Asbury Automotive Group Inc (ABG) 2015 Q1 法說會逐字稿

完整原文

使用警語:中文譯文來源為 Google 翻譯,僅供參考,實際內容請以英文原文為主

  • Operator

  • Good day, and welcome to the first-quarter 2015 earnings call. Today's conference is being recorded.

  • At this time, I'd like to turn the conference over to Vice President and Treasurer, Matt Pettoni. Please go ahead, sir.

  • Matt Pettoni - VP and Treasurer

  • Thanks, operator, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to Asbury Automotive Group's first-quarter 2015 earnings call. Today's call is being recorded and will be available for replay later today. The press release detailing Asbury's first-quarter results was issued earlier this morning, and is posted on our website at asburyauto.com.

  • Participating with us today are Craig Monaghan, our President and Chief Executive Officer; David Hall, our Executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer; and Keith Style, our Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer. At the conclusion of our remarks, we will open the call up for questions, and I will be available later for any follow-up questions you might have.

  • Before we begin, I must remind you that the discussion during the call today is likely to contain forward-looking statements. Forward-looking statements are statements other than those which are historical in nature. All forward-looking statements are subject to significant uncertainties, and actual results may differ materially from those suggested by the statements.

  • For information regarding certain of the risks that may cause actual results to differ, please see our filings with the SEC from time to time, including our Form 10-K for the year ended December 2014, any subsequently filed quarterly reports on Form 10-Q, and our earnings release issued earlier today. We expressly disclaim any responsibility to update forward-looking statements.

  • It is my pleasure to hand the call over to our CEO, Craig Monaghan.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thanks, Matt. Good morning, everyone, and thank you joining us today. For the first quarter, we are once again reporting record results, with diluted EPS from continuing operations of $1.30, an increase of 26%. Our stores continue to produce excellent operating results by maximizing new and used vehicle sales opportunities, improving F&I PVR, pursuing incremental service opportunities, and controlling expenses.

  • In total, first-quarter revenues were up 14% and gross profit was up 11%. And we achieved an operating margin of 4.7%. These results and our strong balance sheet enabled us to deploy over $100 million of capital in the first quarter in the form of share repurchases.

  • Looking forward to the remainder of 2015, we believe automotive sales will remain healthy, and we continue to plan our business for a high $16 million SAR. We will continue to execute our two-part strategy, driving operational excellence and deploying capital to its highest returns. We are extremely proud and thankful for our team's hard work to achieve these outstanding results.

  • Now I'll hand the call over to Keith to discuss our financial performance. Keith?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Thanks, Craig, and good morning, everyone. This morning, we reported record first-quarter EPS from continuing operations of $1.30. This represents a 26% increase from last year, and there were no adjustments to earnings for the first quarter of 2015 or 2014. For the quarter, same-store revenue increased 8% and same-store gross profit increased 7%.

  • Controlling our expenses enabled us to decrease SG&A, as a percent of gross profit, by 90 basis points from last year, to a ratio of 68.5%. SG&A flow-through for the total Company was 40% and was adversely impacted by our standalone used vehicle initiative branded as Q auto. We expect SG&A as a percent of gross profit to be between 68% and 69% over the remainder of the year.

  • Q auto continues to progress along with our expectations, and resulted in an EPS loss of $0.03 in the first quarter, slightly below our previous estimated loss of $0.04 to $0.06. Looking to near-term expectations, we estimate this initiative may reduce EPS by $0.01 to $0.03 in the second quarter of 2015. We continue to focus on our objective of achieving run rate profitability for Q auto by the end of the year.

  • In terms of capital deployment, we invested $8 million in our facilities during the first quarter. Our 2015 CapEx budget is approximately $65 million, and includes $45 million associated with our core annual CapEx plan, with the remaining balance allocated to CapEx related to recent acquisition renovations and construction, which will enable us to move out of facilities that are currently under lease.

  • In addition, we will continue to seek opportunities to purchase property in anticipation of future lease terminations. As Craig mentioned earlier, during the quarter, we returned $102 million to our shareholders through the repurchase of 1.35 million shares of our common stock.

