JetBlue Airways Corp (JBLU) 2013 Q2 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

  • Good morning, ladies and gentlemen.

  • Welcome to the JetBlue Airways second-quarter 2013 earnings conference call.

  • My name is Hope, and I will be your operator for today's call.

  • We have on the call today Dave Barger, JetBlue's CEO, and Mark Powers, JetBlue's CFO.

  • Also on the call for Q&A is Robin Hayes, JetBlue's Chief Commercial Officer.

  • At this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode.

  • Please note that this conference is being recorded.

  • As a reminder, this call includes forward-looking statements about future events.

  • Actual results may differ materially from those expressed in the forward-looking statements due to many factors and, therefore, investors should not place undue reliance on these statements.

  • For additional information concerning factors that could cause results to differ from the forward-looking statements, please refer to the Company's annual and periodic reports filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission.

  • This call also references non-GAAP results.

  • You can find the reconciliation of these non-GAAP results in JetBlue's earnings press release on the Investor Relations section of the Company's website at jetblue.com.

  • I will now turn the call over to Dave Barger.

  • Mr. Barger, you may begin.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Thank you very much, Hope.

  • Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us.

  • This morning we reported second-quarter net income of $36 million or $0.11 per diluted share, our 13th consecutive quarter of profitability.

  • Operating margin was 7.6%, a decrease of 2.6 points compared to last year.

  • Second-quarter results were below those of a year ago, driven primarily by continued maintenance cost pressures and a sluggish economic environment.

  • In addition, the timing of the Easter and Passover holidays had a significant impact on year-over-year unit revenue comparisons.

  • Given our strong leisure franchise in the northeast of Florida and the Caribbean, we estimate the shift of the Easter and Passover holidays from April last year into March this year reduced second-quarter year-over-year PRASM by approximately 2 points.

  • Despite this headwind, we generated record revenues, and held load factor relatively flat while growing capacity approximately 8%, demonstrating the underlying strength of our Business.

  • Throughout the quarter, we remained focused on our number-one priority -- running a safe, reliable airline.

  • In addition, we continued to remain focused on delivering excellent service to our customers through our industry-leading product and culture.

  • We believe our strong brand and differentiated product continue to generate a price premium versus our competitors in many of our key markets.

  • As a testament to the exceptional service provided by our crew members, we recently earned our 9th consecutive JD Power and Associates Award in Airline Customer Satisfaction among low-cost carriers.

  • I would like to congratulate our 15,000 crew members for this remarkable achievement, and thank them for their continued hard work during the quarter and running a safe, reliable operation.

  • Although the yield environment was somewhat sluggish during the quarter, jet fuel prices declined as we experienced a tighter correlation between revenue and fuel.

  • However, on a historical basis, fuel prices remain very high; thus, we have remained keenly focused on running an efficient operation.

  • Our crew members, again, do an excellent job operating in highly congested airspace in the northeast where we have nearly 80% of our operations.

  • As Mark will discuss in greater detail, maintenance costs continue to drive the majority of our second-quarter non-fuel unit cost inflation.

  • To that end, we are pleased to have recently finalized a flight-hour-based agreement with General Electric to service our E190 engines.

  • Moving forward, we believe this agreement will help us smooth out and better predict future related expense.

  • Cost discipline is a critical element of our success, particularly with respect to our network strategy in high-value geography.

  • As we successfully execute on our Boston growth strategy, and margins expand, we expect our growth rate in Boston to moderate over the next few years.

  • Similar to Boston, we are pleased with the margin improvement we are seeing in San Juan as we add capacity.

  • As we discussed in detail at our Analyst Day earlier this year, we are also excited about ROIC accretive opportunities in our focus city of Fort Lauderdale.

  • We have been very successful in Fort Lauderdale as we have grown our Latin American footprint.

  • South Florida's large population and diverse demographic have driven significant leisure and business traffic.

  • We believe there are many Latin American markets with tremendous growth potential currently underserved by other airlines.

  • Given the enplanement cost advantage of Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport over Miami International Airport, and our superior product offering, we believe we are positioned well to grow profitably in Fort Lauderdale, and improve returns over the long term.

  • Before closing, I would like to provide a brief update on a few exciting initiatives under way designed to help us improve ROIC by growing profitably, and achieving our goal to meet and exceed industry PRASM.

  • We believe long-term customer loyalty plays a key part in helping us achieve our goals.

  • Over the past several years, we've made a number of changes designed to enhance TrueBlue, our loyalty program.

  • Most recently, we announced that points earned by members never expire.

  • We believe our loyalty program has a potential to be a source of significant value, both from a core revenue and ancillary revenue perspective.

  • If a JetBlue customer who is not a member today becomes a TrueBlue member, their annual value to us, as measured by revenue, increases by about 2.5 times.

  • Today, only about one-third of our customers are TrueBlue members, so we are very excited about this opportunity.

  • Another area of significant focus for JetBlue has been improving unit revenue performance in our transcon network.

  • In the coming weeks, we plan to unveil more detail regarding our premium transcon product, which is scheduled to debut next year on specially configured Airbus A321 aircraft in our JFK to San Francisco and JFK/Los Angeles markets.

  • We believe this will be a best-in-class product offering that will revolutionize the transcon premium experience, and help us narrow the RASM gap versus our peers in these lucrative markets.

  • Finally, I'd like to provide an update on our plans to launch broadband inflight connectivity.

