使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good day, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the fourth-quarter earnings conference call. At this time all participants are in a listen-only mode. Later we will conduct a question-and-answer session and instructions will be given at that time. (Operator Instructions) As a reminder today's conference call is being recorded.
I would now like to introduce your host for today's conference, Mr. Roland Breunig, Chief Financial Officer. Sir, you may begin.
Roland Breunig - CFO
Thank you, Devin. Good morning and thank you for joining us. Today, Kraig Kayser, CEO and President, and I will be reviewing the results of the fourth quarter and of our 2011 fiscal year which ended on March 31, 2011. But before we do, let me address the standard legal disclaimers.
Information shared during this call may contain forward-looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Because such statements are subject to risks and uncertainties, our actual results may differ materially from those expressed or implied by such comments.
Investors are cautioned not to place undue reliance on such comments which speak only as to the date they are made. Except for ongoing obligations to disclose material information as is required by the Federal Securities Law, the Company does not undertake any obligation to release publicly any revisions to any forward-looking statements to reflect events or circumstances after the date of this call or to reflect the occurrence of unanticipated events.
Some of the comments that we will make will refer to non-GAAP measures. The Company does not intend for this information to be used in isolation or as a substitute for other measures that are prepared in accordance with GAAP. I refer you to our fourth-quarter press release which contains reconciliations of GAAP to non-GAAP measures and to the Investor Information section of our website which is located at www.senecafoods.com.
During our discussion we will be using phrases like full-year ended and year-to-date interchangeably. In addition, unless otherwise mentioned, references to current year and to 2011 or to prior year and 2010, refer to the fiscal years that end on March 31 of 2011 and 2010, respectively.
Now let me turn the call over to Kraig Kayser to talk about our business.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Thanks, [Rolly]. Seneca reported a fourth-quarter net loss of $1.9 million or $0.15 per diluted share versus a net profit of $6.3 million or $0.51 per diluted share in last year's fourth quarter.
Sales for the quarter of $253 million were down approximately 9.4% from prior years' $279.4 million due to reduced selling prices and reduced case sales. The fourth-quarter results reflected the continued price wars in the market from last summer and fall's bumper crops as we promoted heavily to get inventories back in line.
In addition, the quarter was negatively impacted by the timing of Easter this year, in late April, which pushed some holiday sales into the new fiscal year. Twelve-month results show earnings of $17.7 million or $1.45 per fully diluted share on sales of $1.19 billion down from earnings of $48.4 million or $3.96 per diluted share on sales of $1.28 billion in last year's period.
The decline in profits and sales for the full 12-month period were primarily due to lower selling prices compared to the prior year. Roland will review the financial performance in more detail later on, but I wanted to give you a little flavor for kind of the drivers of performance for the quarter and the year.
As previously reported, Seneca has been heavily promoting this year to move the pack. The sales mix is one indicator of the fact. For the fourth quarter, selling prices and mix reflected a decline of $10.6 million while sales volumes or case sales were also down $15.8 million.
While we were promoting heavily, sales remained soft (technical difficulty) had a very strong third-quarter ahead of the December holidays and some of our customers were long on inventory. And Easter, as I mentioned earlier, was in late April which pushed some normally March sales into April.
For the year, sales were off $85 million versus the prior year. 67.4% of that was attributable to reduced sales to two contract packing customers, the first being General Mills, where we have our large production alliance in which we produce their Green Giant can and some frozen product under contract. The other being a large snack customer who discontinued a product we were making for them in our small snack business in Washington state.
In fact, when you remove these two customers, Seneca actually sold more physical cases of product in the prior year, albeit at lower selling prices. We are now in our sixteenth year of production for General Mills and our business with them has been declining in recent years.
While a very important business to Seneca, our overall profitability exposure declines in this business is fairly modest due to the cost-plus nature of the relationship. Nevertheless, it is having a substantial impact on our reported topline sales.
In fiscal 2011, our General Mills alliance represented 16% of total company sales down from 19% in the prior year. If we look at the various commodities in which we compete, the vegetable side of our business remained profitable, albeit at a lower level from previous years, but the fruit side of our business was in a substantial loss position as everything segment of the business was pressing to move excess product.
It's been a very challenging year in the fruit business as back-to-back large peach crops have saddled us with excess cases which are being sold at discount to actual costs through conventional export and government bid programs. The industry has responded by reducing the amount of acres they're planning on contracting this year which should improve the situation. But in the meantime, the industry remains awash in product.
Some of the issues occurring in the fruit business have also impacted the vegetable business over the past nine months or year. As a result of large packs in 2008 and 2009, Seneca has had inventories of several commodities including the largest one, sweet corn.
