Nutex Health Inc (NUTX) 2024 Q3 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

  • Greetings and welcome to Nutex Health Inc third quarter, 2024 financial results conference call at this time, all participants are in a listen-only mode, a question and answer session will follow the formal presentation. (Operator instruction). It is now my pleasure to introduce your host, Vivian Sanders. Thank you. You may begin.

  • Vivian Sanders - Director of Marketing & Business Development

  • Good morning and welcome to New Tech Health Inc third quarter earnings call for the period ended September 30th 2024. My name is Vivian Sanders and I will be your moderator for today's call. We appreciate your participation and interest in our company. Today's call is being recorded. With me this morning is our Chairman and CEO, Dr. Tom Vo, CFO, Jon Bates; President, Dr. Warren Hosseinion; and COO, Josh DeTillio. Our team will provide some prepared remarks and then we'll take questions.

  • Before I turn the call over to Dr. Vo, let me remind everyone that today's call may contain forward-looking statements that are based on management's current expectations, numerous risks, uncertainties and other factors that may cause actual results to differ materially from those that might be expressed today. More information on forward-looking statements and these factors are listed in Thursday's press release and in our various SEC filings.

  • On this morning's call, we may reference measures such as adjusted EBITDA, which is a non-GAAP financial measure. A table providing supplemental information on adjusted EBITDA and reconciling net loss attributable to Nutex Health, Inc. is included in the press release and Form 10-K filed earlier this week. This morning's call is being recorded, and a replay of the call will be available later today. With that, I'll now turn the call over to Dr. Tom Vo, our Founder and Chief Executive Officer.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Thank you, Vivian and thank you all for joining us today. We are pleased to report another excellent quarter for Nutex Health. In the third quarter of 2024 we achieved substantial revenue growth as well as volume growth and continued to show our commitment to enhancing profitability and operational efficiency.

  • I would like to start with some highlights from this quarter. For the three months ended, September 30th 2024. We reported total revenue of $78.8 million which is a significant increase compared to $62.7 million for the same period last year. This equates to a growth of 26%. Some of this growth was due to the four new hospitals that we opened in 2023. The rest were from mature hospitals which are those open prior to December 31st 2021 which had revenue increase of 20.7% during the same period.

  • On the net income side, we incurred a loss, a net loss attributable to Newtek's health of $8.8 million. As compared to a net loss of $5.5 million in the third quarter of 2023. This $8.8 million amount does include a $6.7 million non cash loss on warrant liability, as well as a $2 million non cash stock based compensation expense are just at EBITDA on the other hand, was $13.5 million positive for this quarter compared to just $1.3 million from one year ago, an increase of 938% in terms of cash flow as of September 30th 2024 we've reported net cash from operating activities of $23.1 million as compared to cash from the same time last year of $3 million.

  • An increase of 670%. From a debt perspective our total long term debt remains low at $26.8 million compared to $26.3 million for the same period last year. Our finance lease liabilities which we are required to report due to GAAP. Accounting policies did increase slightly from $213 million to $241 million. This is mainly due to new leases that were signed for facilities opening within the past nine months.

  • From a patient perspective, our hospital division reported 41,668 visits in the third quarter, reflecting a 11% 11.3% increase over the same quarter. Last year of this visit growth, mature hospitals increased by 3.8% in 2024. Compared to the same period in 2023 I would like to take a moment to share some insights regarding our operational performance that is responsible for these positive results.

  • First, I want to emphasize that the achievements we reported we reported today are not just numbers that reflect the dedication and hard work of our team across all levels of the organization. The growth we have experienced in both revenue and patient volume is a testament to our commitment to delivering exceptional health care throughout our micro hospitals as well as population health divisions.

  • Second, our recent opening of four De Novo hospitals in 2023 have all ramped up nicely and contributed to this positive trend. Our mature hospitals are also growing are also showing robust growth in both outpatient and inpatient services. Our ability to adapt to the needs of our patients is key to our ongoing success.

  • Third, our internal coding billing and collections department operationally are getting more experience in working the no surprises Act or NSA claims adapting to specific nuances and solving complex problems in dealing with insurers post NSA.

  • As a result, we are seeing better reimbursement per patient. Looking forward, we are focused on a few strategic initiatives that we believe will drive continued growth. First, continue the NOVO expansions of new hospitals. We are still on track to open between 2 to 4 hospitals per year for 2024. We have already opened hospitals in Green Bay, Wisconsin as well as Post Falls, Idaho. We are on track to open two more facilities later this year.

