Manitex International Inc (MNTX) 2023 Q4 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

  • Greetings. Welcome to the Manitex International Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results Conference Call. (Operator Instructions). I'll now turn the conference over to your host, Paul Bartolai of Investor Relations. You may begin.

  • Paul Bartolai - Investor Relations

  • Thank you. Welcome to Manitex International's Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Results Conference Call. Leading the call today, our CEO Michael Coffey; and CFO, Joseph Doolan; We issued a press release earlier today detailing our fourth quarter and full year 2023 operational and financial results. This release, together with the accompanying presentation materials publicly available in the Investor Relations section of our corporate website at www.manitexinternational.com.

  • I would like to remind you that management's commentary and responses to questions on today's conference call may include forward-looking statements, which by their nature, are uncertain and outside of the company's control. Although these forward-looking statements are based on management's current expectations and beliefs. Actual results could differ materially. For a discussion of some of the factors that could cause actual results to differ, please refer to the Risk Factors section of our latest filings with the SEC.

  • Additionally, please note that you can find reconciliations of historical non-GAAP financial measures in the press release issued earlier today and in the appendix of this presentation.

  • Today's call will begin with prepared remarks from CEO. Michael Coffey; will provide a review of our recent business performance, including an update on the progress we have made on our new elevating excellence initiatives as well as our key priorities for 2024, followed by a financial update and outlook from our CFO, Joseph at the conclusion of these prepared remarks, we will open the line for your questions. With that, I'll turn the call over to Michael.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Thank you, Paul, and good morning, everyone, who's joining us on the call today, our fourth quarter results were a strong finish to a transformative year at Manitex. One year ago, we introduced elevating excellence, a strategy focused on growth, operational efficiency and a disciplined approach to capital allocation in one year of our elevating UPS once we delivered 40% year-over-year growth in adjusted EBITDA, nearly 240 basis points of adjusted EBITDA growth, margin expansion and a significant reduction in our net leverage profile. In a relatively short period of time, we have created a more competitive, more efficient and more profitable organization and we're just getting started.

  • In a few minutes. I will discuss in more detail our accomplishments under our elevating excellence strategy during 2023, as well as our key priorities for 2024. But suffice it to say, I'm very excited about our progress, which enabled us to drive strong results in 2023 and position us for continued success and 2024 and beyond.

  • With that, please turn your attention to page 3 of our presentation. We will begin with the discussion on our fourth quarter highlights. Our fourth quarter performance reflects the second highest quarterly revenue run rate in at least five years, driven by continued strength in our core lifting segment. While revenue was flat versus the prior year, given an elevated prior year comparison, gross margin increased more than 160 basis points, 20.9% in the fourth quarter.

  • Construction activity and demand trends in our North Texas markets remain favorable. In addition, our recently opened branch in Lubbock, Texas continues to ramp up ahead of plan. Our team in Lubbock is quickly building a strong position in that market. At a consolidated level, our fourth quarter adjusted EBITDA margin remained flat versus the prior year at 10.2%, but well above the low single-digit percentage.

  • We delivered pre-pandemic, and we believe the strategic actions taken over the last year have resulted in a structural positive step change and our margin profile for the business as outlined within elevating excellence, we continue to focus on developing a higher-value mix of backlog, one that prioritizes higher margin products and geographies.

  • As we've implemented this approach across the organization, combined with our increased manufacturing velocity, our backlog has declined but this is expected we have discontinued certain products which do not meet minimum margin hurdles. This will strengthen the quality of our backlog, something that we will continue to focus on our current backlog remains three times that of pre-pandemic levels and represents nine months of lifting equipment sales.

  • We are pleased with the visibility that we have entering 2024 and our outlook entering 2024 demand conditions remain strong, and we have been encouraged by the early order confirmations across our core infrastructure, energy and mining market segments, which is supported by healthy indications of interest from various customers as many of our larger dealers are still operating with very limited inventory levels.

  • Looking at some of our key end market trends, the outlook in North American infrastructure market is strengthening due in large part to the stimulus dollars from the infrastructure investment and Jobs Act. This program added over $0.5 trillion in new funding. And while the act was signed in late 2021, we are just beginning to see the majority of these funds benefit. Our markets.