  • Turning to the balance sheet, from a liquidity perspective, we ended the quarter with $1 million of cash, $16 million available in floorplan offset accounts, $90 million available on our used vehicle line, and $165 million available on our revolving credit line.

  • During the quarter, we closed on a $100 million real estate facility, which has a drawdown period through February of 2016 and bears interest at LIBOR plus 2.5%. At the end of the quarter, there was $17.1 million outstanding under this facility, as the proceeds were used to pay off a mortgage due in 2015, which was previously reported in current debt. After accounting for this transaction, we ended the quarter with a leverage ratio of 2.4 times.

  • In summary, we made substantial progress during the first quarter in deploying our available liquidity. And our balance sheet is in position for us to achieve our targeted leverage ratio of 2.5 to 3 times.

  • Now I'll turn the call over to David to discuss our operational performance. David?

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • Thanks, Keith. We are extremely proud of our Company's performance in the quarter. Our gross profit increased 11%, which was driven in growth in all of our business lines. This growth helped produce an operating margin of 4.7%. For the balance of my remarks, I would like to remind you that everything I will be covering with respect to operational highlights will pertain to same-store retail performance during the first quarter.

  • New vehicle revenue increased 9% and gross profit increased 4% compared to the prior year. Our new vehicle unit sales were up 6% and new vehicle margins for the quarter were 5.9%. Our new margins were down as a result of increased market competition. Looking forward, we believe we can maintain these margin levels in 2015.

  • We ended the first quarter with $630 million of new vehicle inventory or 62 days supply on a trailing 30-day basis. We are comfortable with our existing overall new vehicle inventory levels in light of our current pace of business. And we will continue to monitor and adjust our inventory levels to reflect changes in the business environment.

  • Turning to used vehicles, unit volume increased 3%, while used vehicle gross profit remained flat over last year as a result of pressure on margins, which ended at 8.5%. However, our used vehicle gross margins are up over the last two quarters. Going forward, in 2015, we believe our unit growth in used vehicles will continue in the low-single digits. And we believe we can maintain these margin levels. We were able to maintain used vehicle days supply at 34 days, which is in our targeted range of 30 to 35 days.

  • Our F&I strategy remains unchanged. Disciplined execution of F&I sales processes and training create solid sustainable growth and results. First-quarter F&I revenue grew 7% compared to the prior-year period. F&I per vehicle retail for the quarter was $13.65, up $35 on a year-over-year basis. The lending environment remains favorable.

  • In the first quarter, our Parts and Service revenues grew 8% and gross profit grew 10% compared to the first quarter of 2014. Our customer paid business, which represents approximately 54% of our Parts and Service gross profit, increased 4% from the prior year. Our customer paid business was adversely impacted by the weather conditions in February and early March.

  • In addition, reconditioning work was up 19% and warranty was up 26%. For the rest of the year, we believe we can continue to grow our Parts and Service business in the mid-single digit range, while maintaining relatively stable margins. However, there could be some margin pressure increase from increased focus on our quick service initiatives.

  • Finally, we would like to express our appreciation to all of our teammates in the field as well as those in our support center. Our Company continues to improve in all aspects of our business, and our associates are producing best-in-class results in many areas. This is a direct result of your passion and dedication. Again, thank you.

  • We'll now turn the call over to the operator and take your questions. Operator?

  • Operator

  • (Operator Instructions). Rick Nelson, Stephens.

  • Rick Nelson - Analyst

  • Can you comment on regional areas of strength and weakness, particularly Florida, as the Sun Belt states have been a driver?

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • Rick, I'm sorry. Could you repeat the question, please?

  • Rick Nelson - Analyst

  • David, if you could comment on regional areas of strength and weakness, particularly Florida I'm interested in, and any comments on Texas would be appreciated.

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • Florida continues to grow and is performing well and strong. And Texas has been stable with slight growth.

  • Rick Nelson - Analyst

  • Got you. And the mid-single digit comp guidance for the fixed operations, you've been tracking north of that now for four or five quarters. If you could provide some color as to why you still think that mid-single digit is a reasonable objective, and maybe the tailwinds and warranty that we've seen, what your expectation is there.