  • Yes, it takes about 18 to 24 months to open a hospital. We are already working on the 2025, 2026 and 2027 hospital pipeline. We still get requests from all over the country to open these hospitals on a regular basis. Our challenge is to keep up with the demands in areas of the country that have the most immediate need for our brand of medicine and focus on those opportunities for our future pipelines.

  • Second, continue expansion of services for our mature hospitals. We will continue to explore opportunities to expand both our inpatient side as well as outpatient services to meet the evolving needs of our patient population. This may include adding new specialties or enhancing our current offerings all aimed at providing concierge level care closer to home by having a licensed hospital consisting of a 24/7 emergency room as well as inpatient services. We have all the tools necessary to pivot to service lines that are lacking or underserved. In the communities that we serve and actively try to fill that void to provide the maximum value to the community.

  • Third, continue to work with insurers for better reimbursement as we continue to learn more and more about the No Surprises Act, we are slowly getting better reimbursements as evident in our improved financials. We continually strive to obtain fair in network contract with insurers.

  • If this is not possible, we make serious attempts to get a fair qualified payment amount or QPA from the insurers if we do not get a fair QPA and described in the NSA by laws. The first time we proceed with the independent dispute resolution or IDR which includes both the open negotiation as well as arbitration process options.

  • The IDR is a formal process that is available to all providers under the guidelines of the NSA. As we proceed with putting more chart through the through the ID R process, we will continue to report our finding in future reports.

  • Fourth, operational efficiency, improving operational efficiency remains a priority as it allows us to manage cost effectively. While enhancing patient experience, we are implementing best practices across our facilities to streamline processes, reduce waste and improve turnaround times for our patients. Josh Dillio, our COO will address this in further details later.

  • Fifth, innovation and technology, we remain committed to embracing advanced technologies that can improve patient care and operational efficiencies whether it's through electronic medical records, telemedicine capabilities artificial intelligence to automate our coding billing collection services or other digital tools. We aim to leverage innovation and provide enhanced services to our patients. As more technology becomes available, we are able to treat more and more patients at our micro hospitals, providing patient an attractive alternative to the often overcrowded hospital systems.

  • And lastly driving awareness and community engagement, we will continue to engage with our local communities to raise awareness of the services that we provide. By focusing on targeted business development, marketing, brand awareness and community events. We hope to build trust and maintain a strong presence within our regions.

  • Overall, we're optimistic about our trajectory and believe that our focused approach will lead to sustainable growth and value creation. The health care landscape is constantly changing and we are committed to staying ahead of these changes.

  • In closing, I would like to acknowledge and thank you to all our new tech physicians, nurses, technologists, technicians, front desk personnel, administrators, and the entire new tech corporate team from over 13 states are working as one unit to achieve these great results.

  • We all share and believe in the same vision and mission of new tech health and are all aligned to continue to strive to create a long term and profitable company. Anyone that has been involved in health care for a long time will recognize that what new tech health is doing is very unique and very special and fills a definite void in many aspects of medicine.

  • We believe our momentum will continue and we are excited about what the future holds for new tech health. Now, I would like to turn it over to John Bates, our Chief Financial Officer to discuss our financial results in greater detail.

  • Jon Bates - Chief Financial Officer

  • Thank you, Tom and good morning, everyone. It's great to see how our financial results reflect the effectiveness of our strategic initiatives and operational improvements.

  • Our third quarter, 2024 results showed yet another great operational quarter continuing the great quarter improvement in each of the last three quarters this year, we have seen continued growth with the with increased success in both top line growth as well as in our cost controls company wide. So let's start with the third quarter ended September 30th 2024 1st and compare those results to the third quarter ended September 30th of 2023

  • For the third quarter of 2024 our total revenue grew 26% or $16.1 million to $78.8 million versus $62.7 million for the same period in 2023 of the total revenue increase, mature hospitals which are hospitals were open prior to December 31st of 2021 and therefore provided two full years of comparative results increased their revenue by 20.7% for the third quarter, 24 versus third quarter, 23 for hospital division visits. We saw growth as well during the quarter as they increased by 11.3% or 4,225 visits to 41,668 visits in the third quarter, 2024 versus 37,443 visits in the same period of 2023 with mature hospitals growing at 3.8% in the third quarter of 24 over the third quarter of 23.

