使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Abbe Goldstein - IR Contact Officer
Presentation earlier this morning. All of these materials can be found on our website at travelers.com under the Investors section. Speaking today will be Alan Schnitzer, Chairman and CEO; Dan Frey, CFO; and our three segment Presidents: Greg Toczydlowski of Business Insurance, Jeff Klenk of Bond and Specialty Insurance, and Michael Klein of Personal Insurance.
They will discuss the financial results of our business and the current market environment. They will refer to the webcast presentation as they go through prepared remarks, and then we will take your questions. Before I turn the call over to Alan, I'd like to draw your attention to the explanatory note included at the end of the webcast presentation.
Our presentation today includes forward-looking statements. The company cautions investors that any forward-looking statement involves risks and uncertainties and is not a guarantee of future performance. Actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied in the Forward-looking statements due to a variety of factors.
These factors are described under forward-looking statements in our earnings press release and in our most recent 10-Q and 10-k filed with the SEC. We do not undertake any obligation to update forward-looking statements.
Also in our remarks or responses to questions, we may mention some non-GAAP financial measures. Reconciliations are included in our recent earnings press release, financial supplement, and other materials available in the Investor section on our website. And now I'd like to turn the call over to Alan Schnitzer.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Thank you, Abby. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. We're pleased to report excellent fourth quarter and full year results, with strong and broad-based performance across both underwriting and investments. For both periods, the bottom-line results were driven by very strong underlying underwriting income.
Particularly given the written margins remain attractive, this is a durable dynamic. For the quarter, we earn core income of $2.5 billion or $0.1113 per diluted share, generating core return on equity of 29.6%. Underwriting income of $2.2 billion pre-tax increased 21% compared to the prior year quarter.
Benefiting from higher underlying underwriting income, higher favorable prior year reserve development, and a lower level of catastrophe losses. The underlying result was driven by strong net earned premiums and excellent margins. The underlying combined ratio improved nearly 2 points to 82.2%. Underwriting results were strong in all three segments.
Our high-quality investment portfolio also continued to perform well, generating after-tax net investment income of $867 million for the quarter, up 10%, driven by strong and reliable returns from our growing fixed income portfolio. Our terrific underwriting and investment results, together with our strong balance sheet, enabled us to return $1.9 billion of capital to shareholders during the quarter, including $1.7 billion of share repurchases.
Importantly, at the same time, we continue to make significant strategic investments in our business. Even after this deployment of capital, adjusted book value per share was up 14% compared to a year ago. Turning to the topline, to discipline marketplace execution across all three segments, we grew net written premiums to $10.9 billion in the quarter.
In business insurance, we grew net written premiums to $5.5 billion. Excluding the property line, we grew domestic net written premiums in the segment by 4%. As I shared last quarter, the declining property premium is a large account dynamic. We'll continue to be disciplined in terms of risk selection, pricing, in terms of conditions.
Renewal premium change in business insurance was 6.1%. Renewal premium change in auto, CMP, and umbrella remained in the double-digits. Excluding the property line, renewal premium change came in strong at just over 8%. Including workers' comp, which continues to be low single-digits positive.
Given the attractive returns, we were pleased that retention in the segment remained strong at 85%. In bonded specialty insurance, we were net written premiums to $1.1 billion with excellent retention of 87% and positive renewal premium change in our high-quality management liability business.
In our industry leading surety business, we grew net written premiums from a very strong level in the prior year quarter. In personal insurance, net written premiums of $4.2 billion reflected continued strong renewal premium change in homeowners and higher new business and auto.
You'll hear more shortly from Greg, Jeff, and Michael about our segment results. Before I turn the call over to Dan, I'd like to take a step back and talk about what's driving this performance and what's ahead.
About 10 years ago we embarked on an innovation strategy designed to position our business to grow at industry leading returns with low volatility. As you can see on slide 18 of our webcast presentation, over the past decade, we've grown our topline at a compound annual rate of 7% while improving our underlying profitability by almost 8 points.
Notwithstanding a significant increase in our technology spending, that improvement in underlying profitability includes a 3 points or 10% improvement in our expense ratio. As a consequence of all that, compared to 10 years ago, our underlying underwriting income is more than 4 times what it had been.
Our cash flow from operations has more than doubled, and our investment portfolio has grown by 50% to more than $100 billion. As you can see on slide 19, over that same period, core return on equity has averaged more than 1,000 basis points over the 10-year treasury at industry low volatility, and we've grown earnings per share on average by 12%.
In short, the execution of our strategy has been exceptional. We think about all, we think about that chapter as innovation 1.0. our success with Innovation 1.0 is the result of having done three difficult things very well. Identifying the initiatives that really matter and passing on the merely good ideas that don't.
Executing effectively and capturing the value of what we build. Over the decade, we developed the competitive advantage of an innovation skill set. Now we're bringing all that hard-won know-how to innovation 2.0 at Travelers, powered by AI and not too far off quantum computing.
