使用警語:中文譯文來源為 AI 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主
Operator
Good afternoon and welcome to Landar System Incorporated second quarter earnings release conference call. (Operator Instructions) Joining us today from Landstar are Frank Lonegro, President and CEO; Jim Todd, Vice President and CFO; Matt Miller, Vice President Chief Safety and Operations Officer; Jim Applegate, Vice President and Chief Corporate Sales Strategy and Specialized Freight Officer; Matt Dannegger, Vice President and Chief Field Sales Officer.
Now I would like to turn the call over to Mr. Jim Todd, sir, you may begin.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Thank you, Bell. Good afternoon and welcome to Landstar's 2025 second quarter earnings conference call before we begin, let me read the following statement.
The following is a safe harbor statement on the privacy securities litigation Reform Act of 1995. Statements made during this conference call that are not based on historical facts or forward-looking statements. During this conference call we may make statements that contain forward-looking information that relates to Landstar's business objectives, plans, strategies, and expectations.
Such information is by nature subject to uncertainties and risks, including but not limited to. the operational, financial and legal risks detailed in Landstar's form 10-K for the 2024 fiscal year, described in the section risks factors, Landstar's form 10-Q for the 2025 first quarter and our other SEC filings from time to time.
These risks and uncertainties could cause actual results or events to differ materially from historical results or those anticipated. Investors should not place undue reliance on such forward-looking information, and Landstar undertakes no obligation to publicly update or revise any forward-looking information. I'll now pass it to Landstar CEO, Frank Lonegro for his opening remarks.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
I'd like to thank our BCOs and Agents and all of the Landstar employees who support them every day.
It was great to spend time with our BCO Million Milers and Roadstars at our annual All-Star event in Savannah, Georgia recently, and to celebrate their incredible safety accomplishments.
It was my honor to preside over Landstar's fifty-first truck giveaway, awarding newly inducted Million Mile safe driver George Eason, from Owensboro, Kentucky, with a new 2026 Freightliner Cascadia.
The capability, resiliency and level of commitment exhibited day in and day out by our network of independent business owners is unique in the freight transportation industry.
Their adaptability and dedication to safety, security, and service for our customers is truly impressive.
They are exceptional business leaders and key to driving the continued success of Landstar's business model.
Amidst the ongoing challenges in the freight environment compounded by volatile trade policy and lingering inflation concerns, the 2025 second quarter included several important positive developments for Landstar.
While overall revenue was down 1% year over year, truck revenue was up year over year for the first time since the third quarter of 2022, as noted in our earnings release, our second quarter revenue per truckload outperformed pre-pandemic typical seasonality and the number of trucks provided by BCOs was approximately equal to the 2025 first quarter, representing the best sequential truck performance in 12 quarters.
Notwithstanding the political and macro uncertainty thus far in 2025, our focus continues to be on accelerating our business model and executing on our strategic growth initiatives.
In one continued major bright spot, I am extremely pleased with the performance of Landar's heavy haul service offering.
We generated approximately $138 million of heavy haul revenue during the 2025 second quarter for a 9% increase over the 2024 second quarter.
This achievement was driven by a 5% increase in heavy haul revenue per load and a 4% increase in heavy haul volume.
Turning more broadly to our core truckload service offering, the foundational work, we continue to invest in, puts us in a great position to leverage the freight environment when it eventually turns our way.
We are also focused on our commitment to continuous improvement in the level of service and support we provide to our customers, agents, BCOs, and carriers each and every day.
Turning to slide 5, the freight environment in the 2025 second quarter was characterized by relatively soft demand from a seasonal perspective, admittedly comping off a seasonally strong first quarter.
The impact of accumulated inflation remains a drag on the amount of truckload freight generated in relation to consumer spending.
Truck capacity continued to be readily available with small pockets of supply demand equilibrium and market conditions continue to favor the shipper amidst choppy conditions in the industrial economy, as evidenced by an ISM index below 50 for the entire 2025 second quarter, I would note, however, that the combination of sequential truck revenue per load improvement coupled with the sequential compression of our brokerage net revenue margins would indicate a market that we believe is working its way back toward being balanced.
Considering that backdrop, Landstar's revenue performance was admirable in the 2025 second quarter with truck revenue per load 2.6% above the 2024 second quarter, partially offset by a 1.5% decrease in the number of loads hauled via truck over the same period.
Our balance sheet continues to be very strong, and our capital allocation priorities are unchanged.
We will continue to patiently and opportunistically execute on our existing buyback authority to benefit our long-term stockholders.