  • In partnership with ViaSat, LiveTV completed its first Ka-band installation on a JetBlue A320, and conducted the first flight in June.

  • We're currently awaiting Supplemental Type Certification from the FAA, and expect to proceed with fleet-wide installation soon thereafter.

  • In closing, we believe the third quarter is shaping up to be a strong quarter.

  • We have significant revenue opportunities in front of us this year.

  • Based on our current revenue outlook, we expect margins to improve in the second half of the year as we continue to execute our network strategy and contain costs.

  • We also plan to continue improving the balance sheet and make prudent investments in the Business.

  • We believe we can improve profitability by serving underserved customers through our competitive advantages -- our differentiated product and culture with a competitive cost structure, serving high-value geography.

  • At the same time, we remain committed to generating free cash flow and improving returns by at least 1 percentage point per year for the foreseeable future.

  • With that, I would like to turn the call over to Mark for a more detailed review of our financial results.

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • Thank you, Dave.

  • Good morning, everyone, and thank you again for joining us today.

  • This morning we reported second-quarter operating income of $102 million.

  • That's a decrease of $28 million compared to the second-quarter 2012.

  • Second-quarter year-over-year passenger unit revenues decreased by 3.3% on a capacity increase of 7.8%.

  • A soft yield environment contributed to a 1.3% decline in year-over-year fares.

  • The good news is that we were able to stimulate traffic as second-quarter load factors remained relatively flat year over year.

  • Year-over-year passenger unit revenue, or PRASM, fell by 9% in April, increased by 1% in May, and was relatively flat in June.

  • Our June PRASM was negatively impacted, as previously discussed, by a one-month -- one-time, rather, non-cash adjustment of approximately $5 million related to the change in expiration policy for TrueBlue points.

  • Although we were pleased with the performance of our network overall, as other carriers have noted in their own second-quarter calls, second-quarter demand environment was somewhat sluggish.

  • We continue to drive healthy volumes, but at lower yields compared to last year.

  • Our airline partnership strategy continued to deliver strong revenue growth during the quarter.

  • We recently announced our intent to expand our partnership agreement with Emirates to a bilateral codeshare, a significant milestone.

  • Today, we are also pleased to announce that we have evolved our one-way codeshare agreement with South African Airways into a two-way codeshare.

  • As of the end of the quarter, we had partnership agreements in place with 24 airlines around the world.

  • Ancillary revenue also continued to perform very, very well.

  • Second-quarter ancillary revenue per customer was up 4% versus last year to $21.

  • We continue to see growth in high-margin passenger-driven ancillary items such as Even More and TrueBlue.

  • Our Even More offering remains on track to generate approximately $165 million this year.

  • In addition, we recently increased our phone reservation fee, and modified our change fees to an innovative tier structure.

  • Our research shows that customers do not factor change fees into their purchase decisions.

  • For this reason, we believe we can raise change fees without negatively impacting our brand.

  • We expect total ancillary revenues in 2013 to increase about 15% year over year.

  • Moving to costs, quarterly operating expenses increased 7.5% year over year, or $86 million.

  • Fuel, of course, remains our largest expense, comprising nearly 40% of the total.

  • We continue to maintain a fuel hedge portfolio as a form of insurance.

  • In the second quarter, we hedged approximately 17% of our fuel consumption.

  • Additionally, Fixed Forward Price agreements, or FFPs, covered approximately 21% of our second-quarter consumption.

  • Including the impact of fuel hedging, FFPs and taxes, our fuel in the second quarter was $3.06.

  • For the third quarter, we've hedged approximately 30% of anticipated jet fuel requirements.

  • Additionally, FFPs cover approximately 14% of our projected fuel consumption for the quarter at an average price of $2.95.

  • The underlying details of our FFP and hedge positions as of July 26 are more specifically detailed in our investor update, which will be filed with the SEC later today.

  • Including the impact of hedges and taxes, we're estimating a third-quarter fuel price of $3.10 per gallon, and a full-year price of $3.13.

  • Excluding fuel and profit sharing, year-over-year second-quarter unit costs increased by 3.3%.

  • This is in -- at the lower end of our guidance for the quarter.

  • The primary driver of the year-over-year increase was, as Dave mentioned, maintenance expense.

  • As discussed in some detail on our last earnings call, we decided to accelerate performance restorations on our E190 engines, resulting in higher maintenance expense during the first half of this year.

  • These engine restorations were also intended to help address several non-core peripheral engine issues, so as to improve operational reliability and extend time on wing.

  • These actions are already having their intended positive impact on operational reliability.

  • We expect year-over-year maintenance cost growth to lessen in the second half of the year.

  • Again, as Dave noted, we recently signed a flight-hour agreement with General Electric for engine maintenance on our E190 fleet, which is intended to smooth out future maintenance expense.

  • Other operating expense increased more than expected during the quarter due to two items.

  • First, recall we had expected a roughly $8-million benefit in other operating expenses in the second quarter related to the sale of LiveTV's ground spectrum license, which we wrote down in the third quarter of 2010.

  • After additional charges in connection with the sale and disposition of that license, the net gain we recorded in other operating expense was $3 million.

  • Second, we recorded a liability in other operating expense during the quarter related to the pilot pay dispute we previously disclosed.

  • The damages phase of this proceeding recently began.

  • The claimants have not yet specified the amount of damages they are seeking, and there are many variables still to be determined by the arbitrator.