  • Outside of the traditional infrastructure electrical transmission and distribution continues to be a strong growth for us in the US. electrical grid is aged and growing. Energy demands are putting significant pressure on the system. A recent Department of Energy report found that over 70% of transmission lines in the United States were more than halfway through their 50-year useful lifespan. While the average age of large transformers exceeded 40 years.

  • Manitex is well positioned to benefit from the growing investments being made by utilities, and we believe much of the infrastructure spending in the coming years will benefit the business as well as the investment cycle that will continue to drive spending by our customers. Traditional and energy markets and mining activity remains robust. There is still a significant need to invest capital for traditional fossil fuel development and Manitex is benefiting from this trend. Our mining customers have a strong appetite for production and maintenance equipment.

  • This is most visible in Chile where we closed a record year in 2023. The global demand for copper is expected to continue to drive this growth, and we are optimistic with our prospects in Chile, Mexico and Southwestern United States. European markets have similar demands for infrastructure spending to that, that we are seeing in the US. We are expecting stable demand in 2024 with increased growth opportunities for European products from certain Mid East countries and also the Americas.

  • Turning now to a progress update on our elevating excellence strategy and how we are using this framework to guide our business in 2024 and beyond. In 2023. From a high level, we executed on our commercial growth priorities, resulting in share gains within our North South American markets, together with the continued strengthening of our dealership network.

  • From an operational perspective, the progress made in 2023 included new foundations for growth, improved business analytics and have an ability to scale the newly implemented in modern systems. We now have a meaningful runway to continue our improvements and scale that business 2024 and 2025 should be growth years for the company, something that is easier now that we have newer systems to operate with and improved processes.

  • I would like to take a few minutes to update you on our progress with delivering excellence. But first, I want to recognize the talented team at Manitex. We are very fortunate to have these dedicated professionals who are realizing these improvements and bringing creativity and new ideas to the job every day.

  • Please turn your attention to page 5 of our presentation. Let's begin with a few updates on our commercial expansion strategy. During 2023, we repositioned our organization for long-term growth, which included the restructuring of our sales organization and strengthening of our dealer network. We made notable progress growing share in the Americas.

  • This is most notable in further Chile, where we opened a new branch and laid the groundwork for further crane sales expansion. Our Lubbock branch had been delayed earlier in the year, but far outceded its first year sales expectations. The team in Lubbock is now performing at 100%, and we are very pleased with our progress there. We successfully launched new products in 2023. Innovations were introduced within every product group at Manitex, and we look forward to updating the market on further product developments in the coming months.

  • We made good progress on our commercial growth initiatives during 2023. But much of what we accomplished was laying the groundwork for future growth opportunities. Our commercial growth objectives were always more weighted to our 2024 and 2025 in Elevating Excellence, and we are excited about the growth opportunities as we look forward.

  • Let's turn our attention to operational excellence, the second pillar of Elevating Excellence, which is highlighted on Page 6. As you've heard me say on prior calls, 2023 was a year of the process at Manitex. And it was a good year.

  • In 2023. We replaced two of our operating systems and upgraded a third system for businesses now operating on integrated contemporary business processes by design. This will help us reduce costs, increased our production and standardize our processes.

  • These investments were a critical part of our strategy to enable our ability to scale the business and help us attain the margin improvements we are targeting. Manitex is now operating on these new systems. We are positioned for scale, improved responsiveness and better global cooperation.

  • We are pleased that the supply chain pressures that have plagued the industry have continued to ease across our business. We have seen more progress in Europe in 2023, while conditions in the United States have lagged. We fully expect to realize continued global supply chain efficiencies gained in 2024, resulting in reduced costs and additional margin improvements.

  • We have also made tremendous progress on our objective to improve manufacturing velocity, improved unit production and production capacity at our facilities, enabling us to drive growth and improve order fulfillment in 2024 we expect further improvements to our manufacturing velocity. It is important to understand that up till now, all of the increased manufacturing velocity has been accomplished with no additional square footage additions and minimal capital expenditures.