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Rick, this is Keith. For the quarter, obviously, we are up 10%. We are very cognizant that that 10% growth is somewhat fueled by our internal work, which is tied largely to our used vehicle volumes and the work we do in our service bays to prepare our cars for retail.

  • If you look at the warranty and the customer pay business, the warranty is still performing at a very high rate; customer pay was up 4%. If you combine the two, we are up about 8% for the quarter. That's the business that we feel like we control and we are focused on. And that's why we lean our guidance to that level.

  • Rick Nelson - Analyst

  • Got you. And finally, if I could ask you about the availability of subprime finance, if you've seen any changes there in the last quarter.

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • No. It continues to be strong and favorable.

  • Rick Nelson - Analyst

  • Okay. Thanks a lot.

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Thanks, Rick.

  • Operator

  • Brett Hoselton, KeyBanc.

  • Brett Hoselton - Analyst

  • Kind of two areas of questioning. First, on Q auto, I know it's still a little early in the game here, but I guess a couple of questions. One, how is it performing versus your expectations? Are you seeing any thoughts or any differences in terms of the different formats, preferences, good and bad and so forth? And then your sense of when you are ultimately going to evaluate whether or not this is kind of a go or no go situation.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Brett, I'd start off and say we are happy with the progress. I'd say we are actually moving slightly ahead of where we expected to be. As you saw in the results of this quarter, we had a $0.03 loss. We are anticipating a loss of $0.01 to $0.03 next quarter, so we think we will continue to make progress.

  • With respect to the formats, we -- essentially, we've got a small, medium and large format. I think we are learning that the smaller formats are most effective. The larger format is more challenging, but we think there's still opportunity in that store. The other thing we're learning is that the stores that are open the longest are the stores that are doing the best. And I think that's something that you might expect.

  • With respect to where do we go from here, I think we continue to look at this as a tremendous opportunity for us to utilize today's technologies and some of our in-house expertise, and figure out if we can't retail some portion of the 35,000 cars that we are sending to auction every year. And I think we're making progress in that direction.

  • Our objective is to achieve run rate profitability by the end of the year. We think we are headed in that direction. And I think at this point, we just ask for some patience while we continue to work on it, and see where we can get.

  • Brett Hoselton - Analyst

  • And then from a capital deployment standpoint, if I understood you correctly, you're kind of around 2.4 at the end of the first quarter; your target is 2.5 to 3 times; you're fairly close to your target. As we think about capital deployment on a go forward basis, it seems as though you're generating free cash flow in the neighborhood of -- let's say, I don't know, $150,000 -- or $150 million per year.

  • And you've got some growth in your EBITDA, so you're going to see some increase in your availability on your net leverage ratio there. So I kind of roll all that together, and very roughly, it seems like, on a steady-state basis, you guys could deploy somewhere in the neighborhood of maybe a [quarter-of-$1-million] per year, give or take. I'm wondering how would you, if you were in our shoes as investors, think about your capital deployment just in terms of magnitude and kind of pace and so forth on a go forward basis, given that you're very close to your target at this point?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Hey, Brett, this is Keith. I'll start and then I'll hand over to Craig.

  • Yes, correct, we were at 2.4 times leverage at the end of the quarter, recognizing that we also have about $90 million on our used vehicle floorplan line, which we look at that, that is low-cost financing and would include that in what we intend to deploy. But we are well-set-up, as you mentioned, from the Wells Fargo facility we have in place to have another $83 million or so in debt to add. And that would put us in our gross range.

  • I do track generally the numbers you're speaking about as far as free cash flow. I would say some of your number to get (technical difficulty) [quarter-of-$1-billion] is a one-time adjustment instead of ongoing. But we are still committed to it, to getting to the 2.5 times to 3 times range in a balanced way, in a balanced format, looking at internal opportunities, continuing to look at acquisitions.

  • And also, obviously, we've been active on our share repurchase program as well. But it's still a balanced plan here.

  • Brett Hoselton - Analyst

  • I guess what I'm kind of driving at, Keith, is you obviously had a very substantial amount of share repurchase over the past couple of quarters here and in the $100 million range. It kind of seems like the pace is likely to start to wind down to maybe more in the range of $50 million per quarter or something else along those lines. Is that kind of completely out of the ballpark? Or is that directionally kind of the expectation over the next few quarters here?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Brett, it's Craig. I'll jump in. The pace is -- in the long-term, is not sustainable. I mean, in the fourth quarter we did -- let's call it $90 million on share repurchase, two major acquisitions, another $100 million of share repurchase in the first quarter. But I mean -- I would just come back to what Keith said.