  • We recorded a $3-million liability in other operating expenses during the second quarter, which represents our current estimate of potential damages based on our assessment of the arbitrator's ruling, and subject to any [defenses].

  • Of course, any final judgment could materially differ.

  • Moving below the line, non-operating expenses were roughly $4 million higher than we had anticipated due to two items.

  • One, we recorded a $2-million write-off related to refinancing of our hangar and training facility in Orlando.

  • And two, we had a non-cash fuel hedging ineffectiveness loss of approximately $2 million.

  • Moving to the balance sheet, we ended the second quarter with unrestricted cash and short-term investments of approximately $867 million, or 17% of trailing 12-months revenue.

  • Not included in this cash balance is our line of credit with Morgan Stanley for $200 million and our revolving credit facility of $350 million.

  • During the second quarter, we made debt and capital lease payments of approximately $145 million.

  • Third-quarter scheduled principal payments from debt and capital leases are expected to be $70 million, and roughly $185 million for the fourth quarter, both very, very manageable.

  • With strong cash from operations, and manageable capital commitments and debt maturities, for the remainder of the year we believe JetBlue is positioned to maintain strong liquidity throughout the rest of 2013, and generate positive free cash flow.

  • We expect to end the year with a cash as a percentage of trailing 12-months revenue of roughly 15%.

  • Turning to capital expenditures and the fleet, JetBlue ended the quarter with 186 aircraft, including 127 A320s, 59 E190s.

  • For the remainder of 2013, we expect to take delivery of three A320s, four A321s, and one E190.

  • We estimate third-quarter capital expenditures of about $95 million -- $20 million for aircraft and $75 million for non-aircraft-related expenses.

  • We estimate full-year CapEx of approximately $645 million, of which $65 million relates to LiveTV.

  • As to capacity, we expect to increase third-quarter ASMs between 3.5% and 5.5% year over year.

  • We expect 2013 full-year ASMs to increase between 5.5% and 7.5% year over year.

  • This is slightly lower than our previous guidance, reflecting targeted capacity cuts during shoulder travel periods in the third and fourth quarters.

  • As to revenue, while we experienced some yield softness during the second quarter, we were encouraged by recent demand trends, and are seeing for -- that we are seeing for the peak summer travel season, typically JetBlue's strongest period of the year.

  • Both yields and load factor are up year over year.

  • We currently expect July PRASM to increase approximately 4%.

  • While, of course, we have limited visibility, August is also shaping up similar to July.

  • As to the CASM work cost outlook, we expect third-quarter CASM excluding fuel and profit sharing to be up between 3% and 5%.

  • For the full-year 2013, we are forecasting CASM, again, excluding fuel and profit sharing, to be up between 2.5% and 4.5% versus 2012.

  • This is slightly higher than previous guidance due to, in large part, a reduction in ASMs, as previously mentioned, resulting from our third- and fourth-quarter capacity cuts.

  • We believe maintenance unit cost will rise approximately 20% for the full year, accounting for roughly two-thirds of the full-year CASM ex-fuel profit sharing increase.

  • We project CASM, [all in], will be up between 1% and 3% for the third quarter, and up between 0.5% and 1.5% for the full year.

  • In closing, I'd like to thank our customers and investors for their business and support, and our crew members for their hard work in running a safe operation and delivering outstanding customer service.

  • Terrific work on JD Power number nine.

  • And with that, we are happy to take your questions.

  • Operator

  • Thank you.

  • We will now begin the question-and-answer session.

  • (Operator Instructions)

  • John Godyn, Morgan Stanley.

  • John Godyn - Analyst

  • Dave, you've mentioned this improving ROIC target a few times now.

  • I was hoping you could just give us a sense for maybe the range around it.

  • What drives -- what would drive outperformance or underperformance versus that target outside of macro?

  • What's on your mind as key drivers there over the next few years?

  • Thanks.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Sure, John.

  • That's -- thanks.

  • And again, as we highlighted at Analyst Day on both calls this year, we're still, as we're marching forward, our goal is to improve ROIC by at least 1 point on a year-over-year basis as we go into the future.

  • It's quite simple.

  • As we take a look at certainly what we've utilized with the balance sheet in the past but also revenue and cost, I mean, as we look at, again, expanding those margins from a revenue perspective, core revenue, the ancillary revenue piece of it as well, the cost side of the house, and again, it's no surprise with the maintenance burden that we had in the first half of this year.

  • I felt very good about what's in place with the power-by-the-hour agreement with General Electric, and certainly using the balance sheet prudently, as well.

  • So that's how we're looking at running the business, John.

  • And again, nothing has changed.

  • Appreciate the question.

  • Operator

  • David Fintzen of Barclays.

  • David Fintzen - Analyst

  • A question, I guess for Dave or Robin.

  • Just the RASM trends that you're seeing on some of these comments around economic softness, I'm just curious if any geographies stand out.

  • I'm thinking Transcon with some of the competitive capacity coming in and Virgin indirectly coming in to Newark.

  • So I'm just curious, within the network, are you seeing some divergence in areas?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • Hi, David.

  • I'll take that.

  • It's Robin.

  • No, I mean I think when we look back at the quarter, I think the revenue story was very much defined by April, where I think we saw a much bigger Easter and Passover shift throughout the network.

  • So, we had a very strong March.

  • Conversely, April was a month where we had significant negative RASM.

  • May and June, I would -- we were up flat to low single digits.