  • We are developing future plans for facility expansions that will propel the growth in the future. But for now, we are focused on a CapEx light model that is well-equipped to support existing customer demand. In combination. These actions positioned us to deliver more than 310 basis points of gross margin expansion enablers, enabling us to exceed 10% adjusted EBITDA margins for the first time.

  • Our third and final pillar of operating excellence is disciplined capital allocation. We highlight this on Slide 7. As we have discussed in 2023, our capital allocation strategy prioritize debt reduction, select investments in organic growth and maintenance capital to support our existing operations. Our short-term goal was to lower our net leverage ratio below three times, but we are very pleased that we exited the year with a net leverage ratio of 2.9 times, down from 3.9 times at the end of 2022,

  • We were able to accomplish this despite the need to maintain higher than normal working capital. This is directly related to supply chain headwinds. We are now seeing opportunities to safely lower these inventory stocks. As Joe will discuss in more detail, we expect this will result in our ability to unlock much of the elevated working capital that we are operating under in 2023, resulting in further debt reduction.

  • In the coming quarters. As part of elevating excellence in our strategy, we introduced three-year financial targets that we detail on slide 8 of the deck. These goals reflecting our confidence in the underlying strength of our end markets and the benefits we expect from the improvements in our operations. Our targets include 25% revenue growth and nearly doubling our EBITDA and EBITDA margin expansion of 300 to 500 basis points range, resulting in 11% to 13% adjusted EBITDA.

  • On Slide 9, we highlight our progress against these targets. And as you can see, we are trending nicely relative to our goals as a result of our strong execution during 2023, we came in ahead of our year-end targets, putting us well on track to achieve these long-term goals. Joe will cover our 2024 financial targets, but we are excited by the continued progress against our goals and are confident that we are on track for another solid year in 2024.

  • We are grateful for the progress made in 2023. These early successes are fueling our resolve and validating that elevating excellence is the right direction for our company. The results in 2023 were strong, but we are really just getting started and many of these initiatives launched in the past year will have multiple year impacts to our performance here forward. We are also grateful for our customers and dealers and expect another year of solid growth as we continue with our margin expansion.

  • With that, I'll turn it over to John.

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • Thank you, Mike, and good morning, everyone. I will provide some additional details on the quarter, give an update on our liquidity and balance sheet and conclude with commentary around our outlook for 2024.

  • Turning to Slide 11. Net revenue for the fourth quarter of '23 was $78.7 million, essentially flat from the very strong fourth quarter results we generated last year. Fourth quarter revenue growth was negatively impacted by a decline of $1.6 million or approximately 2% from lower truck chassis sales, which are largely pass-through revenue items.

  • At this point, the contribution of chassis sales to our overall revenue has stabilized at a more normalized levels, and we don't expect a meaningful comparison issue as we move into 2024 lifting equipment segment revenue was $70.8 million during the fourth quarter, a decrease of 1% versus the prior year period. And as I just discussed, lower truck chassis sales impacted fourth quarter results and lifting equipment segment revenue would have increased about 2% excluding the chassis sale. While the difficult comparison impacted the reported growth, our lifting equipment business continued to benefit from end market strength as well as improved throughput in manufacturing facilities.

  • Rental equipment segment revenue was $7.9 million in the fourth quarter '23, supported by strong end market demand in key North Texas markets, including contributions from our Lubbock, Texas location, which opened in March of '23. We continue to see the activity in our Lubbock facility, grow and volumes have remained strong in recent months.

  • While we took a bit of a pause related to fleet expansion in 2023, we expect to put capital towards new fleet expenditures in 2024 and expect to see continued strength in our rental business, owing to the favorable demand trends in our key markets and strong execution as of December 31st, total backlog was $170 million, down from $230 million a year ago, driven by increased production velocity. The shift in focus to higher-margin products and geographies that Mike discussed and some modest weakness in certain verticals that are more exposed to the elevated interest rates.

  • Our backlog ended the quarter with North America representing approximately 60% of the total and international, the remaining 40%, as Mike discussed, while our backlog is down from last year, our overall business momentum remains strong and our current backlog remains at roughly nine months of sales, which is a very healthy level and gives us good visibility into 2024.