The PNC industry is well positioned to benefit from AI across the entire value chain. This generation of AI can understand and execute on the complex stakeholder interactions, well-defined processes, data intensive workflows, and massive amounts of unstructured data that characterize our industry.
It gains compound over many interactions. In that context, Travelers is particularly well positioned. As an industry leader, we bring differentiating domain expertise. Because AI amplifies existing strength, leaders in the domain are best positioned to use it to drive improvement.
In addition, we have decades of high-quality data for millions of transactions and interactions, and the scale to invest at significant levels as AI and technology continue to segment the market. We have thousands of engineers, data scientists, and analysts building AI and other sophisticated technologies and solutions.
Dozens of scale generative AI tools are already in production. Millions of transactions are now automated. More than 20,000 of our colleagues use AI tools on a regular basis. And agentic AI isn't a future aspiration. It's embedded in our business operations today. Last week we in Anthropic announced a partnership to empower 10,000 of our engineers, data scientists, analysts, and product owners with personalized, context-aware, and integrated AI assistance.
This initiative will enhance and accelerate the development of software analytics and predictive models. In extensive testing, we achieved significantly improved engineering output and meaningful productivity gains. We expect that this will result in faster and more cost-effective delivery of new capabilities across Travelers.
Everything from product development, the new business prospecting to underwriting speed and quality, the agent and customer service, and more benefiting our business, our customers, and our distribution partners. In our claim organization, more than half of all claims are now eligible for straight due processing.
With customers adopting straight through processing about two third of the time. Another 15% of all claims are processed with advanced digital tools. All of those percentages are growing. To accommodate customers who still prefer to call in to report a claim, just last week we launched a natural language generative AI voice agent that takes first notice of loss by phone.
Early customer adoption is exceeding our expectations. The results are tangible. In our claim organization, investments we've made, including an automation, straight through processing and analytics, refine indemnity payouts, and drive operational efficiencies.
It's worth pointing out that the efficiency gains in our claim organization come through loss adjustment expense benefiting the loss ratio. As just one example, our claimed call center population is down by third and this year we'll be consolidating four claim call centers down to two. And of course we're deploying AI broadly across the business.
Other use cases enhance underwriting decision quality and efficiency and improve the experience for customers, agents, brokers, and employees. So here's some examples from Greg, Jeff, and Michael.
We're so early in this transformation, which means the benefits more effective underwriting, improved operating leverage, and profitable growth will continue to build. To sum it up, our results this year and over time reflect the power of our earnings engine fueled by the disciplined execution of our strategy.
For the full year, core income was up 26% to $6.3 billion or $0.2759 per diluted share, generating core return on equity of 19.4%. And during the year, we grew adjusted book value per share by 14% after returning $4.2 billion of excess capital to shareholders and investing more than $1.5 billion in cutting-edge AI and other technology initiatives.
Our operational and financial success in the face of another year of elevated catastrophe losses for the industry supports our ability to be there for our customers. In 2025 we handled 1.5 million claims. That's about one every 20 seconds and paid out more than $23 billion in claim payments.
We also met our objective of closing 90% of claims arising out of catastrophes within 30 days. 2026 and in future years we'll be there to help our customers and communities recover and to enable individuals and businesses to thrive. Looking ahead, we're also very well positioned to continue generating substantial shareholder value. The durability of our strong underlying business performance provides a powerful foundation for continued strong bottom-line results, leading returns, and strong cash flows.
Operating from this position of strength, we remain highly confident in the outlook for Travelers in 2026 and beyond. And with that, pleased to turn the call over to Dan.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Thank you, Alan. The core income for the fourth quarter was $2.5 billion and core return on equity was 29.6%. As we once again delivered excellent financial results on a consolidated, the full year underwriting results were also excellent on both an underlying and as reported basis. And net investment income was once again higher than a year ago.
The strong fourth quarter finish brings full year core income to $6.3 billion in full year core ROE to 19.4%. In Q4 we generated higher levels of written and earned premiums compared to a year ago while delivering excellent combined ratios on both the reported and underlying basis.
At 82.2%, the underlying combined ratio marked its fifth consecutive quarter below 85%. The combination of higher premiums and the improved underlying combined ratio led to a 15% increase in after-tax underlying underwriting income. That brings the full year after tax underlying underwriting results to $5.5 billion up 23% from the prior year. The growth in underlying underwriting income in recent years is worth an extra minute of commentary.
In 2022, we reported a very strong $2.1 billion after tax. Through the successful and disciplined execution of our strategy, we grew that figure to $3.2 billion in 2023, then to $4.5 billion in 2024, and now to $5.5 billion for 2025. Those earnings are what drive strong cash flow from operations which after averaging about $4 billion for the 10 years from 2011 through 2020 surpassed $9 billion in 2024 and reached $10.6 billion in 2025.
The expense ratio for the fourth quarter was 28.4%, bringing the full year expense ratio to 28.5% as expected. Continue to expect the expense ratio for 2026 to be right around 28.5%. Catastrophe losses in the quarter were $95 million pre-tax.