  • June was a little bit masked with the TrueBlue accounting adjustment of $5 million.

  • Otherwise, I think we would have hit 1% and that wasn't in our Q2 guidance.

  • Originally, we thought that was going to happen in Q3.

  • I described overall demand in quarter two as okay, sluggish, certainly not as strong as going into the quarter.

  • But when I then look ahead into Quarter Three, I'm very pleased with the summer.

  • We're adding about 7% capacity into the July and August months.

  • We're seeing close to mid-single digits in terms of rapid growth.

  • Areas that are performing really well, Latin America, the Caribbean is performing strongly.

  • Very pleased with what we're seeing on Florida, particularly out of New York.

  • The some of the -- if you look at Boston and some of the trends come out of Boston, we're seeing additional capacity come in.

  • So, that's been a little bit more challenging.

  • But again, even as we look into the summer, we're seeing some nice traction there.

  • And then September, though we're not guiding to September, we are seeing -- we will, I think, benefit from very modest increases in capacity.

  • David Fintzen - Analyst

  • Right.

  • And just a follow-up on that, on some of your shoulder capacity adjustments, is that something that you can think -- we can start to carry forward into '14 as maybe a more tactical approach to the shoulder periods?

  • Or is that just something as you were getting into September, you just want to start to phase in for this year?

  • How should we think about that going forward?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • Sure.

  • Thanks, David.

  • We've always made those adjustments, I mean, in previous years, we tended to add a little bit of capacity as we got into the year.

  • This year, as we got into quarter two, we looked at that and said there is an opportunity, I think, to trim.

  • I see that as natural power of the pruning.

  • If you look at that -- if you look back over the last three years, we've actually fully added more capacity into September as any other month as we depeaked the airline.

  • So, we look at September as we've done a lot of work to build capacity in September and flatten the network.

  • So, not necessarily looking to build September as aggressively as we have done in previous years.

  • But again, if you go back to the original capacity guidance we gave at right at the outset of the year, we're now really just falling back to what we had said at the beginning.

  • But I wouldn't read anything into 2014 other than we have the ability to improve and tweak our network based on what we see as you go into a year.

  • Operator

  • Michael Linenberg, Deutsche Bank.

  • Michael Linenberg - Analyst

  • Just -- two questions here.

  • I just want to go back on -- back when you guys reported the December quarter results, when you gave the 2013 guidance.

  • Your capacity guidance at the time was 5.5% to 7.5%, and I know you bumped it up, and now you're bumping it back.

  • But at that point, the CASM ex-fuel guidance was a bit lower for 2013.

  • I think it was 1% to 3%, so we're back to the same capacity growth level, but now it looks like it's about 150 basis points worse.

  • I just -- I didn't know if that was all because of the maintenance or all because of the engines on the 190.

  • I mean, is there something else that's driving the cost pressures?

  • What else may be driving that?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • That's it.

  • You broke it there.

  • It's -- it was the maintenance.

  • As you know, when we entered into this year, we were maintaining a lower year-over-year maintenance profile.

  • As the events of the first quarter transpired, it became very, very clear, as I mentioned, that we needed to get ahead proactively of the E190 CF34 maintenance.

  • And that's it.

  • Michael Linenberg - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • Okay.

  • That's good.

  • That's helpful.

  • And then just my second question, I want to go back, Dave, on the opening remarks.

  • You talked about -- you mentioned margins expanding in Boston and then seeing margin improvement in San Juan.

  • I wasn't -- I don't know if that was specific to the June quarter, but within the context of your overall margins being down close to 250 basis points, if we saw expansion in Boston and maybe the Caribbean, was New York under pressure?

  • I mean, where was the shortfall in the quarter on profitability?

  • Was it increased competition in Transcons, or maybe another part of your network?

  • What may have been lagging relative to Boston and the Caribbean?

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Sure, Mike.

  • Thanks.

  • My comments, by the way, on both of those focus cities are longer term, if you will, over the course of the year and as we're looking into the future.

  • But when you get into the first half this year, listen, the margin degradation that we experienced in the second quarter, as a team, we're disappointed with that margin degradation.

  • And when you start to take a look at -- for 14 years, we understand the Easter/Passover shift, that's obviously a piece of it.

  • We did have a more sluggish economic backdrop, I think, in terms of travel that others saw, as well.

  • And then it's -- if I may, when we think about even the first half of the year.

  • I'm not throwing the Sandy card but there's still impact overhang from hurricane that was in our backyard in the August timeframe, and that carried into the February/President's weekend.

  • People are still just moving back into their houses in the New York metropolitan area, as we all know.

  • So, as we look at specific to Boston though and then very similar with San Juan, the investments in Boston, just last week, we opened our 49th non-stop market out of Boston Logan airport, the most prolific service ever that Boston has experienced in terms of non-stop seats.

  • That was to Houston Hobby Airport right on the back side of Philadelphia.

  • This investment that we're seeing there drives relevance in Boston as we look at margin expansions in our core business very, very positive.

  • Likewise down in San Juan, it's -- again, Boston, no secret.

  • We're looking at Boston, 150, as an internal goal, flights per day.

  • San Juan, as we're moving intoTerminal A, that relevance, especially the investments that we've made as we are lapping same-store sales on a year-over-year basis, very, very positive.

  • And so, there's been incursion in the Caribbean.

  • But I'll tell you what, our focus in San Juan, Mike, we're very, very pleased with what that means into the future for margin expansion out of that focus city.