  • Additionally, the population health division had a revenue reduction of a million dollars to $7.1 million in the third quarter of 24 from 8.1 in the similar period of 23 due to the divesture of two small entities within the division in the 2nd and 3rd quarters of this year.

  • Now we discussed the growth in the hospital revenue and visits we have seen in the third quarter of 24. Now let's discuss the overall facility and corporate cost structure and the improvements in that area.

  • Total facility level operating costs and expenses represented only 72.2% or $56.9 million of total revenue for the third quarter of 24 versus 88.7% or $55.7 million for the same period in 23. As a result of the revenue and facility cost improvement our 2024 3rd quarter gross profit was $21.9 million or 27.8% of total revenue as compared to $7.1 million or 11.3% of total revenue in 2023. A 210% improvement in the third quarter of 24 over 23.

  • From a corporate and other cost perspective, the general and administrative expenses as a percentage of total revenue for the third quarter of 2024 remain consistent at 12.5% compared to 12.4 for the same period in 23.

  • Additionally, on our third quarter income statement, you'll see a line, a line item for stock based compensation with the amount for the third quarter of 2024 being $2 million. Most of that expense is explained in a third quarter 10-Q filing which is within note 11 for your reference. But within that note, we explain that under the terms of four separate contribution agreements for hospitals that were deemed to be under con under development hospitals when New tech went public in April of 2022 when each of the hospitals at that point. So, at that one, when each of the hospitals have been open for two full years, they are then eligible to receive a one-time additional issuance of common stock based upon the earnings of the hospital in the 2nd year of their operations, which we denote as the earnout period

  • With four of these hospitals now entering that earn out period, we began to accrue for the potential earn out for each and in the third quarter of 2024 that amounted to two point or $2.2 million that will be true up each quarter. And until we get to the end of year two for each hospital, at which time, the final calculation will be done and payment will be made 100% in company stock and reported as a non cash stock compensation expense.

  • With regard to the population health division as mentioned previously, we did divest two smaller entities in the 2nd and 3rd quarters of 2024 that had very little impact on the operational side of the population health business as we move forward but did impact population health revenue by around a million dollars in the third quarter as we discussed when it comes to operating income including operating income, which did include the negative impact of that $2 million of non cash stock based compensation expenses noted above for the third quarter of 2024 was $9.7 million compared to an operating loss of 821,000 in Q3 of 23 representing a $10.5 million improvement quarter over quarter.

  • Now net loss attributable to new Tech Inc was $8.8 million for the third quarter of 24 as tom mentioned but was negatively impacted by $8.7 million for the two non cash items noted above for the $6.7 million non cash loss on warrant liability and the $2 million non cash stock based compensation expense.

  • The comparative net loss attributable to new tax was $5.5 million for the third quarter of 2023. So removing the effect of the $8.7 million of non cash items in the third quarter of 24 would show a $5.6 million improvement quarter over quarter from 23 all the way to 24.

  • Now adjusted EBITDA attributable to new tech, which did remove the effect of those two non-cash impairments noted above increased $12.2 million or 938% from $1.3 million in the third quarter of $23 to $13.5 million in the second quarter excuse me, third quarter of 2024.

  • So now on to the nine months into September 30 to 24 compared to the nine months into 23 total revenue for the first nine months of 24 grew by 25% or $44.3 million to $222.3 million versus $178 million for the first nine months of 23 of the total revenue increase. Mature hospitals increased their revenue by 13.5% for the first nine months of 2024. Versus the same period in 23 the hospital division visits saw a similar growth as they increased by 19.6% or 20,146 visits to 122,944 visits in the first nine months of 24 versus 102,798 visits in the same period in 23 with mature hospital visits growing at 7.7% in the nine months in September 24 versus that same period in 23.

  • Additionally, population health division had a revenue growth of 2.1% to $23 million in the first nine months at 24 from $22.5 million in the same period in 23. Despite the divestiture of the two small entities within the division during the 2nd and 3rd quarters, as mentioned previously.

  • In addition to the revenue visit growth noted above facility and corporate level costs also showed improvement for the first nine months of 24 compared to the first nine months of 23 total facility level operating costs and expenses represented 75.4% or $167.7 million of total revenue for the nine months ended September 2024 versus 87.9% or $156.4 million for the same period in 23. So, it represented a decrease of 12.5% in relation to into revenue. The gross profit for the nine months ended September 2024 was $54.6 million or 24.6% of total revenue as compared to $21.6 million or only 12% of total revenue in the same period in 23 which represented 153% increase for the nine months ended September 24 compared to the same period in 23.