As noted in the release during the 1st 6 months of 2025, we deployed approximately $103 million of capital towards buybacks and repurchased approximately 686,000 shares of common stock.
We continue to invest through the cycle.
In leading technology solutions for the benefit of our network of independent business owners and have allocated a significant amount of capital this year towards refreshing our fleet of trailing equipment, specifically on unsided/platform equipment.
Turning to slide 6 and looking at our network, the scale systems and support inherent in the Landstar model help to drive the operating results generated during the 2025 second quarter.
JT will get into the details on revenue, loadings and rate per load in a few moments.
As noted during previous earnings calls, Landstar safety culture is a crucial component of our continued success.
Our safety performance is a direct result of the professionalism of the thousands of Landstar BCOs operating safely every day, and the agents and employees who work to reinforce the critical importance of safety at Landstar.
I'm proud to report an accident frequency rate of 0.67 DOT reportable accidents per million miles during the 2025 1st half, well below the last available national average released from the FMCSA for 2021.
We continue to be committed to driving down that number closer to the company's trailing 5-year average of 0.61 or lower.
This long run average is an impressive operating metric that speaks to the strength, skill, talent, and dedication of our BCOs and the differentiation, our agents are able to highlight in discussions with our freight customers.
I'd also like to take a moment to recognize Landstar's nearly 500 million dollar agents based on our 2024 fiscal year results.
Importantly, retention within the million dollar agent network continues to be extremely high.
Turning to slide 7 and the capacity side on a year over year basis, BCO truck count decreased approximately 6% compared to the end of the 2024 second quarter. On a sequential basis, BCO truck count was essentially flat, decreasing only 9 trucks in the second quarter from the 1st quarter, representing the best net truck count performance in 12 quarters.
It is typical to incur turnover in BCO truck count in a low rate for load environment, BCO turnover continues to be influenced by a persistent low rate per load environment, combined with the significant increase in the cost to maintain and operate a truck today compared to before the pandemic.
Directionally, we are pleased to see our trailing 12 month truck turnover rate dropped from 34.5% as the fiscal year in 2024 to 31.9% at the end of the 2025 second quarter.
Through the 1st 4 weeks of our 2025 3rd fiscal quarter, the number of trucks provided by BCO Independent contractors has declined by 23 directionally consistent with the trend in truck revenue per load experienced during fiscal July.
I will now pass call back to JT to walk you through the 2025 second quarter financials in more detail, JT,
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Thanks, Frank.
Turning to slide 9, as Frank mentioned earlier, overall truck revenue per load increased 2.6% in the 2025 second quarter compared to the 2024 second quarter, primarily attributable to a 3.2% increase in revenue per load on loads hauled by unsided/platform equipment and by 1.2% increase in revenue per load on loads hauled via van equipment. On a sequential basis, truck revenue per load increased 3.2% in the 2025 second quarter versus the 2025 1st quarter, stronger than the typical pre-pandemic normal seasonality increase of approximately 2%.
In comparison to overall truck revenue per load, we consider revenue per mile on loads hauled by BCO trucks, a pure reflection of market pricing as it excludes fuel surcharges billed to customers that are paid 100% to the BCO.
In the 2025 second quarter, revenue per mile on unsided/platform equipment hauled by BCOs was 14% above the 2024 second quarter, and revenue per mile on van equipment hauled by BCOs was 3% above the 2024 second quarter. Delving deeper into seasonal trends on unsided/platform equipment declined 1% from March to April was approximately flat April to May and increased 8% from May to June. The March to April decline and the April to May approximately flat performance both underperformed pre-pandemic seasonal trends while the May to June increase outperformed pre-pandemic historical trends.
With respect to loads hauled by BCOs on van equipment, revenue per mile was more stable, grinding slightly higher as we move through the second quarter, revenue per mile on van equipment hauled by BCOs was approximately flat from March to April outperforming these trends, increased 1% from April to May, outperforming these trends and increased another 1% from May to June underperforming pre-pandemic May to June historical trends.
It should be noted that month to month seasonal trends on unsided/platform equipment are generally more volatile compared to that of van equipment. This relative volatility is often due to the mix between heavy/specialized loads and standard flatbed volume. As Frank alluded to, we've been pleased with the recent performance in our heavy haul service offering.
Heavy haul revenue was up an impressive, 9% year over year in the second quarter, significantly outperforming core truckload revenue. Heavy haul loadings were up approximately 4% year over year in revenue per heavy haul load increased 5% year to year.