  • Operator

  • Savi Syth, Raymond James.

  • Savi Syth - Analyst

  • Just on your expansion out of Fort Lauderdale, I was wondering if you could -- what is -- how much of your growth is going to be driven by growing out of Fort Lauderdale, and just contrast how you built out Boston with how you might grow out of Fort Lauderdale?

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Good morning Savi.

  • It's -- just, If I may and I will tee Robin up for additional color.

  • I think what's really important to also just provide some visibility.

  • The investment that's taking place at Fort Lauderdale/Hollywood International Airport, I'll tell you what, there's not a lot of investment around the country that can really outpace what's happening at that airport.

  • It's $2 billion that Broward County is investing in that airport.

  • It's a second runway.

  • Now where else is a real runway?

  • It was a shorter runway.

  • So when you think about commercial air operations.

  • The work that's taking place -- over a railroad track.

  • This is not easy stuff that's taking place down there.

  • The landside improvements, including the terminals, the expansion in the terminals, our a strategic move over to Terminal 3 adjacent to Terminal 4 in that geography, the Federal inspection sites.

  • I just want to add that backdrop when you think about the demographic in that area in the investment that's taking place.

  • And we really want to say thank you to Kent George and the people down at Broward County for that investment.

  • Robin, a little color in terms of Lauderdale, first, as I said, Boston?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • Sure.

  • I think a couple of differences between the investment curve in Boston and Fort Lauderdale.

  • I mean, as we said before, those are the two markets that we continue to prioritize for growth.

  • So, if look at our network, where our network growth is, it's really out of those two markets.

  • The rest of the network is either flat or close to flat.

  • When we think about the characteristics and differences between those two markets, first of all, Fort Lauderdale was already much bigger and more mature part of our network when we made this decision to accelerate the growth.

  • So, it started from a point of greater maturity than profitability than Boston did when we started.

  • And secondly, if we look at the markets that we are ramping up and growing out of Fort Lauderdale, a lot of it is touching Latin America and the Caribbean, which are markets that have historically and you heard us say this before, ramp up much more quickly than Boston.

  • So, when we look at Boston, San Juan, and Fort Lauderdale, all of which have been three focus cities that we have invested the most in the last three years, Boston was the greatest challenge just because when we started growing it into the business travel market, we knew those were markets that take up longer to ramp up.

  • So we look at Fort Lauderdale and we don't see anything like the investment challenge that we saw in Boston.

  • In fact, in the '09, '10 period, we don't believe that the investment at Fort Lauderdale would be anything like that.

  • Savi Syth - Analyst

  • Got it.

  • And just, if I may, follow up on your comment about that pilot expense that you took.

  • Is that just a retroactive impact?

  • Or is there going to be an impact to the forward pilot costs from that arbitration?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • If I -- can I give you a little bit of color, Savi, on that as a little bit of context?

  • Savi Syth - Analyst

  • Sure.

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • We have disclosed in our SEC filings that the arbitration relates to an interpretation of the pilot employment agreement.

  • Specifically in '07, when we issued across the board market raises to our pilots and we gave some pilots, specifically the E190 first officers, a raise of approximately 25 -- 27% to bring them to a peer competitive salary.

  • The gist of this arbitration is the other pilots who did not receive the same amount of raise claimed that they were entitled to the same percentage increase.

  • We are just now starting the damages phase.

  • It's really too soon to say what this number is going -- the calculation is very complex, and there's a lot of variables involved here.

  • By the way, the claimants have not yet articulated damages that they are seeking.

  • Given the individualized nature of each pilot's compensation, we believe there's a lot of variables that remain to be determined, including the size of the group with a valid claim and what elements of pay could be included in any damages, if any.

  • So it really, really is quite soon to give any more guidance on the impact of when and how much.

  • We could actually be having the same conversation next year.

  • Again, I think that we have recorded, as I noted in my remarks, $3 million in other operating expenses which represents our current estimate of potential damages.

  • It's arbitration.

  • The outcome is very uncertain.

  • Savi Syth - Analyst

  • All right.

  • Thanks so much.

  • If I may just ask, so how do you guys come up with the $3 million?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • We actually applied the rigor of ASC 450, which, as you know, from -- is a fairly rigorous process.

  • Operator

  • Duane Pfennigwerth, Evercore.

  • Duane Pfennigwerth - Analyst

  • Can you talk a little bit about the return on your investment in slots out of LaGuardia and DCA?

  • By our math, half of the markets that passed the one-year mark that you talked about of market maturity were out of these markets.

  • Are you seeing the benefit from maturation that you expected?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • Hi, Duane.

  • Sorry, I turned the mic off when I should have been turning it on, but that's not because I didn't want to speak to you.

  • Good morning.

  • No, we're very pleased with what we are seeing.

  • Certainly the maturation in DCA was aided by our decision to reallocate our Florida flying from Dallas into DCA, so we already had a presence in the area.

  • And the LaGuardia/Florida market have always performed well.

  • We continue to outperform our competitors from a routing point of view from the New York metro area to most of the markets that we fly to Florida.

  • We've been able to continue that and certainly expanded portfolio slots at LaGuardia has also helped that.

  • Duane Pfennigwerth - Analyst

  • Okay.

  • And then I just want to ask about Seattle/Anchorage as well.

  • Did serving that market help or hurt your stated desire to increase returns for the airline this quarter?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • No, it absolutely helped it because we had a -- as I explained before, we had an asset in Seattle, an aircraft that really was in effectively, just a night stopping there.