  • From a corporate and other cost perspective. The G&A expenses as a percentage of total revenue for the nine months ended September of 2024 decreased to 13.1% or just $29.2 million from 13.9% or $24.7 million for the same period in 2023.

  • And operating income for the nine months ended September 30th 2024 was a positive $16.4 million compared to an operating loss of $5.6 million for the nine months ended September of 2023. Net loss attributed to new tech inc improved by $4.7 million from a loss of $4.2 million in the first nine months of 2023 to a loss of $9.5 million in the first nine months of 2024. Even with four non cash expense items related to stock comp expense, the impairment of assets, impairment of goodwill and the loss on warrant liability, as you'll see in our income statement and, and those negatively impacting this loss by $10.2 million. So we're moving these four non cash items.

  • The company would show net income attributable to netting to new tech Health Inc for the nine month period of a slight positive number of six, just over $600,000 adjusted EBITDA attributable to new text which removed the effect of the four non cash impairment items noted above increased $22.4 million or 290% from $7.7 million in the first nine months of 2023 to $30.1 million in the first nine months of 24.

  • Enough about the income statement on our balance sheet. As you can see, the balance sheet remains very strong with cash and cash equivalents at the end of September of 2024 at $46.9 million, up $24.9 million or 113.2% from $22 million as of December 31st 2023.

  • With regard to cash flow net cash from operating activities increased by $20.1 million for the nine months ended September 30th of 24 to $23.1 million as compared to only $3 million for the same period in 2023.

  • On the liability side, our total bank equipment debt decreased by 570,000 to $41.9 million at seven at September 30th of 2024. Down from $42.4 million at December 31st of 2023. With the majority of this debt related to equipment loans at our hospitals for such items as MRI x-rays, ultrasounds CT machines.

  • And this is a slight decrease from year end. But the overall balance is a relatively small amount of true operating debt for a company of our size. And so outside of this normal 40 plus million dollars of bank equipment type debt, the only other items of materiality that look like debt on the balance sheet are the liabilities related to financing and operating lease liabilities which are just the future lease payments to our landlords on our hospitals.

  • Now, these are reflected on the balance sheet because the accounting rules require us to aggregate all lease payments that we pay to a landlord for the entirety of each lease, which in our case could be anywhere between 15 to 20 years and then present value the total lease payments for each of those leases back to the inception of the lease and record both the right of use asset and correspondingly a right of use liability on the balance sheet. For that result.

  • As a result, on our balance sheet at September 30th, 2024, the net asset balance for the operating and financing right of use assets amounted to $209.9 million, which is roughly 48% of the total assets and the net liability balance for the operating and financing right of use liabilities amounted to $262.5 million which is 73.2% of total liabilities.

  • So now most investors and analysts don't view this right of use assets and right use liabilities as real operating debt. So, I wanted to clarify that to you since we seem to get that question a lot. With that now I'll turn it over to Warren to discuss more about the population health business.

  • Warren Hosseinion - President, Director

  • Thank you John and good morning everyone. I'd like to take this opportunity to discuss our population health management division and the results we've seen in the third quarter of 2024. As outlined in our quarterly report, our population health management division is important in our overall strategy at new tech health.

  • As many of you are aware, this division focuses on providing integrated care solutions aimed at improving the health outcomes of our patients. We operate primarily through our networks of independent physician associations or IPH IPAs which are central to our model. For the three months ended September 2024 the Population Health Management division reported total revenue of approximately $7.1 million while this marks a slight decrease compared to the $8.1 million reported in the same period of 2023. It is essential to understand the context behind these numbers.

  • As John mentioned earlier, the decline in revenue is primarily attributed to the sale of two smaller subsidiaries earlier this year. Both of these subsidiaries were unprofitable. Although these divestitures temporarily impacted our top line results, they have enhanced our bottom line and will allow us to concentrate more closely on our core competencies and strategic objectives within the population health base.

  • Adjusting for these divestitures, our core population health management efforts have continued to demonstrate growth. We now manage just over 40,000 patients under value-based care arrangements with multiple payers.

