is going to take office in a few days, their number one issues are healthcare reform, taxes and infrastructure.

  • And somewhere in the top five might be financial services but it is not the top three.

  • A lot of financial services issues I think will be dealt with in the early part of the year but with some implications later.

  • So that is what I said earlier on DOL for instance, we never made a bet on whether something would happen that would cause us to need to slow down because we want to be ready, we would do it anyway.

  • So I think, Erika, the best thinking is that the understanding of what implications and lower regulation might happen will be known probably in the second half of the year and benefited sometime in 2018.

  • But I will also tell you, but for things like an unusual consent order or an event like DOL transition, I think this Bank has peaked on those costs.

  • Our compliance costs in the entire Company are now, in terms of FTE, they are over 7,000 people of our 70,000 and that is up more than twice what it was a few years ago.

  • That is a little high because of these issues I just mentioned, but it is not going to go back to where it was, it is going to stay much higher because that is the cost of running a high-quality bank.

  • We don't have issues other -- but the AML issue which has caused us that kind of extra expense.

  • And so expecting that nothing else comes along, we will see that come down and whatever regulatory reform relief we do see.

  • But most of it, I've got to tell you, it is going to be on the margins.

  • Because most of the stuff is burdened in, it is in the run rate, it turns out a lot of its good operating policy and good compliance review tactics for double and triple checking.

  • And we are not going to give up a lot of that.

  • So at least for this Bank it has got a positive leaning toward improvement, it is late in the year if not next year and it is not going to be significant but it will be positive.

  • Erika Najarian - Analyst

  • Great.

  • My second question is for Andy.

  • I mean it is pretty clear in terms of the 60% to 80% capital return that you target every year.

  • I am wondering, given the stock is trading close to 3 times tangible book if you think about future CCARs, whether you will maybe prioritize the dividend heavier as you think about dividend growth going forward and maybe normalizing to pre-crisis payout ratios.

  • And also how you are thinking about acquisitions, especially depository acquisitions, in terms of your capital strategy going forward?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • So, Erika, as you know, our capital strategy is 30 to 40 on dividends, 30 to 40 on buybacks.

  • We are at the high end on buybacks and at the low end on dividends right now.

  • And I would think about us moving more to our balanced perspective on that as we move forward and as we continue to look at the future years in CCAR.

  • With regard to acquisitions, with the consent order in place right now we are precluded from traditional depository acquisitions.

  • But we are doing things like you saw in the last year with Fidelity and IAG card portfolio acquisitions, we can do merchant acquiring acquisitions and trust and payments business.

  • So that does not preclude us and that is actually an area of focus.

  • So, I think that will be our focus in the short-term.

  • Once we are out of the consent order we may look at traditional depository, but that is not a focus right now.

  • Erika Najarian - Analyst

  • Great, thank you.

  • Operator

  • Mike Mayo, CLSA.

  • Mike Mayo - Analyst

  • Richard, the first question is why are you stepping down?

  • I guess I am -- I mean I am a little confused.

  • I mean you are running a bank with best-in-class performance measures.

  • You have been there 10 years, you are 58, I guess almost 59 and you had many other banks -- have sometimes run banks with worst-in-class performance measures, have been there over a decade and they are a lot older.

  • So what is going on?

  • And also what does it mean when it says you will help move the Bank to new areas of business?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • So, Mike, I don't know if you heard the opening of the call because I answered that question for John McDonald.

  • But basically the reasons are I said in place three years ago that at the 10-year mark, assuming nothing else had changed, that it would be appropriate for a change in leadership because I just feel that way, that is my personal opinion.

  • I indicated that Andy is the perfect candidate, he is sitting right here next to me, let's give him the signal, let's get him the timetable, let's keep him.

  • And thirdly, I do have another calling in life to do something entirely different, which I don't know what it is because I never felt permitted to look until the announcement was passed.

  • And today will be my first day to look into the future along with my wife, who has a very strong view that we want one more thing in life to accomplish and it is going to be entirely outside of the banking industry.

  • So that is the reason.

  • And the rumors of my bad health or early demise are greatly exaggerated.

  • I feel quite good today.