As a result, we were promoting very heavily to move through this inventory bubble. This has resulted in reduced earnings on the can side of our business and even losses in our small but growing frozen vegetable business as the company moves significant quantities of frozen corn through the industrial user market at very low prices.
The good news here is that our vegetable inventory situation is significantly improved over the same time last year. Consequently, we are in a much better position to reduce promotional activity and hopefully improve profitability going forward. Some of the business is on annual contracts, of which a few of the contracts don't end all the way until October.
If you look at the balance sheet, you wouldn't necessarily see this improvement in our situation as reported total inventories are up slightly at year end. However, the mix between finished goods and raw materials and supplies have changed as we are carrying more empty cans in steel and other raw materials and less finished goods.
Higher on hand raw materials is not necessarily a bad thing, because there is some significant inflationary pressures going on in our industry and replacement costs for those raw materials are indeed higher.
As we look forward to fiscal 2012, the outlook is for improving performance in the back half of the year, really due to those vegetable inventories being back in line. That improved performance, however, will be on a FIFO basis as the Company is anticipating a large LIFO charge to earnings this year as a result of the rapid inflation we are seeing in produce, steel and fuel.
To give you some perspective, we have many commodities where we are paying more than 50% prices for produce than we did this past pack season. Steel and fuel are also up by double-digit amounts. While we are planning on passing these increases on, it will nevertheless be a challenge given the anticipated LIFO charge.
Over the four years that we have been on LIFO, we have built up a $90 million LIFO reserve. It's been a significant boost to our cash flow but at a cost to reported earnings.
Now, Roland will review the financial performance in more detail.
Roland Breunig - CFO
Thank you, Kraig. As Kraig has already mentioned, fourth quarter fiscal 2011 sales were $279.4 million versus $253 million a year ago. This $26.4 million or 9.4% decrease was attributable to a $15.8 million decrease in unit volume and a $10.6 million decrease in sales price and mix.
Volume decreases were primarily attributable to our branded can vegetable channel which was impacted, as Kraig said, by strong third-quarter volume improvements and by a late Easter season. The quarter's price mix decrease was primarily attributable to our private label category as we continued to focus on moving inventory.
Fourth-quarter frozen product sales improved by $16.1 million versus prior year caused by strong volume that was helped by our August 2011 Lebanon acquisition and by improved selling prices.
Fourth-quarter sales to General Mills decreased by $8.4 million which included an unfavorable price adjustment under our cost plus alliance program.
USDA sales increased by $4.6 million versus the fourth quarter fiscal 2010. For the full year fiscal 2011, sales were $1.195 billion versus $1.28 billion in fiscal 2010. The $85.5 million decrease, which was 6.7% from prior year was attributable to a $59.2 million reduction in selling price and sales mix and a $26.3 million reduction in sales volume.
As discussed in previous earnings calls, fiscal 2011 sales prices and mix had been adversely affected by heavy trade promotion and aggressive pricing as we have worked through some inventory level issues and have dealt with the recession's effect on consumer demand.
The year-over-year reduction in volume was attributable to our General Mills and snack businesses which was more than offset -- I'm sorry, which more than offset strong growth in our frozen product sales volume. General Mills sales decreased $48.1 million from the prior year due primarily to lower pea and corn packs in the summer and fall harvest period.
Snack sales decreased by $10.7 million due to the loss of a cold pack customer. For the year, USDA sales increased by about $10 million or 28% from the prior year.
As noted, sales have been adversely affected by promotional spending which we deduct from sales when we report net sales.
For fiscal 2011, promotion spending was an increase of $18.7 million or 29.9% versus prior year. The year-over-year increase was highest at the beginning of the fiscal year and has improved during each successive quarter.
Fourth quarter fiscal 2011 promotional spending was $6 million or 27% less than fourth-quarter 2010.
Regarding LIFO, we had a $1 million credit in the fourth quarter fiscal 2011 versus a $2.2 million credit in fourth quarter fiscal 2010. For the fiscal year, we had a $7.9 million LIFO credit in fiscal 2011 versus an $11.2 million LIFO charge in the prior year reflecting a reduction in input costs throughout much of the current fiscal year. As Kraig mentioned, we do not expect this to continue in fiscal 2012 due to anticipated input cost increases.
Fourth quarter fiscal 2011 gross margin was 5.7% of sales versus 9.7% of sales a year ago. Fiscal 2011 gross margin was 7.8% of sales compared to 11.7% a year ago. Now if for comparative purposes we look at gross margins on a FIFO basis, fourth-quarter gross margin was 5.3% in fiscal 2011 versus 8.9% in fiscal 2010 while fiscal year gross margin was 7.1% in fiscal 2011 compared to 12.6% in fiscal 2010.