  • The division is focused on enhancing the quality of care provided to our patients while managing risks and costs. This is particularly critical as we navigate an environment that increasingly emphasizes value-based care and population health strategies.

  • One of the key drivers behind our positive trajectory is our emphasis on building relationships with local physicians and health care providers. By fostering these collaborations, we aim to create a robust network that can share resources, expertise and best practices in managing chronic diseases, coordinating care and improving treatment outcomes. This collaborative approach not only adds value to our services, but it enhances patient engagement and continuity of care.

  • Furthermore, we are enhancing the capabilities of our management services organization which enables us to better support our IPAs and physician groups. In line with our focused growth strategy, we are actively working to launch new ITAs and expand our existing ones, thereby increasing the number of patients we serve under our population health framework.

  • This expansion is integral to achieving economies of scale that can translate into improved financial performance over time. As we move forward, we hope that our population Health management initiative will become an even more significant contributor to new tech health revenue mix. The growing focus on preventative care and holistic patient management aligns well with today's health care landscape which increasingly seeks to address not just individual health events but the overall well-being of populations.

  • In conclusion, while the revenue results for the population health management division reflects a temporary decline due to strategic divestitures. The underlying initiatives demonstrate a solid foundation for growth and improvement in our overall business model.

  • I remain optimistic about our ability to drive both patient engagement and financial performance. In this key segment. With that, I will turn it over to Josh now.

  • Josh DeTillio - Chief Operating Officer

  • Thank you, Warren. I appreciate the opportunity to speak with you today about new tech health operational efficiency, cost strategies and growth endeavors during the third quarter of 2024. As many of you know, operational efficiency is critical in our industry as costs have increased significantly for hospitals, especially in labor and supplies. I'm pleased to report that our efforts to control costs while driving volume have yielded significant results so far this year. We've implemented several cost saving measures that have greatly contributed to our operational efficiency. Over the past few quarters, we focused on three primary areas, labor costs, supply chain management and contract services costs. By closely monitoring labor hours and scheduling efficiently. We have successfully optimized staffing without compromising patient care. We are incorporating more software programs to help us become more efficient with labor including and HR and procurement software that went live in the first quarter of this year. A scheduling software which is projected to go live in the first quarter of 2025 and a software solution for labor analytics in the second quarter of 2025.

  • As our volumes grow, we need more tools to optimize our hospitals, and these programs will give us more transparency and metrics to achieve this proactive management of our supply chain has resulted in notable savings and has helped us mitigate inflationary pressures. We have aligned our suppliers and supply contracts with our primary group purchasing organization, our GPO and we are experiencing this alignment to deliver at least a 15% reduction in supply costs for 2025 from a prior year run rate.

  • This savings is on all of our existing hospitals as there will be incremental supply costs for our new hospitals. But new hospitals will also be on the reduced GPO rate, going rates and pricing going forward. In contract services. We continue to standardize where appropriate for discounted in bulk pricing. We're looking at areas like facility maintenance, shredding services, office supplies, DME, waste management and pharmaceuticals. We have executed on a number of initiatives but have more to go. The local hospital teams have continued to renegotiate local contracts as the whole company has been very focused on cost in 2024.

  • In addition to these cost controls, we're seeing increased volume due in part to strategic growth initiatives. As previously mentioned for the first nine months of 2024 the hospital division total visits increased 122,944 which was up 19.6% from 2023 while mature hospitals were up 7.7% in visits.

  • This growth is a direct reflection of both our business development and marketing strategy and the local engagement of our leadership teams across our facilities. Our business development team has been actively pursuing relationships with various local health care providers and groups and working to enhance and grow our mix of services offered. One of the strategies we've developed is utilizing a new customer relationship management software. This program enables us to manage relationships more effectively track engagement with both prospective and existing patients and analyze data to refine our outreach strategies.

  • We've also placed a strong emphasis on community engagement by participating in local health fairs and offering educational seminars on various health topics. We have, we have been able to build strong relationships within the communities we serve. This initiative not only helps in raising awareness about our services but also positions new tech health as a trusted health provider, engaging directly with our community, fosters goodwill and helps drive patient volume through referrals and repeat visits for the whole family.

  • Our leadership teams across the facilities have been pivotal in our success. Empowering our local leaders to make decisions tailored to their community's needs has been an important aspect of our strategy. Their on the ground insights allow us to adapt quickly to demand fluctuations and service needs.