This represented a mixed tailwind to our unsided/platform revenue for load as heavy haul revenue is a percentage of the category increase from approximately 33% during the 2024 second quarter to approximately 35% in the 2025 second quarter. Non-truck transportation service revenue in the 2025 second quarter was 22% or 21 million below the 2024 second quarter. The decrease in non truck transportation revenue was mostly due to a 20% decrease in ocean revenue per shipment of 14% decrease in ocean volume and a 9% decrease in intermodal revenue per load.
Turning to slide 10, we've provided revenue share by commodity and year over year change in revenue by commodity.
Transportation logistics segment revenue was down 1% year over year on a 2% decrease in loadings partially offset by a 1% increase in revenue per load compared to the 2024 second quarter. It should be noted that our US-Mexico and US Canada cross border businesses both underperformed our domestic revenue performance during the 2025 second quarter.
Within our largest commodity category, consumer durables, revenue decreased 3% year over year on a 5% decrease in volume partially offset by a 2% increase in revenue per load. Aggregate revenue across our top five commodity categories which collectively make up about 69% of our transportation revenue declined approximately 3% compared to the 2024 second quarter. While slide 10 displays revenue share commodity, we thought it would also be helpful to include some color on volume performance within our top five commodity categories. From the 2024 second quarter to the 2025 second quarter total loadings and machinery increased 4%, automotive equipment and parts decreased 16%, building products decreased 6% and Hazmat decreased 7%.
Additionally, substitute line haul loadings, one of the strongest performers for us during the pandemic and one which varies significantly based on consumer demand increased 24% from the 2024 second quarter. As we've mentioned many times before, Landstar is a truck capacity provider to other trucking companies, 3PLs and truck brokers. During periods of tight truck capacity, those other freight transportation providers reach out to Landstar to provide truck capacity more often than during times of more readily available truck capacity.
The amount of freight hauled by Landstar on behalf of other truck transportation companies is reflected in almost all of our commodity groupings, including our substitute line haul service offering.
Overall revenue hauled on behalf of other truck transportation companies in the 2025 second quarter with 19% below the 2024 second quarter, a clear indicator that capacity is readily accessible in the marketplace. Revenue hauled on behalf of other truck transportation companies was 11% and 13% of transportation revenue in the 2025 and 2024 second quarters respectively. Even with ups and downs in various customer categories our business remains highly diversified, with over 23,000 customers, none of which contributed over 8% of our revenue in the 2025 first half. Turning to slide 11 in the 2025 second quarter gross profit was 109.3 million compared to gross profit of 120 million in the 2024 second quarter. Gross profit margin was 9% of revenue in the 2025 second quarter, as compared to gross profit margin of 9.8% in the corresponding period of 2024.
In the 2025 second quarter, variable contribution was $170.5 million compared to $175.1 million in the 2024 second quarter. Variable contribution margin was 14.1% of revenue in 2025 second quarter compared to 14.3% in the same period last year.
The decrease in variable contribution margin compared to the 2024 second quarter was primarily attributable to a decreased variable contribution margin on revenue generated via truck brokerage carriers, as the rate paid to truck brokerage carriers is 46 basis points higher than the rate paid in the 2024 second quarter.
Turning to slide 12 operating income declined as a percentage of both gross profit and variable contribution primarily due to the impact of the company's fixed cost infrastructure, principally certain components of selling general and administrative costs, in comparison to smaller gross profit and variable contribution bases. Other operating costs were $19.6 million in the 2025 second quarter compared to 4.1 million in 2024.
This increase was primarily due to the reclassification of the $4.8 million dollar supply chain fraud charge established during the 2025
1st quarter from customer bad debt to contractor bad debt during the 2025 second quarter, as a result of the finalization of certain financial responsibility-related agreements with the affected independent commission sales agency. Excluding the 4.8 million P&L reclassification, other operating costs increased approximately $700,000 as compared to the 2024 second quarter, primarily attributable to increased trailing equipment maintenance costs partially offset by increased gains on disposal of used trailing equipment.
Insurance and claims costs were $30.4 million in the 2025 second quarter compared to 27.2 million in 2024.
Total insurance and claims costs were 6.6% of BCO revenue in 2025 second quarter as compared to 5.8% in 2024 second quarter.
The increase in insurance and claims costs as compared to 2024 was primarily attributable to increased severity of trucking accidents during the 2025 period, increased severity on cargo claims primarily due to strategic cargo theft and increased net unfavorable development of prior year claim estimates, partially offset by decreased BCO miles traveled during the 2025 period and a decreased frequency of cargo claims during the 2025 period.