Turning to prior year reserve development, we had total net favorable development of $321 million pre-tax in the quarter, with all three segments contributing. Business insurance, net favorable PYD of $205 million was driven by favorability in workers' comp.
In bond and Specialty net favorable PYD of $30 million was driven by better-than-expected results and fidelity and surety. Personal insurance had $86 million of net favorable PYD with favorability in both auto and home.
After tax net investment income of $867 million increased by 10% from the prior year quarter. Fixed maturity NII was again the driver of the increase, reflecting both the benefit of higher invested assets and higher average yields.
Driven by the strong cash flows I referenced earlier, during 2025, we grew our investment portfolio by approximately $7.5 billion to $106 billion. As of December 31, new money rates were about 70 basis points above the yield embedded in the portfolio.
In terms of our outlook for fixed income NII for 2026, including earnings from short-term securities, we expect approximately $3.3 billion after tax, beginning with about $800 million in the first quarter and growing to about $870 million in the fourth quarter.
As with underwriting income, the growth in investment income over the past several years has been significant. Our 2026 outlook represents nearly twice as much fixed income NII as we delivered in 2021, just five years ago. Page 22 of the webcast presentation provides information about our January 1, catastrophe reinsurance renewal.
And we're very pleased with the changes for 2026. Our longstanding CAT XOL treaty continues to provide coverage for both single CAT events and the aggregation of losses for multiple CAT events. The per occurrence loss deductible is unchanged at $100 million and for 2026 we dropped the attachment point to $3 billion compared to the $4 billion attachment point we had in 2025.
We believe in all perils CAT aggregate is the most efficient way to protect the balance sheet. And the combination of our industry outperformance, refined reinsurance structures, and more favorable reinsurance pricing have allowed us to meaningfully improve our coverage with only a modest increase to our total seated premium costs.
We also renewed the enhanced casualty reinsurance program first introduced for 2025. We were once again able to purchase working layer coverage on a roughly margin neutral basis. On page 23 of the webcast presentation, we've again provided both a summary of the seasonality of our CAT losses over the prior decade and a view of our CAT plan by quarter for 2026.
As you can see, the 2026 CAT plan in terms of combined ratio points is higher than both the five year and 10-year averages. As a reminder for your modeling in terms of seasonality. As you can see from the data, the second quarter has historically been our largest CAT quarter.
Also of interest for 2026, we continue to value our relationship with Fidelis and are very pleased to have once again renewed our 20% quota share with them. The renewal includes the same loss ratio cap we've had in place since the quota share began in 2023.
Interest rates decreased during the quarter and as a result our net unrealized investment loss decreased from $2 billion after tax at September 30, to $1.5 billion after tax at December 31. Adjusted book value per share, which excludes net unrealized investment gains and losses, was $1.5801 at year end, up 14% from a year ago.
Turning to capital management, we returned $1.9 billion of capital to our shareholders this quarter, comprising share repurchases of $1.65 billion and dividends of $244 million.
In our prepared remarks last quarter, we indicated that we expected to execute roughly $1.6 billion of share repurchases in the first quarter of 2026, including the use of about $700 million from the sale of our Canadian operations, which did close as planned on January 2.
Even with the increased level of share repurchases we just executed in Q4, given the strong finish to the 2025 year, we now expect repurchases of around $1.8 billion in Q1 of course, the actual amount and timing of repurchases will depend on a number of factors including CAT events and other quarterly earnings impacts, as well as other factors we disclose in our SEC filings.
I'd like to make one other comment on capital management to help with your models. Given the growth we've generated over the past several years and the outlook for continued growth, we're now more likely to issue debt every year, assuming we're comfortable with market conditions. Our recent history has been to issue debt every other year.
Annual debt issuance allows us to maintain a more consistent debt to capital ratio. Recapping our results for 2025, we're very pleased to have delivered net and core income of $6.3 billion and core return on equity of 19.4%. We ended the year with our all-time high and adjusted book value per share and with our largest investment portfolio ever. In short, we're extremely well positioned for 2026 and beyond.
With that, I'll turn the call over to Greg for a discussion of business insurance.
Gregory Toczydlowski - Executive Vice President, President - Business Insurance
Thanks, Dan. Business insurance had another very strong quarter, rounding out another terrific year in terms of financial results, execution in the marketplace, and progress in our strategic initiatives. Segment income for the quarter was nearly $1.3 billion and up more than $100 million from the prior year quarter.
Improvement from the prior year was driven by higher net investment income, higher favorable prior year reserve development, and lower catastrophes. The all-in combined ratio of 84.4% was a great result and about a point better than the prior year quarter.
We're once again particularly pleased with our exceptional underlying combined ratio of 87%. The underlying loss ratio was the second-best quarterly result ever, trailing only last year's fourth quarter record.
The expense ratio remained excellent at 29.3%. Turning to the topline, net written premiums reached an all-time fourth quarter high of more than $5.5 billion. We grew our leading select and middle market businesses by 4% and 3% respectively.