  • Gross profit was $16.4 million during the fourth quarter of '23, up from $15.2 million during the prior year period or an increase of 8%. The increase in gross profit was a result of increased manufacturing throughput, pricing benefits and more favorable mix.

  • As a result of these factors, gross profit margin increased 160 basis points, 20.9% during the fourth quarter SG&A expense for the fourth quarter was $10.8 million, up modestly from $10.1 million for the same period last year. R&D expense was $0.9 million during the fourth quarter, flat from the prior year period. We are pleased to be able to maintain our operating expense levels despite the revenue growth and investments that we are making in the business.

  • Operating income was $4.8 million during the quarter compared to $4.2 million for the same period last year for an increase of 14%. Operating margin in the fourth quarter was 6.1%, up 80 basis points from last year. The year-over-year improvement in operating income was driven by the improved gross margin performance and operating leverage.

  • Adjusted EBITDA was $8 million for the fourth quarter or 10.2% of sales, which is essentially flat from the same period last year. Net income was $5.2 million or $0.26 per diluted share for the fourth quarter compared to net income of $500,000 or $0.02 per share for the same period last year. Net income for the fourth quarter of '23 includes a benefit related to the reversal of an income tax valuation allowance.

  • Adjusted net income was $6.3 million or $0.31 per diluted share in the fourth quarter of 23, up from adjusted net income of $1.8 million, or $0.09 per diluted share for the same period last year. Adjusted net income for the fourth quarter of 23 excludes $0.5 million of stock compensation expense and $0.7 million of other non-recurring expense.

  • Now turning to our balance sheet on Slide 13. As of December 31st, net debt was $85.5 million, which is a decline of roughly $1 million from the end of the third quarter. And as a result of the strong operating results, net leverage improved to 2.9 times at the end of the fourth quarter of '23 compared to 3.9 times at the end of the fourth quarter of '22.

  • We expect to begin to see our working capital usage normalize in the coming quarters, which could result in a reduction of inventory levels, leading to improved free cash flow conversion and ever even further reduced leverage levels as of December 31st, total cash and available liquidity, it was approximately $31 million.

  • Now turning to our outlook. We continue to make tremendous progress on our strategic initiatives, and we remain on target to achieve our 2025 elevating excellence financial targets based on the continued momentum in our end markets and our expectation for ongoing execution against our strategic goals, we are providing full year 2024 outlook as follows which we detail on slide 14. We expect 2024 revenue to be in a range of $300 million to $310 million and adjusted EBITDA in a range of $30 million to $34 million.

  • That completes our prepared remarks. Operator, we are now ready for the question-and-answer portion of our call.

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • (Operator Instructions)

  • Matt Koranda with ROTH Capital Partners.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • It's Mike on for Matt. And maybe a starting point. Starting on the $305 million midpoint revenue guide. We talked about appetite for Rabern fleet expansion in 2024. I guess just how should we think about Rabern revenue growth versus core Manitex's revenue growth that is embedded in the guide?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Yes, so appreciate the question and good early morning to you. So Rabern's fleet expansion is partially replacement, retirement of fleet and partially a growth. So, the majority of the growth is favoring the traditional manufactured Lifting Products segment over the Rental segment.

  • And that's been consistent thus far with our trend over the last two years where the Crane segment will continue to grow. And obviously, the other thing that we're heavily focused on is margin improvement.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • It's helpful. And the press release talks about 2024 focus on adding and two to three new dealer agreements and a focus on new products. I guess just to what degree are these initiatives factored into the guide? Or would these just be upside to 2024?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Well, there's some limit. let me talk about a couple of things strategically. There's a marked trend in the understandable temptation in our industry to go direct and we're taking an opposite view. Our products require localized foot upfit tailoring of solutions that are fit for the purpose to the market that is being served.

  • And we feel like we're a really good manufacturer and a really good partner, but we need the voice of the dealer in that equation.