During the 2025 and 2024 second quarters insurance and claims costs included $2.3 million $1.0 million dollars of net unfavorable adjustment to prior years' claim estimates, respectively.
Selling general and administrative costs were $55.7 million in the 2025 second quarter compared to 54.9 million in the 2024 second quarter.
Excluding the favorable impact of the previously mentioned 4.8 million reclassification, selling general and administrative costs increased approximately $5.6 million as compared to the 2024 second quarter.
The increase in selling general and administrative costs were primarily attributable to an increased provision for incentive compensation, increased information technology costs, increased wages and employee benefit costs and increased costs associated with our annual agent convention.
The provision for incentive compensation was approximately $1 million during the 2025 second quarter compared to a $1.4 million dollar reversal of previously recorded incentive compensation costs during the 2024 second quarter.
Depreciation and amortization was $12.1 million in the 2025 second quarter compared to 14.5 million in 2024.
This decrease is primarily due to decreased depreciation on software applications.
The effective income tax rate was 24.6% in the 2025 second quarter compared to an effective income tax rate of 24.5 percent in the 2024 second quarter.
Turning to slide 13 and looking at our balance sheet, we ended the quarter with cash and short-term investments of $426 million dollars. Cash flow from operations for the 2025 1st half was $63 million dollars and cash capital expenditures were $4 million dollars.
The company continues to return significant amounts of capital back to stockholders with $97 million of dividends paid and approximately $102 million of share repurchases during the 2025 1st half.
The strength of our balance sheet is a testament to the cash generating capabilities of the Landstar model.
Back to you, Frank.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
iven the highly fluid freight transportation backdrop and an uncertain political and macroeconomic environment, as well as challenging industry trends with respect to insurance and claims costs, the company will be providing third quarter revenue commentary rather than formal guidance.
Turning to slide 15, the number of loads hauled via truck in July was approximately 1% above July 2024 on a dispatch basis while revenue per load in July was approximately 3% below July 2024 on a processed basis.
As a result, we view July's truck volumes as slightly better than normal seasonality, whereas July truck revenue per load was below normal seasonality.
It should be noted that the launch point of the second quarter from a sequential pricing perspective was relatively high, given the strong seasonal performance of 2025, second quarter truck revenue per load.
Looking at historical seasonality from Q2 to Q3, pre-pandemic patterns would normally yield a slight decrease in the number of loads all via truck, almost entirely offset by a slight increase in truck revenue per load, yielding a relatively flat top line sequentially.
As noted above, fiscal July truck volumes trended slightly above normal seasonality while fiscal July truck pricing tended slightly below.
With respect to variable contribution margin, the company typically experiences a relatively flat variable contribution margin from the second quarter to the third quarter.
Although we're not providing guidance, there are 3 points regarding the expense side in the 2025 third quarter that we want to bring to everyone's attention.
First, assuming a normalized provision for customer bad debt and normalized employee benefit costs, we would assume SG&A costs would decline by approximately $3 million sequentially as we cycle the impact of the 2025 agent convention held during fiscal April 2025. Second, that approximately $3 million sequential tailwind to SG&A will be partially offset by the impact of our BCO all-star celebration in fiscal July, which we expect to result in a $1.5 million dollar sequential headwind on the other operating costs line, and third, one of Landstar's operating companies, Landstar Ranger, is a defendant in a trial currently underway in El Paso, Texas, involving a tragic accident between an RV occupied by a family and a small independent trucking company that at the time of the accident was hauling a load brokered to it, by Landstar Ranger.
The plaintiffs assert that with respect to the accident, Landar Ranger acted as the responsible motor carrier and not a broker.
Although it is hard to predict the potential outcome of this matter, the trial could result in a substantial verdict against Landstar during the 2025 3 quarter.
Landstar intends to preserve its rights to appeal any such verdict.
Additional information regarding this matter is included in Landstar's second quarter 10Q filed today with the SEC. With that Bell, we'd like to open the line for questions.
Operator
Thank you very much, sir.
Operator
This time we will begin the question and answer session (Operator Instructions)
Jon Chapell, Evercore ISI.
Jon Chapell - Analyst
Good afternoon. Jim hate to start off with super minutia question, but here we go. Frank gave us that SGA outlook for 3Q. You had mentioned earlier the 4.8 million impact to the good guy, in second quarter, SG&A. So when we think about that 3 million minus the 1.5 million sequential decline, is that off the 557 that was actually reported in 2Q or is that the 557 plus the 4.8. And then make the the seasonal adjustment.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Hey, Jon, all good, yes, so the 557 on an as reported basis was inclusive of a P&L reclassed out of SG&A into other operating costs so that favorably impacted the bad debt line in the second quarter of 25, so I would tell you to put that back and then have the $3 million fall off from convention.
