使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good morning. My name is Matthew, and I will be your conference operator today. At this time, I would like to welcome everyone to the Canadian Pacific fourth-quarter 2011 conference call. All lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background noise. After the speakers' remarks, there will be a question-and-answer session. (Operator Instructions).
Thank you. Ms. Weiss, you may begin your conference.
Janet Weiss - IR
Thank you, Matthew. Good morning, and thanks for joining us. The presenters today will be Fred Green, our President and CEO; Kathryn McQuade, our EVP and Chief Financial Officer; Mike Franczak, EVP, Operations; and Jane O'Hagan, EVP and Chief Marketing Officer. Also joining us on the call today is Brian Grassby, our Senior VP Finance and Controller.
The slides accompanying today's teleconference are available on our website. Before we get started, let me remind you that this presentation contains forward-looking information. Actual results may differ materially. The risks, uncertainties and other factors that could influence actual results are described on slide 2 and 3, in the press release and in the MD&A filed with Canadian and US securities regulators. Please read carefully, as these assumptions could change throughout the year.
All dollars quoted in the presentation are Canadian, unless otherwise stated. This presentation also contains non-GAAP measures. Please read slide 4.
Finally, when we do go to Q&A, I would like to remind you for the purpose of today's call is to discuss our financial results and trends. We will therefore not be addressing Pershing Square's investments in CP or answering any questions on that topic. In fairness to all participants, I would ask you to limit your questions to one each.
Here then is our President and CEO, Fred Green.
Fred Green - President, CEO
Thanks, Janet, and good morning, everyone. CP's multiyear plan is built on three pillars -- driving volume growth, expanding network capacity to safely and efficiently support higher volumes, and controlling costs. We exited 2011 having made meaningful progress on all three goals, and we are beginning 2012 with operating momentum, good service and a stronger, more resilient rail network.
After a difficult first half in 2011, our first priority has been to reestablish our reputation for service, which underpins our price and growth plans. We entered Q4 with more contingent labor resources and an upgraded locomotive fleet with the acquisition of 61 new, more reliable, fuel-efficient units, cascading older units out of service.
As I highlighted last quarter, our primary obligation was to prove to our customers that we would return to consistent and reliable service, and we have done just that. Great examples are grain, where we filled 100% of planned orders during the quarter and achieved 92% overall on-time daily spotting; and Intermodal, where we delivered transcontinental train performance of over 90%.
Our operational metrics, a leading indicator of both customer satisfaction and financial results, are showing some compelling improvements.
We finished the year with record Q4 results in car miles per car day, up 20%, active cars online, down 14%, and terminal dwell, where we delivered a 20% year-on-year improvement and set new performance benchmarks. We know asset velocity is the key to our success. Customers place great value on enhanced service, and it comes with the added benefit of lowering our costs.
From a network perspective, we completed our CAD1.1 billion capital plan and delivered on stated network improvements, enhancing productivity, service and velocity. We broke records for train weights this year, and our investments are driving further improvements, including reduced runtimes on our North Line and increased train lengths on export coal.
As we complete years two and three of our network enhancement plans, the benefits will continue to grow.
So turning to slide 7, from a market perspective, our strategic plan is paying off. In June of 2010, we highlighted a CAD1 billion pipeline of market opportunities. We are making significant strides towards our stated goal of driving volume growth by cementing our position with existing key customers and turning opportunities into outcomes in emerging domestic markets.
We just announced a new five-year agreement with Canadian Tire, a major retailer positioned to grow. A new 10-year agreement with Canpotex that delivers higher rates, provides more timely and complete fuel coverage, shortens route miles, simplifies the operation with a hook-and-haul model, and positions CP to participate in planned growth. The deep relationships that exist from the top to the bottom of the Company made this possible.
And from a market development side, the biggest opportunity for us, energy, is bearing fruit. We increased inbound shipments of products like aggregates and pipe by more than 40% in Q4, and we more than doubled outbound shipments of crude oil.
On an annual basis, we grew our energy portfolio by approximately CAD60 million, and there is more to come. We achieved these milestones because of our team's commitment to executing on our multiyear plan. In June at our investor day, we laid out a number of productivity targets, and we are making headway in meeting those targets. As examples, Q4 fuel efficiency at 1.17 gallons per thousand GTMs matched our best ever Q4 performance. Labor, at 4.53 million GTMs per expense employee, set a Q4 productivity record.
And in grain, our hub program and emphasis on velocity delivered record carloads crop-year-to-date, beating our previous record by 10%.
Before I turn the call over to the team, I want to reiterate -- our primary goal is to operate our business better and to do so safely. While we have made progress, we clearly recognize we still have a ways to go. We are delivering on our operational plan and superior service offering. The financials will follow; they are in fact directly linked.
We are aggressively executing on our multiyear plan, which we believe is instrumental in creating long-term value for shareholders. Given recent market successes and the operating trends, we can now, with confidence, narrow the operating ratio range from our low 70s target to 70% to 72% in the next three years, and we are not stopping there.
With that, I am going to turn it over to Kathryn, Mike and Jane to provide more color on our results and outlook, and then come back and wrap up with some concluding thoughts. Over to you, Kathryn.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
Thank you, Fred, and good morning, everyone. We ended 2011 and are starting the year with strong operational metrics, which we expect will translate financially in 2012. As I take you through the fourth-quarter numbers, I will indicate where these operational metrics are starting to deliver financial results. I will also provide an update on our 2012 pension expense, which is a good news story based on the actions we have taken. So let's get into the numbers, and then I will turn it over to Mike.
To make the accountants happy, I will begin with GAAP earnings on slide 9, which includes a large tax item. Total revenues were up 9%, with 4% coming from fuel recovery. Jane will walk you through the details later in the presentation.
Operating expenses were up 11%, with fuel price driving 6% of that increase. Operating income was up 2%. Items below the line total CAD82 million, and I will give you more detail on those in a moment. Net income was CAD221 million, an increase of CAD35 million or 19%, and diluted earnings per share were CAD1.30.