These two markets make up almost three quarters of our net rent premiums for business insurance in the quarter. We saw a decline in national property premiums reflecting our disciplined execution in terms of risk selection, pricing, and terms and conditions.
Excluding the property line, domestic net written premiums were up 4%. As always, our focus is on writing business that meets our risk profile and underwriting standards and where we can get an appropriate price with terms that reflect the exposure's perils.
As for production across the segment, pricing remained attractive with renewal premium change of just over 6%. Excluding the property line, RPC was strong at 8%. Renewal premium change was positive in all lines, including property in double-digits and CMP umbrella and auto.
Retention remained excellent at 85%, and new business of $675 million was up 6% from the prior quarter. We're pleased with these production results in our fields execution of our proven segmentation strategy. Across the book, pricing and retention results this quarter reflect excellent execution, aligning price, terms and conditions with environmental trends for each line.
As for the individual businesses, in select, renewal premium change and renewal rate change both remain strong for the quarter and about flat with third quarter levels. Retention was up 2 points from the fourth quarter of last year as we continue to wind down our CMP risk return optimization efforts.
Lastly, new business was up 6% from the fourth quarter of last year to a healthy $139 million. In our core middle market business, renewal premium change remained attractive at 6.6%. Price increases remain broad-based as we achieved higher prices on about three quarters of our middle market accounts.
And at the same time, the granular execution was excellent with meaningful spread from our best performing accounts to our lower performing accounts. To a large degree, the sequential decline in RPC was impacted by the property line, where RPC remains positive, healthy, and reflective of attractive returns.
We're pleased that middle market retention remained exceptional at 87%, and new business of $395 million was up 11% to an all-time fourth quarter high. As we close out 2025, let me provide a little color on full year results before turning the call over to Jeff.
We're very pleased to report segment income of nearly $3.7 billion. An underlying combined ratio of 88% and top line of $22.7 billion. This was the third year in a row where we delivered and both remained historically high, while new business premiums approaching $3 billion reached an all-time best.
These sustained exceptional results are a direct reflection of our strong value proposition, as well as the successful execution of our thoughtful and deliberate strategies. Beyond our execution excellence, we're pleased with the contributions we're getting from our ongoing strategic initiatives.
The decision support tools we're putting in the hands of our underwriters at the point of sale, including models that derive risk characteristics, refined technical pricing, and summarize historical model loss experience results in better risk selection, pricing, and terms and conditions.
In addition, we're encouraged by the impact we're seeing from our product and user experience initiatives, including how well they've been received in the market. Our new BOP product is now fully rolled out, and our new auto product is live in 46 states.
Both products contain industry leading segmentation, which contributes to profitable growth. We also continue to enhance the insights around our submissions, based on quality and appetite that allow our underwriters to focus on those new business opportunities that we most want to add to the portfolio.
We're pleased with our progress with Gen AI. We're building and executing a robust portfolio of Gen AI initiatives that will enable enhanced risk assessment and selection, ultimately improving loss experience, as well as drive gains in productivity and efficiency, and improve our industry leading experience for our agents and brokers.
As just one example, we've recently rolled out Gen AI agents to efficiently mine both internal and external data sources to better understand and synthesize the risk characteristics and ensure appropriate business classification.
This capability both accelerates the underwriting process and results in improved risk classification and segmented pricing. To sum up, we feel terrific about our performance and financial results in 2025.
We're excited about what we're investing in for the future, and we have the best people in the business, and they're not only executing with excellence in the market today, but they're also helping to shape the transformation of our industry.
In short, we're well positioned for continued profitable growth. With that, I'll turn the call over to Jeff.
Jeffrey Klenk - Executive Vice President and President, Bond & Specialty Insurance
Thank you, Greg, and good morning, everyone. Bond and specialty ended the year with another strong quarter on both the top and bottom lines. In the fourth quarter, we generated segment income of $236 million and an excellent combined ratio of 83%.
A strong underlying combined ratio of 85.7% was a little more than a point better than the prior year quarter. Turning to the topline, we grew net written premiums by 4% in the quarter to $1.1 billion. In our high-quality domestic management liability business, renewal premium change was 2.8%. While retention remains strong at 87%.
We're very pleased with the progress we've achieved to improve pricing through our purposeful and segmented initiatives while continuing to deliver strong retention. As we expected, new business was lower than the fourth quarter of 2024.
As a reminder, this is the final quarter of year over year new business impact from our Corvus acquisition, with the most Corvus production now reported as renewal premium. Turning to our market leading surety business. Net written premiums increased from the very strong prior year quarter, reflecting strong demand for our products and unparalleled value-added services.
So we're pleased to have once again delivered strong results in bond and specialty this quarter. Reflecting on the full year, we're also very pleased with the performance of our business in 2025. In our management liability business, we successfully navigated ongoing soft market conditions and we're among the first carriers to drive higher pricing to improve product returns where needed.
Despite market headwinds, we drove profitable account and premium growth by leveraging our investments in advanced analytics, including the automated delivery of next generation sophisticated pricing models. Our AI investments to automate submission intake for new business reduced our time to ingest submissions from hours to just minutes.