Jon Chapell - Analyst
Great, helpful. And then, another one maybe be a bit in the weeds, the unsigned platform revenue per load, really stepped up sequentially. You'd mentioned kind of the monthly, cadence and then that big 8%. Move from May to June. So how do we kind of put those two together? Did you just have a phenomenal June kind of exit rate, that kind of help you both from a volume perspective and a pricing perspective at the same time, and is that the right kind of launch point if you think about seasonal trends in the 3Q .
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
No, Jon, it's a great question.
So that that comment was specific to BCO van rate per mile on one side of the platform, so our BCO is a percentage of that category is probably 30% or so and the folks that that play in that space, the BCOs, they tend to skew more on the heavy specialized side. So to your point on a sequential basis or unsided/platform revenue per load stepped up about 7% sequentially. It was steady, John, so it was 320 basis point good guy March to April 620 April to May and 440 May to June, so it was impressive and each month and a quarter I would tell you VA revenue per load as well wasn't as, pronounced, but, plus 0.8% plus 0.6% and plus 1.1% April, May to June. So we felt good about rates on both equipment types all the way through the quarter.
Jon Chapell - Analyst
Great. Thanks a lot, Jim. For sure. Thank you.
Operator
Daniel Imbro, Stephens.
Daniel Imbro - Analyst
Yeah, hey, good evening, thanks for taking the questions. For sure. Maybe starting on a higher level one, Frank, I feel like a few months ago, a lot of uncertainty from shippers.
I think about some of your bigger movers this quarter I think auto down 17 energy electrical up meaningfully can you offer some color by any market on how you're thinking about the back half of the year, any updated thoughts and how they're changing and by those big end markets you're exposed to.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, no, good question. Nice to hear your voice and I'll kick it, over to Jim Applegate here in a second, but when you look at the second quarter and then think about the translation into the third quarter, I think you're largely going to see the same trends I would say, automotive absent a move in interest rates, or incentives or something like that to stimulate demand, I would continue to see auto as being something that is a bit sluggish until we see interest rates and tariffs find their equilibrium.
Housing hasn't been our friend either, so on the construction side that's obviously going to impact building products and things like that. On the other side of building products is going to be the data center business and things like that which have done fairly well in JT's remarks, he did mention the cross-border business both US, Mexico and US Canada and it's again until I, until we see something that shows a level of stability politically and through trade, I do think we're going to continue to see that on the year over year probably trend to the negative side, I think that on the positive side, the data are all things that we are seeing on the positive side, the data centers, the wind business, the government, the heavy haul business that we mentioned are all things that we are seeing on the positive side and I think you're going to continue to see that in the, into the third quarter.
Jim Applegate - Vice President and Chief Corporate Sales, Strategy & Specialized Freight Officer
Yeah, no, I think it, I mean Frank well said, we do look at, kind of the data centers and everything it's kind of powering that whole infrastructure build with AI, the electrical equipment, we need the power generation, type stuff is really been a positive and that's going to continue.
We see we see a pretty long runway, and I think a lot of that infrastructure build out is just in infancy, and I think you know you can tack on, just some of the administration things now that they're doing with the big beautiful bill and trying to spur domestic investment, it plays very nicely into additional Infrastructure type investment so we're very positive about that, I think Frank touched on, kind of some of the negatives that, around the tariff related, impacted industries, automotive, obviously, very down, and until you get some clarity as far as you know where some of these tariffs are going to shake out I think that continues, same thing with, other like metals and kind of some of the consumer related products I think you're going to continue to see some choppiness over on that end.
Daniel Imbro - Analyst
That's helpful, and then JT maybe a near term one on the 3Q kind of set up I guess. I think Frank mentioned variable contribution margins typically flat sequentially from 3q or 2q to 3q obviously rates have underperformed seasonality I would think that's helping variable contribution margin, but how should we think about BCM relative to the historical flat, is there any offset we should be aware of from mixed or something else that would keep us from being better than that seasonally normal.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
It's a good question, Dan sort of Frank's point, I mean, we're essentially flat if you go back 15 years and walk 22 to 3Q to your point, if the if the rate softness, today, full disclosure today is day two of July close, so I don't have perfect visibility, but to your point, if the rate revenue for load softness we're seeing in July results in wider spreads on the brokerage side that could be a tailwind to VCM outperformance. The other thing I would call out, that Miller can speak to better than me. the BCO utilization number was a good number in the second quarter. I think it ticked up 3% year over year. Now that could be face a little bit of a headwind with the rate direct direction we see rates going in July, but if that continues at a strong clip, that could help, and conversely, if rates fade a little bit, that could be a headwind from utilization side that that's how I'm thinking about it.