  • And so that is the timing for that.

  • And I don't know why some people stay longer, I don't know what the issues are at other companies.

  • But mine was not to time it; mine was not to set this moment in time based on how the Company is doing.

  • It was three years ago to set a timetable that if at the 10-year mark it seemed right, and it now does, we have got everything lined up and the perfect guy to do it.

  • And so, that is exactly what it was.

  • And the Board, of course, has all those decisions.

  • I can't make any decision I want on my own without their complete endorsement and their very careful due diligence, which they did all of, and they are quite excited about this transition as well.

  • Mike Mayo - Analyst

  • And then as far as Andy, is this business as usual?

  • Are you going to have some tweaks or strategic changes?

  • Or what degree of change might you implement especially with Richard still as Chairman?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Hanging around (laughter).

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • So, Mike, Richard and I have been together for 10 years and the strategies and decisions that we have made and the position of the Bank is a combination of all of us, the management committee and the two of us.

  • So I don't expect major changes.

  • We are continuing to focus on one bank from the perspective of the customer, technology and innovation will continue to be an area of focus as it has been as things move digitally.

  • And I would maintain that we are the best bank right now and I am certain that we have one of the best management teams out there.

  • So I couldn't be more honored and pleased to take this on.

  • Mike Mayo - Analyst

  • All right, well, thank you.

  • Operator

  • Saul Martinez, UBS.

  • Saul Martinez - Analyst

  • Congratulations on the roles.

  • I wanted to ask you about the longer-term guidance you had -- you outlined at your Investor Day.

  • And I think you guys have addressed it I guess in a directional fashion thus far, but sort of a broader question.

  • You guys gave pretty expensive guidance on revenues, expenses, through the cycle provisions, business line growth.

  • And obviously the backdrop has changed, we are kind of at an inflection in terms of -- potential inflection in terms of the economic backdrop, regulatory backdrop and whatnot.

  • But how are you guys thinking about the longer-term guidance that you outlined today versus mid-September when you had your Investor Day?

  • And where are you feeling more comfortable; where are you feeling less comfortable?

  • If you could just kind of give us a directional sense of that.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • So, Saul, as you know, that guidance was based on a three-year view.

  • And it was a three-year view of what we would call sort of a more normal rate and economic environment.

  • I think as we sit today we are probably more comfortable about getting there in the three-year window that we talked about, certainly from a rate perspective.

  • What we predicted thus far is occurring.

  • The economy seems to be at least steady and slightly improving.

  • And so, I would say we continue to feel good about those projections and our expectations are still to get there in that three-year window.

  • Saul Martinez - Analyst

  • Okay, that is helpful.

  • I guess more of a specific follow-up.

  • I think last quarter you talked about utilization rates on commercial lines being around 25%, 26%.

  • Any change there?

  • Are you seeing any of the optimism from companies starting to filter through in terms of borrowing [the] pipeline for credit and whatnot?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Saul, while the talk and optimism and discussion is more positive, the utilization rates are flat.

  • Still at 25% as they have been for the past few quarters.

  • Saul Martinez - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • All right, thanks a lot.

  • Operator

  • Kevin Barker, Piper Jaffray.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • Congratulations on the new roles for both of you.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Thanks.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • I just wanted to follow up regarding some of your comments around the tax rates moving down to 5% to 6% effective tax rate.

  • And obviously your reinvestment of some of those tax credits.

  • Obviously it is very early in this discussion, we still have a ways to go before we figure it all out.

  • Were there any specific line items around possibly low income housing tax credits or BOLI that you expect to go away?

  • And at what level do you expect to have to reinvest those assets?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, so let me take a stab at it.

  • And I think your question was really around tax policy and tax credit sort of investments and then where we might see either changes in the nature or type of investments.

  • So we invest in really kind of four different areas: affordable houses is a very significant part of it; new market or economic development sort of tax credits is the second; a little bit of historical tax credit; but then also renewable energy.

  • When we end up talking to people that are kind of plugged into the tax credit kind of market, we don't see a lot of change coming with respect to affordable housing because of all the policy implications associated with that.