  • And instead of just having an asset sitting on the ground and not producing any returns, we actually created a roundtrip to a market where fares are historically be very high; the returns are not good.

  • It's a seasonal service.

  • So when we look at this -- the revenue that, that market generates versus the cost of adding that capacity given that the aircraft was there, so it really is just fuel marginal cost of carriage and crew costs, very, very happy with it.

  • Operator

  • Jamie Baker, JPMorgan.

  • Jamie Baker - Analyst

  • It's a little unusual to see capacity and CASM both rising simultaneously, particularly for a more mature airline.

  • And of course, I'm sensitive to some of the maintenance issues and seniority pressures, as well.

  • But I guess it still calls into question whether you're really achieving many economies of scale.

  • I remember ValuJet, managers had to build their own desks.

  • You go to visit Ryanair and you need sunglasses in the office, because there are no blinds in the windows.

  • I realize those airline business plans are somewhat different than yours.

  • I just don't understand why there's so much cost creepage at JetBlue and here's the sensitive issue, do you need to rethink the no furlough policy?

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Jamie, it's -- thanks.

  • By the way, it's -- as we look at that as well, as we're adding aircraft, what's happening with the -- with our CASM trend.

  • By the way, it's not just the ex-fuel and the profit sharing CASM, but the all-in CASM.

  • We're just so hyper-focused on things like Sharklets and on the A320 fleet, the retrofit.

  • But I mean specific to no furlough, absolutely not.

  • I mean, that's -- this is part of our success over the course of 14 years.

  • When we think about the direct relationship, our model and the importance of that model, and people will try to work into what's the cost of that, and what do you gain as a result of it.

  • But there is not one discussion that's taken place as a result of what's happening with our CASM creep when we look at the no furlough policy period.

  • And again, it's -- I just can't tell you how important the direct relationship is also in -- when we talk about even things like Net Promoter Score, what that means to RASM and J.D. Power nine years in a row, some people will say, what's the benefit of it?

  • The benefit is attracting that higher yielding, loyal customer long term.

  • So no move at all on no furlough.

  • Operator

  • Hunter Keay, Wolfe Research.

  • Jared Shojaian - Analyst

  • Hi, this is actually Jared Shojaian for Hunter.

  • Good morning, everybody.

  • Dave, you talked a little bit about how your product and your brand is helping you drive a price premium.

  • I know in the past you've talked about how Net Promoter Score has a positive correlation with RASM.

  • So I get that.

  • But have you seen any evidence that shows Net Promoter Score is also correlated with ROIC?

  • Because if I just look at some the other airlines, Allegiant and Spirit, they generally have a lot of customer complaints, so presumably they have a lower NPS score, yet they also do the highest ROIC in the industry.

  • So I guess that's the question.

  • Have you seen any evidence that higher NPS also leads to higher ROIC not just RASM?

  • Thanks.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Sure.

  • Thanks, Jared.

  • It's -- I think our -- listen, the headline for us is there are room for multiple models in the Airline business.

  • And when we started flying in New York back in 2000, we never decided -- we weren't going to be the next ValuJet.

  • We weren't the next, if you will, super discount carrier.

  • So as you mentioned other brands and their ROIC metrics, there is plenty of room for brands like that.

  • On the other end of the spectrum when we think about the network carriers, by the way, all of the product of what's happened with bankruptcies and mergers, they've got a different model, right, in terms of whatever the math is, right, 17% of the customers drive 49% of the revenue or whatever the math is.

  • So what we are seeing as a younger brand also, into our 14th year, this middle space, this sweet spot that we talked about at Analyst Day, you bet.

  • I mean, when we look at our independence and our successful growth as a young Company, we're still purchasing our aircraft.

  • We're still acquiring our network.

  • And that's always going to have an impact on return on invested capital.

  • We're not leasing a used aircraft out in the marketplace, as an example.

  • It's a -- when we see the product, the ability to take Boston to the largest size that Logan Airport has ever seen for one carrier is unprecedented.

  • What we've seen in the New York metro, as the five airports that we fly to here today, is unprecedented.

  • When we see the loyalty that we see between the Northeast and Florida as the largest carrier, unprecedented.

  • Airlines in the past, the ability to go into markets like San Juan, Puerto Rico, where people would say it's all leisure, it's all discretionary.

  • And as we're growing profitably in that part of the world, unprecedented.

  • I'll close with this, Jared.

  • The reason we're putting in the premium product on the transcons into those big markets is we know that from an NPS perspective, we are below our peers when it comes to a -- it's a RASM disadvantage.

  • So, we know we're missing out on those customers.

  • We also know that because we don't have Wi-Fi in the aircraft, we're missing out on those customers.

  • It's the number one squawk that we get for those customers who are road warriors that fly us all the time out of, say, Boston and New York.

  • So, you bet there's a correlation and I think, closing, there's room for more than two models in the industry landscape.

  • And I think that we're proving that.

  • Jared Shojaian - Analyst

  • Great.

  • Thanks for that color, Dave.

  • Appreciate it.

  • And then, Mark, just one last one for you.

  • You mentioned in your prepared remarks that from the internal analysis, you believe you're able to increase change fees without hurting the brand.

  • Can you just help us understand what goes into that analysis?

  • I'm curious why that would differ from, say, charging for first checked bag.