The OR for the quarter was 78.5%, up 150 basis points. Higher fuel price makes up almost all of that increase. So essentially, our fourth-quarter OR would have been flat year-over-year.
Turning to slide 10, included in our GAAP results was a tax adjustment of CAD37 million, or CAD0.22 diluted EPS, resulting from the resolution of certain income tax matters related to previous-year tax filings and estimates. Our diluted earnings per share excluding the income tax benefit was CAD1.08.
Now let's look at each of the expense line items in more detail. Let's start with compensation and benefits on slide 11. In total, comp and benefits was up CAD27 million or 7% for the quarter. Incentive comp was down CAD18 million. However, this was partially offset by stock-based compensation, which was up CAD15 million due to a higher stock price.
Training costs are up CAD10 million this quarter, in line with our hiring. We will see training costs essentially flat in 2012, with higher levels in the first half and reducing into the second half of the year.
Wage and benefit inflation increased this line CAD8 million, and our pension expense was higher by CAD4 million.
Volume-related expenses were up CAD6 million, and we saw improvements in our crew-trained ratio, a function of our fluidity. We ended the year at the 14,764 expense employees. Looking at Q1 2012, we expect the number of average expense employees to be relatively flat.
Other items total CAD2 million and includes the impact from the closure of our Calgary back shop, a key deliverable in our locomotive reliability centers, or LRC, strategy. Bringing some locomotive work back in-house is key to our LRC plans and shifts expenses from purchased services to the comp line. As a reminder, our multi-year shop consolidation plan, which reduces from eight regional facilities to five -- to four highly efficient super shops, will result in long-term structural cost savings of over CAD15 million to CAD20 million a year when the final phases are complete. But as Mike will tell you, the true lift comes from better reliability and availability, and the work to date is already delivering results.
Turning to slide 12, fuel expense was up CAD65 million or 32% on the quarter. We saw CAD6 million in savings, or 3% improvement in fuel efficiency, a reflection of the operational metrics the team delivered in the quarter. We are on track to deliver on our multiyear target of improving fuel consumption by a CAGR of 1% to 2%.
Price increased this line CAD58 million, as our all-in cost was US$3.45 per gallon, up from US$2.68. This 29% increase in price, while substantially recovered in our fuel surcharge program, still negatively affects our OR by 130 basis points since it is just a recovery with no margin.
Higher workload increased fuel expense by CAD10 million on the quarter, and other items netted to CAD3 million.
Turning now to purchased services on slide 13, we were up CAD10 million, or 5%. Relocations were favorable by CAD4 million. In 2010, Operations completed a reorganization which reduced the number of operating territories from 11 to six. In New York, Mike spoke to the importance of his new organization, which reduces layers and clarifies accountabilities all the way to the front-line worker to speed decision-making.
Shop expenses were lower by CAD3 million, a result of the insourcing of locomotive work I just spoke to. These decreases were offset by higher volume-related expenses of CAD8 million, IT expenses of CAD4 million, locomotive overhaul costs of CAD4 million and casualty costs of CAD3 million.
Q4 land sales were on target at CAD20 million, finishing the year at CAD25 million. The timing of land sales is hard to judge, but in 2012, you can expect to see land sales in the range of CAD10 million to CAD15 million, most expected in the latter half of the year.
Turning to the remaining operating expenses on slide 14. Materials were up CAD2 million on the quarter, driven largely by the increase in price of non-freight fuel. Equipment rents saw benefits from our operating fluidity. Foreign car rents were down CAD4 million, as the Ops team drove improved terminal dwell and train speeds to reduce the number of active foreign cars online.
Offsetting this decrease, however, were higher leasing costs, driven by higher rates and volume. With the record-setting car miles a day the Ops team is delivering, you can expect many of these longer-term leased assets will be returned as leases expire.
Depreciation was up CAD2 million on the quarter, which is consistent with our accelerated capital program.
Now let's go to slide 15. Other income and charges were up CAD15 million, driven by higher advisory fees of CAD6 million, lower FX gains of CAD3 million and debt-related costs in the quarter totaling CAD4 million. Other items netted to CAD2 million. And finally, interest expense was down CD4 million on the quarter.
Looking at 2012, interest expense should be about CAD280 million. During Q4 we issued CAD625 million of debt to pre-fund our pension plan, and you will see the benefit of this transaction in our pension expense, which I will speak to in a moment.
Turning now to slide 16. Excluding the tax benefit I had spoke to earlier, our Q4 effective tax rate came in at 20.7%, bringing the effective rate for the year to 23.5%, in line with our projected annual tax rate of 24% to 26%.
Looking at 2012, we expect our effective tax rate to rise slightly and to be in the range of 25% to 27%. We will see very low cash taxes in 2012. Pension prepayments are tax-efficient, and as a result, we do not expect to be cash-taxable in Canada until 2015. Any cash taxes we will have in 2012 will be related to our US operations.
Turning to pensions on slide 17, our defined benefit pension expense for 2011 was CAD46 million. With the voluntary prepayment made in late 2011, our defined benefit pension expense for 2012 is now expected to be CAD41 million. Our pension strategy, net of interest, is accretive to earnings.
As we have stated previously, pension expense is a substantial headwind for CP. We still see our pension expense increasing significantly over the next several years, and currently estimate pension expense to be CAD125 million in 2013.
Now let's turn to the cash side of pensions. With the additional prepayment, I am now planning to range contributions to be between CAD100 million and CAD125 million for each of the next few years. This is down from our previous estimate of CAD125 million to CAD150 million.
Turning now to slide 18. I am pleased with how we've been able to position the balance sheet and to put our surplus cash to work in 2011 on our productivity initiatives, supporting our capital plans. During the year, we increased our dividends by 11% and completed our planned accelerated capital program.
We focused on managing the balance sheet to maintain flexibility and reduce volatility. We repaid US$245 million of maturing 2011 debt, called US$101 million of 2013 debt, financed our new locomotives at very attractive rates and made our CAD600 million pension prepayment.