And we recently extended automation capabilities to renewal workflows. We've also made important investments in sales effectiveness and enhancements to our product offerings. And capitalizing on our Corvus acquisition, we've successfully extended cyber risk services to customers across our portfolio.
This includes always on threat monitoring with same day alerts, continuous dark web surveillance, 24/7 access to a tailored policyholder dashboard. And personalized security consultations from our in-house cyber experts. As we've expected, these capabilities are helping our customers to more effectively manage cyber risks and are mitigating our exposure to evolving cyber vulnerabilities.
In our surety business, we drove solid growth by capitalizing on our industry leading expertise and premier value-added service offerings. We've entered into new and expanded distribution arrangements, domestically and internationally, that position us for continued growth.
We've more closely aligned and integrated our outstanding Canadian surety operation, which contributes to our position as the leading surety in North America. And in our commercial surety flow business, we've leveraged AI to enhance distribution, submission, and fulfillment experiences, improving efficiency and fueling growth.
All of these investments and initiatives and the terrific execution by our outstanding team drove another strong year of profitable growth in bond and specialty, and we're excited about the opportunities that lie ahead. And with that, I'll turn the call over to Mike.
Michael Klein - Executive Vice President, President - Personal Insurance
Thanks, Jeff. I'm very pleased to share that personal insurance generated segment income of more than a billion dollars in the quarter, and a combined ratio of 74%. Both results reflect the strong underlying fundamentals of our business.
For the full year, personal insurance generated over $2 billion of segment income and a combined ratio of 89.5%. These results improved compared to the prior year, notwithstanding significant losses from the California wildfires, reflecting the strength of our diversified book of business and our disciplined approach to selecting, pricing, and managing risk.
Net written premiums in the fourth quarter were comparable to the prior year reflecting strong renewal premium change in homeowners and other and higher auto new business premiums. Full year net written premium increased 2% to a record $17.4 billion.
In auto, the fourth quarter combined ratio was 89.4%, reflecting a strong underlying combined ratio and favorable net prior year development.
The underlying combined ratio of 92.2% improved just over 4 points compared to the prior quarter, driven by continued frequency, continued favorable frequency across coverages with sustained moderation and severity, partially offset by the impact of continued moderation in earned pricing.
This quarter's underlying combined ratio included a 3 point benefit related to the re-estimation of prior quarters in the current year. The full year auto combined ratio of 85.7% represents improvement of over 9 points compared to the prior year, as we experience favorability in both frequency and severity.
In homeowners and other, the fourth quarter combined ratio of 60.3%, improved by 7.5 points compared to the prior year quarter, primarily as a result of improvement in the underlying combined ratio and lower catastrophe losses.
The underlying combined ratio of 59.9% improved by 5.5 points compared to the prior year quarter, reflecting the impact of our actions to achieve target returns. The year over year favorability was primarily related to the benefit of property earned pricing, as well as favorability and non-catastrophe weather and non-weather losses.
Stepping back, the 2025 full year property combined ratio of 93% was a notable improvement compared to the prior year. This reflects our actions to manage exposures in high catastrophe risk geographies, along with favorable non-catastrophe weather losses.
Turning to production, our results reflect continued disciplined execution to position our diversified portfolio to deliver long-term profitable growth. In domestic auto, retention of 82% increased slightly from recent quarters.
Renewal premium change of 2.2% continued to moderate as expected and will continue to do so in 2026, reflecting our sustained profitability and our focus on generating growth. Auto new business premium was up year over year as new business momentum continued in states less impacted by our property actions.
In domestic homeowners and other retention of 84% remained relatively consistent with recent quarters. Renewal premium change remains strong at 16.7%, as we concluded our efforts to align replacement costs with insured values.
We continue to expect RPC to drop into the single-digits beginning in early reflecting improved profitability and values that have now largely aligned with replacement costs. Quarterly new business premium and policies enforced declined compared to the prior year.
These production results reflected the deliberate choices we've made to improve profitability and manage volatility in property. Over the past few years, we've executed a granular strategy to reposition our portfolio to optimize our risk return profile.
The results have been meaningful. We reduced property policies enforced by 10%, with most of that decrease coming from high cat geographies, reflecting disciplined risk selection and concentrated actions to manage volatility and reduce local market aggregations of exposure.
While these actions impacted auto policies in force, the impact was muted. As we grew auto in many of the markets less affected by our property actions. Demonstrating our ability to sustain a competitive position where portfolio economics remain favorable.
Overall, the net impact of our actions is shifting the portfolio back toward a better balance between auto and property. Looking ahead to 2026 as we wind down many of our actions in property, we're focused on maintaining this progress by deploying property capacity in support of writing package business.
The strength of our 2025 results reflects years of disciplined execution and strategic investment. Since the year in 2020, net written premiums grew $6 billion to $17.4 billion while we generated an average combined ratio of 98%.