  • Thanks.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • I'll defer that, if you don't mind, to Robin Hayes.

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • Sure.

  • I'll take that.

  • In terms of change fees, we don't believe that change fees are material to the decision to purchase a ticket.

  • So when we research our customers, the size of a change fee or the rules around a change fee are featured pretty low.

  • So we've always taken a, from a per commercial perspective, if you want change fees that we want to be competitive with the majority of the market.

  • When -- what Mark was referring to is when we made the recent restructuring of our change fees a couple of months ago, we actually took the advantage of more than 60 days out, actually lowering the change fee from $100 to $75, and then within a 60-day period, again subject to where the fare was, but for most customers, increasing it from $100 to $150.

  • We believe that is a reasonable thing to do, because customers who are changing early, it's much easier for us to sell that -- we sell that seat and we sell that inventory.

  • So actually, it makes sense for customers and it makes sense for us, coupled with the fact that we don't overbook, as well.

  • So it's important that we don't have that as a lever that some of the other airlines have.

  • So change fees, why change fee didn't apply on the first bag?

  • Because first bag is very material in a customer's decision to book.

  • We see the majority of our customers now pricing a decision around the first bag into the fare they pay.

  • That is why markets like New York and Florida, we significantly out-RASM some of our competitors who do have a first bag fee because in essence, we're capturing it in the fare.

  • We believe that, in that way, the first bag argument isn't necessarily purely -- necessarily accretive.

  • The combination of getting in the fare and some of the operational benefits that go with not having a first bag fee.

  • I hope that answers the question.

  • Operator

  • Dan McKenzie, Buckingham Research.

  • Dan McKenzie - Analyst

  • Couple of quick questions here.

  • My first question is just really house cleaning.

  • Regarding the fleet-wide installation of broadband, will the cost be expensed as incurred or capitalized?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • It will probably be capitalized.

  • And it can't be capitalized fast enough.

  • We can't wait for this product to get out here.

  • Dan McKenzie - Analyst

  • Okay, good.

  • And then secondly, I wonder if you can talk a little bit more about Emirates.

  • Where are we at in the DOT review, and if approved, what's the ramp-up period?

  • And then, just in general, what are your expectations?

  • And are there plans to convert other partners to do a two-way codeshare relationships as well?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • The question about Emirates, we're still in the DOT review period, Dan.

  • We expect to get that approval pretty in the near term.

  • So fingers crossed.

  • And then the ramp up is going to be pretty quickly done after that.

  • I mean, we are ready to go.

  • And then, the office is announcing the second one today with South African Airways two-way code.

  • And again, where we see a sizable benefit of moving from one to two-way code that can [jumpsize] some of the additional complexity that goes with it from a JetBlue perspective, one way versus two-way, then absolutely we'll continue to add partners.

  • Operator

  • Glenn Engel, Bank of America.

  • Glenn Engel - Analyst

  • Does your guidance include any pay increase yet for the pilots?

  • I thought you felt that your pilots were low versus others.

  • And two on the cost side, again, it's been several years where the cost continued to grow faster than the industry.

  • When do you expect your costs to start doing better relative to the industry?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • With respect to wages, pilot wages in particular, again, as you know, we intend to be competitive so that we can attract and retain the best pilots.

  • I think as we may have discussed in prior calls and conferences, the whole assessment of wages is probably something that will be a very ripe conversation in 2014.

  • And part of the discussion, of course, is probably, it's not just W2 to W2, as we look at other airlines.

  • So, it's going to be a very robust and healthy conversation with our Pilot Values Committees and individual pilots.

  • So, no, our guidance does not include any of that adjustment through the end of this year.

  • Glenn Engel - Analyst

  • And on the cost side in general?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • On the cost side in general, there's a lot of really interesting things going on apart from the wages side of it, moving the entire, I think, maintenance platform to a flight hour-type of basis.

  • So, not only are we going to have more predictable costs, but certainly, you won't see a lot of repeat of the events that you saw this year.

  • We have obviously engines on the E190, but there's a lot of component work in the cells and that sort of thing on the balance of the E190 and some portions of the A320s that we want to include in the flight hour platform.

  • Fourth quarter of this year we start the delivery of what I think is really going to be a very, very fundamental CASM driver and that is the A321.

  • I'm extremely excited about that.

  • We have actually all eight airbuses being delivered here after, include Sharklets and we continue to work diligently with Airbus on a transaction that would provide us the ability to retrofit all of our A320s with Sharklets.

  • And that is every bit, particularly, on range routes a 3% gas, good guy.

  • And then as we start to get closer to 18%, the transformational thing on fleet in particular is the advent of the neo, which is probably every bit of 14 --

  • Glenn Engel - Analyst

  • I guess where I'm trying to come from really is if I look in the first half your margins were down a 2 points, and the industry's were up 1.5 point.

  • Your -- you touched on it earlier, your PRASM was up less than the industry because you were growing so quickly, but your CASM was up more than the industry.

  • When do you think we can start seeing reversal of that where your CASM starts -- the growth starts to leading to CASM doing somewhat better than the industry and the PRASM starts -- stops underperforming the industry?

  • Mark Powers - CFO

  • As we build our five-year model, we are building precisely for that with caveat pilot wage issues.

  • And as we are truly building our five-year model, that is exactly what we're building.

  • I would Again repeat Dave's comment, which is that the first half March in contraction, particularly as we look at the other airlines, this quarter is highly disappointing.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • If I may, too.