Selling expenses as a percent of sales increased from 3.4% in the fourth quarter fiscal 2010 to 3.5% in fourth quarter 2011 due to a decreased sales level, but were flat at 2.9% for the fiscal years of 2010 and fiscal 2011.
General and administrative expenses as a percent of sales increased from 2.2% in fourth quarter fiscal 2010 to 2.6% in the fourth quarter again due to decreased sales but were flat at 2.2% for the fiscal years. Overall, selling, general and administrative expenses decreased from 5.7% in fourth quarter fiscal 2010 to 6.1% in fourth quarter 2011 but again were flat at 5.1% for the full years.
As we have previously disclosed, the Company recorded a plant restructuring cost of about $1.4 million in fiscal 2011 related to workforce reductions at several locations. These charges were primarily recorded in the third quarter. No restructuring charges were incurred in fiscal 2010.
The Company recorded other operating income of $0.8 million in fiscal 2011 versus other operating expense of $0.2 million in fiscal 2010. The 2011 other operating income was primarily attributable to a $0.7 million gain on the Lebanon acquisition required to be recognized under purchase accounting rules.
Interest expense decreased by $0.2 million in the fourth quarter and by $0.8 million for the fiscal year compared to their respective periods a year ago. This was due to interest savings from a $32.1 million debt retirement in the fourth quarter fiscal 2010 which were offset by higher average borrowings on the line of credit during fiscal 2011.
Average line of credit borrowings increased by approximately $5.2 million in the first quarter and by approximately $24.4 million for the year compared to the respective periods a year ago. The line of credit was used to fund the $32.1 million debt retirement as well as the $20.3 million Lebanon acquisition in August 2010.
The Company's fourth quarter effective tax rate increased from 26.1% in fiscal 2010 to 43.9% in fiscal 2011. The spike in the higher fourth-quarter 2011 effective rate was due to the Company's pretax loss in the quarter and changes in some tax provision estimates. On a year-to-date basis, our effective tax rate decreased from 35.8% in fiscal 2010 to 24.7% in fiscal 2011 due primarily to favorable settlements of IRS audits for 2006, 2007 and 2008 tax years.
Due to the reasons covered, the Company did incur a net loss of $1.9 million in the fourth quarter fiscal 2011 versus net income of $6.3 million in fourth quarter fiscal 2010. For the year, the Company reported net income of $17.7 million in fiscal 2011 versus $48.4 million in fiscal 2010.
LIFO basic and diluted loss per share was $0.15 and $0.15 respectively in the fourth quarter fiscal 2011 versus earnings per share of $0.52 and $0.51 respectively in fourth quarter fiscal 2010. For the year, LIFO basic and diluted earnings per share were $1.45 and $1.45 respectively in fiscal 2011 compared to $3.98 and $3.96 respectively in fiscal 2010.
Our fourth quarter fiscal 2011 LIFO credit of $1 million increased diluted earnings per share by $0.05 whereas the fourth quarter fiscal 2010 LIFO credit of $2.2 million increased diluted earnings per share by $0.11. For the years, the fiscal 2011 LIFO credit of $7.9 million increased diluted EPS by $0.42 while the fiscal 2010 LIFO charge of $11.2 million reduced diluted EPS by $0.60.
On a FIFO basis, fourth-quarter diluted EPS was a $0.20 loss in fiscal 2011 versus earnings of $0.40 last year and full-year diluted EPS was $1.03 this year compared to $4.56 a year ago.
EBITDA decreased from $16.7 million in fourth quarter fiscal 2010 to $4.6 million in fourth quarter fiscal 2011 primarily due to the $10.6 million reduction in sales price mix and a $1.2 million decreased LIFO credit. For the year, EBITDA decreased from $106.7 million in fiscal 2010 to $54.4 million in fiscal 2011 due primarily to the $59.2 million reduction in sales price mix and an increase in operating costs that was partially offset by a $19.2 million decrease in the LIFO charge.
Free cash flow, which is defined as cash from operations less CapEx was $46.6 million for fourth quarter fiscal 2011 versus $87.9 million for fourth quarter fiscal 2010 reflecting reduced earnings and changes in working capital from the prior year.
For the year, free cash flow was negative $2.5 million in fiscal 2011 compared to a positive $17.3 million in fiscal 2010. This was primarily due to the reduced earnings between the years.
Inventory, as Kraig said, is virtually flat. At the end of 2011, inventory was $455.2 million versus $446.5 million a year ago.