  • And so part of what we're saying is that's a strategic output that we're focused on this year that will help us grow long-term. The dealers are not necessary for that level of growth, but they're necessary for our long-term growth, if that makes sense. We're not prepared to announce which dealers that we're working with, but as soon as we have all the crossed and all the dotted, we'll be eager to announce that because that's just part of our long-term strategy specifically for the European products that require that level of expertise and upfit.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • Got it. That's helpful. Mike. Maybe just on gross margins, I guess, low step-down quarter over quarter, but still remain up year-over-year and looks like we're structurally higher. So that's great. And Joe, maybe just help us understand how large of a drag, the steel prices were to gross margins in the quarter, and it looks like we have implemented some additional price increases in 4Q as well. I guess just when do these fully filter through the backlog?

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • Yeah, so the steel prices primarily really affected the US. We were able to offset much of that in Europe. We started increasing some prices in the United States. We put in some blanking on the term certain additional surcharge. So we put in some additional surcharges, so they offset some of the price.

  • But we had a fairly sizable purchase price variance that really affected us throughout 2023 in the US. We're trying to offset that in 2024, but that was it was a pretty significant a couple of million, $3 million plus impact to the overall P&L out of the United States. So we're trying to offset that in 2024 with some additional surcharges and the price increases that I mentioned that were put in place in late in 2023.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • Got it. And a couple of million of impact in the quarter or the year?

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • For the year.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • Okay, got it. Okay. Thanks for that. Last one for me, guys. Press release talks about opportunities to deploy capital beyond debt reduction. It sounds like we'd prioritize organically investing back into the business or we could go out and be acquisitive? Maybe just provide some more color on where we see opportunity to reinvest back into the business? And then what type of bolt-on acquisitions would make the most sense if that's the route we choose to go?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Well, the first part. I appreciate the question. So recent the production growth opportunity for our European product line that requires additional fabrication and assembly production space over the next two to three years in Europe, largely in support of North America. North America will largely be in final assembly, finished assembly and mounting operation where Europe would be a manufacturing operation.

  • So, we're working on redeploying capital to meet those growth curves that are going to be if they're necessitated, not just because many of our operations are closing in on maximum output capacity want to redesign the rewind, the clock about a year.

  • The focus of 2023 was to get the processes in place to feed system growth in at that time, we saw an opportunity to improve our production through better process, better scheduling and better systems. And that's what's happening in the first three years, but we have to prepare for the future growth.

  • And so the first segment is organic. And we see that as a really interesting opportunity to grow our organic production capacity to meet the demand for our products, largely in North America and also in South America.

  • And the second one, I hate ducking questions, but we this is this is a business that will get prepared for acquisitional growth. We're just not prepared to talk about that publicly right now, and that's something you may recall, my commitment and Joe's commitment was to get the business on a solid footing, take care of our investment or our investors and show them that these returns and this initiative is working. And at that point, we'll be ready to acquire and we're not at that point yet. but our eyes are focused on that.

  • Unidentified Participant

  • Very clear, sounds good. That's all for me guys. Thank you.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Okay, appreciate that.

  • Operator

  • Ted Jackson with Northland Securities.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Thanks. Good morning and congratulations on a great quarter and a great year.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Good morning, Ted.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • So, most of actually, my questions believe or not, just got kind of knocked off, but just some color around a few of them. One of the initial questions for me was to ask about milestones with regards to PM being brought into North America. It sounds like from the previous discussion that it has to do with the growth of the dealer network. Is that a fair assumption? So, if we were to kind of sit here on the sidelines and watch you guys play on the field in 202?

  • One of the things that we want to look for is some kind of new dealer announcements and that those dealer announcements will be tied to your endeavor to bring articulate product into the North American market?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Yeah, I appreciate the way you phrase it and you're correct. So, some local markets have different DOT regulations, and they have different configurations. And you know that product line some way prides itself with the ability to tailor a solution to a customer need or a series of solutions. And so we want we want to attract and maintain dealers look at this product segment as strategic to their growth and have strong product support capabilities within the market that they're serving.

  • And that's absolutely fundamental. So, you can expect those announcements as the year actually as the next two years progress. And we are observing and looking for new dealers and also some strengthening the product portfolio of our current dealers by adding European products to the mix.