  • Glenn, just a couple of thoughts here, right, because it was asked earlier in the call, as well, regarding cost create, right, you, Jamie, both and others, right.

  • I have highlighted this at Analyst Day, and, whether they are investors or potential investors, and there's nobody at this Company that talks about this issue more than Mark Powers.

  • And as we talk about as we are growing and as we're becoming more efficient, your last question, the above the line of the PRASM.

  • As I look at A4A Industry performance and how we're doing it with a simplified model, and the ability to really be rewarded with the investments that we've made and we continue to make in Boston and in places like Kennedy Airport as we're building out our own terminal.

  • The [OIC] question on the first part of call with our own cash as opposed to the port's cash.

  • As you start taking a look at down into Florida, Fort Lauderdale 100.

  • That relevance, what's happening in San Juan, The Long Beach Terminal, the premium product.

  • Lots of opportunities to really harvest not only core revenue, but I think there's some real exciting items and ancillary revenue.

  • As we go below the line from a cost perspective, it's a -- there is -- as we look at the ability to use automation in our SOC, we have that project well underway.

  • Whether it's how we dispatch, whether it's how we crew, whether it's how we service recover, I'll tell you, I don't know how many days we lived in ground delay programs or ground stops over the last 90 days in New York.

  • But we have to be better than others in terms of how we navigate this airspace.

  • And I believe that we are.

  • When I take a look at what's happening with RNAB and RNP, and by the way, things like airport not of the future but of today, the ability to use technology to streamline the airport environment and bend that cost curve.

  • Listen, we get it and we know that there is -- this is really probably the one challenge that we have to take to hit us or take in ASMs and let's continue to bend that cost curve and the team is focused on it, Glenn.

  • Operator

  • Bob McAdoo, Imperial Capital.

  • Bob McAdoo - Analyst

  • I signed on a little late, so you may have already covered it.

  • But can you tell us what the next steps are in the timing and status to whatever of the whole inflight Wi-Fi project?

  • I know it's an important piece of what you need to get done.

  • I'm just trying to figure out how long, where are you, and how long is that going to take and --?

  • Robin Hayes - Chief Commercial Officer

  • I will take that, Bob.

  • It's Robin, and good morning.

  • By the way, Dan, a slight correction to an answer I gave you earlier.

  • I said that we hadn't received Emirates approval from the DOT.

  • We actually received that on the 24th of July.

  • So my apologies.

  • So we are now obviously able to move.

  • We are still waiting for UAE and Italian Authorities approval.

  • So, my apologies for giving an incorrect answer on that

  • In terms of Wi-Fi, we're very excited.

  • The flight testing went very well.

  • We're currently waiting for a Supplemental Type Certificate to be granted by the FAA.

  • That application was put in in early July and it's normally a 30-day review cycle.

  • Once we have that, that's a very, very important milestone in this program.

  • It's our intent then to fly three aircraft round for a 90-day period to just further test and refine the system.

  • And once everything -- once we are reassured that those tests are done and everything is working as it should, we will then move to a fairly significant rollout across the initiative of the A320 fleet and then the 190 fleet.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • And if I may as well.

  • Bob, thanks for that question as well because as we add more color on to Flight Five, really Robin and the LiveTV team working with ViaSat.

  • We were on that aircraft on the ground just a couple of weeks ago and utilizing the on-ground experience, which is efficient compared to the in-air experience.

  • It's really exciting when we look at the competitive landscape.

  • And hopefully, we'll have an opportunity for analysts and also investors to experience it, right?

  • As we get into the September time frame and we've got the airplanes.

  • Hopefully, we are through the STC process and experience it, and come up and try to really, really ping this thing hard as customers are going to do.

  • They're expecting that.

  • I'll tell you what, it's well worth the wait, we believe, in terms of what's happening with the broadband experience.

  • I really appreciate the question, Bob.

  • Bob McAdoo - Analyst

  • So, should we think mid-next year, it will be half done?

  • Mostly done?

  • If everything goes according to Hoyle.

  • What's -- how quickly can we start to see that, you think?

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • It's the three aircraft later this year, but I think it's -- and again, it's not as we've really given a whole lot of color in the 2014 but the 320 fleets going to go through first.

  • The Embraer fleet right now will follow.

  • But I think what we're going to see is maybe an opportunity to even try to advance out to the left.

  • And so listen, there's a -- we're not going to let a lot of grass grow under this.

  • I mean, it's -- the installation and hopefully with what we're doing with the 320 fleet simultaneously will be installing the Sharklets on a retrofit basis under the 320s, as well so we can be really efficient in terms of that modeling.

  • But again, later this year, we'll have more color and certainly as we close the year and give color on 2014.

  • Operator

  • Mr. Barger, we have no further questions at this time.

  • Dave Barger - CEO

  • Great.

  • Hope that if I may, just thank you so much for all of the analysts and others joining us this morning for our second quarter call.

  • I would like to close this call on behalf of the JetBlue leadership team to thank our front line crew members, 15,000 strong.

  • J.D. Power, nine years in a row, simply unprecedented.

  • And doing that in the most congested airspace, not just in the United States, but the world.

  • Really, so hats off to our crew members.

  • We look forward to talking to all of you as we close the third quarter in the October time frame.

  • Thank you.

  • Have a great day.

  • Operator

  • Thank you, ladies and gentlemen.

  • This concludes today's conference.

  • Thank you for participating.

  • You may now disconnect.