  • We will continue to deploy capital until we get our net leverage. And by net I mean net of our floorplan availability, any cash on the balance sheet. We want to get that number in that 2.5 to 3 times range. We're working to get there. And we will pursue opportunities across the board, whether that be internal investments, acquisitions when they make sense, or share repurchase.

  • But obviously, I mean, just the math says we can't continue at the pace that we are running, certainly, in the fourth quarter. And you saw that lighten up a little bit the first quarter.

  • Brett Hoselton - Analyst

  • And then finally, just in the used cars, you had a difficult comparison last year. I mean, you did a fantastic job. And really, over the past few years, you've done a very nice job on the used car side.

  • So, I think last year, if I remember correctly, your same-store was up around 10%, so you had a difficult comparison. So up 3% not entirely surprising. Sounds like on a go forward basis, you're kind of thinking maybe mid-single digits. Was there anything unusual in the first quarter other than maybe a difficult comparison that kind of slowed the pace down in the quarter?

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • No, I wouldn't -- this is David -- I wouldn't say so. Our used to new ratio came in at 85%, which was up from the previous quarters. Certainly not what the first quarter was in 2014, but a good pace overall.

  • Brett Hoselton - Analyst

  • Excellent. Thank you very much, gentlemen.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thanks, Brett.

  • Operator

  • Bill Armstrong, CL King & Associates.

  • Bill Armstrong - Analyst

  • Midline domestic comps up 12%. That's obviously a very strong number, I was wondering if you drill down a little bit and tell us how -- what was going on there that drove such a strong comp?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • It's really just the market that's driving it. Toyota 7 is off to a great start this year, like several of the other midline imports. And we've just benefited from that within our markets.

  • Bill Armstrong - Analyst

  • No, I meant domestics, not the imports.

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • We've had -- Ford has performed fairly well for us. Our other domestic brands have really been most of that increase. We've seen great results with GM and Chrysler.

  • Bill Armstrong - Analyst

  • Got it. Okay. That's all I had. Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Brett Jordan, BB&T Capital Markets.

  • Brett Jordan - Analyst

  • Just a little bit more color on the Q auto. Could you give us sort of some perspective on what you're seeing in the fixed ops there, as far as service or the F&I attachment in that channel?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Yes. We have very little fixed business in the Q stores at this time. It's just starting to come to life. We just don't feel we have enough units in operation yet for that to be significant.

  • Our people in the service drives -- or not in the service, in the bays -- are essentially spending the vast majority of their time preparing the cars to put back on the front line. The -- but otherwise, on the front end of the store, we feel like we are doing very well with our front-end grosses. Our F&I PVRs are not as high as the F&I PVRs we see in our store -- in our core stores, but they are good.

  • And like I said earlier, we feel like it's working; we are headed in the right direction. I would remind you that it's a very different format. It is a fixed-price format. The cars are fixed-price; the F&I products are fixed-price. It's a selling process that runs off of an iPad. There's not a traditional F&I office.

  • So, it's an environment where we would expect to potentially see lower front-end growth, because we also have a lower cost structure. I would say it is -- I'll come back to -- it's working, we are still learning, but we are very happy with the direction that it's in.

  • Brett Jordan - Analyst

  • Okay. Thank you. And then a question -- you'd made a comment about some margin pressure from quick service initiatives. Is that pressure because you're building overhead in anticipation of demand? Or is that pressure because you are seeing a category that's got a lower gross margin attached to the pricing?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • It's a category with a low gross margin attached. And it's our initiative to go after our independents and our local markets.

  • Brett Jordan - Analyst

  • Okay. And then one last question. Could you give us the number of lease penetration in the quarter? You know, what percentage of your units were leased?

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • We don't have that available right now. Matt will get it to you afterwards.

  • Brett Jordan - Analyst

  • All right, great. Thank you.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • John Murphy, Bank of America Merrill Lynch.