  • Or in the economic development because when you think about what the administration is trying to do, they are trying to stimulate economic development.

  • So we don't see a lot of change to that.

  • Probably where that change is going to occur will be with respect to renewable energy type of credits.

  • And to be quite frank, the law had already incorporated a phase-out of those over the next four or five years anyway.

  • So we didn't really anticipate a lot of impact to us with respect to where we were going to invest and what the implications associated with were going to be.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • So when you say the 5% to 6% decline in the effective tax rate on a 10% decline in the actual rate with some reinvestment tax credit, depending on how that all plays out.

  • If you were to see a 10% decline in effective tax rate would you believe that the decline in earnings would be close to 30% or 40% or do you expect -- 30% to 40% of the 10% or something closer to 10% or 20% of the 10%?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • In fact I implemented it.

  • It isn't a decline in earnings, it is actually an improvement in earnings because of the fact that we are paying less in tax expense as opposed to more.

  • So in my example our effective tax rate would go from 28%/29% down from there and that actually would be a positive from a profitability standpoint.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • Yes, what I mean is so with the tax credits -- what I am saying is if you had a 10% decline would it be a 5% to 6% improvement in earnings or would it be more of a 7% to 8% improvement in earnings?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • No, it would be a -- again, this is all simple math, etc., in terms of how I am portraying it right now.

  • But it would be a 5% improvement in our effective tax rate.

  • So you would have to kind of do the math from there.

  • But it is not a 5% improvement in earnings or anything like that, it is a 5% reduction in our effective tax rate.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Using the 10% example.

  • Kevin Barker - Analyst

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Vivek Juneja, JPMorgan.

  • Vivek Juneja - Analyst

  • Congratulations again.

  • Let me add that.

  • A couple of quick questions.

  • Just one just for Terry, just want to confirm that when you said percentage drop in expenses in the first quarter that I heard it correct, that you are referring to 1% drop in expenses, Terry?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, we would expect on a linked quarter basis it would decline about the 1% range.

  • Vivek Juneja - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • Then the other line item that you said, I can't remember whether it was you, Andy.

  • You said equity investment gains should run at the fourth-quarter level.

  • What is the level of equity investment gains and also what is the amount of equity investments?

  • And is that increasing because you have increased investments?

  • Can you talk a little -- can you give us some color on this three items there?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, other income represents a whole variety of different things.

  • It includes trading income, it includes end of term and retail product revenue.

  • It includes equity investments.

  • It is just a whole variety of different things and they kind of move sometimes in different directions.

  • So it is really hard to kind of narrow it down to specifically equity investments.

  • And I wouldn't want to kind of take you down that path or mislead you with respect to that.

  • I guess my point is that when I end up looking at other income and the impact of equity investments within other income I think it is going to be fairly stable relative to the fourth quarter.

  • That is what I would tell you.

  • Vivek Juneja - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • And have you -- what is the dollar amount of investment that you will have made in equity investments and has that increased recently?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • It hasn't increased and it is not something that have kind of specifically disclosed in the past.

  • Vivek Juneja - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • One last quick one, AML.

  • Are you -- can you just give us an update on timing of when you expect to get out of that one?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Yes, Vivek, this is Richard.

  • We don't have timing on that.

  • We are an OCC bank, so they are really our binding constraint.

  • We are making great progress, we are moving forward.

  • There is a bifurcated view I think on any consent order.

  • One is you get to where you need to be, then you need to prove you can stay there for a while.

  • Then they need to audit to confirm the sustainability.

  • So we are in the between stages one and two right now.

  • So it depends on how long that will take.

  • Back to Erika's question, I do think that as regulatory reform starts to maybe lighten a bit I think those kinds of issues move more swiftly.

  • I hope there will be a faster conclusion from beginning to end on anything any bank has been called out to improve.

  • Because I think part of the issue as we are just in these issues for a very long time and maybe unnecessarily extended periods when the performance has likely been accomplished, the remedy has been done and it is sustained and it just needs too long to prove it.

  • So I think we have talked about this year being that year to get all those steps done.

  • If I had to make a guess we are probably late this year, early into next year.