Looking forward, we have no debt maturities in the near term, a renewed revolver going out to 2015 and improved earnings. Our liquidity position is strong and our balance sheet is flexible. When you look at our cash flow before the voluntary pension prepayment, we generated CAD1.1 billion from operations. After investing in the future of the business through CapEx and returning cash to our shareholders in the form of dividends, cash flow was a negative CAD124 million before the pension prepayment. As I said, CP is putting its surplus cash balance to work for the benefit of the Company and our shareholders.
Turning to capital expenditures on slide 19. In 2011, we delivered on our accelerated capital program of CAD1.1 billion, which includes the multiyear productivity investments we spoke to on investor day. We focused on several key programs -- our western corridor, where we invested CAD25 million in 2011 and plan to spend approximately CAD35 million in 2012.
On the North Line, this year we invested CAD86 million, which included accelerating 30 miles of track originally scheduled for 2012. Over the next two to three years, we will complete the remaining CAD158 million of investment.
In the US Midwest, where we are focusing on our north-south corridors, we completed CAD22 million of network investments and intend to invest approximately CAD40 million in 2012 to support our growth business. We invested CAD40 million in enhancing our IT systems, and you can expect a continued run rate of CAD50 million to CAD80 million over the next two to three years as we upgrade this essential part of our infrastructure.
In total, our 2012 capital program will be in the range of CAD1.1 billion to CAD1.2 billion, in line with the multiyear plans that we provided to you in June last year. These capital enhancements are important building blocks to meet our growth and efficiency targets, and it is key to improving service reliability as volumes grow.
With that, I will hand it over to Mike.
Mike Franczak - EVP, Operations
Thanks, Kathryn. The Operations team delivered a solid performance in the fourth quarter. Not only did we fully recover the network, we delivered record-breaking improvements in several key operating metrics and fully restored our service levels. This improvement is consistent with the projections we made last quarter.
These results were achieved through the disciplined execution of our integrated operating plan, the multiyear plan programs we started over a year ago, and by focusing on our core priorities of service reliability, efficiency and safety. We are off to a solid start in 2012, and will continue to drive improvements in all key aspects of our business.
Let's get started on slide 21. This quarter, personal injuries/safety improved 3%. Despite a strong improvement relative to the first three quarters of the year, our train accident rate increased 9% in Q4. Notwithstanding this result, it is our second best quarter in the last number of years. Our focus on safety continues in all aspects of our operations and remains a central element of our multiyear plan.
Please turn to slide 22. Our continued work on building new sidings and extending current ones to support our long-train strategy is paying dividends, as we set new full-year records in both train weights and train lengths. We saw our biggest gains on our bulk trains, where we increased weights and lengths by 1% and 2%, respectively. Take our coal trains, for example. We met our target of completing five siding improvements, with four more to come, and have extended the Fording River Mine Loop track, which allows us now to load 152 car trains at Teck's highest-producing coal mine. With these improvements, we are now running eight coal sets at our design target of 152 cars.
As we leverage our planned investments in the network and our use of distributed power technology, we will increase the productivity of our Vancouver export coal and potash trains by more than 15%. In doing so, these longer, more fuel-efficient trains will reduce the total number of trains required, thus creating labor savings, reduced track and equipment wear, and lower associated maintenance requirements.
The enhanced efficiency we are achieving with longer trains is and will continue to be a key driver of a value creation for Canadian Pacific.
Please join me on the next slide, 23. Gross ton miles per active horsepower was flat for the quarter, but we saw solid improvement month-over-month, and I'm confident this trend will continue. Gross ton miles per expense employee improved 1%, setting a new fourth-quarter record. This is a key measure of our employees' productivity and another area where we will continuously improve.
Please turn to slide 24. During the quarter, we moved higher volumes while realizing successive steady improvements in all of our service and efficiency metrics, setting Q4 and full-year records in both terminal dwell and car miles per car day. Looking at the quarterly results, train speed improved by 8% due to our ongoing capacity investment and our rigorous approach to executing the plan every day. Our continued focus on the execution of our first mile/last mile program and our ability to aggressively store railcars drove a 20% improvement in terminal dwell.
These improvements helped drive car miles per car day down 20%, allowing us to move 5% more gross ton miles with 14% fewer active cars. This is a key measure of asset utilization, and we expect further improvement in 2012.
Lastly, we realized a 3% improvement in fuel efficiency, tying a previous Q4 record. This is our largest single operations expense, and we were able to effectively control it through targeted investments and disciplined execution. With 61 new AC locomotives now online and another 30 coming in Q1, we are well-positioned to remove higher-cost, less-reliable, less fuel-efficient locomotives from the property.
We now have over 260 locomotives equipped with Fuel Trip Optimizer, or FTO, technology. And by year-end 2012, we will have over 50% of our large road fleet FTO-equipped.
Our planned remanufacturing of 50 locomotives used in yard and road services is under way, providing not only increased fuel efficiency, but also upgraded haulage capacity and locotrol capability to support the expansion of our long-train strategy in the US Midwest.
Through these commitments and programs, we remain on track to achieve our goal of realizing 1% to 2% in annual fuel savings over the next several years. And in comparison to 2011, I expect to realize a 3% to 4% year-over-year improvement in 2012.
Let's move on to slide 25. As you can see in our key efficiency metrics, we have made significant improvements in our network since the start of 2011. And we have started 2012 on an excellent note, continuing to sustain or improve on our key metrics. As we progress with the programs outlined at our investor days in 2010 and 2011, I expect further improvements to be realized across all of these metrics.
The improved efficiencies allow us to do more with less and to reduce our asset pools. In some cases, this means returning leased assets; in others, deferring or forgoing the acquisition of additional resources. For example, by reducing the number of active cars online by 14%, we have now set ourselves up for rail car lease returns.