CapEx was $3.9 million during the fourth quarter fiscal 2011 and $6.1 million during fourth quarter fiscal 2010. For the year fiscal 2011, CapEx was $19.5 million versus $20.8 million for fiscal 2010.
Finally, the Company's $250 million line of credit is scheduled to mature in August 2011. We are in the process of negotiating a replacement line of credit that is expected to be in place prior to the August maturity date. Although it is subject to change, the agreement being negotiated provides for a five-year term, a $250 million facility that is seasonally adjusted to $350 million and interest based upon an agreed-upon LIBOR base spread.
Now I would like to turn it back over to Kraig for concluding comments.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Thanks, Roland. All in all as we work through one of these downturns in our business that periodically occur, we remain very well positioned to succeed. It takes time to work through the excess inventories once they occur since we are only packing our products once per year and subject to the fickle finger of mother nature. Periods like this are difficult and require some patience.
But our company was profitable in 2011 and we expect to emerge from this period stronger than ever.
With that, we would be happy to answer any questions.
Operator
(Operator Instructions). Bruce Baughman, Franklin Templeton.
Bruce Baughman - Analyst
A couple of questions. What is the planned CapEx for 2012?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
We don't actually do any projections, Bruce, but I can tell you that historically CapEx and depreciation have pretty much matched, been pretty close to one another, and we don't expect that to change.
Bruce Baughman - Analyst
All right. Do you -- can you say anything about the outlook for GMOL sales in 2012?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, I think there has been a fairly consistent trend with General Mills. They have taken the approach that they are willing to forgo market share for profits in the past, and there isn't anything that would lead us to believe that that will change in the future.
Bruce Baughman - Analyst
Okay. Do you anticipate any covenant changes in the new financing agreement you are negotiating?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
There will be some changes to the covenants. It is a whole new agreement. It is five years after the last one we did, but we are -- we don't -- we are in the process of negotiating it and so it is difficult for us to get into significant detail. But we feel very good about where we stand in the process of putting a new agreement together.
Bruce Baughman - Analyst
Okay, but you made some comments about looking for better results in the second half of the coming fiscal year as least before LIFO effects. Do you anticipate being able to show any kind of meaningful net reduction in debt?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, it depends on how you look at that, because we have got significantly higher costs coming into this pack season so our borrowings will actually be going up on a seasonal basis.
Roland Breunig - CFO
Price increases.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Yes, we are going to be taking up but the fact of the matter is as we -- our cash flow projections, we have got scheduled long-term debt repayments, but they are fairly modest this year.
Roland Breunig - CFO
There is really nothing -- no debt repayments of significance looming for a year or so.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Yes, but we will be generating cash if our profits return more than this past year.
Bruce Baughman - Analyst
Okay, all right, I will get back in line. Thank you.
Operator
Bryan Spillane, Bank of America Merrill Lynch.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Good morning. Just I guess the first question is just can you, Kraig, can you talk a little bit about as you are I guess contemplating price increases, just what you are expecting to see at retail? And I guess the reason why I ask is there a lot of food companies, most food companies are raising prices and we are seeing that now actually begin to show up on the shelf price, and the demand elasticity so far actually it hasn't been that bad.
So I guess my question is do you think that you will see a lot of the higher pricing -- I guess at least initially in vegetables show up all the way at the shelf? Or are -- what are you thinking in terms of volume elasticity?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
I think that there is certainly a high probability that it will show up at shelf. But the fact of the matter is we sell our products, let's just say 24 cans in a case, and so $1 increase in the case cost, which is substantial for us in percentage terms only reflects a $0.04 increase at the shelf level per unit.
And so we have the experience of a similar situation back in 2008 with the ethanol crisis and a substantial increase in prices, we weren't -- we basically were able to pass those on at that point in time. And then in turn the consumer really did not slow their demand to any significant degree in our products.
And then this year I think we are kind of looking at the same -- our pricing then has gone back down again as a result of the inventory bubble and we are looking at similarly sized increases as we saw back into 2008 and 2009.
So I feel pretty confident that there won't be that much price elasticity of demand with respect to our products. Our products generally are still significantly less expensive than other alternatives out there, albeit fresh produce or other foods that people will be eating, fresh or processed fruits and vegetables tend to be a very good bargain on putting on a plate.
Roland Breunig - CFO
And that price gap has actually widened. I mean I would think it puts from a retailer's perspective, it gives you -- it gives the category more flexibility I guess to price up with more general inflation.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Yes, I mean the $64,000 question is always that magic price point of $1 a can on vegetables. And generally, Private Label has been below $1 a can and I believe will remain under $1 a can in most cases and certainly on promotion will be. I think things slow down a little bit once you get to be over $1 a can.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, and Kraig, on fruit, you mentioned that there are still inventory there for the industry. Just how far along do you think the industry is in terms of getting it balanced?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, I can't speak for the industry, I can only speak for Seneca.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
And I think Seneca has worked hard this year to get its inventories in line. You can look at published USDA data that shows where our competitors and ourselves have been bidding and how well we have done with USDA bids.