  • This decentralized approach enhances our responsiveness and supports our commitment to delivering quality care. Looking forward we are committed to maintaining this trajectory of growth and operational efficiency. As we expand our footprint by opening new facilities and transitioning existing operations, we will continue to prioritize cost management while ensuring that we meet the health needs of our communities.

  • In summary, our focused strategies in managing costs and driving volume growth combined with strong leadership and community engagement are shaping a promising future for new tech health. Our commitment to operational excellence remains a top priority as we strive to enhance shareholder value while keeping patient care at the forefront of our efforts.

  • I will now turn it back over to our moderator, Vivian to open the line for questions. Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Thank you, Josh. On the call, we have Bill Sutherland from Benchmark Company, as well as Thomas McGovern from Maxim, who will now ask our team their questions.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • I guess I'll, I'll start off. it's Bill. Good quarter. Hey, wanted to think about the fourth quarter a little bit. Thinking about the seasonality as you're seeing it, the timing of the two new hospitals and, particularly interested in kind of how you're seeing patient visits in the fourth quarter. I think you get some positive seasonality as I recall.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • This is Tom, Bill. Yes, I, I could answer this. Definitely our business, does have seasonality to it. Fourth quarter with, being colder flu season typically have higher volume, and that continues through the first quarter and then 2nd and 3rd quarter, it dips a little bit. So for sure, we are expecting a better numbers in the fourth quarter in terms of, of volume.

  • But as you know, this year it's been a little bit a little bit warmer. So, the flu season hasn't been upon us yet but having said that that will come because typically every year it's, it's the same sort of pattern.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • Okay. And your hospitals are going to be, I guess near the end of the quarter. Then the two new ones.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yes, the two new ones, are projected to open in November and December.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • Okay. On the CapEx line, John noticed it's been very, it's been a lot lower this year, year-to-date than last year. What's the outlook for CapEx, I guess going forward? Given your plans?

  • Jon Bates - Chief Financial Officer

  • Yeah, I mean, I think that you'll see that as we certainly would open up the facilities. We will definitely be, be adding more, right. Each, each one of those as we go, we've had two this year and then potentially as Tom indicated two more later in this year.

  • And I think we talked about on average every year, some being in the 2 to 4 range, but I would anticipate that going up a little bit as we go through this process of, of adding that equipment as, as we open each of those, those of those facilities.

  • But right now, everything is pretty much in line, and we have a, you know, real solid opportunity for getting, for getting those in place. And as you probably know, we talked about this before where you have to put some of the equipment in months before something would open. So there's some that you can wait until right around opening.

  • But there's, you know, MRI S and some of those machines, you have to do several months ahead of time. So we have to plan for that. And so we'll continue to watch it, but I think it should be, you know, consistent with a little bit of an uptick. I would anticipate over the next couple quarters in that line.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • Okay. And then last for me, Tom can give us a little more color on the, on your progress with the NSA arbitrations or not just the arbitration but negotiation and I guess the degree to which you, you're taking on more arbitrations, talk about the impacts that that has near term on revenue and then longer term.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah, so from an arbitration standpoint, it's going well, we started the process at the end of June and as you know, it takes about six months or so for the whole process to get completed from beginning to end where if we win on the arbitration side, the money then enters our bank account.

  • So, we're still working on that, and we still have some data that we're still trying to sort out. But so far, the trend is going well. And so far, our results are consistent with the published data out there regarding arbitration. But we will know a lot more hopefully in the fourth quarter when we report and definitely the 1st and 2nd quarter of next year regarding our success and our experience with the arbitration from new tech Health.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • Remind us what the what the data has been. In terms of industry wide think it's been a pretty high success rate, right?

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah. So, industry, the data that's publicly available essentially shows a win rate of roughly 70% to 80% for the provider. And the return that they get is according to published data, almost doubles that of what they get initially. And so that's what the data shows. And so far, once again, our trend is pointing to our similar data, but once again, we're still very early because June was only maybe five months ago and it does take roughly six months or so to get you know, money in the bank.

  • And even after you win the arbitration, the insurance company still has to pay and, you know, the definition of arbitration is that is binding. And so, since we're all kind of new at this, we're still waiting to see what happens even after we win and, and the we get a favorable result as to, you know, what the insurance company actually does with that information.