Our first mile/last mile program has been instrumental in driving some of these results. Our Canadian rollout of this program is now essentially complete, and our US implementation work will be complete by Q2 2012. We have seen significant reduction in arrival-to-place times of rail cars, and most customers are now proactively managing their pipelines to avoid demerge assessments.
And while the improved service levels resulting from the program have generated positive customer feedback, we are always looking to raise the bar on service and efficiency. By the end of 2012, we will cut arrival-to-place times by 24 hours across the network.
The results of our Canadian grain reliability program are equally impressive. We filled 100% of the orders we planned to fill during the quarter. Daily on-time spotting performance for the quarter was 92%, and 96% for the month of December as we continued to improve. Vancouver export grain cycles improved by 11%, and winter grain cycles to eastern Canadian ports improved by 19%.
Jane will speak to some other impressive record-setting grain metrics, but you can expect to see more improvements as we roll out our US grain reliability program fully in 2012.
Please join me on slide 26. We have now completed the second phase of our Locomotive Reliability Center strategy, which will reduce the number of major locomotive repair facilities from eight to four highly-efficient super shops with improved repair capabilities. These shop consolidations will be completed by the end of 2012, and we have already realized a 1.3% improvement in locomotive availability in Q4 versus last year. As a point of reference, a 1% improvement is equivalent to roughly 15 locomotives, and affords us the ability to reduce our overall fleet.
Shop productivity continues to improve, with labor hours per unit maintained down 4%. Our cycle times improved 16%, with our [Ailis] shop realizing a 30% improvement in Q4. These high-production shops and our lean, continuous-improvement approach will drive further improvements in locomotive availability and reliability.
In engineering, our recently negotiated agreement with the Teamsters provided us with the ability for extended rotating work cycles, greater rest day flexibility and the ability to move crews outside their normal seniority districts. This allowed our prairie rail crews in Manitoba and Saskatchewan to exceed the targeted equipment utilization rate with a 35% increase in productivity.
As a result of our lean approach, we have also realized significant year-over-year productivity improvements for our rail and tie crews, as measured by block rates or units per block hour. This improvement enabled us to complete all planned work by the end of September and advanced 30 track miles' worth of upgrades on the North Line.
Please turn to slide 27. To sum up, this quarter was all about improving service and efficiency, and we delivered, setting many new records. We not only regained the confidence of our customers, but in many cases, surpassed their expectations.
Our multiyear plan and operations is well underway and producing great results. In the fourth quarter, we realized excellent performance and service and efficiency, and we expect to see reduced expenses quickly follow as we continue to drive out surplus assets and further improve fuel efficiency.
The network is fluid, with many of our performance metrics exceeding earlier established targets. And we will continue to raise the bar. Accountabilities are clear, and our team is motivated.
Going forward, our main focus will continue to be delivering sustainable improvements in service reliability, efficiency and safety, creating value for customers and shareholders. For 2012, our plans include completing another 15 infrastructure projects as part of our long-train strategy to meet demand and improve productivity; continuing to drive our fuel-efficiency programs; completing the implementation of our Locomotive Reliability Center program; expanding our scheduled grain program to the US; further improvement of our first and last mile programs to reduce the need for assets; and building on our existing safety management system. These are just a few of the many programs we have planned for 2012 to drive sustainable improvements in our march towards a lower operating ratio.
I will now turn you over to Jane.
Jane O'Hagan - EVP, CMO
Thank you, Mike, and good morning. I am very pleased with the results the team produced for the quarter and over the year. Let me start by elaborating on our successes we've had leveraging the great product Mike and his team has produced. Then I will walk through the quarter and our views for 2012.
At investor days in years past, we talked about a number of market development initiatives, including strengthening our bulk portfolio, capitalizing on Asian demand and making our markets in energy. In 2011, we delivered on those initiatives.
In bulk, our Teck partnership is an example of how we are maximizing value by delivering both growth and efficiencies. We have also secured a new contract with Canpotex, and we introduced a new grain product in Canada that has delivered market share and carloading records. Lastly, we have opportunistically developed new thermal coal business, all in line with this strategic objective.
For energy, CP is the only carrier that serves all three of the North American energy plays -- the oilsands, the Bakken, the Marcellus Shale -- and we have delivered on our market development strategies with both CP and customer investment in infrastructure, resulting in solid growth for inbound materials, outbound crude and byproducts.
Our core intermodal business is back, and we continue to improve. But while there is more to do, I assure you that we are working aggressively to improve our business.
I will start on slide 30 with an overview of revenue performance in the quarter. On the quarter, there was minimal FX impact. Overall, Q4 '11 freight revenues improved 9% over Q4 2010. Revenue ton miles were up 4%, and carloads were flat. Fuel surcharge revenue accounted for 4% of the overall revenue gained, with price and mixed driving the remaining 5% of growth.
We delivered on our price plan targets in every quarter of 2011.
Great service leads to value and growth. Our customers are commenting positively on CP's service reliability, and in 2012, we will leverage these service improvements for value in the marketplace. I will summarize the performance by market and offer some perspective on what I see as I look into 2012.
Grain is a great story. As a result of the scheduled grain product launched in August 2011, our Q4 Canadian grain business grew more than 25% in revenue and carloads. In contrast, reduced production and weak demand for US grain drove an approximate 15% reduction for that franchise. Our net results at 8% revenue growth demonstrates that we've been able to capitalize on strong markets for Canadian grains and oilseeds to offset weakness in US grain exports.
Our excellent service reliability and supply chain collaboration in Canadian grain has resulted in record carloads crop-year-to-date, 10% above our best year of '06, '07.
In the US, given the high global feed grain inventories, we expect ongoing volatility for the remainder of the crop year.
Looking forward through the first half of 2012, Statistics Canada's December forecast increased Western Canadian production estimates for the six majors from approximately 45 million metric tons to 47.4 million metric tons. This represents an approximate 5% increase over the previous estimate, and with our sustained service performance, we should deliver good share in volumes in Canadian grain through the balance of this crop year.