  • But that is based on my own guess and we are not [M&T], we are not another bank that has this issue.

  • We are U.S. Bank and we are dealing with our own issues and we are moving swiftly with our key regulator, the OCC, to prove to them that we have got the message, we have got the sustainability and we are ready to move forward.

  • But, it is not imminent, but let's hope that it is not too much into the future either.

  • Vivek Juneja - Analyst

  • Okay, thanks, Richard.

  • Operator

  • Peter Winter, Wedbush Securities.

  • Peter Winter - Analyst

  • You guys have had nice growth in the other earning assets, the excess liquidity with all the deposit growth.

  • Any thought with the move up in rates to reinvest in securities?

  • Or is it you want to hold onto it just thinking that deposits will outflow given the outlook for better loan growth?

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • Yes, it is really a couple of different things.

  • We do expect it to really kind of abate again and we will see deposit outflows occurring, which is why, especially in the fourth quarter, we tend to hold the cash balances.

  • We see a run up in deposits with respect to, for example, our corporate trust business and then that ends up getting deployed in terms of structures, etc.

  • If the economy moves up or starts to improve and businesses start to make those business investments that we expect, we do and we would see some disintermediation of deposits at that particular point in time because that is where they would start to -- we would start to see outflow there.

  • Peter Winter - Analyst

  • Got it.

  • And just a quick -- just another question, housekeeping.

  • You mentioned with the recent increase in rates that the fee waivers on money market accounts will be minimal in 2017.

  • Just what was that impact in 2016?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • So two years ago at its peak -- this is Andy, the money market waivers were just about $100 million and we received back, so to speak, about 75% or 80% of it in 2016 so that is why Terry says there is a limited amount remaining in 2017.

  • Terry Dolan - Vice Chairman & CFO

  • And the vast majority of that we'll probably see in the first quarter and then it will be gone.

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • Yes.

  • Peter Winter - Analyst

  • Got it, okay.

  • Thanks.

  • Operator

  • Gerard Cassidy, RBC.

  • Gerard Cassidy - Analyst

  • A question for you -- on your loan to deposit ratio, average loans to average deposits is about 82%, what is the optimal level that you guys like to keep that ratio at?

  • Andy Cecere - President & COO

  • We don't strive for an optimal ratio, Gerard.

  • It is a function of loan growth and demand and deposit growth and demand.

  • So it is just an outcome.

  • And if we have more than that some of it goes in the investment securities or cash as referenced by Terry; if we have less than that we have plenty of funding opportunities being a very highly rated bank.

  • So we are not striving to a specific ratio, it is just an outcome.

  • Gerard Cassidy - Analyst

  • Okay, thank you.

  • Richard, you mentioned earlier in the call that you're sensing that the banks are smarter in terms of the deposit pricing.

  • How much of an influence do you think that the industry's low loan to deposit ratio may have on that if at all?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • I don't know the answer to that, Gerard.

  • But I know the temptation would already have been present if it was there.

  • So the first couple of moves a year ago and now a month ago I think that based on hunger for banks to do well that probably would have been as [heightened] as an opportunity as possible.

  • So I am just of the mind that that temptation is past and people are going to be thoughtful and smart as we move up.

  • Obviously as rates get further and deeper beyond 25 basis points things will start to pick up.

  • But the arbitrage between deposit and loan rates will start to get wider which is good for banks and that is why people are betting that banks will do better in part.

  • And I think we have just gotten smarter.

  • People are more thoughtful, their balance sheet makes more sense to them and there is other levers to pull, but I just don't think that is going to be one of them (inaudible).

  • Gerard Cassidy - Analyst

  • Great.

  • And then just a final question.

  • Again, Richard, you touched on some of the regulatory aspects of what is going on in the industry and of course it is not the top priority of the incoming administration, as you have identified.

  • We hear a lot about relief [fees] for the banks under $250 billion in assets from a regulatory standpoint.

  • The so-called global SIFIs are not going to see as much relief.

  • Can you point where you guys are positioned, obviously above $250 billion but less than a global SIFI, what would be ideal relief for banks your size?

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • That is a great question because -- don't hate me for this answer, but we don't think there would be a lot of change even if we were given relief.