Over that same period, our domestic auto book grew both in terms of [PIF] and premium. And in our homeowner's portfolio, our actions to address profitability, geographic distribution, and terms and conditions have meaningfully improved risk adjusted returns.
In addition, we continue to invest in and deploy strategic capabilities. As just one example, we're leveraging artificial intelligence to make our renewal underwriting process more effective and efficient. We start with a proprietary AI enabled predictive model that scores every account in the property portfolio.
Based on this score, accounts with the highest probable risk of loss are presented to underwriters for review. From there, our renewal underwriting platform leverages generative AI to consolidate data into summaries of relevant actionable information for our underwriters to evaluate.
With early results showing more than a 30% reduction in average handle time. The net result is that our underwriters focus their efforts on decisions most likely to improve profitability and do so more efficiently. To sum up, thanks to the continued diligent efforts of our team and with support from our distribution partners, personal insurance continues to deliver on a long track record of profitably growing our business over time.
Now I'll turn the call back over to Abby.
Abbe Goldstein - IR Contact Officer
Thanks, Michael. And we're ready to open up for Q&A.
Operator
(Operator Instructions).
Gregory Peters, Raymond James.
Gregory Peters - Analyst
Good morning, everyone, and as you said in your comments, you did have a great year, so congratulations. I wanted to-- I thank you for the commentary around the technology. You know I've been asking you about this off and on like others have, for a couple years now. In Dan's guidance for, the expense ratio, I think he said it's going to be flat in '26, 28.5% versus what it was in '25 versus the same in '24.
So I guess what I'm trying to reconcile is the emphasis on growing your strategic investments, you're harvesting efficiencies with these technology investments, just wondering when the structural shift in the expense ratio might materialize and maybe, I was looking at the responsible artificial intelligence framework section of your website.
Maybe you could talk about some of the regulatory and other considerations that might delay some of the expected benefits from your technology fund.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Greg, thanks for the question. I appreciate it. In terms of the expense, I mean, we give you a sort of a year outlook of where we'd like it to be, and that's not something that happens to us. That's something we manage, and we talk a lot about, trying to optimize operating leverage. So, in other words, we want the gains from the efficiencies that we're generating, and that just gives us a lot of flexibility in the way we run the business.
We can let it fall to the bottom line if we want through lower expense ratio. We can continue to invest it in other capabilities. Just gives us the flexibility to manage the business. And as I shared in my remarks, the extent that some of these productivity and efficiency benefits are in the claim organization, those come through loss adjustment expense in the loss ratio. Again, we've got the flexibility there to think about that as an operating leverage component, but just in terms of where those benefits are or where they might arise in the future.
In terms of the regulatory environment, we it's, from our perspective, it's constructive. We try to make sure that we're using the technology in ways that are thoughtful and careful and, frankly, we as a company and we through our trade association are on a regular basis working with policymakers to make sure that we're achieving, smart public policy and regulations as it comes to the development and implementation of technology.
Gregory Peters - Analyst
I guess and thanks for the answer, I guess related on the regulatory front, there are an increased example or more examples of regulators becoming more focused on the profitability of the insurance business and particularly the personalized business and. I'm just curious if you have a view on any regulatory pushback, you might be getting on the profit levels in your business and if you think there's anything, bigger issues at play that's going to spread throughout the country as it relates to that.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, Greg, we certainly understand the affordability issue and think it's an important one for all of us to be focused on and we are focused on it. Let me just put the profitability of our personal insurance business into some perspective. We had a good year in '25, we had a good year in 2024, but the two years prior to that, our combined ratio was over 100, and if you look at the last five years it was a 98, I think.
So that would be below our target returns. And so this really is a business that you need to look at and manage over a period of time. And I think when you think about personal insurance results over a period of time, I mean, certainly in our case you wouldn't say that we're over earning. So we are trying to get the right price on the risk and earn a fair return for helping customers manage their risk.
Operator
Ryan Tunis, Cantor Fitzgerald.
Ryan Tunis - Research Analyst
Hey, thanks, good morning. Alan, in your prepared remarks, I think you mentioned that in business insurance. Renewal premium change ex property was a little over 8%. I think that number was 9% last quarter. Just curious how much of that 1 point of deceleration is attributable to rate versus exposure.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, it's what we're looking for the exact breakout, Ryan. It's a little bit of both. Yeah, I mean, Ryan, if you look at the middle market webcast, you can see exposure was down. You can do the math between rate and RPC. It's not perfect math. So to Alan's point, a little bit of an exposure and a little bit of rate.
Ryan Tunis - Research Analyst
Got it. And then, I guess just on the property side. Clearly was a bit of a challenging year in in the large account space just from a trading standpoint just curious how you guys are thinking about. Overall rate adequacy of national property headed into 2026.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, Ryan, it's a challenging year. I mean, the pricing dynamic is what the pricing dynamic is, but to a very large degree, that's reflective of the profitability of that business. I mean, that business has been achieving, rate gains over a very long period of time, and it's gotten to a point where the profitability was strong. So we don't. Really look at a macro level and look at it and say it was challenging and appropriate.