  • So that's part of the strategy. I do want to remind everyone that we also do have international accounts. And so if you were to look today at our LinkedIn account, you'll see a government military contract delivery that's in process that was finished yesterday. And so our Texas factory is fully equipped to outfit PM products and sell them to international and corporate national accounts. But the strength of our offering in North America will be predicated on a combination of both of those.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Okay. Sticking with regards to kind of the whole PM thing and the capacity so I understood, I thought it was nice clarity with regards to capacity for kind of core of the manufacturing of the product being into Europe being done in Europe and then that's where you'll be really expanding your base. But am I correct with regards to your answer there that this is something that you're evaluating with the idea that you will put that capacity in place in '25, not in '24?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Well, on the actually we put some of it in place in 2023. So we expanded our Romanian fabrication plant in 2023 to feed growth. And so by year-over-year, our units produced increased about 7% in Italy in finished products that were delivered to the market. I remember Italy was operating in systems that were originally designed decade ago.

  • So, they were really handicapped with the operating systems that they are using. And we updated them, giving them contemporary technology and a modern ERP with regard to schedule output. And that happened earlier in 2023.

  • So those benefits are in place from a process standpoint, we increased a little bit of production capacity in Romania. We'll continue with that production capacity in 2024 and '25, but there will be a step growth and that we'll be announcing sometime after 2024.

  • We can look at with regard to expansion and forgive all the words, but I want to make sure we're clear on this when we evaluated our strategy, we looked at most of our products. In general, our footprint allowed for as much as 30% growth in our current factories.

  • What needed to happen is we needed to have production systems that would facilitate that growth with better scheduling. And of course, those things were offset with the headwinds of supply chain dramas and post pandemic issues that all manufacturers are dealing with, and we're moving to that process at a really good pace now. And we've moved our attention toward longer-term growth, including factory expansion to facilitate that. So that helps and I hope that clarifies it better.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • It does. And honestly, it's a great segue into it's a little bit of a sloppy question or a simple question, but it does actually have some relevance to me. We've talked you talked about it in the presentation of adding into the rental fleet. So, and then, as you know, I pay a lot of attention to free cash flow?

  • So, Joe is really more to you and maybe to you, Mike. But I'm curious as to what the target is for 2024 CapEx? And then given the fact that you're looking to increase production capacity in 2025 I know it's a long way out, but it is important. Maybe some color on how you're thinking about 2025 CapEx with kind of that in the backdrop.

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • Yeah, So I'll start with it, Mike, and if you want to add, that's fine. Ted, we've talked about the CapEx. And as we said, we took a little bit of a pause on Rabern in 2023, but we're seeing a lot of growth coming out of the Lubbock facility as well as out of Amarillo.

  • So, we're looking at probably total CapEx in 2024, roughly $10 million. Most of that was going to be allocated to building up the rental fleet for the Rabern business. We'll deploy a little bit of CapEx in the other two businesses in PM and in Manitex in 2024, but then we'll evaluate what that means in 2025 based on what our growth needs will be at that point in time.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Go ahead, Ted,

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Well, I was just going to say, I guess why I'm asking really about '25 is more that I assume if you're going to be increasing your manufacturing capacity that that's going to cost some amount of money. So I mean it maybe it's like we're not prepared to talk to it, but [indiscernible] why I'm asking?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • (multiple speakers) Well, we're not I appreciate the question. And I think it's really fair of the honest truth is on we don't have the footprint expansions to a position where we're prepared to talk about those accurately. We are expecting expansion through equipment and production. So, in the last two years, we've made some modest CapEx improvements with regard to robotic tooling and robotic tooling directly correlates to throughput from an efficiency standpoint and a timing standpoint.

  • And we have more of those plants scheduled in 2000, late 2024 and late in 2025. We are, but we have, and this is going to sound about as firm as Jell-O. So, I apologize about we have some very interesting ideas. We just haven't tested them fully, and I'm reluctant to release them until we have the full understanding of the plan. But the beauty of our manufacturing business by design is it's CapEx light. And that's one of the things that we like about it.