  • Liz Suzuki - Analyst

  • This is Liz Suzuki on for John. Looking at your gross profit per unit for both new and used, we saw some year-over-year decline in both. And combined with the higher average selling prices, it caused some margin compression that you mentioned. Is the competition that you talked about, is it both on new and used? And why do you think that's getting more aggressive than it has in the past?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • You know, I think it's been competitive for a while. I think there's always going to be a little bit of movement up and down between the quarters. There's pressure on used; there's pressure on new. The transparency of the Internet and everything that's involved, I think we are fairly stable.

  • Liz Suzuki - Analyst

  • Okay, great. For the Parts and Service business, you talked about a plan to add 200 to 400 techs over the next one to two years. If we think about your parts and service capacity, do you think by the time you add the techs that you need that you could theoretically see same-store sales in Parts and Service accelerate? Like, is it a capacity constraint issue in terms of your labor? Or is it more just the market dynamics?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Over the next two years, we will certainly add the techs that we need to. Our facilities aren't at capacity. We have the ability to add the technicians. And with that, the business will come with it.

  • Liz Suzuki - Analyst

  • Great. Thanks very much.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Steve Dyer, Craig-Hallum.

  • Steve Dyer - Analyst

  • I think you responded to an earlier question about demand or trends in Texas being -- I think you said stable. I think previous quarters, maybe Q4, you had said that they were still positive, so I don't know if I'm reading too much into it. Have you seen -- I know you don't have a lot of exposure to energy regions, but have you seen any sort of change in demand given energy prices?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • No. No, the business has been pretty stable for us there, and we really don't.

  • Steve Dyer - Analyst

  • Okay, thanks.

  • Operator

  • James Albertine, Stifel Nicolaus.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • I had a question for Keith. I think you had answered a previous question and I just missed it. I see your gross profit progression as it relates to the Parts and Service category. Can you talk a little bit about the reconditioning and prep growth in terms of the revenue there?

  • What I'm getting at here is, we're looking at 19% growth in profit; I think last quarter was something north of 10% as well. And yet you did 3% -- compares notwithstanding, 3% used retail unit growth. So I guess my question is, can you make the argument that there is some spring-loaded used retail growth here in the second-quarter, perhaps? Or how should we think about the connection between those two things?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Yes. Jimmy, I don't know that there's some spring-loaded benefit to used naturally coming forward from this phenomenon. I would say, though, that we do have the ability, on the reconditioning side and the Parts and Service side, to put additional work into our cars. We have done that over the last couple of years.

  • As you mentioned, we've shown pretty healthy increases in internal rates, and that's built into the cost of the car. And when you consider we've been able to achieve that and hold our margins on used relatively stable -- albeit down a little bit this quarter, but relatively stable -- I think, overall, it's a pretty good job.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Oh, I would agree with that. Understanding the market conditions down whatever it was, 2-and-change-percent year-over-year in GPUs is quite a good result. Just wanted to make sure. It sounds like it's more processes than it is unit volumes that's driving that GP growth. Correct?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • That would -- that's correct. And over time, we would expect those two to migrate back together -- for the (multiple speakers) to be driven by used vehicle volume.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Got it. And I've noticed over the last several quarters you've sort of -- if I understand it correctly, the availability on your used line has sort of hovered around $90 million. Is that correct? Am I understanding that's the availability?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Yes, that's correct. The current availability is at $90 million.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Right. So I guess my question is, is there an argument that -- what's the argument for keeping $90 million outstanding when you're in the process of sort of optimizing your used retail channel? Right? I mean, isn't that an argument for another 4,300 units you could be deploying, arguably?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • I don't know that I'm following the question. We look at that as -- we only have $10 million borrowed on our used vehicle line today. We have $90 million additional to borrow. It's a very cheap financing source for us that we intend to utilize.

  • But as far as investment in, and from an operational standpoint, how many vehicles we have on the ground, I think is where you're getting to, we are constantly evaluating our dealerships for our day's supply, and having adequate inventory to sell through to our customers.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Okay. So is $90 million sort of the availability that you've kind of identified as an optimized level? Or do you see that coming down over time, as you put more investment into used inventory, Q auto and within your core model?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • I would look at that $90 million differently. I would look at that $90 million as a line that we can pull on when we want cash to deploy.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Understood. All right.