  • So, and we'll know a lot more hopefully in this quarter and next quarter.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • And let me if I could sneak one more on this, How, what percentage of your claims are you putting into arbitration?

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • From our standpoint between 60% to 80%. Yeah, the what we find is that the insurance company are paying relatively low the first time. And so we, we initiate the process through the IDR process. And then from there we go to open negotiation first and if we can't negotiate, then we go to arbitration. So there's definitely a step wise approach to that process. So you, you just can't create to arbitration, you have to go through open negotiation.

  • Bill Sutherland - Analyst

  • So, the 60% to 70% relates to just going through the entire process, not just arbitration process. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thanks Tom. Thanks everybody.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Hey, guys, this is Tom McGovern with Maxim Group. So, yeah, so first question, going to touch and congrats on the quarter guys. You know, great performance there.

  • So first question going to piggyback on one of the earlier questions asked on the hospital opening. So it sounds like you guys have pretty clear visibility on the two that will open by the end of 2024. Just curious though, I mean, one of the great things about your business model is that you have a lot of levers to pull that, you know, can augment the timeline for, for these openings.

  • So, just curious, is there anything you see now that might push that December opening into 25 or are you fairly confident that it'll occur by the end of the year?

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah. Thomas, thank you for the question and, and welcome, welcome to the, to the team, so to speak. Thank you for joining us. So, to answer the question. So, our first opening in November is pretty certain we already have a licensing from the state. We have a team assembled, we have all the staff trained. And so that opening is, is relatively on track for this month, November.

  • And the second opening, I think to your question is slightly not as certain. And the reason is that it is located in Florida where we had a hurricane and and that push everything back a few weeks with dealing with the hurricane and everything else. And so, in essence, we're still on track to hopefully open by December.

  • But there are a few levers to your point that we have to push in order to make that happen. But we, but we're still very optimistic that we're going to be able to open that. And by the way, the hurricane really did not do any damage to our hospitals. And just a side note, I mean, we've been, we've been in about probably 10 different hurricanes in the past with our operation, Texas, Louisiana and now Florida. And for the most part, our hospitals have fared very, very well. And there's a reason for that. The reason is that for the most part, these hospitals are built to withstand, you know, pretty much anything that nature could stand, could throw at us. And typically the state want these hospitals to be the last structure standing.

  • So that if everything is wiped out, at least the hospital is still open and we could see patients afterwards.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Got you. Glad to hear that you guys. Yeah. No, absolutely. I'm, I'm glad you guys, managed to get to the hurricane relatively unscathed. Okay, so then as we look at 2025 you know, you guys have been staying around four hospital openings, we could expect 2 to 4 per year, but it's looking more like four and 25. Again, you know, considering that you guys have a good deal of influence on the timing of these openings.

  • What should we expect in terms of cadence? Should we expect, you know, maybe a hospital a quarter or do you think that these openings might be weighted to one half of the year? Maybe one of the first three in the second and any kind of visibility on that would be very helpful?

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah. No. We have we have four hospitals planned for 25 also just like in 24. We I think from, in terms of the cadence, the one will open, I would say in the either first or second quarter of 25 and then we should have three at the end of 25.

  • And so all, all four of them are essentially under construction as we speak. And so really, it just depends on construction time.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Got you. Okay. So then, you know, something that was mentioned earlier on the call is driving patient volume, but you guys have seen seem to have done very successfully, particularly. It's great to see that mature hospitals are seeing higher patient volume.

  • So, you know, one of the things you guys called out with was the introduction of new services and capabilities across your portfolio of hospitals. So I'm just curious now, you know, you guys in the past year, just, you know, correct me if there's anything else I'm missing here, but you guys introduced some behavioral health specialties, did substance abuse or, you know, particularly for, for alcohol, I believe abuse disorder. And then you guys have also in the past worked with the va when, when those hospitals are are overrun.

  • So, so it's great to see that your hospitals are very customizable to meet the community needs. I'm curious if across your, your facilities and maybe with some of these new openings, you're seeing different trends in these communities, but have you identified any new services that you're looking to introduce in, in Q4 or 25 or, or any kind of visibility or color you could add on that would be helpful for our, our outlook. Thank you.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah, and just could probably chime in also. But no, we're, we're always trying to innovate. We're always looking for solutions to problems and and the great thing about being in a lot of different localities and different states and different communities is that we see the needs of each of these communities and we try to solve it.