  • And it's not working capital like we saw that last year with our inventory that thankfully is coming down and that's going to have a direct correlation to debt repayment and making the business even further efficient along those lines. But capital improvement, the business model is attractive because it is lighter than others and certainly lighter than the rental segment.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Okay, I've got two more questions and I'll get out of the way. I'm a simple one is on the past, take this quarter aside, we've kind of been looking at a 28% a tax rate within the model. And so a simple question is, does that hold as we think about 2024?

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • I think it does tell you know, this year was was incredibly quirky because of the release of the valuation allowance that we had. But I think that's probably a best estimate at this point because of the impact of the foreign income on the US tax, it gets a little dicey, but I would use 28% return. I think that's the best estimate we can come up.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Okay, thanks. And then my last one is backlog is elevated still even though it's trending down? I mean, do you see I mean, given you say you have nine months of the sales and backlog. But when we get to the back half of '24, that we'll see kind of a stabilization, if you would, with regards to back log relative to for lack of a better term kind of the truck aerial revenue, Cold Lake up well below kind of maybe one or a little above as we get to the back half of this year?

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Yeah, so we think come first of all, we're thrilled with the growth of the business. Our backlog is historically elevated. If we look back and take the pandemic out of the equation and go back 10 years. This is a business that generally doesn't have a 9 to 10 months' worth of backlog at its disposal, let alone a year as we did on roughly a year ago. So, what's happened with the backlog is we're becoming more efficient in addressing it faster, which is a good thing.

  • The second issue with our backlog is we become by design, we've become more selective. So we have eliminated certain segments of our products that had lower marginal performance than what we wanted. And we're selling in to more of a selective market than we had in the past. We were doing that to improve our overall margins and the EBITDA generated by our operations. So those two things have changed the backlog a little bit.

  • The other thing, quite frankly, is some that become a little cautious with regard to interest rates in other segments are moving ahead, pretty boldly. So the industrial segments, government works, highways, power generation, and we put this in our press release really, really happy with how those are working on.

  • I mentioned in the last call in midyear last year, it was uncomfortable for us to have the length of the backlog, not the size, but the lengths because from the time you take the order and then you produce the order. A lot of variables have changed, and we're working hard to shorten the delivery time, which improves customer satisfaction and improves our margin profile. So, in summary for 2024, we feel very comfortable and confident in how we're looking at the year.

  • And we've got a really good line of sight for the business that's in hand, we feel very comfortable with how our products are performing. Our dealers are performing in the markets with regard to their demand for what we're doing and dumb, but I would be I would be more comfortable with something that's closer to about six months worth of our production capacity just because we can satisfy our customers quicker and the margin profiles are sustained.

  • So again, I'm being very verbose here, but there are some manufacturers that were taking orders and then pricing them at delivery. And we didn't do that. We added some surcharges, and that's a painful discussion to have with your customers.

  • But pricing in that delivery is actually a point of pain for a lot of our competitors right now. And we've been trying to be as fair with our customers as possible in a terrific set of markets. And most of those challenges have normalized in the last year, which positions us pretty well.

  • So, I hope that answers your question, Ted, were on work. You know, in talking to us is that we're always a little more conservative than some people want us to be, and we're cautious and careful in what we say. But Joe and I and the management team are really looking forward to 2024 and what's happening within our markets and how this business is performing.

  • Ted Jackson - Analyst

  • Okay. Well, again, congrats on the quarter. Thanks for answering on my questions. And I will leave the questions to others now. Take care.

  • Joseph Doolan - CFO

  • Thanks, Ted.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Thanks, Ted.

  • Operator

  • Thank you. And we have reached the end of the question-and-answer session. I'll now turn the call back over to CEO, Michael Coffey for closing remarks.

  • Michael Coffey - CEO

  • Thanks very much, operator, and just a closing comment of thanks to our investors that put their faith in our business and have stayed with us for such a long time. We really appreciate that and want to thank you some of you, and we look forward to visiting with it, ROTH and just a few weeks out in California and Joe and I will be out there, and we hope to see you all personally. And with that, we'd like to conclude our call and wish everyone the best of the year. Thank you.

  • Operator

  • This concludes today's conference, and you may disconnect your lines at this time. Thank you for your participation.