We've also made great progress in coal. Revenues grew 25% on flat year-over-year carloadings. We have diversified our portfolio through the development of new markets. We have replaced low-margin, short-haul US thermal coal with growth in long-haul export met coal, and as we told you, secured new PRB coal through Ridley Terminal. We lapped the short-haul US reduction in Q1 2012, so you won't have to hear me talk about it anymore.
As Mike has noted, we are ahead of schedule for our long-train conversion of export coal sets, and are delivering excellent performance and efficiency. Looking forward, the long-term fundamentals for met coal demand remained intact, and Teck continues to expand production. Our network and the supply chain are fully prepared to respond to Teck's growth. We remain confident in the long-term growth prospects of this segment.
In the near-term, economic uncertainty is creating some potential risk in global met coal markets. PRB volumes may prove to be a partial counter, with expanded capacity now online at Ridley Terminal. Volatility and the timing of demand may result in average revenue per car noise if we see a lull in export met volumes while the shorter-haul PRB exports continue on pace.
Now I will move to sulphur and fertilizers on slide 33. We are delighted with the new Canpotex agreement. The new contract delivers both price and productivity improvements. Revenue per car increases, we have a fully responsive fuel program, and by leveraging the shorter mile North Line routes and more long trains, we will be able to decrease CP's unit cost on export potash.
The agreement continues our long-term partnership, secures a very large majority of the volume to Vancouver B.C., and maintains our exclusive route to the Portland, Oregon outlet.
The 10-year term provides the foundation for both CP and customer investment to facilitate further low-cost growth in this key segment.
For 2012, we are seeing some uncertainty around first-half shipment timing, but full-year demand for fertilizers is expected to be solid, based on the agronomic fundamentals. There is significant product positioned, and we have seen some global and North American production adjustments to manage inventory, but we expect demand to build through the first half as the crop applications progress.
So while there is some uncertainty around the timing, we are modeling 2012 total fertilizer and sulphur volumes in line with 2011.
Turning to slide 34, in Q4 2011, Intermodal revenues declined 2%, with 6% fewer units versus Q4 2010. As Mike has told you, the operation ran very well in Q4. Our service reliability and our on-time train performance was excellent, and our Intermodal customers noticed. We have 100% of our shipping lines and their key lanes. As we continue to deliver quality service, they can grow their business on CP, and we will improve our joint market share.
We have seen volumes stabilize in our core markets and expect them to build into Q2 and beyond. Importantly, we have not lost any contracts. Our customers and CP growing volume lane by lane as they gain confidence in our sustained performance. We are meeting with customers about the timing of volume growth on an ongoing basis, and I was recently back in Asia to reinforce our customer relationships there.
While our core business is back, I am not yet satisfied with our current Intermodal volume, and through service and our slate of market development initiatives we will deliver further growth. We just signed a five-year deal with Canadian Tire, a leading Canadian retailer and one of our top five intermodal customers. And we continue to expand our colocation strategy.
We will do more, so stay tuned. There is more to come in 2012. Looking forward, despite global economic volatility, a slower pace of growth in China and excess shipping line capacity, by executing on our initiatives the resulting recovery of share with growth in the North American GDP should drive CP intermodal volume growth of GDP plus for 2012.
Moving on to slide 35. I am excited about the market opportunities in our merchandise portfolio. We are delivering quality service. We continue to build collaborative relationships with customers and are making new markets, particularly in energy. We are all proud of the focus and the effort of our team, driving a year-over-year 18% revenue growth.
In automotive, Q4 2011 revenue increased 25% with increased car loadings of 15%. The growth was driven by increased light vehicle sales, both sequentially and year-over-year, CP's diversified portfolio, our solid service, and relationships with market-leading partners. Forecasts indicate continued growth in North American vehicle sales in 2012, and we are modeling demand growth consistent with sales projections.
Industrial products revenue grew 20% on unit growth of 12% year-over-year. Of note, in Q4 we opened a new long-haul direct crude oil market to the US Northeast and secured new facility developments in the CP served oilfields. We have a proven crude by rail product, and are leveraging our network and its capability for further growth. Stay tuned in the coming weeks for significant announcements on how we are driving more growth in industrial products.
In all, we are very excited about the prospects in front of us. We have the foundation to deliver continued strength and double-digit growth rates through 2012 and beyond. Overall, we will expect strong merchandise growth of two to three times GDP in 2012.
We spoke to you in the past about our market development initiatives, and our results show that we are delivering growth throughout our book of business. We demonstrated sustained service performance across all our customer segments, and this has allowed us to deliver against our price targets. Looking to 2012, our service is supporting our customers' growth and enabling our market development strategies. We are making our markets in energy, growing with existing and new customers in global bulk commodities, and executing on our plan to deliver growth and value today and throughout 2012.
With that, I will hand it back to Fred to wrap it up.
Fred Green - President, CEO
Thanks, Jane. From a market perspective, we remain positive about our prospects for the bulk commodities and energy markets, and we continue to position the organization for longer-term growth. And we see a tremendous number of opportunities in both existing and new markets.
Operationally, we are making great strides in enhancing our efficiency, and we are starting to see the payoff from the network enhancements and process improvements that are underway.
We have improved customer confidence, and we will continue to take costs out of the system, while maintaining and improving service levels across our network.
We have returned to more efficient and sustained operational performance. And as we described today, we have achieved double-digit improvements across several of our key metrics. These improved operational results in Q4 set the stage for meaningful improvements in our financial performance in 2012, starting as early as the first quarter.
Our team has focused on achieving an operating ratio of 70% to 72% in the next three years, and we are confident that we will do so. And once we hit those targets, we won't stop.
Before turning it over to Q&A, as Janet mentioned, the purpose of today's call is to discuss our financial results and trends. We will therefore not be addressing Pershing Square's investment in CP or answering any questions on that topic.
Now I will turn it over to the operator to open up the line for questions.
Operator
(Operator Instructions) Cherilyn Radbourne, TD Securities.