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • I don't look at it -- well, I look at the operational standpoint of building inventory totally separately. If we have a opportunity to grow our used vehicle business by deploying capital into inventory, we'll go ahead and do that.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Understood. And the last question for Craig -- oh, sorry, go ahead.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • I was going to jump in and say kind of the way I think -- if you were talking to a General Manager in the store, the way they would think about it is, they want to have 30 to 35 days worth of used vehicle inventory on the front line. That -- we then roll that up into a dollar investment in used vehicle inventory.

  • We kind of put that completely to one side; work hard to stay in that 30 to 35 range. That seems to be a number that keeps us efficient. We have internal rules that once a vehicle ages much beyond that, we start to force that car's movement within the system or we force it to auction.

  • The line itself we kind of look at as a payable. And right now we are only using a portion of that. And what is the excess essentially is essentially liquidity that we've got available to us to redeploy.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Understood. Thank you for that clarification as well, Craig. And then, if I may, just a last question on the M&A environment that I know -- Craig, you've been great about kind of talking us through historically the ranges that you've seen. And it certainly marries with what we are hearing. Evaluation expectations are going up, it sounds like, among sellers.

  • Just wanted to get maybe an update on the current state of the environment and sort of how you see consolidation playing out at this stage. Thanks so much.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Sure thing. I think there's -- well, I'll start. It seems we're always talking to someone. We are talking to people today, so there's always a transaction that's being contemplated. But I would say today, at least from our perspective, there seems to be a lot more talk about consolidation in the press than what we see happening on The Street.

  • The -- I think seller's expectations continue to increase for a number of different reasons. But there are still people who are willing to sell car stores. We still see transactions that look like they could potentially get done at reasonable prices, but we are seeing fewer and fewer of those.

  • James Albertine - Analyst

  • Understood. Thanks again, gentlemen, and good luck in the next quarter.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thank you.

  • Operator

  • Paresh Jain, Morgan Stanley.

  • Paresh Jain - Analyst

  • Just a follow-up on the new GPU. You mentioned on the last call that you expect new GPU to kind of hover around the $2,100 mark. And now 1Q came in lower than that. And it's obviously just one quarter and it's maybe seasonally the strongest or the weakest. So, I guess just a couple of questions here.

  • Would you still be comfortable with that level? And despite all the pressure from midline imports, why doesn't strong luxury, better truck mix, and idle credit conditions help convert those pricing gains into improved GPUs?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Well, maybe -- this is Craig -- maybe I'll take a first shot at it. I think there's a number of things that are happening in the market.

  • Luxury, you're right. Luxury is a higher-price vehicle typically generate larger margins, but many of the luxury manufacturers are also starting to sell more and more lower-priced units, which we move in the market much lower grosses. I think that's playing into the market.

  • David talked earlier about the transparency that we see in both new and used. I mean, that's a reality today. We look at this $2,100 number that you talk about, and even if you just look us over the last nine quarters, that number has been very stable. It feels to us like it will continue to be stable. I mean, yes, it varies quarter-to-quarter, but we've been in this $2,000 to $2,100 range for quite some time now, and we believe that it will continue to exist.

  • David or Keith, do you have anything to add?

  • David Hult - EVP and COO

  • No, I agree.

  • Paresh Jain - Analyst

  • Got it. So, a follow-up on the capital allocation strategy. On the last call -- and you mentioned on this call as well -- that you want to return excess capital to shareholders, in the absence of acquisition, to hit those leverage targets of 2.5 to 3 turns. Now, just trying to understand how the current share price and multiple is being used into that decision-making? Or is it just more about hitting those leverage targets, regardless of where the current price is?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • No, we're -- I think the overriding factor for us is that we think -- we don't know exactly what our optimal capital structure is, but we think getting leverage into that 2.5 to 3 times range is where we should be. We are working to head in that direction.

  • We are not -- we don't think we are smart enough to determine what is the exact price that we should be buying or not be buying. I think we think of it as more as an exercise in which, with respect to share repurchase, we are returning capital to our shareholders. You could argue that it's essentially no different from a dividend.