Daniel Imbro - Analyst
Great, appreciate the color, guys. Good luck.
Thanks.
Operator
Thank you, we'll move on to the next person coming from the line it's Scott Group of Wolf Research, your line is now open.
Scott Group - Analyst
Hey, thanks afternoon guys, I just want to clarify one thing about Q2 just to start, right? So the, there was a reclassification of that what 4.8 million or whatever of costs from one line to another, but the net of it is clean, right?
So like the dollar $20 is a is a clean quarter and we just take like the earnings from Q2 and then add back 1.5 million for the net of the agent convention, is that right? Or do we need to I just did that, is that right?
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, so what, when you think about the agent matter that we talked about last quarter, as you think about the classification on the P&L we had to move a couple of things around, but you're correct, the net number is 0 in terms of that reclass. I'll let JT hit the other moving parts.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
That's absolutely right, Scott.
You're thinking about the right way. It was a zero penny impact in the second quarter just P&L geography, so yeah, the convention falls off, $3 million tailwind BCO all starts by 1.2 to $1.5 million headwind discrete to the third quarter.
Scott Group - Analyst
Okay, perfect. Okay, that's what I thought. And then the BCO count flat sequentially that's good to see the number of approved and active brokerage carriers fell off a decent amount is. Is that you're, are you seeing accelerated pieces of bankruptcies, is that what's causing that or any additional color there?
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, one of the things we telegraph, Scott on the last call was we mentioned on the last call that there would be a pretty significant change as a result of some things that Matt's doing there, so we did exactly what we thought it was going to do but I'll let Matt pick up the color
Matt Miller - Vice President and Chief Safety & Operations Officer
Just a great deal of efforts is happening on the fraud front and really becoming more selective on who we're choosing to do business with is a result of all the work that's going on there to really cull through the carriers that are in the database and make sure we're partnering with those we want to partner with.
Scott Group - Analyst
and then just last one, you talked about the rev per load finally inflecting positive and in Q2 and I guess July is back negative again, do we think this is there something unusual about July from a comp standpoint, or is this just we can't get a sustained inflection yet.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
I think the short answer is the last thing that you said when I look at the sequential improvement, which literally started, March to April to May to June, we thought maybe we were catching a bid there, when you look at it in retrospect, I think there's a couple of things. There were some unique items in Q2, you've got certainly the road checks and Memorial Day, and then you had the very late quarter implementation of the English language proficiency, which we got what, Matt, weeks of or something like that, so that will remain to be seen what happens there, and then we probably had some tariff full forwards in the first half of the year which probably give it a little bit of bid and then the launch point, from June to July, it was a pretty good June number for us and it'll be good July 2024 number, so I think you're coming off of some heavier comps and demands just, inventory levels are probably a little higher based on some of the pull forward you've got the tariff uncertainty and I think it's too early to tell what the ultimate impact is going to be from the big bill, but we're certainly favorable on the things that we saw in there.
Scott Group - Analyst
Thank you, appreciate it guys. Thanks.
Operator
Thank you, we'll move on to the next person coming from the line of Bruce Chan.
Bruce Chan - Analyst
Hey, good evening guys appreciate the time here. Maybe just a follow up on some of the end markets, you mentioned that, substitute lion hall was nicely this quarter, wondering if that was related to post pauses restocking at the end of the quarter and maybe, get your thoughts on whether that sustains into 3 q or, maybe that falls off a little bit and then, I know it's early, but any kind of early read on, what the sort of peak season looks like, especially with that line.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Hey Bruce, so substitute line off for us is probably our least diversified end market so we had some pretty good demand in the first quarter from one of the big parcel players, in the second quarter we had pretty solid demand from the other parcel player, along with one of the LTLs, so, just less diversified and you could have one or two shippers, really move the needle there for thoughts on read through to the back half.
I'll let the sales team come in.
Matt Dannegger - Vice President and Chief Field Sales
Hey, Bruce, this is Matt Dannegger, in regards to the peak, we're right at that time of year where we start looking into that and to JT's point, it's really just on our part, a handful of the parcel players and substitute line haul.