It's not, you can certainly find examples of accounts, and we'll scratch our head and say, gee, we're surprised that got priced that way and honestly more than price, we're surprised sometimes with the terms and conditions that that we see given away in the marketplace that we're not willing to do. But, sort of writ large, we look at it and we say, it's not so, not so crazy when you think about where the returns are.
Operator
David Motemaden, Evercore.
David Motemaden - Analyst
Hey, thanks. Good morning, Dan. Just had a follow-up just on the capital return. So hear you loud and clear on the $1.8 billion that's expected in the first quarter, but just given what sounds like a change in terms of the just how you guys are managing the debt load, and what looks like, a billion dollars of excess at the holding company now before the Canada proceeds and think about the buybacks throughout the rest of this year outside of 1Q '27 just given the current growth environment.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Hey David, so I'd say not really. I mean we can't really sit here, at the very beginning of the year and give much guidance on what we think buybacks are going to look like in, the second, third, and fourth quarters of this year. So there's no change in our capital management strategy, and we made these comments, last quarter when we alerted you to the fact that we did expect in Q1 because we had, as you recognize, reached a point where we're probably carrying a little more.
No change in the overall capital management strategy and the rest of the year is going to be impacted by all the usual things that would impact buybacks. We do CAT losses with the growth environment.
And we're going to responsibly manage the capital, right? We're not looking to hoard capital. We're looking to hold the right amount, and when we have excess, it's not ours, and we're going to give it back to the shareholders.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
The only thing I'm going to add to that, David, is our first objective for every dollar of capital that we generate is to invest it back into the business.
David Motemaden - Analyst
Got it. No thanks. That makes sense, and then at slide 23 and the 7.8%, is in 2026, if I just sort of do rough math on the 2025 premium levels that implies, a little bit above $3.4 billion, $3.5 billion which is above. Where you guys have the retention at your, aggregate XOL. So could you help me understand a little better the moving pieces there, how much of a drag that might be on BI.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Sure, David, thanks for the question. So I guess I'll start with the second part of it and say, we don't expect no improvements in pricing in the reinsurance environment and a couple other things we're doing around the edges that, we don't think the year over year impact of season premium is going to be really importantly though, what you were getting to in terms of CAT load on a the thing you got to remember when you think about the attachment point of the treaty is the first $100 million of every event.
If we thought we were going to have 3.x million dollars billion dollars of CAT losses next quarter or anything over 3 hours, we said with this treaty historically this is really we're buying tail protection for the balance.
That's still true. Clearly with the $3 billion retention compared to a $4 billion retention, we're a lot closer in on the tail of possibly being able to hit that book. But if we looked at, if you look, for example, at if we had that treaty in 2025, we would not have attached that treaty.
Operator
Mike Zarinsky, BMO.
Mike Zarinsky - Analyst
Hi, good morning, a caller you gave on, technology initiatives to share what you, maybe roughly exposed or shrinkage to be on a percentage basis, this year versus maybe last year or so.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah Mikey, we gave you an example of a narrow view of that in our claim organization in our call centers. We're not going to get into projecting headcount beyond that, but what I would say is premium per employee is up thanks to some productivity and efficiency initiatives, and we expect premium per employee to continue to go up.
Mike Zarinsky - Analyst
Okay. Switching gears for my follow-up to, commercial lines, I think we can tease it out based on, the com tell us, and cap, what was the change in their thanks.
Gregory Toczydlowski - Executive Vice President, President - Business Insurance
Yeah Mike, good morning. But you know that would predominantly be the GL line and the umbrella, and in my prepared comments I shared with the umbrella head. What I didn't include was GL. GL Bank has been running in the mid-single-digits in terms of the renewal premium change. Those would be the two components outside of the comp.
Operator
[Katie Stocky, Autonomous Research].
Unidentified Participant_1
Yeah, thank you. Good morning, Alan. You mentioned in your prepared remarks that the strength seen in underlying underwriting this quarter is the momentum seeming to continue to slow down here. Keep those underlying results hold in 2026.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, good morning, Katie. So, Dan's underwriting income, in our prepared remarks, and you can see it in the slides in the webcast. We are a larger and more profitable company today than we have been historically, and thanks to investments that we've made and so on.
We are very confident in our initial levels, and we're very happy with the business that we're putting on the books. So when you combine those premium levels with, an underwriting income, and if you look at the, trajectory, you get a sense of we're confident it'll continue to be a strong foundation for strong results, in the years to come.
Unidentified Participant_1
And then as Follow-up, I think last year in the fourth quarter, the business insurance underlying loss specialty lines, I guess with the net this year that probably seems to be holding in fairly and let us know if there was any similar additions.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Katie it's Dan. So you know we did say, as you recall from last year, that we were including in. The a year loss pick for 2024, what we called sort of a load for uncertainty related to the casualty lines '25, and we did do that again in 2020 to get the question out of the way as we head into 2026. Our planned loss ratio for 2026 once again includes an uncertainty provision in the casual and the generally performed about as we expected. The business insurance workers' comp favorability has really been driven by driven by workers' comp, but long tail line still in the casualty space, a little bit of uncertainty, so we're going to stay prudent and stick with that low.