  • What we do do, though, is we look at what's the relative return on investment that we can achieve when we buy a share of stock versus pursuing internal opportunities or pursuing acquisitions. That becomes the trade-off for us. But we are very much interested in taking advantage of the opportunity we have to deploy some liquidity, and we will continue to move down this path.

  • Paresh Jain - Analyst

  • Understood. And finally, if I can squeeze in one more on Q auto. You haven't given any volume numbers, obviously, but can you give us a sense of what percentage of sales are coming from wholesale being retailed? And what percentage is just Q auto taking share from peers in the market? Thank you.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • I would just point out that we have 88 stores, core stores, and three Q auto stores. So it's a very small part of our business today. It is not a material amount of our used vehicle sales. I don't believe that we are disrupting any markets.

  • I think we've got something on our hands here that's very interesting. We are making progress; we're selling cars. We are learning. We are learning how to solve this puzzle of creating a marketplace where we can retail cars that otherwise would've found their way to the auction. We've still got a lot to learn, but we like the fact that at three stores, it's very manageable.

  • And we think the smart thing to do is continue to work on those stores. There are some more technologies coming to play in those stores. There could be -- we are working with our technology partners. We are working with our financing partners. We are experimenting with a number of different things and it's -- we think it's just right the way we are doing it, and this is what we want to stay focused on right now.

  • Paresh Jain - Analyst

  • Thank you very much, guys.

  • Operator

  • David Whiston, Morningstar.

  • David Whiston - Analyst

  • Continuing on Q auto, I was just curious on -- is one rationale for going to the time and expense of this -- a new brand and standalone store is just that, that way, you can get some consumers into a store to buy a used vehicle who wouldn't normally go to a new car dealer to look for a used vehicle?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • It's -- we're trying to figure out who the customers are. And we are learning that the customers in each of the markets are different. So -- and one of the markets, for example, is primary subprime. But in another market, we can sell luxury cars.

  • It's -- I guess I would come back to kind of our overriding view, is that we are not consuming a lot of capital with this. It is not terribly disruptive to our core operations. We've carved out a group of people who are dedicated to it. And we are learning. And I think that's the important thing.

  • We are learning, I think, a brand is important -- obviously, a brand is important. And we do believe that as these stores continue to operate and get more time under their belt, they are becoming more relevant in their marketplace. They are becoming more relevant online. And we think those are some of the things that are helping them continue to improve their volumes.

  • And we've just got to continue down that path. It's going to take some time, and -- but we feel like we are headed in the right direction. And it is well worth our effort and your investor, our investor, our investments as shareholders, to give this thing a shot. In fact, we think we would be remiss if we didn't give it a shot, because we believe there's a real opportunity here.

  • David Whiston - Analyst

  • I completely agree there's no reason to auction stuff you can retail. I was just trying to get more into the angle of why go through the time of the separate brand? So, that's helpful. Thank you. And what, if anything -- this is a more broad market question on the industry -- what, if anything, concerns you about consumers' ability and willingness to buy a vehicle in your markets now, new or used?

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Oh, I think it's a great time to be in the car business. Just the fact that the product is absolutely phenomenal, we continue to see new product every day. Interest rates are as low as they have ever been. I don't -- I mean, inventories are under control. We've learned, I think, to become much more better with our processes. We continue to find ways to improve productivity, so our flow-throughs have been, I think, very healthy. It's really hard to find much to complain about in today's marketplace.

  • David Whiston - Analyst

  • Okay. And last question, how much better can your SG&A to gross ratio get?

  • Keith Style - SVP and CFO

  • Yes, this is Keith. We commented that we think we can be at 69% to -- 68% to 69% over the remainder of the year. We think we could operate well within that range. Obviously, a lot of the ratio is dependent upon business growth and gross profit growth. So, as our business grows, we are able to drive that even lower than those levels.

  • David Whiston - Analyst

  • Okay. Thanks so much.

  • Craig Monaghan - President and CEO

  • Thank you. Well, that concludes our discussion for today. We appreciate you joining us, and look forward to talking to you again next quarter.

  • Operator

  • This does conclude the conference. We thank you for your participation.