  • We are a very large Company.

  • And systemically important have a lot to do with whether you would break the world if you fell apart.

  • But in our case we are very important wherever we are.

  • And I think most of the practices that we have been performing, particularly stress testing and recognizing where the risks are, those are better practices and we are really good at it and we keep a lot of those, Gerard.

  • So a lot of those would not go away.

  • I would say some of the relief would be in the consumer enforcement area.

  • I have long asked, I have pleaded with Rich Cordray to consider making the CFPB an endorsement agency, not an enforcement agency -- and I am not being clever here.

  • The idea that they would put out the basic tenets for the top-rated banks to be customer protective, customer supportive, financial literacy, do the right thing and they told us what those rules were we would kill ourselves to be at the top level.

  • Every day we would do all we could to be positively vexed toward getting better every day.

  • And instead there is just this undue sense that the enforcement side of the spirit comes from trying to get you and do something wrong and not instead work to get better but try to find a mistake -- many cases that were human, err and in many cases in rural sets that weren't even there when they were done.

  • So that would be my favorite -- that would be beneficial to all of us.

  • We are $440 billion or $450 billion, we are not a G-SIFI, but we are definitely a SIFI, and we are okay with that.

  • And we will come with it all the responsibilities that attend to being very, very thoughtful in your compliance, above reproach in your customer care and doing everything the right way as best you can.

  • And if you don't, get it right as soon as you figure it out.

  • So, not a lot would change for us and we have actually not enjoined with some of the smaller regional banks in trying to relieve some of that -- getting some of that relief because we just don't think it would change the way we run our Bank.

  • Gerard Cassidy - Analyst

  • Great, appreciate the color.

  • Thank you.

  • Richard Davis - Chairman & CEO

  • Yes.

  • Hey, before we close since (inaudible) get to the last question, just a couple of thoughts on the Bank and the environment.

  • We do believe that the rate environment, steeper yield curve than it was 90 days ago, likelihood of interest rates -- we think those are bankable.

  • We think banks deserve that, long overdue and it is going to get better.

  • That is part of our modeling and we think that is important.

  • The economy being better actually trumps all of that.

  • A really good economy -- we are a reflection of what our customers feel.

  • And when that economy kicks in, and we hope it does, that will be more important than anything.

  • But disappointing as you might be to hear it, we are like canaries in a mine -- we can see balance sheets, we can see customer behavior.

  • Optimism is high but actions are not present yet.

  • So we are going to wait and see on that one.

  • And then tax reform might be other big one that benefits us and our customers.

  • As I said earlier, based on my understanding of the budget process it is probably going to be a late year issue.

  • So I think banks should bank, you should bank on banks doing well by the interest rate environment.

  • I think you should expect the economy and taxes to be two of the best benefits that will accrue, probably even bigger than rate.

  • But I think those come later in the year.

  • And we are balancing the bank to manage through a slight beneficial quarter one and two and then much more beneficial probably quarter three and four.

  • And this is my last call, 41 of them.

  • So I just want to tell you guys how much I appreciate -- as a class of investors and analysts you have been fair and thoughtful and balanced and you have treated this Company very well.

  • And I appreciate that very much.

  • We have also in-kind been transparent, we have been very complete and thorough in our forecasting and I think we have been as candid as we know how to be because we trust that the relationship that we have with you is part based on transparency and clarity.

  • So I want to thank you for that relationship.

  • I want to encourage you to keep that relationship with us.

  • Terry and Andy will be a remarkable team.

  • And despite the fact that I want things to change for the betterment of this Company, I think you will be appreciative that they will be thoughtful and measured and very well telegraphed.

  • So to end on a sports note, because that is how I kind of think of my life, this is rather like a great relay race.

  • And we are on the backside of the track and Andy and I are running together now because he is about to pick up the baton, he has got the perfect cadence, I have got the perfect speed.

  • Our hands come together, the baton hands off and we are off to another race.

  • And that is exactly how I hope you see it.

  • So with that, operator -- or Jen -- I think you can close the call.

  • Operator

  • This concludes today's conference call.

  • You may now disconnect.