So we're starting to look at that now. We don't have a full look at what that's going to be yet we're only firm that up September October, and have a better look at rates and volumes, but the early is, we're not looking for a huge peak, just like last year, a lot's changed, since the post COVID over the last couple of years, I think there's more people going back into the stores.
You got e-commerce, they're finding different ways to manage their own transportation, so we're just not seeing the same amount of that substitute line haul from our traditional customers that we've seen in the past.
So, early estimation like I said, probably a little bit flat I think last year we were 1 or 2% over 23 and we're probably looking pretty similar this year, flat, maybe up a little, maybe down a little bit, but no huge swings like we've seen in in some of the years past, but we'll have better information on that, later on in the in the fall.
Bruce Chan - Analyst
Okay, yeah, super helpful and then just a quick follow up on the forwarding side.
I know, smaller part of the business, but, obviously a big drop off in the second quarter I imagine, related to tariff, kerfuffle, any line of sight on that, improving so far in in 3Q.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Bruce, I do not have a view based on July, thus far, we saw ocean rates probably start to roll over a quarter or two ago and I think on a year to year basis that continued, and sequential, I believe it continued as well, but to your point, not a huge piece for us and cut some project type stuff can influence that from quarter to quarter.
Bruce Chan - Analyst
Got it. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you, we'll move on to the next person coming from the line of David Zazula of Barclays, your line is now open.
David Zazula - Analyst
Hey, thanks for taking my question. But you answered the question about the brokerage capacity providers but sequentially the BCO count, the losses seems to have stemmed. We there any actions you took to be able to, better recruit or better retain BCS during the quarter.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, no, David, good question, a quarter ago, we mentioned that as the rate environment stabilized and as the actions that Matt and his team have started to take, to hold, that we would see fewer cancellations and more ads, obviously being in the second quarter versus the 1st quarter is helpful just from a seasonal perspective.
We were delighted to see effectively a flat, quarter over quarter of BCO count and continuing to do everything we can on the, recruiting and the qualifications and the orientation and everything we do from a retention perspective.
I will let Matt sing his own praises because he's done a heck of a job for us in the last 6 months.
Matt Miller - Vice President and Chief Safety & Operations Officer
I appreciate that, Frank. I appreciate the question. Yeah, ads are tough in this environment would love to get a little bit more help on rate that said, as Frank mentioned, we have a number of strategic initiatives focusing on how we recruit, how we qualify, how we onboard without sacrificing safety. Safety is one of those things we hold near and dear to the heart, a big differentiator for us.
That said, best gross ads in 7 quarters, sequentially the gross ads were up 9.5% and year over year the gross ads were up 12.5%, so overall, pleased with the improvement we've seen.
David Zazula - Analyst
Thanks, and then if I just squeeze one in on heavy haul seems like a very positive environment for you out there are there any headwinds on the horizon?
Is that segment, exposed to tariffs or you know anything else that would keep that from continuing the momentum.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, I think on the on the heavy haul side, not necessarily tariff related, there's a little bit that goes cross border, we keep our eyes on, but a lot of that's domestic, I think the question on everybody's mind as we look at the big bill is what the impact of that's going to be on wind energy and some of the things that have been subsidized but let me let Jim Applegate talk a little bit more about that.
Jim Applegate - Vice President and Chief Corporate Sales, Strategy & Specialized Freight Officer
Yeah, and it relates to, kind of near term, no, I mean we're hearing from all of our customers and it's pretty broad based. I mean we're not just kind of, pigeonholed in one customer or one industry we're seeing it and when machinery, electrical equipment, data centers, even 3PLs that kind of specialize in that type of movement of equipment, we're seeing it across the board so we feel we're pretty well insulated from a customer and industry standpoint there are some things in the bill to Frank's point, the alternative energy credits, we're keeping an eye on that, but we do feel, no matter what happens, people need energy, people need power, we're going to see that business.
Just kind of moved it to different customers, and different providers depending on where they're going to need to kind of build their power to power all this investment that's happening across North America right now. So we still remain bullish on it, but we're keeping a good eye on, what, customers might benefit from this bill. Thanks so much.
David Zazula - Analyst
Thank you so much.
Operator
We will move now to the next person coming from the line of Brian Ossenbeck of JP Morgan. .
Brian Ossenbeck - Analyst
Hey, thanks. Good evening, appreciate you taking the question, just to go back to the comment on the EOP and it was a lot of other different implications from that via their truckload.
Regulations out there as well that might tighten some capacity but just want to get your thoughts, having some, exposure to that, especially down around the border, we imagine a lot of the focuses so any thoughts in terms of what you've seen so far and any trends you expect, with that going to be a big impact to capacity or not.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
A good question, Brian.