Cherilyn Radbourne - Analyst
Thanks very much and good morning. I hate to open the question period by asking a question on pension, but I wonder if you could review for us why it jumped from CAD41 million to CAD125 million in 2013. Give us some sense of what you mean by normal equity market returns and modest increases in bond yields, and comment on whether you would consider another prepayment in 2012 to try and bring down that CAD125 million.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
Good morning, Cherilyn. Man, that is a lot of questions in one question. But we can certainly take it off-line if you have additional questions.
But what we are seeing is very consistent with what we gave you in the latest investor day. We always knew that it was going to rise over the multiyear period. The pension prepayment did substantially bring that down. It brought it down CAD47 million in 2012; it will bring it down slightly less than that in 2013 and on out.
But what we see is, of course, the low interest rate environment that continues to put pressure. And so everything is an estimate over the longer term. But what we have is our -- what we believe is that the pension will essentially increase as our equity losses from 2008 continue to be amortized. That is a five-year period. We did have equity losses in 2011 as well that will be amortized over the remaining five years.
So our legacy pension burden or headwind is less because of our pension prepayment, and will be a function of market returns which would be more historical. So we usually estimate about 7.5% on equity returns, and so not astronomical equity returns. And what we look to see is interest rate environments closer to historical norms.
In terms of a pension prepayment, I don't see anywhere in the near future a need for any additional pension prepayments. What we are anticipating is this prepayment would last us out through 2015. And certainly most people assume that the interest rate environment would become more historical further out. So that will start correcting what I believe is some illogical values for our pension liability that is being caused by the low interest rate environment.
So I am not -- unless something really changes in terms of the economic environment, I am not seeing a real need for any pension prepayments.
Cherilyn Radbourne - Analyst
Okay. Thanks for the full answer, and I guess that was at least one from me.
Operator
Fadi Chamoun, BMO Capital Markets.
Fadi Chamoun - Analyst
A question on margin. Just wanted to understand -- so in 2010, you had 77.6% operating ratio. From what we are seeing in terms of your metric across the board, they are at least as good or better than where you were in 2010, and even the pension headwind is a little bit more moderate, at least in 2012, versus what we had expected.
Is it realistic for us to assume that we can see a reversal in the margin to the 2010 level this year? And if not, what is sort of the pluses and minuses that are going in there?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
I will start off. 2010 is still -- I mean, a lot of things have changed since 2010, and as I've said, we've got higher training costs that we are experiencing right now and some IT costs. So there are some one-time items that have longer-term value, but actually hit the expense line items in our OR when you are comparing to 2010 versus 2011 fourth quarter.
I gave some guidance in terms of what we are seeing in terms of our training costs you will see and 2012 -- or 2011 -- 2012 training costs essentially flat with 2011, but it will be higher at the beginning of the year and kind of tailing off. So when you look at it, we have -- we are seeing productivity and efficiency, and we would see a more return to more historical OR levels. But there will be still seasonality in our OR overall.
Fadi Chamoun - Analyst
Okay. So I guess it is a realistic outcome if the market behaves in terms of your top line as you had expected, but with some quarterly seasonality. Is that what I should be taking away from this?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
Yes, I think that's fair.
Fadi Chamoun - Analyst
Okay. Thank you.
Operator
Turan Quettawala, Scotia Capital.
Turan Quettawala - Analyst
I guess maybe -- you gave a lot of color on the fuel side. I just wanted to understand better, on the employee side, I know there is some attrition that will play out here. When should we start seeing that happen and the decline in expense employees? Maybe just longer-term, you could give broad numbers.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
What we are seeing is productivity improvements on a GTM basis, and it will be a function overall of continuing to improve on that metric. We have our continued attrition, which is about -- over 1000 employees a year, which attrit out over the next five years. So while we did go into the winter months, it takes -- what -- nine months to train and to have employees available. We did have them ahead of the winter.
Mike and the team are always aggressively sizing the amount of requirements to what Jane is projecting in terms of the business level. So we are not seeing in our projections any major increase. And as I said first quarter, we expect our active employees to be essentially flat with where we ended the year. And of course, we are going to look for higher business levels as we go into 2012.
Turan Quettawala - Analyst
Okay. But I guess you said over 1000 employees a year over the next few years. Should we expect some decline there as well or not? Or it just going to be more GTMs per employees that will go down -- that will go up.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
What we measure, of course, our productivity will be productivity per GTM. So as we see growth in GTMs, we want to see productivity lifts from our long-train strategies, our shops, our ES work, as well as our (multiple speakers).
But anyway -- so what we are actually focusing on is productivity per business level. And so it will be a function of the business level, and Mike will size his resources appropriately. But what we are seeing, at least for the first quarter, is essentially a flat active employment.
Operator
Chris Ceraso, Credit Suisse.
Chris Ceraso - Analyst
I have a question about the OR target, with just a couple of subparts. First of all, what sort of a role do you expect pricing to play in getting down to the 70 to 72 range? Is it half of it, is it a third of it? And is 3% or so per year pricing, is that enough to get you there?
And then secondly, in the same context, just to clarify, when you say in the next three years, is that from today, so we are talking about 2012? And how much exactly of an increase in discount rates are you expecting?
Fred Green - President, CEO
It's Fred. I'll start and just say that for perfect clarity, 2012, 2013, 2014 are the three years that we refer to. So our 70% to 72% operating ratio target is for that time frame, and that we are not going to stop there.
So maybe I can ask Kathryn to deal with the discount question and Jane on pricing with regard to our expectations.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
So I would refer you back to our investor day, and it is still very consistent. We still see growth -- more historical growth in our volumes, Jane's inflation plus pricing levels. So essentially, I think if you go back to our investor day, about 50% of it came from the revenue lift and about 50% from productivity, and that of course was being offset by our pension headwinds. So that -- and then on the discount rate, I guess you are asking about the pension plan.