Operator
Meyer Shields, KBW.
Meyer Shields - Analyst
Much and good morning. I think it was probably for Dan. I know you talked about not having much of an overall margin impact from lowering the capacity reinsurance attachment point. Should there be any impact on a seasonal basis? In other words, is there any pressure on.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Yeah, I don't think so Meyer, again, because when we look at our terms of, what we're going to pay out for seated premium, given the pricing dynamic in the reinsurance space and again some other changes we made around the margins have much of an impact.
Meyer Shields - Analyst
Okay perfect thanks and just a question, are you comfortable growing the more CAT prone states policy counts in line with the overall book or are we still constraining growth?
Michael Klein - Executive Vice President, President - Personal Insurance
My prepared remarks about deploying property capacity attaining the progress that we've made, implies that certainly at most we would grow CAT prone states in line with the rest of the portfolio, but we do still have some spots where we'll be constrained. So I'd expect an aggregate the property PIF growth will continue to trail off, the growth trajectories of both lines should improve.
Operator
Alex Scott, Barclays.
Alex Scott - Equity Analyst
Hi, thanks for taking the question. First one is on, just earlier, how are you viewing the prospects for M&A relative to organic growth at this point? And I mean, the profitability seems fairly attractive, but the growth obviously a bit lower. So I'm just trying to gauge if your organic growth isn't quite as attractive to you. Could M&A be a way that you go.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
Alex, I'm going to give you the same answer I've given probably for 10 years. I'm sorry for, probably not going to be the satisfying answer you're looking for. But the answer to our, that question for us is we're always looking for M&A opportunities and you know we've got the capital and we've got the expertise to diligence the deals and find the deals and execute the deal, he's looking for attractive inorganic opportunities and, but I would have answered that question the same way, at any point in the last decade.
Alex Scott - Equity Analyst
Understood. I guess second one for you on error to be a wider range of outcomes again how that affects, the way that you go about pricing maybe across all your businesses, but I'd be particularly interested in personal auto.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
A couple of quarters ago when my view that we thought that the impact was going to be back and look at the transcripts and we shared a fair amount of commentary about how we got there. And at the time for lines that are potentially impacted, we did provide a little bit of, a little so far, hasn't even been the relative that we expected. Now, as the world changes, certainly that dynamic could change, but we feel like the provisions that we've made in the loss picks for potentially impacted lines are there to cover it.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line.
Of go ahead.
Unidentified Participant_2
Yeah, thanks. First one for Michael I'm just curious, Michael, the personal auto insurance space is getting increasingly more competitive, some new entrants in the agency space. Maybe you could talk a little enable, Travelers to actually maybe recoup some of the market share you've lost over the last couple of years in personal auto, given the competitive dynamics in that market.
Michael Klein - Executive Vice President, President - Personal Insurance
Yeah, thanks, Brian. I would start with, the marketplace is always competitive, and certainly is around competition in the IA space. The first thing I'd say about that is I think it's a great validation of our strategy to be largely an independent agent carrier for personal lines, and the value of choice and advice, in this type of a marketplace.
The second thing I would say is we've competed successfully in the independent agent channel for years. We remain confident in our ability to compete successfully in that channel, and I think, a handful of competitive advantages in the space, certain agents, our investments in digitization, again, I've been talking about this for the last several quarters, the value of our package value and our ability to deliver a balance sheet protect that we have in that space, and again, we're confident in our ability to compete going forward.
Daniel Frey - Chief Financial Officer, Executive Vice President
Yeah Brian, it's Dan. I just add one more comment in there on the auto space in particular. So but if you looked at the business now compared to what it was, say, five years ago, we're up. We're one of only a very small number of carriers. It's actually got a higher PIF count. Now than we did five years ago, and our view always again on growth is how do you think about growth over time, right? We're not really looking to influence a growth number in the next quarter or even necessarily the next year. What's the right balance of returns and are you sure that you're growing over time?
Unidentified Participant_2
Always welcome your thoughts on the tort environment and casualty trend and what you see here, going forward. Anything positive that's developing here that maybe, curves that kind of lost.
Alan Schnitzer - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer
It continues to be a very challenging environment, and I wish I could say that we saw improvement. It can a little bit. A little bit of a difficult tort environment and, certainly the impact of tort costs is in fact is impacting affordability for businesses and consumers and I think we're seeing that in some states. And so that's, potential positive. The other thing we are seeing more of is discussing, and that's also a very good thing. So, we are continuing to put our shoulder into it, and there's more work to do.
Operator
Thank you. That's all the time that we have for questions. I would now like to turn the conference back over to Ms. Abbe Goldstein for closing comments.
Abbe Goldstein - IR Contact Officer
Thanks everyone for as always, please feel free to follow-up with Investor Relations. Thanks everyone and have a good day.
Operator
Thank you for your participation, and you may now disconnect.