I believe that -- I mean certainly Seneca still has excess fruit that we need to move and that is just a fact. It's -- we have made progress but we have more to go. It really depends somewhat on what happens with Mother Nature this year in California on the size of the pack. But I feel that we are past the worst of it, because significant amounts of trees have been pulled out of the ground last year, in the last two years actually and reduced amount of product is going to be packed by the industry, based on published reports by Industry Association.
So I think progress is being made but I can't really speak to where our competitors stand with respect to us.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, and then in terms of I guess a follow-up to the last question or about the covenants, will you end up -- do you think you will end up with a higher interest rate? Do you think you will end up with a higher rate than the last loan agreement?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, we published over the last five years our spread over LIBOR which was 100.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Right.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
In our published documents and the markets have moved up since then. So we do expect to be paying more than that number. How much more, we are not prepared to discuss.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
And when will that -- when will that actually happen?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, we are working with our lenders right now. The facility matures in August, and we have absolutely no concern whatsoever about putting a new facility in place.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Okay, okay.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
None whatsoever, and we don't -- if you want some flavor, we do not expect it to be punitive in terms of the terms and conditions if that is what people's concern is.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, no, that's helpful. And then, I just want to make sure I heard correctly, you do expect that your operating cash flow should be better in this coming fiscal year than it was in the past -- in fiscal 2011?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
We certainly hope so and I indicated that with the new pack season and some of the things that are going on out there that we are anticipating improved profitability. And if our CapEx is going to be similar in terms of dollars to prior years, then you would expect to see significantly improved cash flow.
Roland Breunig - CFO
And I think along the lines of what Kraig mentioned earlier, if we use perhaps the 2008 ethanol issue as a template, we were out there then and are now in terms of passing some price -- anticipated cost increases along. There is a delay in the payments that we make to the growers because growers are paid after the pack, so that should help our margins a bit as well and cash flow.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
If I remembered it right, in your fiscal '09, it was the way it flowed, you saw more -- we saw more of the price increases flow through beginning like in your fiscal second, third and fourth quarters then in the fiscal first quarter?
Roland Breunig - CFO
Right. There tends to be a bit of a delay in those costs actually hitting the cost of sales line. You are right, and it is roughly maybe half a year or so.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, and that is just a function of --
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
But also keep in mind, Bryan, that we have some annual contracts that we are living with in a loss position that many of which allow right up until the end of the new pack. So as I say, I wouldn't anticipate improvement until the back half of the year.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, okay. And then one last one just in terms of -- and correct me if I am wrong -- I guess I assume that in the fruit business there has been a higher proportion of export and government contracts as you try to move -- as you have moved your excess inventory and once that rebalances, you ought to have a more normal mix of revenues, right? So it will be less of it will go to those governments and maybe more value channels? Is that right?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
That's correct, and we have owned this business since 2006, and we have seen years where inventory has been tight and the Company was very profitable and the food business. And then just back-to-back big peach packs. We are talking about above budget packs which the whole industry essentially had to deal with. And so it's just going to take a little bit of time, but we have been in fruit and vegetable processing for many, many, many years and we have seen cycles and we have a full understanding of how they play out and we are subject to Mother Nature, but we just ride them out, work through the excess inventories and continue to reinvest our cash back into the business to try to lower costs.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay, and then if I could just sneak one more in. Kraig, just given how much stress there has been in the industry, is it -- have you seen or are you seeing maybe more opportunities for acquisitions now?
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Well, we don't talk about acquisition activity in the prospective future but there is no question there has been a lot of stress. If you just look at our own financial performance and we are a large player. Everybody, I would assume, has been put in the same position and there is no question there is stress in the industry. And we are all looking forward with hopefully improved performance on a go forward basis. But again, it depends somewhat on mother nature and inventories.
Bryan Spillane - Analyst
Okay. All right, well, Kraig, Rolly, thanks for taking the questions and enjoy your holiday weekend.
Roland Breunig - CFO
Thanks, Bryan.
Operator
(Operator Instructions). I am showing no further questions.
Kraig Kayser - President and CEO
Okay, well thank you very much. Appreciate your time this morning.
Roland Breunig - CFO
So long.
Operator
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your participation in today's conference. This concludes the program. You may all now disconnect. Thank you and have a nice day.