  • And so behavior, health or treating substance abuse, depression, alcohol detox, opiate detox. Those are all as a result of the community reaching out to us and say, hey, can you help us with this? And so with us being a licensed hospital with, you know, pretty much all, most of the tools to do this, you know, we work with our local physicians and nurses to, to pivot to those service lines and try to resolve them as, as best as we can.

  • And so that was sort of like the genesis of of behavior health and some of the other service lines going forward. Once again, we're always innovating, always looking for ways to solve the problems of the community. And so now we're looking at at PI personal injury and taking care of those types of patients. We're looking at wellness, health, things like that.

  • And once again, these are all basically solutions to the community. We're looking at doing more procedures at our hospital in a few states, in a few hospitals were starting to do procedures in our hospital. And so the point is that, you know, because we're able to pivot, we're relatively a flat line organization and so we can move in in many different directions. And our hospital is, you know, think of it like a car, you have a car and we could pivot and drive it in any different direction that we need to just depending on the need of the community and you know, our ability to solve problems and, and create solutions for the communities.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Great. I appreciate that response. Next question is on some of the cost savings that you guys have achieved and then looking forward at how you guys are going to kind of continue this trend as you expand your network. So you guys, Josh called out specifically the labor cost supply chain in the contract services.

  • So, so first just maybe high level, what do you see is something that of those three, what do you think is the, is the greatest opportunity for you guys to further improve your cost structure? And then maybe if you go in a little bit more detail on the labor cost, you mentioned that there were two Software's that were going to be implemented between the fourth quarter and early 25 or maybe it was about 25.

  • So maybe if you could just talk a little bit about that specifically and kind of what you're hoping to achieve by implementing these software services.

  • Josh DeTillio - Chief Operating Officer

  • Sure. Yeah, this is Josh couple things. So, so we really view all three buckets as big opportunities. There's not really one that's more than the others. We've already executed on a number of the items in terms of the labor software. We are creating an entire labor suite where we had, as I mentioned, the HR so and procurement software as well as the next one coming is a scheduling soft where so the teams will be able to schedule their teams more efficiently, communicate better and then really optimize staffing to the volume.

  • And then the last one is a labor analytics metric tool software that we will implement, which will give us a little bit more insight into daily trends and really being able to staff the volumes better. We we already operate our hospitals very from a labor standpoint. So we're already pretty much there, but there are always opportunities to improve there. And as you heard on the supply chain, we're looking at about a 15% reduction and that's really reduced pricing across the board.

  • And then the contract services really leveraging our size and scope to get some of those ones that I mentioned really at national type contracts with significant discounts across the board. So we're continuing to focus on costs.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Got you. I know that that's very helpful. And then my last question will just be on the variable interest entities. So you guys discussed and explained on the call. You know, why you have to carry some of those on your balance sheet. You guys were successful in removing 18 variable interest entities, your balance sheet through discussions with lenders. And I know that there were two last time we spoke, there were two still on your balance sheet and you guys were in active conversations with the lender to remove them.

  • So just curious if there's been any progress on that, if you guys have had any discussion or any indication as to when we could expect those to be removed from the balance sheet.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Yeah. No, we've made a lot of progress in trying to remove those two facilities and, and both of these are in Albuquerque, the two hostels in Albuquerque. And in essence, the bank has already told us that they plan to remove that by the end of the year.

  • So that's, that's where we're at Once again, it's up to the bank, but they have confirmed that that their intention is to remove those by the end of the year. So we'll see what happens hopefully.

  • Thomas McGovern - Analyst

  • Right now that that's all great to hear. I appreciate you guys taking the time to answer all of my questions. And again, congrats on the quarter.

  • Jon Bates - Chief Financial Officer

  • Thanks, Thomas.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Thank you, Thomas and thank you, Bill.

  • Vivian Sanders - Director of Marketing & Business Development

  • Hello. All right. If there are no additional questions for us on behalf of the new tax health management team, we appreciate everyone for dialing in and listening to our third quarter earnings report. A ca a recording of this call will be available on our website for a limited time. If there are any additional questions, please send an email to investors at nutexhealth.com and we will do our best to answer in a timely manner. Take care everyone.

  • Thomas Vo - Chairman of the Board, Chief Executive Officer

  • Thank you, everyone.

  • Operator

  • Thank you. This does conclude today's teleconference. We thank you for your participation. You may disconnect your lines at this time.