Chris Ceraso - Analyst
Well, two things there. One of them was, in your comment about the 2012 expense expectation, you said a modest increase in discount rate. So I wanted to know -- is that 25 bps, is it 50 bps. And then within your 2014 number, how much higher do you think rates will be by the time we get there, within the 70% to 72%? Is it 50 bps higher, is it 100 bps higher?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
It is a very gradual rise in 2013/2014, and about 100 over the three-year period.
Chris Ceraso - Analyst
Okay, that's great. Thank you very much.
Operator
Benoit Poirier, Desjardins Securities.
Benoit Poirier - Analyst
Maybe just one question. What are the main impediments to reach a 65% operating ratio in 2015?
Fred Green - President, CEO
Benoit, that, as I think we've made very clear in the multiyear plan, we've got a very, very specific and detailed plan that provides us the opportunity to apply the initiatives you've seen, the growth initiatives, the expansion of the capacity. And that, all-in, properly executed, which we plan to do, delivers the 70% to 72%.
There are clearly a, as Ed Harris quoted not very long ago, substantial difference in the structural makeup of different railroads, and it is unrealistic in these time frames, in our view, to get to those numbers.
Benoit Poirier - Analyst
Okay. Thanks for the time.
Operator
Jeff Kauffman, Sterne Agee.
Sal Vitale - Analyst
Thanks for taking my question. This is a Sal Vitale on for Jeff Kauffman. Just a quick question. On the labor side, just working out the increase in wage and benefits, I think it worked out to about 2% year-on-year versus 4Q '10. What should we be thinking about the inflation in that line, say, going forward for 2012?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
We are planning about between 2% and 3%.
Sal Vitale - Analyst
2% and 3%, okay. And then you said the trend costs would be roughly flat in 2011. Is there anything else on the labor side that we should be thinking about?
Fred Green - President, CEO
Maybe I'll just jump in on that one, and maybe it follows up on an earlier question. But I did comment on the fact that we are continuously driving improvements in our labor productivity rates. Those are linked to our long-train strategy, the work we are doing in our locomotive reliability centers. We are seeing improvements in our crew train ratios. All of these kinds of things will be factored back into our manpower sizing and our training rates, so I'm expecting to see improvements through this year as well, which will also factor into the labor line.
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
And just another thing to keep in mind was the guidance I gave on stock-based compensation. About CAD1.00 increase in stock price is about CAD1 million in additional expense as well. So that is something to keep in mind.
Operator
Matt Troy, Susquehanna Financial.
Matt Troy - Analyst
You had gone to great lengths to detail some of the productivity initiatives or service investments, cost investments, to make sure that this winter did not have a substantial impact on your service capability. In light of what has been a relatively milder start to winter -- I mean, we are almost in February -- is there an opportunity near term to scale back some of that resource investment to have a beneficial impact on margins, sooner than we would have expected had it been more snowy and cold? Thanks.
Fred Green - President, CEO
I want to stress that what we said we would do in this quarter was to ensure that we were delivering a first-class product. And I'm really delighted with what Mike and his team have done.
We were and are sized to deal with any difficulties that might come our way, including such things as a week of minus 40 at night and minus 30 in the day, which we've just come through and come through very well.
And we've also sized ourselves to have some upside opportunity. There are some circumstances today available to us and we have taken some of those resources and applied them to seize the moment in that upside opportunity that we are seizing.
So the phrase that I used at the time and I stand by is that we will deliver improved service, we will deliver fluidity and asset improvement. And when we have done that, both to our own satisfaction, which drives our costs down, and to our customers' satisfaction, that gives them consistent, sustained reliable service, we will recalibrate resources. But we are not going to get ahead of ourself and do that.
So the answer is yes, we will, but we will do it in a thoughtful way and consistent with the quality of the product and the reducing cost as a result of having the right level of resources in place.
Matt Troy - Analyst
Understood. Thank you.
Operator
Jason Seidl, Dahlman Rose.
Jason Seidl - Analyst
One question for Jane, the other question for Kathryn. Jane, you mentioned that obviously there is some uncertainty around potash fertilizer for 2012, and to expect sort of relatively flat volume type numbers.
Could you -- does that mean we are going to expect maybe negative in the first half of the year, maybe growing to positive throughout? And then what does it look like over the longer term, not only the recent contracts that you signed with Canpotex, but maybe some of the non-Canpotex players that are going to be coming in over the next few years?
Jane O'Hagan - EVP, CMO
I would start off by answering your first question. While we did indicate that there is certainly inventory and significant inventory that is positioned at this point in time, we are modeling that 2012 is going to look a lot like 2011. So we expect that the demand will continue to progress as the year moves along, because we believe the fundamentals in the potash world continue to be strong.
With respect to modeling and talking about certainly the Canpotex agreement and growth, again, the share does depend on the mix between Vancouver and Portland. And so as you are thinking about your modeling, if you had modeled just a little over 80% on that projected volume, that will give you an idea of where we are with growth and as the market progresses.
Jason Seidl - Analyst
Okay. And Kathryn, in your expenses, when you go through them, you noted there was a CAD6 million year-over-year differential in advisor expense. Could you talk about what that was and do we expect that number to continue to creep up?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
Well, we really didn't ask for these types of one-time expenses, but we are going to do what is necessary to ensure that our shareholders have all the information they need to understand the state of our business and our multiyear plan and how we will create long-term value for our shareholders. So they are going to continue at least into the first quarter.
Operator
David Newman, Cormark Securities.
David Newman - Analyst
Just on the pension again, not to beat a dead horse, but there has been some discussion -- there is a lot of companies in sort of the same position -- that the government might provide some relief at some point here, especially now we've got a reiteration that we are going to be keeping the rates relatively low for quite a period of time.