I'll let Matt fill in some of the numbers that we've been looking at, and obviously the FMCSA is publishing in arrears of their experience with ELP enforcement.
We think from a BCO Fleet perspective that we don't have any exposure. I mean we have a very disciplined approach to qualifying and recruiting and retaining our BCO so we don't feel like we have any unique exposure, at Landstar, but obviously if there are, any other capacities that happen to come out, we see it as a benefit to us certainly regionally, if not nationally, depending on the size of the bill might take over.
Matt Miller - Vice President and Chief Safety & Operations Officer
Hey Brian, I appreciate the question. So to Frank's point, we really don't see that as a Landstar specific challenge and to this point we've not received any violations that relate to that, that said, this was implemented June 25, coming out of the executive order on April 28, so the data that we have so far from FMCSA really covers 10 days, so it's June 25 through July 4.
So far 349 out of service violations, that's the big change here is that it's now an out of service violation, so you wouldn't have likely seen any out of services prior to June 25th, so that 349, it's hard to read into 10 days with, the potential enforcement ramp up so we think come next quarter we'll have a much better read on that. Coming out of that executive order on April 28th, there's also a review of non-domiciled CDLs, and that has the potential to have an impact, but right now, Secretary Duffy announced an FMCSA compliance reviews of the state's issuing non-domiciled CDLs, so that's kind of a wait and see right now. I think there is potential there, Brian.
Brian Ossenbeck - Analyst
Okay, thanks for the thanks for the rundown there. Maybe it's a follow up for Jim. Can you just talk about the insurance, costs and claim trends. It sounds like you've got a potential settlement coming out so we can talk a little bit more about that and then also just the underlying trends that you're seeing when it comes to claims and then you know what you think renewals are going to start to look like, before we get there before too long.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Just to be clear color on the second quarter?
Brian Ossenbeck - Analyst
The one coming up you mentioned that could hit in the third quarter, I think, the accident claim, and then just more broad comments about just severity instance premiums, just generally about the backdrop.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, on the first one, Brian, let me take that one obviously we we're alerting investors and analysts to the fact that we have an ongoing trial, and given the fact that it's an ongoing trial would probably shouldn't go into any level of detail, if you go back to my prepared remarks and look at a couple of the disclosures in the 10-Q. You get a sense of what we're talking about. I'll let JT hit the trends as well as, potential impact on renewal as we get into to next year.
Jim Todd - Vice President and CFO
Thanks Frank, yeah, Brian, so, you heard Frank in his prepareds talk about a little slightly higher DOT accident frequency and as a result of that we've seen our severity or cost per crash, on the trucking side run hotter thus far in 2025, than in 2024. We wrapped up our, insurance renewal, back on May 1, on an apples to apples basis we actually achieved a slight decrease, but we procured some additional risk transfer, on some other policies that basically brought it to flat, year over year which if you go back, two years, three years, five years, we were pleased to achieve a flat renewal despite the fact, clearly exposure is running lower and truck revenue per load, has continued to, run soft, as compared to 2022, which then pressures your insurance as a percentage of that BCO revenue number.
I've got to think Brian, that flat year over year compares really well against the peer group.
Credit to the safety profile and the professionalism of the of the BCOs.
Brian Ossenbeck - Analyst
Right, okay. Thanks very much guys.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Thanks Brian.
Operator
Thank you. So we will have the last person to ask the question coming from the line Stephanie Moore of Jefferies. Stephanie Moore from Jefferies
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Bell, we can go ahead and close out it sounds like we lost her.
Operator
That is noted so at this time I show no further questions. I would like to turn the call back over to you, sir, for closing remarks.
Frank Lonegro - President, Chief Executive Officer
Thank you, Bell. In closing, while the freight environment remains challenging. We do see some positives in the near term. We were encouraged by the sequential pricing trends during the second quarter and with a choppy industrial economic backdrop, we were pleased with the 9% year over year revenue increase in our heavy haul service offering and regardless of the economic environment, the resiliency of the Landstar variable cost business model continues to generate significant free cash flow.
Landstar has always been a cyclical growth company, and we are well positioned to navigate the coming months as we continue to look forward to higher highs when the freight market turns our way. Thank you for joining us this afternoon. We look forward to speaking with you again on our 2025 3rd quarter earnings conference call in late October. Thank you.
Operator
Thank you for joining the conference call today. Have a good afternoon. Please disconnect your lines at this time.