And I guess the second part of that is, you've got some big contract renewals for the labor front coming in the next few years. Is there any opportunity at all to kind of look at maybe a DC or an amended, hybrid DC plan, as well as getting maybe greater labor flexibility to match your productivity improvements?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
So to the first part of the question; then we'll turn it over to Fred for the second part. We are actually leading some advocacy with the government. As everybody knows, the low interest rate environment is actually a function of the economy to stimulate investment, and actually it is very negative for businesses with DB plans, because it is forcing additional funding into that, and the inability to invest in growth capital or really things that help stimulate the environment, the economy in total.
So we are in discussions. I think we are talking with the Minister and trying to advocate for some relief over the longer term. And we are doing that with another group of -- with our group of about six other major companies as well. So stay tuned. It would be nice if we could get some help and relief in this area and I think it is what is best for the economy and what is best for the country as well.
David Newman - Analyst
Any initial thoughts on what your position is? Would you like to have sort of like a 10-year amortization -- is that what the goal is? Maybe spread it out a little bit more through cycle?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
Well, we are looking at various different things that the Minister would consider. So it is a lot of details. But what we would best like to see is temporary relief from certain things that would allow us to move through this unusually low, historically low interest rate environment.
Fred Green - President, CEO
David, let me pick up on the second point. I think it is public knowledge, because the other parties released it way back in -- I think it was in September -- that we have approached, in this round of negotiations, our unions that we are dealing with. Now, I would note, we deal with 39 different union agreements.
But in that discussion, we have certainly engaged with the other parties to make sure that there is a deep and comprehensive understanding about the legacy pension. I mean, this is something that has been around with agreements that are applying from the '70s and '80s that is now coming home to roost, and it is important that we fully educate each other. And with that, I am hopeful that we will find a resolve that will address the, obviously, very substantive pension headwinds that this Company faces. And if we do that and do that well in a collaborative way, we will all be winners, and that is our objective.
Janet Weiss - IR
It is Janet. And I know today's participants have pretty busy schedules, so we are going to take two more calls, and then if there is any outstanding questions, we would be more than happy to handle them off-line.
Operator
Walter Spracklin, RBC Capital Markets.
Walter Spracklin - Analyst
I guess my first question is on the share gains that you saw go the other way with the service disruptions from earlier this year or last year. Curious as to what traction that you've made. I know Mike has done a great job on the service side. Jane, you said you are hearing your customers come back or hearing your customers speak positively on it. Understanding you didn't lose contracts, but I think your customers' customers did move on different routes away from CP during that time.
How confident are you that you are starting -- that you will be getting some of that market share back, and have you seen early signs of it?
Jane O'Hagan - EVP, CMO
Why don't I just start with one of the first wins for right out of the gate? I think that when we look at grain and we think about our year-over-year and where we are today, again, one of the clear things that we said that we would do is that we would position, with our new scheduled grain service, a product and earn back our market share. And as a result of that, we've seen record crop-year-to-date carloads, about 10% of our best year in '06 and '07. Again, this is based on our excellent service reliability, our supply chain collaboration and all of the things that we've done in that market.
I think that if you also look at our merchandise portfolio and you look at where we are with respect to our growth on the energy side, that growth, given the quality of the service that we have in place, has certainly on the energy side been faster than anticipated. And again, based on the quality of that product, we expect more in that area as well.
Certainly with respect to Intermodal, our focus is clearly to do exactly what we did with respect to grain. Again, our domestic share is looking good. We are back in that area. As I said before, we have 100% of our key lines. And their key lanes are back. And again, our focus in this regard is to continue to build on that consistency of service. And as we see that service consistency maintained, we are going to expect a steady increase in our volumes.
Walter Spracklin - Analyst
Okay. That's great color. Appreciate that. And just a housekeeping. You mentioned split -- or your price and mix. Could you split the two up there?
Kathryn McQuade - EVP, CFO
On the price side, on price and mix, we were talking about 5%, with our price and mix being positive.
Operator
Tom Wadewitz, JPMorgan.
Tom Wadewitz - Analyst
Thanks for squeezing me in here. Appreciate it. Wanted to see if we could get some comments in terms of just a little more granular on where you were at with average train length in 2011, full-year or fourth-quarter, in coal, potash and Intermodal, and what you think that can go to in 2012. If you could give us some more numbers to think about that, that would be helpful. Thank you.
Mike Franczak - EVP, Operations
Okay, Tom, I will talk to that. Through 2012, I think if you take a look at the coal trains, for example, we will be ramping up from the eight sets I noted earlier into the upper teens, as we bring on the other siding projects or infrastructure projects that we spoke to.
We are at our 170 numbers right now for the potash trains, so we will continue to run those and ramp up a little bit there further. As well as our Intermodal trains, we will continue to ramp up. And Tom, I would refer you back to the slides that we shared with you at investor day that showed how we were ramping up each train series over the coming year or two, as we brought on the different infrastructure projects. And we can get those back to you.
Fred Green - President, CEO
I would just add to that that although the deep cold has obviously shortened a few trains in the last week or so, we are back to normal now. But success is not just dealing with the bulk trains and the Intermodal trains. But to the extent that Jane continues to have success based on the great quality of product, Mike's merchandise trains will also expand over the course of time.
The secret for us is asset utilization, it's fluidity. We need to keep things moving. So we are not driven at this point exclusively by train length. We are driven by miles per car day and by keeping those assets moving and the service levels very, very high.
Tom Wadewitz - Analyst
Do you reach the target levels in 2012 for those three segments, or is there still some waiting for some of the CapEx to come in?
Mike Franczak - EVP, Operations
No, there will be more to come after that, Tom, right through '13, as well.
Operator
Mr. Green, there are no further questions at this time. Please continue.
Fred Green - President, CEO
Okay. Well, thank you all for your time and your interest in Canadian Pacific. Our multiyear plan, with this we think and believe -- we are confident we are going to take the right steps in the operational excellence and to deliver financial results. We appreciate the strong support we've received from customers, from shareholders, employees and other stakeholders of Canadian Pacific, and we will continue to deliver on our objectives.
And we look forward to providing a progress report on our next quarterly conference call. Thanks very much.
Operator
This concludes today's conference call. You may now disconnect.